Consolidating protection for intellectual property rights

As Vietnam strives to forge a digital economy, there is a growing need to protect intellectual property rights. 

consolidating protection for intellectual property rights

E-commerce and social media are two areas that intellectual property rules now must take into account. 

Tran Manh Hung, managing partner of law firm BMVN, a member of Baker McKenzie, writes about the relations between protection and social media, and the challenges to go digital.

With more than 20 years of internet integration and a booming population, it is unsurprising that Vietnam is consistently listed as having one of the highest number of social media users per capita in the world. In 2023, it is estimated that there will be around 52.8 million social network users in the country, up from 43.8 million in 2017.

Under Vietnamese laws, a social networking site is defined as a system of information that provides its users with services such as storage, provision, use, search, sharing, and exchange of information, including the provision of private websites, forums, online chats, audio and video sharing, and other similar services.

Many aspects of social media are covered by Vietnam’s extensive intellectual property (IP) regime, which includes the Law on Intellectual Property, the Civil Code, the Penal Code, and their guiding regulations, as well as international treaties that Vietnam is a signatory of. Further relevant laws include those on IT, e-transactions, online information security, and the recent Law on Cybersecurity.

However, as in other countries, Vietnam has had to strike a balance between promoting and taking advantage of the opportunities of social media with its corresponding issues and potentially negative consequences. These mounting issues and unanswered questions highlight the interplay between IP law and social media as an emerging area of concern for lawmakers and law practitioners.

consolidating protection for intellectual property rights

Tran Manh Hung, managing partner of law firm BMVN, a member of Baker McKenzie

Digital piracy

Online piracy is a problem in Vietnam. Pirated content is distributed through a multitude of websites that allow viewers to watch or download movies and TV programmes online for free, whilst making money from advertisements. Many sites are unable to show that they possess copyrights for any of their content, which includes music, movies, e-books, software, and mobile phone applications.

Online piracy causes significant harm and makes it difficult for legitimate online platforms to compete with pirated sites. For example, online piracy in Vietnam is directly impacting the international and local film industry, because new movies are frequently available online while they are still in their theatrical run. A vast number of movies are captured right off the screen by camcorders snuck in by cinema-goers and are then distributed to bootleggers throughout the world.

Online trading

E-commerce has seen rapid expansion in Vietnam, with total retail revenue reaching over $8 billion in 2018, representing a drastic rise from $2 billion in 2013 and $1 billion in 2012. Online platforms play a major role in supporting e-commerce through online shopping sites, social media platforms, and over-the-top applications.

This market expansion has also seen a corresponding rise in commercial fraud and the distribution of counterfeit goods. The use of social media platforms for conducting business has made it considerably harder for inspectors to discover IP violations. In 2018 alone, over 35,000 violating products were removed from e-commerce platforms and more than 3,000 accounts were locked.

It is undeniable that the trading of counterfeit, banned, and smuggled goods on e-commerce sites and social networks is both rampant and damaging to consumption and its corresponding societal benefits.

Online sellers of smuggled and counterfeit goods often adopt tricks and techniques in order to deceive buyers. For example, when posting images on an online channel, sellers often use genuine goods in order to gain the trust of buyers and mislead them into believing that they are genuine sellers. However, after the products are ordered, the genuine goods are swapped for counterfeit ones, which are ultimately delivered to the consumer.

Merchants often use transaction addresses which are different from the actual warehouses used to gather the goods. They also sometimes stock, hide, and sell counterfeit goods from their place of residence in order to hinder inspections.

Another difficulty that authorities encounter when dealing with fake and IP infringing goods on e-commerce sites is that the websites selling the counterfeit goods often use top-level domains, hosts located outside of Vietnam, and fan pages to run ads. Policies and technical measures adopted by e-commerce channels to detect and remove counterfeit goods have so far failed to significantly prevent counterfeit sales.

 

Notice concepts

From a policy perspective, the government could look to the “notice and stay down” concept recently adopted in the EU’s Directive on Copyright in the Digital Single Market, or the “notice and take down” concept, which is also widely used to prevent infringements in the US under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. These two concepts share the same core principles, as both require internet service providers (ISPs) to take down any infringing content upon receiving notice.

However, the “notice and stay down” concept additionally requires that ISPs have to make their best efforts to prevent the future uploading of specific unauthorised works. Nevertheless, for these procedures to be effective actions taken by hosting service providers to take down content must be consistent and long lasting.

The “notice and take down” concept has faced considerable challenges in effectively preventing the lightning-speed circulation of information, while the requirements of the concept may be difficult for small ISPs to fulfil. However, in spite of these challenges, it is still important for Vietnam to adopt or attempt to experiment with such methods. With applicable modifications to tailor them to the Vietnamese legal regime and social context, these methods could help to more strictly regulate the liabilities of ISPs operating in Vietnam.

Proactive methods

On the IP right holder’s side, it is crucial to take proactive actions to counteract copyrights/trademark infringements rather than to solely rely on the authorities. One of these actions is the strict monitoring of online infringements. Depending on the type of products and services, infringements may occur on social media sites and posts or pay-per-click advertising.

Therefore, it is important to spend time searching for any such infringements. The right holders may even use automatic search mechanisms in order to conduct searches more efficiently.

On the other hand, in order to protect trademark rights, trademark owners need to file for trademark registration as soon as possible as Vietnam adopts the first-to-file principle. This action will help trademark owners prevent bad faith trademark applications as well as reduce the legal costs that may arise from ensuing dispute resolutions.

In addition, right holders should carefully monitor the IP Gazette published monthly by Vietnam’s IP Office in order to detect any trademarks that may have been filed in bad faith and to accordingly oppose such mark before its application is accepted. Trademark owners can also design counterfeit resistant packaging, involving a broad range of legal and proactive actions.

A counterfeit resistant method that is potentially applicable in Vietnam may include the use of visible markings with special dyes or inks to make it difficult for replication but easier for the competent authorities to determine if the goods are counterfeit or not.

Responsibility of ISPs

Service providers are also responsible for contributing to the movement against IP infringements. Pay-per-download mechanisms and subscription services, as used by service providers such as Spotify to control music piracy, have been proven to be an effective approach for combating IP infringements.

In addition, termination of access to social networking sites in cases of repeated infringements, as applied by YouTube, is also a method to be considered. Service providers should also provide users with the right to file reports against any acts of trademark and copyright infringement.

However, it is important that users be made to provide sufficient evidence of the infringement in order to avoid misleading or fraudulent reports that could result in the removal of lawful posts. This procedure has been adopted by international ISPs, such as YouTube and Facebook.

It is important that local ISPs and e-commerce websites such as Shopee, Tiki, and Lazada implement similar initiatives in order to protect the lawful rights of their users and to adequately respond to counterfeits. VIR

Intellectual property rights revised

Intellectual property rights revised

Dinh Huu Phi, director general of the Intellectual Property Office of Vietnam, talks about Vietnam’s efforts to develop its intellectual property law to an international level.

VN e-commerce and fintech firms successfully call for huge capital in 2019

VN e-commerce and fintech firms successfully call for huge capital in 2019

E-commerce and fintechs accounted for four-fifths of the total number of big calls for capital in 2019. The biggest deal was worth $300 million.

 
 

Other News

.
Coronavirus: Lufthansa agrees €9bn rescue deal with Germany
Coronavirus: Lufthansa agrees €9bn rescue deal with Germany
BUSINESSicon  26/05/2020 

European markets rose on the bailout deal news, which sees Germany take a 20% stake in the firm.

Pharmaceutical enterprises enjoy good earnings in Q1
Pharmaceutical enterprises enjoy good earnings in Q1
BUSINESSicon  26/05/2020 

Increasing demand for medicine amid the COVID-19 pandemic has helped most pharmaceutical enterprises report positive business results in the first quarter of this year.

Vietnam hopes to redraw map of supply chains as more companies leave China
Vietnam hopes to redraw map of supply chains as more companies leave China
BUSINESSicon  26/05/2020 

Experts believe that the departure of large manufacturing corporations from China, plus the plan to boost global economic development, will bring new opportunities to Vietnam.

During COVID-19, VN real estate markets gather online
During COVID-19, VN real estate markets gather online
BUSINESSicon  26/05/2020 

Realtors have been trying to sell products online and through mobile apps.

VN ready to be world’s factory, but is the world?
VN ready to be world’s factory, but is the world?
BUSINESSicon  26/05/2020 

Vietnam attracted US$12.33 billion worth of foreign direct investment in the first four months of 2020, a year-on-year decrease of 15.5 per cent due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, according to the Foreign Investment Agency.

A common voice in labor relationship needed
A common voice in labor relationship needed
BUSINESSicon  26/05/2020 

Covid-19 has forced many enterprises to lay off their employees. However, the biggest headache in the labor relationship is how to seek a common voice between employers and employees.

Transport Ministry proposes State to compensate controversial BOT tollgates
Transport Ministry proposes State to compensate controversial BOT tollgates
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

The Ministry of Transport has proposed that the Government compensate developers of two out of four build-operate-transfer (BOT) tollgates and shut them down due to protests among road users.

Covid-19: A test for realtors
Covid-19: A test for realtors
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

Heavy debts and tightened credits plus sales slump due to the Covid-19 pandemic will soon expose the Achilles’ heel of many financially weak real estate enterprises. Here is why.

Covid-19 pandemic: Policy responses to stop shutdowns
Covid-19 pandemic: Policy responses to stop shutdowns
FEATUREicon  25/05/2020 

The pandemic and the healthcare crisis it triggers have ignited an economic storm in many countries. If the economic turbulence is not managed well, it will lead to a financial crisis and/or a debt crisis. 

HCM City gets ready for new foreign investment wave post-COVID-19
HCM City gets ready for new foreign investment wave post-COVID-19
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

Vietnam and Ho Chi Minh City in particular have remained appealing to foreign investors who are continuing to pour capital into the southern economic hub despite the COVID-19 pandemic.

Stimulus welcomed as Vietnam accelerates economic reactivation
Stimulus welcomed as Vietnam accelerates economic reactivation
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

The ongoing pandemic has completely upended lives and economies across the planet, restricting movement, shutting schools, forcing people to work from home, and jeopardising employment for millions.

Investment promotion on the world wide web
Investment promotion on the world wide web
BUSINESSicon  26/05/2020 

Given the government’s proposed spending cuts for overseas business trips and conferences, Vietnam should quickly adopting online investment promotion.

Philippine pivot does not impact on Vietnamese rice export
Philippine pivot does not impact on Vietnamese rice export
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

After a year letting the private sector import rice on a “tax-based mechanism” instead of a quota-based mechanism in line with the G2G regime, the Philippine side is considering a comeback to the previous regime to import 300,000 tons of rice. 

Share set to increase, facing corrections
Share set to increase, facing corrections
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

Vietnamese stock market is forecast to move higher this week, where correction and volatility is expected.

Many lawmakers do not want to legalize household businesses into enterprises
Many lawmakers do not want to legalize household businesses into enterprises
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

Several deputies of the legislative National Assembly have expressed their disapproval over a proposal to convert around five million household businesses in Vietnam into enterprises legally.

Investors need to consider carefully before buying old apartments: experts
Investors need to consider carefully before buying old apartments: experts
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

Experts have recommended investors consider carefully before buying old apartments to ensure investment efficiency.

Vietnam to help local firms cope with trade remedies
Vietnam to help local firms cope with trade remedies
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

The Vietnamese Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) is planning to increase the number of training courses it organises on trade remedies for the domestic production industry.

VN needs to change its ways to attract FDI leaving China: experts
VN needs to change its ways to attract FDI leaving China: experts
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

Vietnam has some great advantages while competing with regional countries in attracting capital flows moving out of China after the COVID-19 pandemic, experts have said.

E-commerce titans step up fake product fight
E-commerce titans step up fake product fight
BUSINESSicon  25/05/2020 

Overseas e-commerce companies Lazada and Shopee may lose their positions in Vietnam if they keep demonstrating limitations in protecting consumers from low-quality and fake goods.

Over half of population to shop online by 2025
Over half of population to shop online by 2025
VIDEOicon  25/05/2020 

Vietnam is aiming to have 55 percent of its population shopping online by 2025, with average consumer spending rising to 600 USD per year, according to a master plan on e-commerce development for 2021-2025.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN