Crystallising investment rules for infrastructure developers

Vietnam is now a magnet for overseas financiers wishing to implement infrastructure initiatives before transferring them to the state. 

Crystallising investment rules for infrastructure developers

As more international companies place their trust in Vietnam, the country must do more to ensure laws and regulations are watertight and clear 

Tran Son Vu, head of the Promotion Agency under the Association for Studies and Consultancy for Business and Investment Activities in Vietnam, writes about the pros and cons in regulations regarding non-refundable transfer in these projects.

Many governments around the world, including in Vietnam, are facing difficulties in infrastructure development in service of socio-economic development because of limited financial resources.

Thus, public-private partnerships (PPP) in general and projects under non-refundable transfer (NRT) in particular are considered optimal solutions to funding in infrastructure. They help ease pressure on state budgets and reduce dependence on official development assistance, while improving investment efficiency.

The application of NRT to projects is seen as a sound direction for Vietnam now. However, some related regulations of foreign investor assets in the country remain inconsistent and unclear.

Appealing advantages

In fact, there have been almost no difficulties in NRT of foreign-invested enterprise (FIE) assets to the Vietnamese state under commitments after the projects end their lifespan because general regulations in this area have been made clear.

According to Article 15 of Decree No.29/2018/ND-CP issued last year on procedures on determining public ownership of assets, investment registration agencies shall, at least 30 days prior to the date of terminated operation, announce to local departments of finance about cases of FIEs that have to conduct NRT of their assets to the Vietnamese state under previous commitments.

Within five days, the relevant department of finance must propose the provincial and municipal chairman of the people’s committee to establish an asset inventory and classification council. The council is in charge of receiving assets from the FIE, and then listing, classifying, and preserving the assets.

After that, based on inventory and classification results, the finance department will ­create a dossier proposing ­determination of public ownership of assets. Within five days, the chairman will issue a decision. As for assets of PPP projects, they are transferred to the Vietnamese government based on the content of the contract. Over the past few years, Vietnam has been implementing a model with NRT projects with a flexible legal framework in order to create a stable and fair investment climate which can attract more international investment.

PPP regulations have been mentioned in a number of laws, with specific decrees and guiding circulars. Regulations regarding PPP and NRT projects such as build-operate-transfer (BOT) and build-transfer-operate (BTO) have been clearly stipulated in Decree No.63/2018/ND-CP, released last year on PPP investment.

Though there is no regulation about what an NRT project actually is, the explanation of concepts in the decree’s Article 3 can make it easy to understand: NRT is a committed obligation in BOT and BTO contracts.

When transferring the project to the state, the investor will conduct NRT, with capital recouped by the investor during the operation of the project.

There are several stages involved. First, for BOT contracts, after completing the project, the investor shall have the right to operate it for a fixed period of time. After the venture terminates, the investor will transfer the project to an authorised agency. For BTO contracts, after completing the project, the investor shall have to transfer it to the authorised agency and then has the right to operate it within a fixed period of time.

Next, the processes and procedures for implementing PPP projects, and BTO and BOT projects especially, have been clearly stipulated. Procedures on deciding on the investment of the project are specified for each type, and for the state’s demand for using resources based on a policy to boost decentralisation and increase the responsibility of units’ heads. In these initiatives, all processes and procedures for preparing the project and selecting investors have been suitable to international practice, making it favourable for foreign investors.

Thirdly, timeframes and information in the contract must be made public in order to raise transparency, helping investors become more secure about their involvement, and also preventing a situation in which financiers take advantage of preferential policies in order to make profit themselves illegally.

Finally, the process for transferring works of NRT projects to the Vietnamese state includes transfer conditions and procedures which are specified in Article 58 of Decree 63.

According to the article, one year before the transfer date or within the time fixed in the contract, the investor shall have to produce an announcement in the media on the transfer of the projects to the state, with clear procedures and time for concluding the contract, as well as payment of debts.

 

The competent state agency will appraise the quality, value, and situation of the project under commitments in the contract. It will also list the transferred assets, determine any damage if applicable, and require the enterprise to repair and maintain the works.

The investor shall have to ensure that the transferred assets are not used to guarantee loans or other financial obligations that appear before the time of transfer, except for other regulations stipulated in the contract.

The investor is also responsible for transferring technology and training, and conducting regular maintenance of the project so that it can operate well in line with requirements in the contract.

After receiving the project, the authorised state agency must manage and operate it in line with their function and power.

In addition, Article 16 of Decree 29 has also provided more specific regulations on the process and procedures on determining public ownership of assets transferred to the state under the PPP contract. The article also states clearly, “Costs for appraising the quality, value, and situation of assets and other costs as per relevant regulations (if there is) in order to conduct transfer and receipt of the assets are arranged in the state budget’s recurrent spending of the state agency that inks the contract.”

Muddy waters

Though some regulations in Decree 63 are close to international practices, Vietnam’s legal framework on PPP and other legal regulations on NRT for foreign-invested projects cause headaches for investors not from this country.

Specifically, detailed regulations for PPP activities are now largely incarnated on a decree level. They also overlap as they are mentioned in many laws, such as those regarding the state budget, investment and public investment, environmental protection, enterprises, the land, construction, and public debt management. Thus, regulations for PPP investment at the decree level cannot go against the laws.

The failure in reflecting the nature of the PPP has made it difficult for the implementation of such projects, meaning that it would also be difficult to obey the PPP contract.

Moreover, Decree 63 only stipulates “date of transfer” in a general fashion, without any specific provisions on verifying important points such as the time for completing construction or beginning the transfer of the project.

The specific determination of these points of time is extremely important as this is a foundation for determining policies on insurance and ­incentives or determining sanctions on the delay in transferring the venture as earlier committed.

Furthermore, at present, there is a lack in support and incentives from the state which can help increase PPP project success. The existing regulation in Decree 63 mentions the state’s capital contribution, but so far no PPP project has received this type of capital in the state’s plan on middle-term public investment plan due to a series of difficulties.

In addition, investors are also interested in a government guarantee mechanism. Government guarantee for risks, especially revenue-related risks, are considered a type of provision of the government. A lack of a government guarantee for PPP projects has been largely attributed to the delay of a number of transport projects partaken in by international investors, such as the Dau Giay-Phan Thiet and Tan Van-Nhon Trach expressways. VIR

Tran Son Vu

HCM City to collect infrastructure fees at seaports

HCM City to collect infrastructure fees at seaports

The Customs Bureau of HCM City has proposed that city authorities collect infrastructure fees at seaports to increase revenue for the city.

Building credit: How SOEs can get foreign financing for infrastructure

Building credit: How SOEs can get foreign financing for infrastructure

State-owned enterprises (SOEs) face unique challenges when it comes to attracting foreign financing for infrastructure projects. But there are solutions.  

Bank loans to BOT, BT infrastructure projects in Vietnam worth $4.72 billion

Bank loans to BOT, BT infrastructure projects in Vietnam worth $4.72 billion

Bank loans for build-operate-transfer (BOT) and build-transfer (BT) infrastructure projects by the end of September this year reached nearly VND110 trillion (US$4.72 billion), up 1.85 per cent against the end of 2018.  

 
 

Other News

.
Foreign investors look forward to Vietnam’s imminent IPOs in 2020
Foreign investors look forward to Vietnam’s imminent IPOs in 2020
BUSINESSicon  14/02/2020 

Nearly 100 Vietnamese companies will need to hit the road for share auctions by the end of 2020 to meet the government’s target of privatizing state firms.

PM Phuc allows border gates to re-open
PM Phuc allows border gates to re-open
BUSINESSicon  14/02/2020 

Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc approved the resumption of imports, exports and transport of goods through three sub-border gates between Vietnam and China to help local firms.

VN industrial sector’s growth likely to slow down due to COVID-19
VN industrial sector’s growth likely to slow down due to COVID-19
BUSINESSicon  14/02/2020 

Growth of Vietnam’s industrial sector is likely to slow down in the first quarter of 2020 due to negative impacts from the acute respiratory disease caused by a novel coronavirus (COVID-19), according to the General Statistics Office (GSO).

VN to issue lists of preferential tariffs under EVFTA
VN to issue lists of preferential tariffs under EVFTA
BUSINESSicon  14/02/2020 

The Vietnamese Government is set to issue a decree on the lists of preferential export tariffs and special preferential import tariffs to implement the EU-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement (EVFTA) when the deal comes into force in Vietnam.

New driving force for Vietnam-EU relations
New driving force for Vietnam-EU relations
VIDEOicon  14/02/2020 

The European Parliament has ratified the EVFTA and the EVIPA. The ratification has opened up new horizons for more intensive, comprehensive and effective bilateral cooperation 30 years after the establishment of diplomatic ties.

Two scenarios for Vietnam’s economic growth
Two scenarios for Vietnam’s economic growth
BUSINESSicon  15/02/2020 

If the nCoV epidemic lasts a long time, the GDP is expected to decrease.

BUSINESS NEWS HEADLINES FEB. 14
BUSINESS NEWS HEADLINES FEB. 14
BUSINESSicon  14/02/2020 

Large retail formats to dominate HCM City’s retail market

Vietnam says to ratify EVFTA in May
Vietnam says to ratify EVFTA in May
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The EVFTA will be ratified in May and take effect in July this year if everything fares well, said Minister of Industry and Trade Tran Tuan Anh.

Japanese firm to attract Vietnamese workers via football
Japanese firm to attract Vietnamese workers via football
BUSINESSicon  14/02/2020 

Japanese electronic device maker Lion Power is tapping into football’s popularity in Vietnam as a way to recruit technical trainees amid a labour shortage in Japan, reported the Asian Nikkei Review.

COVID-19: Mong Cai completes preparations to resume border trade
COVID-19: Mong Cai completes preparations to resume border trade
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Mong Cai city in Quang Ninh has basically completed preparations to resume trade through the Mong Cai International border gate, after a suspension due to the outbreak of coronavirus (COVID-19).

BUSINESS NEWS HEADLINES FEB. 13
BUSINESS NEWS HEADLINES FEB. 13
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Ministries seek new export markets for farm produce

EVFTA, EVIPA unleash market potential for European firms
EVFTA, EVIPA unleash market potential for European firms
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The EU-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement and the EU-Vietnam Investment Protection Agreement offer significant business opportunities for European enterprises, German Federal Minister for Economic Affairs and Energy Peter Altmaier said.

VN’s GDP growth to reach 6.25 percent if COVID-19 outbreak is contained in Q1
VN’s GDP growth to reach 6.25 percent if COVID-19 outbreak is contained in Q1
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Vietnam’s gross domestic product (GDP) growth is expected to reach 6.25 percent in 2020 if the outbreak of coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is contained within the first quarter of this year, according to the Ministry of Planning and Investment.

WB’s new strategy helps Vietnam better utilise solar power
WB’s new strategy helps Vietnam better utilise solar power
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The World Bank (WB)’s new approaches to bidding and deployment for solar projects will help Vietnam substantially boost and effectively manage its abundant solar energy resources.

Local airlines sustain coronavirus-triggered loss of VND10 trillion
Local airlines sustain coronavirus-triggered loss of VND10 trillion
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Local carriers had incurred total losses of over VND10 trillion as of February 10, Tuoi Tre reported, citing the head of the Civil Aviation Authority of Vietnam (CAAV) Dinh Viet Thang.

Foreign ownership cap yet to be applied at payment intermediaries
Foreign ownership cap yet to be applied at payment intermediaries
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has removed a regulation capping foreign ownership at 49% for local payment intermediaries from a draft decree on noncash transactions.

Over 36 tons of masks exported amid local virus scare
Over 36 tons of masks exported amid local virus scare
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

More than 36 tons of face masks was shipped overseas from HCMC within one week even though the domestic market is falling short of the product and the Government is finding ways to shore up mask supplies.

Prices of goods under State watch should be kept unchanged to curb inflation: GSO
Prices of goods under State watch should be kept unchanged to curb inflation: GSO
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The Government should not raise the prices of any products under its management, especially medicines, fuels and electricity, in the first half of 2020 to keep the full-year inflation rate under control, stated the General Statistics Office.

EU lawmakers approve free trade deal with Vietnam
EU lawmakers approve free trade deal with Vietnam
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The European Parliament (EP) on February 12 ratified the EU-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement (EVFTA) and the EU-Vietnam Investment Protection Agreement (EVIPA).

Vietnam vows to obtain $300 billion in export turnover
Vietnam vows to obtain $300 billion in export turnover
BUSINESSicon  14/02/2020 

The Prime Minister has set the goal of exporting $300 billion worth of products this year, but with the coronavirus outbreak, this proves to be an impossible mission.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN