Tax payers have right to appeal audit decisions: NA deputies

Tax payers can appeal the decisions of State audit agencies if they believe the decisions are illegal or harmful to their operation, National Assembly deputies said on Friday.

Tax payers have right to appeal audit decisions: NA deputies
Minister of Finance Dinh Tien Dung discusses the draft on amended Law of Tax Management at the 14th National Assembly's seventh meeting.

Tax payers can also sue the State audit agencies for making those decisions, NA deputy Nguyen Huu Cau said at a debate of the 14th National Assembly’s seventh meeting.

Such suits would comply with the amended law for the Law of Audit 2015, according to Cau.

Under the draft Law of Tax Management, the State audit agency must send a request to the tax payer so tax is collected when the agency carries out its duties at the tax department.

If anything is found against the rules and the tax payer disagrees with the request, the tax payer may appeal the decision.

Then the tax department is required to re-calculate the tax they should be paying.

However, the process outlined in the draft law disables the State audit agency’s decision and jurisdiction, which goes against the Constitution and the Law of Audit 2015 on the legality of the audit reports and decisions.

The rules clearly state the report or decision of the State audit is binding, Cau said.

If those being audited disagree with the decision, they have the right to appeal and the decision maker – the State audit – must be bound to that decision, not the tax department, he said.

He suggested policy makers reconsider the draft. If the State audit agency disagrees on a tax payer’s duties, the tax department must issue a decision based on the State audit’s opinions. Then the State audit will follow the process of tax collection and appeal.

Cau also said the State Inspectorate should be held more accountable in tax collection so there is no room for personal interests in enforcing the Law of Tax Management.

 

However, allowing the State Inspectorate to deal with tax collection wrongdoings may be complicated, deputy Nguyen Truong Giang said.

“What the State Audit and the State Inspectorate do is under the Law of Audit and the Law of Inspection, not the Law of Tax Management,” Giang said.

The two State agencies do not focus on tax collection and management only, so binding the two agencies to this draft law may be overlap their duties, he added.

According to Minister of Finance Dinh Tien Dung, the decision of the State audit agency is binding, but not administrative and the State Audit of Vietnam is the final level to handle appeals.

Tax payers often appeal the decisions of the tax departments, not the State audit and inspection agencies, he said.

Tax delays

Some deputies wanted to raise penalties for delaying tax payments from 0.03 per cent per day to 0.05-1.5 per cent per day.

They expressed concern that the 0.03 per cent penalty rate is too low compared to some banks’ interest rates and businesses can take advantage of this.

But the National Assembly Standing Committee proposed deputies keep the current penalty rate to foster the development of businesses, especially as the global economy has encountered some negative developments in the last two years.

According to deputy Duong Minh Tuan, the penalty rate should be raised, to at least level with bank interest rates, so that businesses cannot save the money, which is supposed to be paid at the tax department, for some returns.

“That action would be unfair for those strictly following the rules,” he said. “There should be separate regulations for that businesses that want tax exemption or reduction.”— VNS

 
 

Other News

.
Some service businesses are thriving amid Covid-19 crisis
Some service businesses are thriving amid Covid-19 crisis
BUSINESSicon  20/02/2020 

While many industries have suffered from Covid-19 epidemic, taxi drivers and shippers are earning more money.

Govt’s new decree removes barriers to automobile imports
Govt’s new decree removes barriers to automobile imports
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

Automobile importers in Vietnam will no longer have to obtain a Vehicle Type Approval (VTA) certificate from authorities in exporting countries, making it easier for them to import cars into the country.

VN investment inflow below expectations after CPTPP
VN investment inflow below expectations after CPTPP
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

A year since the CPTPP came into force, trade between Viet Nam and other members of the trade deal had posted significant gains, but the potential to expand remained large, according to the Ministry of Industry and Trade.

VN central bank makes net cash withdrawal amidst high inflation pressure
VN central bank makes net cash withdrawal amidst high inflation pressure
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

The State Bank of Vietnam made a net cash withdrawal worth VND86 trillion out of the economy through open market operations (OMO) from January 20 to February 14.

Real estate businesses ask VN Government to remove difficulties
Real estate businesses ask VN Government to remove difficulties
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

The Vietnam Real Estate Association (VNREA) will next month propose solutions to Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc to remove difficulties in administrative procedures, capital and cut loan interest for real estate businesses.

Farm produce prices slump as Covid-19 hits exports
Farm produce prices slump as Covid-19 hits exports
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

The suspension of trade in seafood and agriculture products at some northern border gates with China as a measure against the novel coronavirus (Covid-19) has caused a demand-supply imbalance in the market.

PM tells sugar firms it's time to sink or swim
PM tells sugar firms it's time to sink or swim
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

The sugar industry will have greater development opportunities if it can re-organise itself more effectively, Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc said at a meeting on Tuesday.

FDI in Vietnam expected to surge after the epidemic
FDI in Vietnam expected to surge after the epidemic
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

 As a major foreign investment hub, China is hit hard by the new strain of coronavirus, now known as Covid-19, but this also provides an opportunity for other countries to accelerate efforts to attract new foreign investment.

Van Don approved to develop into entertainment hub with casino
Van Don approved to develop into entertainment hub with casino
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc has approved Van Don District in the northern province of Quang Ninh as a multisectoral sea economic zone and entertainment hub that will include a casino.

Covid-19 takes toll on small, large firms
Covid-19 takes toll on small, large firms
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

The novel coronavirus, now officially named Covid-19, has dealt a blow to both small and large firms.

Coronavirus hits supply chains of U.S. firms in Vietnam: AmCham Survey
Coronavirus hits supply chains of U.S. firms in Vietnam: AmCham Survey
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

A number of U.S.-invested firms in Vietnam suffering supply chain complications have deep concerns about the economic impact of the novel coronavirus, or Covid-19, a survey of American Chamber of Commerce (AmCham) members indicated.

Coronavirus may lower Vietnam’s State budget by VND42.3 trillion: ministry
Coronavirus may lower Vietnam’s State budget by VND42.3 trillion: ministry
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

The State budget may face a shortfall of some VND42.3 trillion (US$1.8 billion) this year due to the ongoing spread of the novel coronavirus, or Covid-19, according to the Ministry of Planning and Investment.

Le Hoang Diep Thao no longer Trung Nguyen shareholder
Le Hoang Diep Thao no longer Trung Nguyen shareholder
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

Dang Le Nguyen Vu, founding chairman and general director of Vietnamese coffee giant Trung Nguyen Group, has bought all the group shares held by his ex-wife, Le Hoang Diep Thao, so she is no longer a shareholder of the group.

Eight business fields to suffer most from Covid-19
Eight business fields to suffer most from Covid-19
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

Three major scenarios for economic development in 2020 have been drawn up by Can Van Luc and researchers from BIDV.

How will exchange rate and interest rate be affected amid Covid-19 outbreak?
How will exchange rate and interest rate be affected amid Covid-19 outbreak?
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

SSI Research says the financial market in 2020 will be unpredictable and much less active than the forecasts released at the end of 2019.

Ride-hailing cars must display taxi signs
Ride-hailing cars must display taxi signs
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

All cars providing passenger transportation services via ride-hailing applications will be treated like taxis from the beginning of April, when the pilot project for tech-based cars ends.

Clearer legal framework on certifying condotel and officetel projects
Clearer legal framework on certifying condotel and officetel projects
BUSINESSicon  19/02/2020 

The MoNRE has just issued a document to guide land-use regimes and ownership certification of non-residential construction, including condotel and officetel.

Hanoi hands out red books to foreigners
Hanoi hands out red books to foreigners
BUSINESSicon  18/02/2020 

Six foreign organisations and 35 foreigners were granted red books to purchase a number of apartments in Hanoi.

HSBC signals mass job cuts as profits plunge
HSBC signals mass job cuts as profits plunge
BUSINESSicon  18/02/2020 

Interim chief executive Noel Quinn reveals extensive job cuts and restructuring to shake up the bank.

Coronavirus triggers boom in private jet inquiries
Coronavirus triggers boom in private jet inquiries
BUSINESSicon  18/02/2020 

Private jet firms have seen a huge rise in people hoping to hire planes but they can't meet demand.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN