Anti-transfer pricing measures also applicable to domestic enterprises

Tax management performed on enterprises which conduct affiliated transactions will rely upon the principle of fairness, transparency and no discrimination against neither domestic nor foreign enterprises, said a top taxman.

The essence of Decree No. 132/2020/ND-CP on the tax management of enterprises with affiliated transactions will tolerate no discriminations against neither domestic nor foreign-invested enterprises when it comes to anti-transfer pricing, said Dang Ngoc Minh, deputy general director of the General Department of Taxation.

Anti-transfer pricing measures also applicable to domestic enterprises

The essence of Decree No. 132/2020/ND-CP on the tax management of enterprises with affiliated transactions will tolerate no discriminations against neither domestic nor foreign-invested enterprises when it comes to anti-transfer pricing

Mr. Minh explained that transfer pricing has been also practiced among domestic enterprises as a result of policies on preferential tax regimes in accordance with locations and industries. That means Vietnam’s corporate income tax policies differ in line with the nature of industries, enterprises’ scale and incentive periods.

Which is why enterprises that are entitled to preferential tax rates and those who are not subject to different corporate income tax rates.

To reduce their tax obligations to be fulfilled to the State, domestic enterprises have also conducted transfer pricing by shifting taxes from an enterprise subject to high tax rates to those with lower ones or without any taxes at all, said Mr. Minh.

Furthermore, the deputy general director of taxation said transfer pricing among domestic firms relates to enterprises belonging to the same business group or conglomerate if they work in extensive industries, multiple fields and across provinces and cities.

“Transfer pricing may emerge in whatever locations where tax incentives are applicable,” said the top taxman.

Mr. Minh even pointed his fingers to transfer pricing activities which might have been carried out between a lucrative enterprise and another suffering losses in the same business group or corporation to cut tax payments when there is no discrepancies in the corporate income tax rates.

In another occasion, Dr. Do Thien Anh Tuan, a lecturer from Fulbright Vietnam University, said the labyrinth of policies on tax incentives in accordance with businesses’ locations, industries, investment scales and work force’s size has prompted enterprises, foreign and domestic alike, to practice transfer pricing from locations without incentives to those eligible for preferential tax rates.

Nominally, Vietnam’s universal corporate income tax rate has been cut from 32% to 20% since January 1, 2016. However, if regulations on tax incentives provided by Vietnamese state agencies, from central to local, in different forms and scales are taken into account, the average tax rate is way lower.

Furthermore, the related authorities have appeared to be laxed on investors as far as taxes are concerned, an attitude which is deemed to erode tax-policy compliance of enterprises.

Mr. Tuan argued that these are among the challenges faced by such developing countries as Vietnam in their bid to fight transfer pricing because the domestic market is plagued with weaknesses like inadequate or unreliable business information. Meanwhile, the database on taxpayers is incomplete and loosely arranged.

The interest cost woe

 

To plug the above loopholes, Mr. Minh contended that tax management will have to rely on the principle of fairness, transparency and no discrimination against neither domestic nor foreign enterprises, in line with Decree No. 132.

Decree No. 132 will inherit all regulations on the control of interest cost at 30% as stipulated in Decree No. 68/2020. Moreover, regulations stipulated in the new decree will allow the control of interest cost after the deduction of the interest of deposits/loans in accordance with Decree 68/2020 and other appropriate regulations in Decree 20/2017, ensuring both the effective management of affiliated transactions intended to falsify tax payment and the facilitation of business activities.

What’s more, the new decree will put forward a multitude of regulations compatible with international practices and Vietnamese practicalities to curb transfer pricing.

Assoc. Prof. Pham The Anh, chief economist of the Vietnam Institute for Economic and Policy Research (VEPR), contended that compared with Decree No. 20, Decree No. 132 contains important revisions.

First, said Mr. Anh, when calculating the total interest rate/EBITDA to apply to the interest cost ceiling, Decree No. 132 opts for total net interest cost—interest cost after deducting interest of deposits and loans.

Secondly, the decree also paves the way for enterprises with interest cost surpassing the ceiling to move it to the next period of taxation, but not exceeding five years. Previously, if the rate of the total interest coat/EBITDA was higher than the ceiling, the enterprise in question is not allowed to deduct its tax.

“The new rule helps enterprises having big investment—which are often formed by loans in a certain year—redistribute its interest cost in the following years,” said Mr. Anh.

Another positive point of Decree 132, as this economist put it, is the requirement that multinationals have to compile their country-by-country report.

Dr. Anh, however, also argued that the lift of the ceiling of the total interest cost/EBITDA from 20% to 30% is unreasonable. According to the economist, less than 5% of the total number of foreign-invested enterprises had the total interest cost/EBITDA higher than the 30% threshold in 2016, the period before Decree 20/2017 on tax management of enterprises with affiliated transactions was issued.

“If firms without affiliated transactions are left, the remaining number is very small,” said Mr. Anh.

Furthermore, another concern voiced by enterprises over interest cost applicable to calculate the total interest cost/EBUTDA is interest cost incurred between enterprise with affiliated transactions and any parties, whether with or without affiliated transactions, or only interest cost incurred among the related parties with affiliate relations. This is yet to be clarified by Decree 132 and should need more clarification and instructions in the coming time.

Another notable point of Decree 132 relates to the group of those whose deducted interest cost are not restricted when identifying the taxable corporate income tax which has been supplemented, including: loans from official development assistance, preferential government loans obtained from foreign loans, loans for the implementation of national targets, such as the new rural area program or sustainable poverty reduction, and the like.

SGT

Decree to prevent transfer pricing could inadvertently harm Vietnamese companies

Decree to prevent transfer pricing could inadvertently harm Vietnamese companies

Setting a cap on loan interest deductability is a tool to prevent foreign invested enterprises (FIEs) from conducting transfer pricing. However, the application of the regulation on Vietnamese enterprises as well has stirred controvesy.

 
 

Other News

.
Proper mechanism needed to export farm produce by sea to China
Proper mechanism needed to export farm produce by sea to China
BUSINESSicon  15/01/2022 

The Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development and the Ministry of Transport recently co-hosted a conference on promoting the export of agricultural products through maritime transport as a way of devising a proper mechanism for farm exports.

Hanoi to establish 2-5 new industrial parks by 2025
Hanoi to establish 2-5 new industrial parks by 2025
BUSINESSicon  15/01/2022 

The Hanoi government has approved a plan to establish an additional two to five new industrial parks (IPs) in the 2021-2025 period.

What’s behind Tan Hoang Minh’s sky-high bidding price?
What’s behind Tan Hoang Minh’s sky-high bidding price?
BUSINESSicon  15/01/2022 

Tan Hoang Minh won the bid in a ‘duel’ to buy the 3-12 land plot in Thu Thiem new urban area in HCM City, but finally gave up.

Vietnamese FDI attraction likely to hit US$40 billion this year
Vietnamese FDI attraction likely to hit US$40 billion this year
BUSINESSicon  15/01/2022 

Amid rapid economic recovery following the COVID-19 pandemic, Vietnam’s foreign direct investment (FDI) attraction this year is anticipated to record positive signs and hit US$40 billion, according to insiders.

Agriculture Ministry denies that cross-border exports are low-quality products
Agriculture Ministry denies that cross-border exports are low-quality products
BUSINESSicon  15/01/2022 

Vietnam exported $3.52 billion worth of vegetables and fruits in 2021, an increase of 8.6 percent over the year before. China remains the biggest client consuming 54.5 percent of the exports.

Online shoppers warned of cunning tricks
Online shoppers warned of cunning tricks
BUSINESSicon  15/01/2022 

Along with the popularity of online shopping in Vietnam come several cunning tricks of criminals to steal money from consumers. 

Vietnam to be Asia's next startup hub
Vietnam to be Asia's next startup hub
BUSINESSicon  14/01/2022 

In an interview with Bloomberg recently, Binh Tran - co-founder of Ascend Vietnam Ventures - said that Vietnam's nascent start-up sector is developing and Vietnam is becoming the next technology hub of Southeast Asia.

Police ask for documents of 11 Hanoi-based projects of Tan Hoang Minh Group
Police ask for documents of 11 Hanoi-based projects of Tan Hoang Minh Group
BUSINESSicon  14/01/2022 

The Police Agency for Investigation of Crimes on Corruption, Economy and Smuggling (C03) of the Ministry of Public Security has asked the Hanoi People's Committee to provide documents related to projects based in Hanoi of the Tan Hoang Minh Group.

US$15 billion bailout package a stimulus to economic recovery
US$15 billion bailout package a stimulus to economic recovery
BUSINESSicon  15/01/2022 

Given the severe impact of COVID-19, the National Assembly’s recent approval of a VND350 trillion (US$15 billion) economic recovery package is considered by businesses and experts as an extremely important leverage and motivation moving forward.

HAGL sells over 48 million shares to pay debts
HAGL sells over 48 million shares to pay debts
BUSINESSicon  14/01/2022 

Hoang Anh Gia Lai Joint Stock Company will sell more than 48.1 million shares of its subsidiary HAGL Agrico (HNG) from January 17 to February 15 to pay debt.

Lang Son to stop receiving fresh fruit vehicles from Jan 17 to Tet
Lang Son to stop receiving fresh fruit vehicles from Jan 17 to Tet
BUSINESSicon  14/01/2022 

The northern province of Lang Son has announced that it would stop allowing vehicles transporting fresh fruits to its border gates for export to China from January 17 until the lunar New Year holiday or Tet.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS JANUARY 14
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS JANUARY 14
BUSINESSicon  14/01/2022 

Cashless payments account for over 70 percent of retail transactions in 2021

Stock market sets new record on billion dollars of capital inflow
Stock market sets new record on billion dollars of capital inflow
BUSINESSicon  14/01/2022 

The Vietnamese stock market continued to reach another historic record, with the largest number of new accounts opened in December after 21 years of operation.

WB forecasts Vietnam’s growth at 5.5 percent in 2022
WB forecasts Vietnam’s growth at 5.5 percent in 2022
BUSINESSicon  14/01/2022 

The World Bank (WB) has forecast that Vietnam’s economic recovery is likely to accelerate in 2022 as GDP growth is expected to rise to 5.5 percent from 2.6 percent in the year just ended.

Vietnam reconsiders electricity sources after making international energy commitments
Vietnam reconsiders electricity sources after making international energy commitments
FEATUREicon  14/01/2022 

Vietnam’s commitments at 26th United Nations Climate Change Conference of the Parties (COP 26) will have a big impact on the country’s energy system. 

Vietnam’s economic growth forecast to rebound strongly in 2022
Vietnam’s economic growth forecast to rebound strongly in 2022
BUSINESSicon  13/01/2022 

Some foreign financial organisations have issued relatively positive predictions for Vietnam’s economy this year, with growth expected at 6.5 - 6.7 percent.

Three factors behind FDI attraction in Vietnam
Three factors behind FDI attraction in Vietnam
BUSINESSicon  13/01/2022 

Low labour costs, a geographical location close to Asian supply chains, and Japan and the Republic of Korea (RoK)'s efforts to promote greater overseas investment are considered as three factors in boosting Vietnamese foreign direct investment (FDI).

Live streaming attracts young people to earn money
Live streaming attracts young people to earn money
BUSINESSicon  13/01/2022 

Making money on online platforms and social networks is increasingly popular in the labor market, streamer jobs have become popular keywords for many young people.

Ample room for Vietnam's aviation investment
Ample room for Vietnam's aviation investment
BUSINESSicon  16/01/2022 

Private investors will have more options to invest in aviation infrastructure, which has been dominated by state-owned enterprises. 

Power Development Plan VIII under revision again
Power Development Plan VIII under revision again
BUSINESSicon  13/01/2022 

The draft Power Development Plan VIII is being revised again and expected to be submitted to the Prime Minister for approval in the first quarter of 2022.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN