ASEAN-wide tax race for FDI a road leading into the abyss

ASEAN countries should stop offering aggressive tax incentives in order to attract foreign funds, as it could create an unfair business climate among enterprises and lead to an acute state budget deficit.

ASEAN-wide tax race for FDI a road leading into the abyss
Groups such as Oxfam have warned that some tax incentives work against small- and medium-sized enterprises. Photo: Le Toan

 

Despite a sound economy and immense growth potential, many countries in the ASEAN still collect low amounts of revenue, which the experts believe is the result of large tax incentives to companies, especially for foreign investors.

According to a recent report by think tank Vietnam Institute for Economic and Policy Research (VEPR) and international non-government organisation Oxfam, tax losses due to corporate tax incentives were estimated to be 6 per cent of GDP in Cambodia and 1 per cent of GDP in the Philippines.

The situation could be much worse for countries whose tax revenue makes up nearly 80 per cent of the total budgetary revenue like Vietnam, Indonesia, and Thailand.

These lost revenues could have been crucial now in covering large parts of the extra budget spending on responses to COVID-19, illustrated in the cases of the Philippines and Vietnam whose lost revenues are estimated to be equivalent to a third of their financial efforts in response to the outbreak.

“ASEAN countries are competing with each other by reducing their corporate income tax (CIT) rates and offering aggressive tax incentives to both domestic and foreign investors. International institutions like the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) and the UN Conference on Trade and Development have repeatedly warned the ASEAN to stop offering redundant tax incentives due to their costs on budget revenue, tax base erosion, and creating room for tax avoidance and evasion,” said Babeth Ngoc Han Lefeur, country director for Vietnam at Oxfam.

Lefeur also mentioned that aggressive tax competition also makes the region a fertile ground for profit shifting. Countries like Thailand, Indonesia, and Malaysia are estimated to lose 6-9 percentage points of potential corporate tax revenues due to profit shifting. The race to the bottom is a lose-lose game.

Aggressive not always best

Across the bloc, the average CIT rate has fallen over the last 10 years, from 25.1 per cent in 2010 to 21.7 per cent in 2020. Specifically, there is no country increasing the CIT rates during this period.

Experts state that while countries can attract some foreign investors when providing more incentives than others, some can have more fiscal gains through multinationals’ profit shifting. However, all ASEAN countries lose in this competition.

“There is no significant evidence that tax incentives increase foreign direct investment (FDI) but quite the opposite. Most current corporate tax incentives in the ASEAN do not aim at attracting long-term investments,” added Lefeur of Oxfam. “Rather, they try to compensate for weak governance and poor infrastructure and feed the short-term desire of shareholders to cut corporate tax payments to the bare minimum. Furthermore, tax incentives created an unfair investment environment against local small- and medium-sized enterprises who rightfully deserve at least equal benefits.”

Aggressive tax exemption, tax reduction, and incentives could erode tax bases and implement harmful practices. Thus, governments cannot find sufficient resources for investing in essential sectors.

On the other hand, the OECD argues that tax holidays and government programmes that offer a tax reduction or elimination to businesses, and other profit-based incentives should be reduced and eliminated.

Currently, tax holidays in the ASEAN often last for five-20 years, with Brunei and Indonesia offering the longest periods of tax holiday of up to 20 years.

“The race to lower tax incentives in order to attract FDI is over. There’s a recognition that countries should compete against each other through better infrastructure, education, healthcare system, stable legal framework – but not with aggressive tax incentives, especially those like tax holidays that provide a zero CIT rate for 10 or 20 years,” said Johan Langerock, tax policy expert at Oxfam Novib.

While tax exemptions and holidays are limited to certain groups of investors, tax preferences are more widely applied to various business activities. Businesses can enjoy CIT reductions of 50-100 per cent.

In Vietnam, tax deductions are applicable to additional expenses relating to employing female workers in companies in the manufacturing, construction, or transport sectors and to ethnic minority workers in all types of business.

 

The shifting sands

But the overuse of tax incentives could consequently bring about a race to the bottom as neighbouring countries try to outdo each other in generosity in their efforts to attract investors from industrialised countries.

“The process of shifting production from China to the ASEAN region may worsen this competition between countries, as they seek to attract overseas funds inflow to further their own interests in boosting economic development, without seeing the wider regional picture,” said Pham Van Long, researcher at VEPR.

According to Setyo Budiantoro from Indonesia’s Ministry of National Development Planning, there was a long history of tax competition between the Philippines, Vietnam, Thailand, and Indonesia, with the countries vying with one another for manufacturing investments and using tax incentives as a tool to attract FDI.

For example, in 1996, competing to lure investment from the US firm General Motors, the Philippines offered a CIT exemption of eight years and Thailand offered a similar exemption, but with an additional amount equivalent to $15 million.

In 2001, Vietnam offered a CIT exemption of 10 years in order to lure Canon’s investment from Japan, but was out-competed by the Philippines, which offered an exemption of 8-12 years.

In 2014, in an attempt to entice investment from Samsung of South Korea, Indonesia offered a CIT exemption for 10 years, while Vietnam offered one for 15 years.

“It is high time for ASEAN members to co-operate and agree upon the common minimum standards for corporate tax incentives in the region. This is an important part to prevent public revenue loss and unnecessary competition among countries, which is also to achieve the common goal of building a more sustainable and resilient region,” noted Nguyen Anh Thu, president of VEPR.

Ah Maftuchan, co-coordinator of Tax and Fiscal Justice Asia added, “ASEAN member states need to collaborate and discard ‘beggar-thy-neighbour’ tax policies, including race-to-the-bottom tax incentives that translate into lost revenues which have left poorer countries and people struggling to make ends meet.”

Fresh data from the State Audit Office of Vietnam reveals that around 50 per cent of foreign-invested enterprises (FIEs) in Vietnam reported losses. In Ho Chi Minh City alone, some 60 per cent of 3,500 FIEs said they have experienced losses for years, noted Deputy State Auditor General Doan Xuan Tien.

While most local companies in the apparel and footwear sectors have capped profitability, FIEs in the same industries reported huge amounts of losses despite enjoying several tax incentives from the Vietnamese government.

Tien cautioned that FIEs might use the trick of selling services and products to their associated businesses at low prices, but buying materials and machines at high prices.

A recent report from the International Monetary Fund showed that governments lose at least $500 billion annually as a result of corporate tax shifting, including in Vietnam. VIR

Luu Huong

Vietnamese businesses burdened with taxes, FIEs at ease with tax exemptions

Vietnamese businesses burdened with taxes, FIEs at ease with tax exemptions

Studies have found that Vietnam’s taxation system offers many incentives to foreign invested enterprises (FIEs), but puts an increasingly heavy burden on Vietnamese enterprises and people.

RCEP to send strong signal on ASEAN's commitment in promoting trade

RCEP to send strong signal on ASEAN's commitment in promoting trade

Iman Pambagyo, Director General of International Trade Negotiations at the Trade Ministry of the Republic of Indonesia and Chief of the RCEP Trade Negotiating Committee of ASEAN, 

 
 

Other News

.
Welcoming the 'upgraded' CAEXPO
Welcoming the 'upgraded' CAEXPO
BUSINESSicon  07/09/2021 

The 18th China-ASEAN Expo (CAEXPO) will kick off in Nanning, China as scheduled, and here comes the "CAEXPO Moment" again.

Deposit interest rates fall, deposits drop to 10-year low
Deposit interest rates fall, deposits drop to 10-year low
BUSINESSicon  06/09/2021 

Commercial banks continued easing deposit interest rates in late August, causing deposits at banks to fall to a 10-year low.

45-day social distancing has hurt Hanoi's economy but public health has been protected
45-day social distancing has hurt Hanoi's economy but public health has been protected
FEATUREicon  07/09/2021 

Hanoi’s economy has suffered heavily from social distancing and travel restrictions over the last 45 days, but in exchange the Covid-19 outbreak has been under control.

All-round report on Vietnam’s startup ecosystem to be unveiled
All-round report on Vietnam’s startup ecosystem to be unveiled
BUSINESSicon  06/09/2021 

The Vietnam Open Innovation Landscape Report 2021, the most comprehensive and up-to-date overview of the local startup and innovation ecosystem so far, is set to be released in December.

Vietnam's steel sales increase due to exports
Vietnam's steel sales increase due to exports
BUSINESSicon  06/09/2021 

Steel enterprises have boosted exports while facing difficulties in domestic consumption due to the COVID-19 outbreak, according to the Vietnam Steel Association (VSA).

Pro-competitive policies in logistics sector can help Vietnam recover from the pandemic
Pro-competitive policies in logistics sector can help Vietnam recover from the pandemic
BUSINESSicon  06/09/2021 

Pro-competitive policies can help Vietnam continue its progress in logistics sector and help the country recover quickly from the impacts of the pandemic, the Organisation of Economic Co-operation and Development said in its two latest reports.

Foreign investors withdraw cash, but will return soon: experts
Foreign investors withdraw cash, but will return soon: experts
BUSINESSicon  07/09/2021 

Market experts forecast that foreign investors will undertake strong net buying in the fourth quarter of this year to prepare for next year’s economic recovery after large-scale immunisation campaigns.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS SEPTEMBER 6
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS SEPTEMBER 6
BUSINESSicon  06/09/2021 

E-commerce sales in Vietnam expected to reach $56 billion in next five years

E-commerce platforms resume delivery in HCM City as ban is lifted in red zones
E-commerce platforms resume delivery in HCM City as ban is lifted in red zones
BUSINESSicon  06/09/2021 

E-commerce platforms have resumed deliveries in HCM City and some of the city’s extremely high risk areas (red zones) since August 30, a week after they were banned.

Mooncake makers face unprecedented difficulties
Mooncake makers face unprecedented difficulties
BUSINESSicon  06/09/2021 

Online sales are being implemented by mooncake businesses with a variety of products from the common to the high-end.

Vietnam manufacturing output declines on Covid-19 outbreak
Vietnam manufacturing output declines on Covid-19 outbreak
BUSINESSicon  05/09/2021 

Vietnam’s manufacturers are facing an uphill task to keep operation amid restriction measures.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS SEPTEMBER 5
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS SEPTEMBER 5
BUSINESSicon  05/09/2021 

Ports see increase in goods handling despite COVID-19

Finance Ministry urges stricter control over risky corporate bonds in Vietnam
Finance Ministry urges stricter control over risky corporate bonds in Vietnam
BUSINESSicon  05/09/2021 

The Ministry of Finance (MoF) has tightened control over risky corporate bond issuance.

More sci-tech content in upcoming China-ASEAN Expo
More sci-tech content in upcoming China-ASEAN Expo
BUSINESSicon  06/09/2021 

The whole universe hidden in the VR glasses, magnificent images shown on transparent screens, unmanned aircraft applied in seeding and fertilization..., sci-tech exhibition has become the new hot spot in the China-ASEAN Expo (CAEXPO) in recent years.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS SEPTEMBER 4
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS SEPTEMBER 4
BUSINESSicon  04/09/2021 

Vietnam scores high in employee experience

Foreign investors keen on education
Foreign investors keen on education
BUSINESSicon  04/09/2021 

Overseas funds continue to cash in on Vietnam’s education sector with a view to diversify investment portfolios.

Rice exporters feel strain of restrictions
Rice exporters feel strain of restrictions
BUSINESSicon  04/09/2021 

The disruption of the production chain in the past few months is pushing rice exporting and processing companies into an increasingly difficult situation.

Garment and textile groups bemoan curbs
Garment and textile groups bemoan curbs
BUSINESSicon  04/09/2021 

With the autumn-winter season coming up, Vietnam’s garment and textile industry could cash in on the increased demand for clothing. 

CAEXPO embraces RCEP opportunities
CAEXPO embraces RCEP opportunities
BUSINESSicon  04/09/2021 

Cooperation is deepened to improve substantial economic and trade results.

E-commerce platform imports billions of US dollars of Chinese goods
E-commerce platform imports billions of US dollars of Chinese goods
BUSINESSicon  04/09/2021 

The Vietnamese Ministry of Finance believes that it is necessary to have regulations to control exports and imports transacted through e-commerce platforms.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN