Plucking up courage to enter foreign exchanges

The increasing demand for finance has prompted a clutch of Vietnamese corporations, such as FLC Group, to seek out overseas initial public offerings, but after previous failures, few want to be the first to try their luck. 

plucking up courage to enter foreign exchanges

A slew of well-known Vietnamese companies often look to making a stock exchange outside the country, but resolving barriers in order to do so remain complex (Photo: VNA)

Last week, FLC Group chairman Trinh Van Quyet, announced that his group is ramping up efforts to be listed on the Singapore Stock Exchange (SGX) at the bourse’s 20th anniversary event, a move which he said would “bolster its business, hone its image, and replenish overseas capital.”

“The SGX is a top international destination which provides value to businesses that want to extend their overseas ambition,” added Quyet. “FLC aims to become listed on the SGX next year or in 2021.”

FLC Group has been preparing to give the go-ahead to proceed with the international share sale for more than two years. Earlier in November, the property developer cancelled the issuance of 300 million shares for its current shareholders.

FLC is not the only local group preparing groundwork to file an overseas initial public offering (IPO), with Novaland’s Board of Directors recently showing their ambition of tapping into Singapore’s capital market, and VietinBank expecting to receive fresh overseas injection by listing abroad by its annual meeting in April.

“We hope that VietinBank, as one of the banks having the largest market capitalisation in Vietnam, will become the first lender to list overseas,” said chairman Le Duc Tho.

In 2017, the domestic market was teeming with excitement when VNG Corporation, an internet titan in Vietnam, signalled its IPO probabilities in the United States, the world’s largest public equity market which has provided capital to the likes of Google, Facebook, and Amazon.

Chairman and CEO of VNG Le Hong Minh did not hide his ambition to expand the company international footprint. “If VNG could manage to list abroad, it will also pave the way for other local companies as well,” said Minh.

Elsewhere, Vietnam's first private budget airline Vietjet also said it had begun proceedings to list shares overseas, following a successful IPO at home in 2017.

In 2008, dairy giant Vinamilk had been approved on the SGX, but its IPO plan has been delayed year after year. The firm, more than a decade later, is still nowhere closer to entering the regional bourse.

The number of Vietnamese companies awaiting approval to list overseas is big, including major firms such as SSI Securities, Vinamilk, Petrolimex, and Hoang Anh Gia Lai among others. However, all of those have postponed the launch of their long-awaited overseas IPO, putting future flotation in jeopardy.

Vietnamese firms’ failure to convince foreign funds that own the bulk of American or Singaporean stocks about their IPO plans could discourage peers from listing and attracting the skeptical glare of the markets.

Some analysts, on the other hand, see a tepid proposition for local companies being provided foreign public funds.

Long Phan, Vietnam director at the Institute of Certified Management Accountants (Australia) (CMA Australia) told VIR, “Foreign markets’ deep bench of experienced investors generally awards higher valuations than domestic investors in local bourses do, and offers more liquidity which might boost firms’ performance. But greater capital also comes with stricter requirements, as seen in the cases of SGX in Singapore and Nasdaq in the US, and I don’t think Vietnamese firms such as FLC Group could keep up with these requirements.”

That said, a series of high-profile flops, not just from Vietnamese firms, have tempered investors’ ambitions, intensifying the competition. Even WeWork, one of the most prominent startups in the world, withdrew its plan for an IPO a few months ago, signalling the need to reduce losses and revamp the business before making a new attempt at a public market listing.

 

According to Phan, two particular sets of mandatory listing regulations in the SGX rule book which thwarting potential IPOs include heightened corporate governance and information disclosure demands.

“Listing firms must qualify for strict requirements of governance and board structure, which require close-knit relationship among investors. Furthermore, all Singaporean-listed firms will have to ensure that independent directors make up one-third of their board seats,” said Phan.

Market watchdogs also remain cautious since those rules, seeking to enhance board quality and diversify, have not been popular among Vietnamese firms just yet.

Currently, the local legal framework associated with overseas listing has been updated via Decree No.58/2012/ND-CP and Decree No.60/2015/ND-CP released in 2012 and 2015, respectively.

“Market regulators want to help Vietnamese firms selling their stakes and list abroad as we all acknowledge this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for them to access the global financial market,” explained Ta Thanh Binh, director of the Market Development Department under the State Securities Commission.

According to Decree 58, firms still need to follow Vietnamese listing rules if they want a dual listing in Vietnam and abroad. For some company founders, the added burdens of a dual IPO, including public regulatory filings, dent the appeal of a listing.

Challenges still colour the landscape, and vary for each company, spanning different factors such as transactions, payments, or information disclosure.

“Foreign public markets force more financial disciplines, which Vietnam’s standards often lag behind,” said Phan Dung Khanh, investment director at Maybank Kim Eng Securities. “For instance, firms have to comply with the specific disclosure requirements prescribed in International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS), but vast differences between local and global standards might pose a challenge for domestic firms.”

Dang Xuan Canh, managing partner at consultancy RSM Vietnam added, “Many accountants in Vietnamese companies are not yet trained to switch to IFRS, because their undergraduate study does not meet the level yet.”

The aborted deals of Vinamilk, VNG, Hoang AnhGia Lai, and Petrolimex have been seen as a signal that the high valuations companies have built up in public or private ownership will not stand up to the scrutiny of global public markets.

Minh from VNG admitted that his firm requires significant time and effort to meet strict criteria on shared liquidity, financial health, and corporate governance. For a Vietnamese firm, this seems to be a long and arduous task.

“The excitement at prospects of Vietnamese companies hitting overseas public markets is nowhere to be seen, and listing plans could receive a poor reception from world-class public markets, at least over the next two or three years,” noted Phan from CMA Australia. VIR

Luu Huong 

VN banks’ profits from foreign exchange trading dwindling

VN banks’ profits from foreign exchange trading dwindling

One thing that stands out in many banks’ third quarter reports is the sharp drop in profits from foreign exchange trading activities.

Banks in Vietnam see decline in foreign exchange trading results

Banks in Vietnam see decline in foreign exchange trading results

Q3 finance reports show that a series of banks had unsatisfactory results in foreign exchange trading or took losses.

 
 

Other News

.
FTAs momentum for Vietnam's exports
FTAs momentum for Vietnam's exports
BUSINESSicon  24/11/2021 

Since joining the World Trade Organisation 15 years ago, Viet Nam has become a part of 17 FTAs, which are either under negotiation or underway. This has helped create a momentum for the country's exports.

Textile - garment industry may flourish in 2022: insiders
Textile - garment industry may flourish in 2022: insiders
BUSINESSicon  24/11/2021 

The textile - garment industry is expected to thrive and earn 40 billion USD in exports next year, when the COVID-19 pandemic is forecast to ease in Vietnam and the world.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS NOVEMBER 23
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS NOVEMBER 23
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2021 

Demand for industrial, logistics estates at core of enquiries next year: Savills

Enterprises of agricultural export to China strive to adapt to new market regulations after COVID-19 impacts
Enterprises of agricultural export to China strive to adapt to new market regulations after COVID-19 impacts
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2021 

China's increasing demand for imports of high-quality agricultural products has contributed to boosting the recovery of domestic production and export after the COVID-19 pandemic impacts.

Vietnam - US trade likely to reach 100 billion USD this year
Vietnam - US trade likely to reach 100 billion USD this year
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2021 

Vietnam–US trade could hit 100 billion USD in this year, up 221 times against the figure in 1995 when the two countries normalised relations.

Special working groups set up to speed up public disbursement
Special working groups set up to speed up public disbursement
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2021 

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has decided to establish six working groups to accelerate the disbursement of public investment capital in 2021 at ministries, agencies and localities.

Vietnamese investors pour money into realty bonds despite China’s Evergrande case
Vietnamese investors pour money into realty bonds despite China’s Evergrande case
FEATUREicon  24/11/2021 

Realty bonds often catch special attention in the primary market thanks to attractive interest rates, even though warnings are often issued about their risks.

Vietnam Airlines to fly non-stop to US
Vietnam Airlines to fly non-stop to US
FEATUREicon  24/11/2021 

The first commercial flight from HCM City to the West Coast of the US is scheduled to take off on November 28, 2021. Vietnam Airlines’ CEO Le Hong Ha talks about the opening of the special air route.

Enterprises of agricultural export to China strive to adapt to new market regulations after COVID-19 impacts
Enterprises of agricultural export to China strive to adapt to new market regulations after COVID-19 impacts
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2021 

China's increasing demand for imports of high-quality agricultural products has contributed to boosting the recovery of domestic production and export after the COVID-19 pandemic impacts.

Petrol, animal feed, fertilizer prices cause higher production costs
Petrol, animal feed, fertilizer prices cause higher production costs
FEATUREicon  23/11/2021 

The increase in price of fuels and input materials of many products has occurred in 2021. Notably, the price fever of many commodities has not shown any signs of "cooling down".

Vietnam eyes 4 GW offshore wind power capacity by 2030
Vietnam eyes 4 GW offshore wind power capacity by 2030
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2021 

Vietnam will increase offshore wind power capacity to 4 GW from 1 GW and onshore wind power capacity to nearly 17.34 GW from about 1.26 GW by 2030, according to the latest draft of the National Power Development Plan VIII.

Use of Fintech services rises 3.5 times in 4 years in Vietnam
Use of Fintech services rises 3.5 times in 4 years in Vietnam
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2021 

In only four years, the rate of Vietnamese using services of Fintech companies has increased from 16% to 56%. 

Garment and textile exports likely to reach US$38 billion this year
Garment and textile exports likely to reach US$38 billion this year
BUSINESSicon  23/11/2021 

With export turnover surging by 11% to reach approximately US$32 billion during the past 10 months of the year, the local garment and textile industry is anticipated to rake in roughly US$38 billion this year.

Banks await more foreign strategic investors
Banks await more foreign strategic investors
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2021 

Several banks are currently issuing dividend paying shares as well as making strong efforts in finding more foreign strategic investors to increase capital. 

Famous businesswomen meet in prison because of land irregularities
Famous businesswomen meet in prison because of land irregularities
FEATUREicon  23/11/2021 

Nguyen Thi Loan, Chau Thi Thu Nga, Pham Thi Tuyet Nhung and Truong Thi Kim Soan, once famous businesswomen in the real estate market, have had to pay for their illegal business affairs.

Trading value at stock market reaches record high
Trading value at stock market reaches record high
FEATUREicon  22/11/2021 

Cash keeps flowing into the stock market, including during trading sessions when the VN Index falls.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS NOVEMBER 22
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS NOVEMBER 22
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2021 

Vietnamese Ambassador to Australia Nguyen Tat Thanh attended a ceremony to inaugurate the Vietnam-Australia Trade and Investment Promotion Centre on November 20.

Vietnam's import-export revenue forecast to hit new record in 2021
Vietnam's import-export revenue forecast to hit new record in 2021
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2021 

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) has forecast that total import-export revenue this year may reach a new record, at between 640 - 645 billion USD, with a slight trade deficit.

Vietnam – RoK Industrial Park to take shape in Hung Yen
Vietnam – RoK Industrial Park to take shape in Hung Yen
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2021 

The northern province of Hung Yen has issued a decision on the establishment of the Vietnam – Republic of Korea Economic Cooperation Industrial Park (IP).

Land prices rise in suburban Hanoi due to planning rumours
Land prices rise in suburban Hanoi due to planning rumours
BUSINESSicon  22/11/2021 

The Hanoi property market is once again seeing a wave of increased land prices in suburban areas, thanks to rumours of some districts being developed under the model of "city within a city".

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN