Was Taylor Swift really banned from playing her hits?

Taylor's label can't stop her performing her own songs. The problem comes when she puts them online.

"I don't know what else to do," declared Taylor Swift in a lengthy Twitter post last week. "I just want to be able to perform my own music."

The star was distressed and upset. She wanted to play a medley of her hits at Sunday's American Music Awards but her old record label had forbidden it.

Or so she claimed. The label hit back with a statement of its own, saying it hadn't tried to stop the show and that Swift's narrative "does not exist".

Insults were traded, politicians weighed in and, eventually, a settlement was reached.

Big Machine Records issued a statement on Monday night saying it had agreed "to grant all licences of their artists' performances" for "the upcoming American Music Awards".

It didn't mention Swift by name but the implication was clear: Her performance could go ahead.

But the second half of the statement was the really interesting part.

"It should be noted," said the label, "that recording artists do not need label approval for live performances on television or any other live media.

"Record label approval is only needed for contracted artists' audio and visual recordings and in determining how those works are distributed."

In other words, Swift never needed permission to play hits like Shake It Off, Love Story or I Knew You Were Trouble at the AMAs (in any case, performance rights belong to the publisher, not the record label).

What she couldn't do was put them online afterwards. And that matters.

Last year, 6.5 million viewers tuned in watch the AMAs on television, down from 9.15 million a year earlier, but clips from the show went viral.

Cardi B's carnivalesque performance of I Like It has racked up 28m views on YouTube alone, for example - making that platform more valuable to her as an artist than the TV broadcast itself.

Taylor Swift obviously wants her performance archived online, too... but that's where things get tricky.

"If Taylor was performing her own songs live at a festival, which wasn't being broadcast, it wouldn't be a problem," leading music and entertainment lawyer Talya Shalson tells the BBC.

"The issue in this situation is that, as it's a recorded performance, that would effectively be a re-recording" of the star's biggest hits.

"It's very common for labels to put in a re-recording restriction, which normally lasts three or five years after the end of the artist's deal," she explains.

Such a clause prevents the artist from taking their songs, recording them again and delivering them to another label, allowing the original rights-holder to "protect its investments".

A crucial bit of background to this story: Swift fell out with Big Machine in June this year, after the label was bought by Justin Bieber and Ariana Grande's manager Scooter Braun for $300 million.

 

Swift made no secret of her dismay. One of Braun's on-and-off clients is Kanye West, who has tormented Swift for more than a decade, interrupting her at award shows, disparaging her in his songs and putting a waxwork of her naked body into a music video.

Swift believes Braun encouraged and endorsed some of those actions, which is why she issued an impassioned statement this summer, saying she felt "sad and grossed out" by Braun taking control of her back catalogue, including every album she released up to 2017's Reputation.

She called the deal "my worst case scenario" that "stripped me of my life's work"; but later announced plans to re-record all of her old music, undercutting the value of the master tapes held by Braun and his investment company Ithaca Holdings.

Speaking to Good Morning America over the summer, she revealed the process would begin next year.

"My contract says that starting November 2020, I can record albums one through five all over again," she said.

"I think it's important for artists to own their work," she continued. "I'm gonna be busy, I'm very excited."

(Coincidentally, she played Shake It Off during the same TV appearance, apparently without any restrictions from Big Machine.)

Swift wouldn't be the first artist to record "forgeries" of their biggest hits: TLC, Prince and Def Leppard have all used the tactic to regain control of their music.

But her plans apparently spurred last week's tussle. In her initial statement, Swift said she'd been told the AMA medley could go ahead if she "agreed not to record copycat versions of my songs next year".

As leverage, Big Machine seemed willing to classify any archive of the performance as a "new master recording", putting Swift in breach of her contract.

But that is a "technical argument" which "to my knowledge, is not a position that a label has taken before," says music industry lawyer Susan Genco.

She describes Big Machine's original stance as "counter-intuitive and against the label's interest" because, if millions of people see Swift play on Sunday, they're likely to go out and stream her back catalogue, boosting the label's profits.

In that light, the decision to halt the performance seems misguided at best; vindictive at worst.

It's an ugly story, and one that's as old as the music industry itself: A young artist signs a restrictive contract at the start of their career, and only becomes aware of the consequences when it's too late.

In this case, Swift was able to mobilise her fans, who paid to erect #IStandWithTaylor billboards outside Big Machine's offices in Nashville; and the media, who covered the fall-out in blow-by-blow detail, until she got the outcome she wanted (although a planned Netflix documentary is still in dispute).

As an added bonus, a lot more people now know that Swift is performing at the American Music Awards this weekend, where she is due to receive the Artist Of The Decade award.

As Van Morrison once put it: "Music is spiritual. The music business is not."

Follow us on Facebook, or on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts. If you have a story suggestion email. BBC

 
 

Other News

.
Ao dai through the lens of Russian photographer
Ao dai through the lens of Russian photographer
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  23/03/2021 

Ao dai (Vietnamese traditional dress) brings out the elegance and strength of Vietnamese women, and it always leaves a strong impression on Russians, said Vera Mazhirina, a Russian journalist and photographer.

A self-portrait of painter Le Pho auctioned for one million dollars
A self-portrait of painter Le Pho auctioned for one million dollars
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  23/03/2021 

The painting “Autoportrait dans la forêt” (A self-portrait in the forest) by Le Pho (1907-2001) fetched over one million dollars at an auction at Sotheby's, Paris on March 16.

VN marksmen to miss 2021 Olympics
VN marksmen to miss 2021 Olympics
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  22/03/2021 

Vietnamese shooters failed to win a card to the 2021 Olympics in the final qualifying round of the World Shooting Cup.

Cai luong theatre offers new projects
Cai luong theatre offers new projects
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  22/03/2021 

HCM City’s Tran Huu Trang Theatre in co-operation with its partner, the city’s Department of Culture, Sports and Tourism, will launch two projects offering cai luong shows in the city and neighbouring provinces next month. 

Swimmers compete at home, hope to win Olympic berths
Swimmers compete at home, hope to win Olympic berths
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  22/03/2021 

Vietnamese swimmers will have A chance to earn their Olympics slots this May.

Entertainment News on March 22-28
Entertainment News on March 22-28
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  22/03/2021 

MUSIC & PERFORMANCES

Love praised at festival in Thanh Hoa
Love praised at festival in Thanh Hoa
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  22/03/2021 

A festival to celebrate love and marriage will be held in the central coastal city of Sam Son of Thanh Hoa Province by local authorities as a special tourism product for the locality.

The 200km journey of a world chess champion
The 200km journey of a world chess champion
FEATUREicon  22/03/2021 

Nguyen Thien Ngan, 10th grader at Chu Van An High School, Thai Nguyen Province, has earned people’s admiration for winning nearly 180 medals after nine years of competition.

Victorious artist: 40 years as a woman in disguise
Victorious artist: 40 years as a woman in disguise
FEATUREicon  21/03/2021 

Every Lunar New year, a man impersonates a traditionally dressed woman and immerses himself in a ritual dance to pray for blessings for everyone.

A “phenomenon” of modern literature passes away
A “phenomenon” of modern literature passes away
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  21/03/2021 

Writer Nguyen Huy Thiep, who has been considered a phenomenon of Vietnamese literature passed away on Sunday at his home in Hanoi. He was 71.

Ceramic buffalo sculptures feature traditional culture
Ceramic buffalo sculptures feature traditional culture
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  21/03/2021 

A collection of ceramic sculptures, “Buffalo garden,” by artisan Tran Nam Tuoc features the traditional culture and also reminds a familiar image of the animal in Buddhist meditation.

Hanoi’s sleeping beauty awakens
Hanoi’s sleeping beauty awakens
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  20/03/2021 

Aficionados of Hanoi who love and care about Vietnam’s age-old architecture have been enthralled over the last week after hearing of a beautifully-preserved mansion in the capital’s Ngoc Ha Village.

Keeping culture, language and song alive
Keeping culture, language and song alive
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  21/03/2021 

“I just hope for good health so that I can continue pursuing my passion for preserving the traditional culture of the ethnic San Diu people.”

Bodily limits overcome by creativity
Bodily limits overcome by creativity
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  20/03/2021 

There is no limit on creativity and no disadvantage could ever prevent you from being creative, and you need to look no further than Trieu Hong Ho Em from Cho Moi District in the Mekong Delta’s An Giang Province for an example of how true that is.

Young artists reinvigorate traditional theatre
Young artists reinvigorate traditional theatre
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  20/03/2021 

Young artists in traditional music and theatre are working to develop and promote their art among young audiences in HCM City. 

“Cultural” stairs in Hanoi
“Cultural” stairs in Hanoi
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  19/03/2021 

The stair has been a familiar gathering spot of the building’s residents, both the old and the young, after work and school.

HCM City museums launch apps for viewing exhibitions
HCM City museums launch apps for viewing exhibitions
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  19/03/2021 

Museums in HCM City are using smart technology to offer online displays as part of their effort to develop business amid the COVID-19 pandemic. 

Vietnamese representative chosen among top seven hot picks by Missosology
Vietnamese representative chosen among top seven hot picks by Missosology
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  19/03/2021 

As the world’s leading publication on beauty pageants, Missosology has named Vietnamese contestant Do Thi Ha among its top seven hot picks for the upcoming Miss World 2021 pageant.

A life-changing trip leads to a new direction for Magda
A life-changing trip leads to a new direction for Magda
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  19/03/2021 

Magda Nowicka, originally from Poland, resigned from her job as a food and beverage manager in the UK and travelled for three years in Asia before moving to Vietnam.

Marksman Tran Quoc Cuong shoots for Olympic slot in India
Marksman Tran Quoc Cuong shoots for Olympic slot in India
ENTERTAINMENT & SPORTSicon  18/03/2021 

Marksman Tran Quoc Cuong is aiming for an Olympic berth in shooting at the World Cup tournament in India.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN