Administrative reform: Personnel is the key

Another cycle of state administrative reform is coming. This is the time to review the results of the administrative reform program in the 2011-2020 period and set the orientation for the next decade.

Administrative reform: Personnel is the key

Public administration reform (PAR) is a process for all stakeholders from the public and non-public sectors. In the past decade, there were many systems to monitor the performance of the government apparatus at central and local levels, managed by organizations, associations, and non-governmental organizations, contributing to a push to improve public service efficiency.

Attempts to increase rankings

The chart below shows the change from zero to many measures to help government agencies at all levels examine themselves over time.

The indexes contributing to the change of local public service governance and provision include the Provincial Competitiveness Index (PCI) of the Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry (VCCI), the Provincial Governance and Public Administration Performance Index (PAPI) of UNDP and its partners in Vietnam.

Timeline of public performance evaluation indicators

In addition, many international indicators are contributing to promoting innovation in Vietnam. The country is making great efforts to increase its position in international rankings in the spirit of Resolution 02/NQ-CP on performing main tasks and solutions to improve the business environment and enhance national competitiveness in 2020.

Indicators such as the UN's e-government index, the UNDP's human development index, and the World Bank's business environment are being periodically monitored by Vietnam.

Facing the requirement to strengthen national competitiveness and the task of realizing the goals set out in the state administrative reform program, the administrative apparatus, especially grassroots authorities, are under increasing pressure. Meanwhile, the key element of the apparatus is the contingent of cadres, civil servants and public employees.

In order to serve people and businesses with integrity and professionalism, the organization of public service personnel needs to be done scientifically, employees should be recruited based on actual capacity, with assignment records and be assessed in many dimensions, and inspections of the public service should be done fairly.

Some indicators measure performance of government apparatus

However, based on statistics of the PCI, PAPI and Provincial Anti-Corruption Assessment (PACA) indicators, harassment and raising difficulties toward businesses and citizens by public employees at administrative agencies is still a problem. It is still a fact that there are many doors and intermediaries at administrative agencies that businesses and people have to pass. According to the PAPI index, in the assessment of the effectiveness of corruption control, fairness in recruitment of employees in the public sector was rated at the lowest level.

Lack of KPI for efficiency of public services

 

According to PAPI surveys, the positions that must rely most heavily on relationships to get at commune-level government agencies are the staff who perform land-related administrative procedures. Other positions such as judicial officers, teachers at public primary schools, and staff of People's Committees of communes, wards and towns also require relationships to be recruited.

In that context, the promise of building a contingent of enthusiastic, “talented” civil servants has not been realized after 20 years.

In addition, public service inspection seems to be very formal. Regulations on inspection and examination of public services do not favor unexpected inspection and examination. If only periodic inspections are launched, state agencies have time to prepare thoroughly for the inspection, so it is difficult to accurately assess the performance of daily public service activities of cadres and civil servants.

Meanwhile, the implementation of job positions and the application of assignment records to cadres and civil servants by law were suspended after this mechanism was trialed at a number of ministries, sectors and localities without unknown causes.

So far, there is still no Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for civil servants at each level and in each sector. The civil service system seems to lag far behind in the application of effective HR management solutions in comparison with the private sector.

No need to streamline commune-level payroll

With a population of more than 96 million, associated with commune, ward and town authorities, the contingent of communal cadres and civil servants are under pressure to serve the people, but they are not given adequate attention. These employees are not promptly informed with necessary information, and have not been properly trained to implement policies and law enforcement at the grassroots level.

Many directions and instructions of provincial authorities on improving operational efficiency to improve public administrative service indicators do not reach civil servants at commune level. For example, at a meeting on the PAPI survey, with the participation of more than 700 civil servants who are chairman and vice-chairman of communes/wards/towns in Ho Chi Minh City, only five people raised their hands after they were asked whether they knew about the PAPI index. Only one of them knew about the Satisfaction Index of Public Administrative Services (SIPAS) index. None of them knew about sectoral indicators such as the Government Inspectorate's PACA.

There is also a need to reconsider the payroll streamlining. Payroll streamlining is mainly carried out at the grassroots level, where additional civil servants are needed, especially in densely populated provinces home to migrants such as Hanoi, Ho Chi Minh City, Binh Duong and Dong Nai.

The solution suggested for this situation is to localize the demand for public service staff. It is also necessary to separate urban and rural governments to ensure a more appropriate allocation of human resources and budgets based on local conditions.

The payroll streamlining should focus on the intermediate level (districts) and provincial and city levels, not commune, because administrative agencies at this level have to handle many citizen-related tasks.

Do Thanh Huyen (Public Policy Analyst, UNDP Vietnam)

 
 

Other News

.
Water puppetry made from discarded materials
Water puppetry made from discarded materials
FEATUREicon  09/03/2021 

Mr. Ho Van Than (60 years old, Quynh Thien ward, Hoang Mai town, Nghe An province) is very admired for his flair in turning scrap shops into riveting electric puppets.

Covid-19 and digital transformation
Covid-19 and digital transformation
FEATUREicon  09/03/2021 

Digital transformation is keeping life going but in a ‘new normal’ state.

Covid-19 vaccinations begin in Vietnam
Covid-19 vaccinations begin in Vietnam
FEATUREicon  08/03/2021 

On the morning of March 8, the first Vietnamese were injected with Covid-19 vaccine at four places: 

‘Foreign eagles’ and ‘Viet dragons’ do the 'tango dance' together
‘Foreign eagles’ and ‘Viet dragons’ do the 'tango dance' together
FEATUREicon  09/03/2021 

Vietnam needs to create favorable conditions for ‘Viet dragons’ and ‘foreign eagles’ to join the "tango dance" that brings benefits to both sides, according to VIetnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry (VCCI) chair Vu Tien Loc.

6th grader's website and its unexpected success
6th grader's website and its unexpected success
FEATUREicon  08/03/2021 

A free website with a homework search engine was launched in 2013 by a boy in the 6th grade.

Trees thousands of years old – treasures beyond price
Trees thousands of years old – treasures beyond price
FEATUREicon  08/03/2021 

No measure of money can be exchanged for the mark of time. These trees, with a lifetime of over 1,000 years, are associated with national culture and history.

Another road for Covid-19 vaccines
Another road for Covid-19 vaccines
FEATUREicon  07/03/2021 

Western nations have the capacity in terms of economic potential and the legal and moral aspects to promote access to vaccines on a global scale.

Digital transformation and the digital economy
Digital transformation and the digital economy
FEATUREicon  06/03/2021 

The fourth industrial revolution, digital transformation and the digital economy are mentioned many times in documents of the 13th Party Congress. 

Vaccine nationalism
Vaccine nationalism
FEATUREicon  06/03/2021 

Vaccine nationalism has become alarming, as politicians have criticized the previous US President Donald Trump for his "America First" doctrine.

Online stalls help ‘rescue’ farm produce in North
Online stalls help ‘rescue’ farm produce in North
FEATUREicon  06/03/2021 

Hai Duong’s first farm produce, including cabbage and chicken eggs, are being sold on voso.vn, an e-commerce website, while an online stall distributing Hai Duong’s produce has been set up.

Are Vietnam’s e-commerce platforms inferior to foreign competitors?
Are Vietnam’s e-commerce platforms inferior to foreign competitors?
FEATUREicon  08/03/2021 

Some reports show that Shopee has left its rivals far behind, and that Tiki is competing equally with Lazada, while Sendo is in the fourth position.

Carer for cemetery devotes daily life to martyrs
Carer for cemetery devotes daily life to martyrs
FEATUREicon  08/03/2021 

For the last 40 years, she comes to clear grass, burn incense, and sit and talk at the martyrs’ graves at the cemetery every day.

Vietnamese rush to buy cars as prices fall
Vietnamese rush to buy cars as prices fall
FEATUREicon  05/03/2021 

Though the automobile market has become big enough for manufacturers to step up domestic production, industry policies remain unencouraging.

Vietnamese professor in the UK and memories of Vietnam
Vietnamese professor in the UK and memories of Vietnam
FEATUREicon  05/03/2021 

Prof. Duong Quang Trung, Research Chair of the Royal Academy of Engineering and Professor at Queen's University Belfast in the UK, had a talk about science and other topics with VietNamNet.

Fleeing the city, woman moves to mountainous area to farm, be close to nature
Fleeing the city, woman moves to mountainous area to farm, be close to nature
FEATUREicon  06/03/2021 

Leaving the urban life and a highly paid job behind, May chose to settle in a mountainous area, and enjoy gardening and farming.

When the flag of institutional reform is raised
When the flag of institutional reform is raised
FEATUREicon  05/03/2021 

Institutional reform and improving the business environment reflect the Government's enduring determination over the years, benefiting people and businesses.

'Taking people as the roots' and the desire for development
'Taking people as the roots' and the desire for development
FEATUREicon  04/03/2021 

The report of the 12th Party Central Committee on documents submitted to the 13th Party Congress presented by Party Secretary General and State President Nguyen Phu Trong outlined strategic development issues of the country over the coming years.

Businesses go downhill, another bailout proposed
Businesses go downhill, another bailout proposed
FEATUREicon  04/03/2021 

The Ministry of Planning and Investment (MPI) is considering asking the government to launch the second support package to help businesses stand firmly amid the Covid-19 pandemic.

Perfumed buffaloes and other strange possessions
Perfumed buffaloes and other strange possessions
FEATUREicon  03/03/2021 

Buffaloes in Hoi An do not work on farms, but are made-up and perfumed to bring good fortune for their owners. They are just one example of a number of strange possessions of local Vietnamese. 

Foreign woman loves Ao Dai, brings Vietnamese silk to the world
Foreign woman loves Ao Dai, brings Vietnamese silk to the world
FEATUREicon  03/03/2021 

Born and raised in Europe but Liisi has a special passion for Vietnamese Ao Dai (traditional gown) and Vietnamese silk products.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN