Crafting a complete framework for online services

Some articles of draft Decree No.72/2013/ND-CP regarding the management, provision and use of internet services and online information have come up against contrasting opinions, mostly from overseas companies providing related services in Vietnam. 

Managing director of the Asia Internet Coalition Jeff Paine clarified the problems that foreign suppliers may struggle with if the draft decree is approved.

Crafting a complete framework for online services
Managing director of the Asia Internet Coalition Jeff Paine

The draft decree aims to resolve inadequacies in management and also assure the rights and benefits of related businesses, aiding them in getting involved in the online service market. Can the draft decree fulfill its targets?

The main concern with the draft decree is the impact that it will have on post-pandemic economic recovery efforts by the Vietnamese government. The pandemic has created a range of new issues for the digital industry which is directing all its efforts to provide effective communication, entertainment, logistics, telemedicine, and tele-education services.

At the same time, online service providers are building solutions in these areas to ensure there is no compromise to users’ security and privacy. The extreme nature of the requirements in the draft decree will certainly force some service providers to limit offerings to Vietnam, depriving consumers and businesses of critical options and dampening competition and innovation.

Vietnam has a booming internet economy. According to a 2019 research report by Google, Temasek, and Bain & Company, Vietnam’s digital economy reached $12 billion in 2019 on a 38 per cent annualised growth rate since 2015. With the gross merchandise value of its internet economy set to account for over 5 per cent of the country’s GDP in 2019, Vietnam is emerging as the most digital of all economies in Southeast Asia.

The draft decree, which contains provisions that will impact regional and local players alike, could unintentionally impair the growth of Vietnam’s e-commerce market, at a time when countries are depending on the digital economy to drive post-pandemic economic recovery.

Based on a document the Asia Internet Coalition (AIC) sent to the Ministry of Information and Communications, the requirements of the draft Decree 72 are very strict and will affect some service providers. Which areas will cause the largest difficulties for companies?

The draft Decree 72’s proposed content controls raises serious data privacy and governance concerns, while proposals to license online platforms create new barriers to entry that could harm smaller enterprises and startups that are leveraging these to power Vietnam’s digital economy. Local data storage requirements also ignore the importance of free cross border data flow to global economies, likely increasing cost and complexity for businesses and reducing Vietnam’s attractiveness.

Article 22 of Clause 5 stipulates processes for content takedown requests, with a specific turnaround time. Under the proposed amendments, the public information provider is required to identify the violating information and take appropriate action within 24 hours. Generally, the regulation should not attempt to compel foreign companies to take down customer content hosted on their systems where such content is hosted on equipment outside of Vietnam (and maybe lawful content in the country in which it is hosted).

 

Requests to remove unlawful content and law enforcement requests in relation to content should be directed to the entity responsible for publishing it, not the hosting intermediary.

Importantly, 24 hours for the first notice is an insufficient amount of time for content to be reviewed. Specific turnarounds such as 24 hours are neither reasonable nor consider the realities of business models and abilities to remove content or the complexities of the process. This causes undue operational burdens to providers.

Opinions are still being collected on the decree. What related recommendations do you propose to make it more complete and favour online service suppliers in general?

The AIC believes that the internet has an immensely positive impact on society. We support the development of a transparent legal framework that would promote the digital economy’s continued contribution to Vietnam’s growth. Such a framework must account for the sheer diversity of business models that contribute to the overall growth of e-commerce, the exponential speed of innovation in e-commerce solutions, and the industry’s present and potential benefits to Vietnam’s socioeconomic landscape.

The AIC believes that three key principles should guide the development of an effective regulatory framework with respect to the draft decree.

Firstly, it is important to clearly define what companies can do to fulfil their legal responsibilities, including content removal obligations. A lack of clarity in the definitions, procedures, and restrictions placed on companies will hinder efforts to implement and comply with regulations (for example due to misinterpretations of vague rules), and also cause an undue increase in the cost of doing business for local, as well as, international developers and service providers.

Secondly, a regulatory framework should have sufficient flexibility to accommodate new technology. While laws should accommodate relevant differences between platforms, given the fast-evolving nature of the ICT sector, laws should be written in technology-neutral ways that address the underlying issue rather than focusing on existing technologies or mandating specific technological fixes. Finally, laws should support companies’ to publish transparency reports about content removals and provide people with notice and an ability to appeal the removal of content. They should also recognise that fairness is a flexible and context-dependent notion. VIR

Van Anh

Legal framework lags behind e-commerce development in Vietnam

Legal framework lags behind e-commerce development in Vietnam

E-commerce development is improving, but state management in this field is facing many difficulties because the legal framework cannot cover all e-commerce activities.

Legal framework needed to promote OTT media services

Legal framework needed to promote OTT media services

Vietnam needed to build a legal framework to promote the development of over-the-top (OTT) media services as the Government strives to build a digital economy and accelerate digital transformation.  

 
 

Other News

.
17th CAEXPO to benefit China-Vietnam cooperation
17th CAEXPO to benefit China-Vietnam cooperation
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2020 

China and Vietnam are friendly neighbors connected by mountains and rivers, and have achieved fruitful results in the sustained economic and trade cooperation. 

Office rental rates to fall by end of year: experts
Office rental rates to fall by end of year: experts
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2020 

Office rental rates will continue to drop while supply will be in the non-central business district areas in HCM City in the coming time, according to property research companies.

'Ghost' restaurants flourish in Ho Chi Minh City
'Ghost' restaurants flourish in Ho Chi Minh City
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2020 

Without tables, chairs or waiters, "ghost" restaurants are flourishing in Vietnam, serving only online customers.

When private businesses get stronger
When private businesses get stronger
FEATUREicon  23/11/2020 

The private sector is very active in key sectors of the economy. If there is a "push", they will become an important force with other economic sectors to take the country forward.

Coastal industrial zones attractive to investors
Coastal industrial zones attractive to investors
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2020 

Vietnam’s industrial zones property located near the sea is attracting great attention to investors as they maintain high occupancy rates and rental prices, heard attendants at a conference held in Hanoi on Thursday.

Smarter logistics will benefit Vietnam: experts
Smarter logistics will benefit Vietnam: experts
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2020 

Smarter logistics are key for Vietnam to advance in the global value chain amid the fourth industrial revolution and the COVID-19 pandemic, experts told the Vietnam Business Summit 2020 held in Hanoi recently.

HCMC real estate market poised to recover next year
HCMC real estate market poised to recover next year
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2020 

The real estate market in HCMC has seen signs of recovery since August and is expected to see a strong rebound during the upcoming traditional Lunar New Year holiday and next year, according to the HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA).

Vietnamese firms to invest in three key aspects for digital transformation
Vietnamese firms to invest in three key aspects for digital transformation
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2020 

Many companies in Vietnam are considering an approach to workplace digital optimization beyond Covid-19.

Louis Vuitton, Christian Dior join Hanoi luxury market
Louis Vuitton, Christian Dior join Hanoi luxury market
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2020 

Leasing flagship stores of Louis Vuitton and Christian Dior show stronger sentiment towards luxury brands in Vietnam.

Thousands of Mercedes-Benz recalled in Vietnam over defective airbags
Thousands of Mercedes-Benz recalled in Vietnam over defective airbags
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2020 

Some 3,200 Mercedes-Benz cars in Vietnam have been found to have problems with Takata airbags, according to the Vietnam Register.

Binh Dinh-based Phu Cat airport proposed to become international one
Binh Dinh-based Phu Cat airport proposed to become international one
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2020 

The Binh Dinh government has written to the Ministry of Transport and the Civil Aviation Authority of Vietnam proposing turning Phu Cat Airport into Phu Cat International Airport.

Vietnam, Oman to foster bilateral trade
Vietnam, Oman to foster bilateral trade
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2020 

The two-way trade turnover increased sharply from US$117 million in 2017 to US$200 million in 2019.

Ministry working to promote growth of support industries
Ministry working to promote growth of support industries
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2020 

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) has introduced a range of measures to boost the growth of support industries in a bid to promote the engagement of local companies in production chains.

What does the 'rescue' of Vietnam Airlines reveal?
What does the 'rescue' of Vietnam Airlines reveal?
FEATUREicon  22/11/2020 

The national airline of Vietnam finally saw "the light at the end of the tunnel" when the National Assembly agreed with the Government's proposal for solutions to help Vietnam Airlines overcome difficulties caused by the Covid-19 pandemic.

Electronics industrial clusters to be piloted
Electronics industrial clusters to be piloted
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2020 

The Ministry of Planning and Investment has instructed localities to review and report on the development of industrial zones with investment projects in the electronics industry with a scale starting from US$20 million.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS HEADLINES NOVEMBER 23
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS HEADLINES NOVEMBER 23
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2020 

Businesses in support industries growing in quantity, quality

Real estate inventories see decline: ministry
Real estate inventories see decline: ministry
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2020 

Inventories in the real estate market have been on the decrease thanks to increasing liquidity, according to the Ministry of Construction (MoC).

Up to 16,000 foreigners buy housing in Vietnam in last five years
Up to 16,000 foreigners buy housing in Vietnam in last five years
BUSINESSicon  21/11/2020 

Between 14,000 and 16,000 foreigners have bought housing in Vietnam since July 2015, mostly from China, the Republic of Korea, Japan, Taiwan (China), and Singapore, the HCMC Real Estate Association (HoREA) estimates.

Global media positive about Vietnam’s growth despite COVID-19
Global media positive about Vietnam’s growth despite COVID-19
BUSINESSicon  21/11/2020 

A number of regional and global news agencies have quoted data from international research institutes and organisations as saying that Vietnam’s economy is on track to grow despite the impact of COVID-19.

Challenges and opportunities from Covid-19 for Vietnam's M&A market
Challenges and opportunities from Covid-19 for Vietnam's M&A market
BUSINESSicon  21/11/2020 

Low interest rates could open up new opportunities for investors to take advantage of the cheap capital to buy shares and acquire new assets via M&A deals.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN