Wading through current condotel entanglements

The condotel market has been stagnant for the last two years and many developers are falling on hard times. Kevin B. Hawkins, co-executive partner from Zico Law Vietnam, offers suggestions to help developers in the country cope.

wading through current condotel entanglements

Investors and buyers will be much aided through more stringent regulations regarding the condotel segment

Over the past couple of years, we have witnessed the identification and attempts to solve the condotel issue in Vietnam with limited success.

There has been confusion over the term “condotel” and what it really means in practice.

The prime minister issued a directive in April 2019, charging various ministries with developing clear regulations and procedures with respect to the condotel market, urging the resolution of the condotel issue by the third quarter of last year.

However, we still do not have any clear guidelines. Unfortunately, the situation has actually become worse.

Developers have seen projects stall, condotel sales have dropped considerably, and buyers are seeing their promised revenue streams evaporate as developers renege on their promises to pay 10 per cent (or more) per annum.

These buyers then face even more hardships trying to make mortgage payments based on the expectation of such income. Serious problems require a serious call to action.

I will set out five potential actions to help unravel this tangle and move forward. These actions are by no means exhaustive and not all of these are legal measures – some are just practical steps – but all require some measure of political will and public fortitude in order help solve the condotel problem.

What’s in a name?

For condotels, the short answer is “everything:”

Condotels are commonly thought to refer to the combination of condominium and hotel. The problem here is that while a condominium is often thought to refer to a titled property, a hotel is a hospitality service provider.

The simplicity of this definition underscores the inherent problem of how it should be regulated – as a property interest or as an investment in the hospitality sector.

A specific law, or even a government decree, needs to define condotels and delineate it and other similar investments such that condotels only refer to actual titled properties within a resort project that also has the right to sell residential housing.

For all other cases where the resort/hotel only has a service licence and therefore limited operations period (for example 50 years), these should be “non-condotel” investments.

These may be referred to as investment participation properties (IPP) and could include: (a) membership in hotel clubs which provides the buyer the right to use a condo or villa in a resort for a certain number of days each year; (b) usage rights attached to a specific condo/villa in a resort with a share in the revenue stream of the condo/villa; and (c) long-term lease of a condo/villa in a resort with the investor receiving a revenue stream from the rental income from placing the unit in the hotel’s rental pool (essentially, a sub-lease).

Note that the third option is not available to foreign investors, who would not have the right to sub-lease such a lease agreement. Legislation that would make this distinction clear may help to resolve the confusion and improper use of this term to the detriment of both buyers and developers.

Full disclosure of the investment and the rights and obligations of buyers and developers will ensure a more efficient market for both condotel and IPP products.

A condotel is not a camel

There is a familiar aphorism that a camel is just a horse designed by a committee, criticising the process by which inputs from various committee members result in an awkward, ungainly, and possibly ugly creature compared to the intended sleek, agile, and beautiful stallion that we might find adorning the hood of a Ferrari.

Although the prime minister’s directive issued last April was well intended, it assigned ministries various obligations to resolve the issue.

The Ministry of Construction (MoC) was supposed to provide “amendments to regulations and standards for construction”, the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment (MoNRE) was charged with “amending the land use regime” and issuing land use right certificates for properties like condotels, and the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism (MCST) was directed to “promulgate regulations on the sale and management of condotels”, with the MoC taking the lead in co-ordinating and “urging and checking the implementation” of the prime minister’s directive. With this combination of authorities, each vying to have input into the final result, it is no surprise that the third quarter of 2019 deadline went past without any final solution.

 

It may be that the government or the National Assembly need to elevate this issue for it to be resolved with a law or decree that will specifically detail a framework for condotels and other IPPs, and assign relevant authorities with responsibilities for their respective obligations, for example the MoNRE for condotels and the MCST for IPPs. Only with a clear delineation of supervisory responsibilities will this market move forward with better regulation.

Unrealistic expectations

If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. It is often alluring to see advertisements for condotel projects where the developer is offering “guaranteed” annual returns of 10 per cent or more.

For most investors, this return on investment within 10 years while still retaining rights to the underlying asset property seems very attractive. If the investor can obtain bank financing for rates under the promised return then this is truly a win-win investment.

The problem here is that these promised returns are not really guaranteed and are contractual obligations, which may be difficult to actually enforce if necessary.

The recent case of Cocobay Danang is a prime example, where the developer has already reneged on its obligation to make such payments to buyers. This case is occurring with other developers who over-promised to entice buyers and now cannot pay these returns. This has had a chilling effect on the market with buyers losing trust and developers then unable to sell units.

Developers need to restore trust in the process. Before the Law on Real Estate Business (REB) came into effect in 2015, there was a loss of confidence in the apartment construction sector.

Apartments were being sold off the plan, before certain construction milestones had been achieved and there was no guarantee for the amounts advanced by buyers to developers. Projects went unfinished and developers absconded with advance payments.

Aside from required construction milestones, Article 56 of the REB law requires that developers obtain a bank guarantee for the amounts paid in advance by buyers. If the developer cannot complete the project, then the bank guarantee could be drawn upon to return the funds to the buyers.

If such a bank guarantee obligation was included in the law/decree to regulate condotels and IPPs supporting the promised returns to investors then there should be renewed confidence in the process. However, the cost of such a measure may be difficult for developers to shoulder, who may need to reconsider both the rates of returns and the period for payments. Restoring confidence and trust is essential to moving the market forward.

The anecdotal accounts from condotel investors all seem to have the same thread: the investor relied upon the promised guaranteed returns from the developer in order to finance the purchase with a mortgage.

Once the developer cancelled the expected revenue stream, the investor is no longer able to afford mortgage payments and is liable to the bank for the borrowed amount. This is because Vietnam’s civil law allows for such mortgage obligations to be a full recourse against the borrower, as per articles 305(3) and 307(3) of the Civil Code 2015.

This is different from mortgages in most western countries, which are non-recourse, and only allow the bank to step in and satisfy the loan obligation by selling the property asset.

For the IPP cases mentioned, where the bank is not taking an interest in the underlying property but rather on the promised income return from the developer, this financing could be considered. With the suggested bank guarantee obligation to be included in a revised law, there should be little risk for the banks to lend on such basis.

It may not be common for many property buyers in Vietnam to engage legal counsel to review their documentation and advise them of the risks and obligations.

However, just because a famous football player endorses a particular project as a great place to live should not be the basis of a significant financial investment. Buyers should alter their practice and factor-in the relatively small cost of having their investment and documents reviewed by a lawyer before entering into any firm commitment.

Dialogue needs to move forward and legislation needs to be put in place to regulate the market and restore confidence of buyers and developers alike.

On February 14, the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment officially issued a guideline to local authorities on providing ownership for condotels in Vietnam with a lifespan of 50 to 70 years. This guideline was crafted over the past two years, and officially ratifies condotels as one of the products of the real estate market.

The guideline was based on the Law on Tourism 2017, the Law on Land, and Circular No.27/2018/TT-BTNMT dated December 2018, stipulating that service purposed land (which condotels are built on) are permitted to be leased in 50 years and could be extended to 70 years for large-scale projects situated in difficult localities.

The ministry also released the procedure process for ownership certificate granting. It requested all related local departments to review all condotel projects in the locality. For those which have sufficient dossiers, submissions for ownership can now begin. VIR

Owners of Cocobay Da Nang condotels propose solution to profit problem

Owners of Cocobay Da Nang condotels propose solution to profit problem

 Many owners of units at the Cocobay Da Nang condotel project have proposed to convert profits owed by Thanh Do Company into land or houses at Cocobay, according to a statement from Thanh Do.  

Condotel investment risky yet promising property segment

Condotel investment risky yet promising property segment

Investment in condotels remains appealing despite defaults in profit commitments by property developers, but a clear legal framework is needed to protect investors’ rights, according to experts.

 
 

Other News

.
Beauty queens gather in Hanoi
Beauty queens gather in Hanoi
BUSINESSicon  30/03/2021 

The two runner-ups, Tu Anh and Huyen My, joined Miss Vietnam World Ngo Phuong Lan, actors Huynh Anh, Doan Quoc Dam and actress Diem Hang at a recent event in Hanoi.

Need for digital transformation personnel sees sharp rise: report
Need for digital transformation personnel sees sharp rise: report
BUSINESSicon  27/03/2021 

As firms are accelerating digital transformation, the need for information technology (IT)-related roles, namely data engineer, infrastructure engineer, or chief technology officer (CTO), is also rising significantly.

MIC focusing on popularising Mobile Money
MIC focusing on popularising Mobile Money
BUSINESSicon  27/03/2021 

The successful implementation of Mobile Money is one of the major targets of the Ministry of Information and Communications (MIC).

Private sector unable to create necessary value chain
Private sector unable to create necessary value chain
BUSINESSicon  26/03/2021 

Vietnamese enterprises are facing setbacks and obstacles in the process to build value chains, which are essential for growth, healthy competition and more export opportunities in foreign markets.

Mobile money attempts to topple classic banking
Mobile money attempts to topple classic banking
BUSINESSicon  27/03/2021 

The newly-launched mobile money pilot programme is expected to heat up competition for domestic players but also open collaboration opportunities to cash in on the niche market.

New phase on horizon for solar power development
New phase on horizon for solar power development
BUSINESSicon  28/03/2021 

Vietnam, a rising star in Asia in solar power development, is to slash feed-in tariffs for rooftop solar installations this month, 

Land speculation continues, realtors incur big losses
Land speculation continues, realtors incur big losses
BUSINESSicon  28/03/2021 

A leading Vietnamese real estate developer has reported an additional loss of tens of billions of dong, raising its total loss in 2020 to VND500 billion, though land prices are escalating all over the country.

Bridging the tech-led links in investment
Bridging the tech-led links in investment
BUSINESSicon  28/03/2021 

Although Vietnam has been improving its business and investment environment significantly throughout the last four decades, the cooperation between domestic and foreign-invested companies could be much improved.

Ministry aiming to collect taxes from e-commerce sellers
Ministry aiming to collect taxes from e-commerce sellers
BUSINESSicon  26/03/2021 

The Ministry of Finance has asked digital-based businesses and delivery service companies to provide information about e-commerce sellers using their platforms and services so they can be taxed.

Vietnam GDP growth set to rebound to 6.6% in 2021: WB
Vietnam GDP growth set to rebound to 6.6% in 2021: WB
BUSINESSicon  27/03/2021 

Vietnam and China are the only two economies in East Asia and Pacific experiencing a V-shaped rebound where output has already surpassed pre-pandemic levels.

Wind power overdevelopment faces risks
Wind power overdevelopment faces risks
BUSINESSicon  27/03/2021 

Sharing the same fate as solar power, sales of wind power in Vietnam are expected to be difficult because of "severe excess electricity" at some point in time.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS MARCH 27
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS MARCH 27
BUSINESSicon  27/03/2021 

Programme supporting enterprises in optimising opportunities from EVFTA debuts

Gardener confirms mutant orchid transaction, promises to pay tax
Gardener confirms mutant orchid transaction, promises to pay tax
BUSINESSicon  26/03/2021 

Bui Huu Thanh, the owner of the mutant orchid garden, said that he has actually sold a Ngoc Son Cuoc mutant orchid for VND250 billion following reports that the transaction was fake.

Trade deficit with China grows as imports soar
Trade deficit with China grows as imports soar
BUSINESSicon  26/03/2021 

The value of Chinese imports in the first months of 2021 alone reached $15.42 billion, twice as much as the value of Vietnamese exports to the market.

Regional tensions throwing investing trajectory up in air
Regional tensions throwing investing trajectory up in air
BUSINESSicon  25/03/2021 

Political stability has been seen as one of the main reasons for Vietnam’s success in recent years in terms of attracting foreign investment. 

Investors forced to wait on HSX technical upgrades
Investors forced to wait on HSX technical upgrades
BUSINESSicon  25/03/2021 

However, despite the vast potential of the equity market, the ongoing technical outages at the HSX have lowered investors’ appetite, as their buy and sell orders rarely match up.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS MARCH 26
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS MARCH 26
BUSINESSicon  26/03/2021 

Anti-dumping investigations launched into imported welding material products

Female tycoon leaves post, daughter makes US$1 billion
Female tycoon leaves post, daughter makes US$1 billion
BUSINESSicon  25/03/2021 

Southeast Asia Commercial Joint Stock Bank (SeABank) on March 24 listed more than 1.2 billion SSB shares on the Ho Chi Minh Stock Exchange - HOSE (HSX) with the reference price of VND16,800 per share and the price range of +/- 20%.

Agencies, local authorities give back tens of trillions of VND
Agencies, local authorities give back tens of trillions of VND
BUSINESSicon  25/03/2021 

Ten ministries and agencies, as well as 45 localities, are giving back the capital allocated to them as they did not spend all the money they received in 2020.

Five suburban districts to become inner districts, land price soars
Five suburban districts to become inner districts, land price soars
FEATUREicon  25/03/2021 

The plan to turn some suburban districts in HCM City into inner districts is only on paper but it has triggered a new land fever in localities.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN