Fairness for private sector

Enterprises in Vietnam’s private economic sector have not received land and taxation incentives while they are restrained by institutional regulations, policies and thousands of procedures and formalities.

Fairness for private sector
To promote equality among economic sectors, the State should build a legal system applicable to business, which needs to embrace transparency, equality, clarity and simplified procedures – PHOTO: MINH DUY

“Equality” was one of the 10 key words given by Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc to private enterprises during Vietnam Private Sector Economic Forum held in Hanoi on May 2.

Equality, explained the Prime Minister, is to give the private economic sector fairness before the law, and equitability in competition and in resource allocation versus other sectors, in particular, accessiblity to capital, technology, management and human resources.

However, in practical terms, inequality in resource allocation has been a serious hurdle to the development of the country’s private economic sector.

Contrasting pictures

In recent years, the private economy has emerged as one of the key growth drivers pulling along the entire economy as it accounted for some 42% of Vietnam’s gross domestic product, created 30% of the national budget and provided jobs for some 85% of the country’s labor pool.

Despite all the improvements, the real strength of this economic sector is basically “weak and scattered.” A few private business groups have been formed. However, they don’t have the ability to turn the tables.

A prerequisite for the development of the private sector and its larger contribution to the national economy relates to the existence of big business groups which are forceful enough to support the rest of the corporate sector in moving forward. This model has been proved successful in South Korea, Thailand, Taiwan and suchlike.

In Vietnam, however, during the past decade, although the contingent of small- and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) has expanded, the number of big business groups has remained unchanged.

“The economy accommodates way too many SMEs and business households,” said Nguyen Minh Cuong, an economist with the Asian Development Bank (ADB).

“This should be a source of concern.” Statistically, up to 95-97% of Vietnam’s total enterprises are small businesses or microenterprises. It’s therefore very tough for them to engage in global supply chains.

Dang Quang Khoi, director of An Lap Plastic Co., a second-tier supplier for a big electronic company in Vietnam, said of the dozens of plastic product suppliers of foreign-invested enterprises (FIEs) present here, only two of them are “pure” Vietnamese companies.

“This situation poses a big risk because our output is mainly for the foreign investment sector,” said Khoi.

Human resources, technology and management, according to Khoi, are the challenges his 300-strong company has been facing. Citing human resources as an example, he said his company’s work force changes on the daily basis.

Some employees quit even before they finished their training at An Lap although Khoi had paid them salaries and allowances equal to the common level in the industry, he said. As the quality of its staff is not high, his company’s managerial level is not high either.

“It’s extremely tough for us to fill high-level management vacancies,” said Khoi. “We have to train senior workers to fill the posts. But these people lack managerial competence as well as other skills.”

Shortages of human resources and capital have barred SMEs from investing in state-of-the-art technology, which significantly dents their competitiveness and deprives them of the opportunity to take part in global supply chains.

 

Uneven quality of services and products is the major obstacle which keeps private SMEs from entering into global supply chains in the context that the international marketplace has set ever-higher standards on the environment and health, according to the representative from the ADB.

In dire contrast with the skinny body of local private enterprises are robust FIEs. The foreign investment sector has grown continuously and cranked up pressure on their local counterparts.

FIEs have developed robustly partly because they enjoy overwhelming advantages over their private domestic rivals, like finance, management, market strength, technology and the ability to engage in global supply chains.

However, the crux of the issue—according to Tran Dinh Thien, an economist who is a member of the Prime Minister’s group of economic advisers, a thinktank—is that FIEs know how to maximize incentives given by Vietnam to foreign investors.

In addition to natural treatments, such as abundant work force, low costs, geographical locations as well as market scale and growth rate, other important policy incentives are land accessibility, taxation reduction and exemption, and competition among provinces.

“These incentives are totally unavailable to private Vietnamese enterprises,” said Thien.

“Vietnamese enterprises are tied up and restrained by institutional regulations, policies and specific stipulations on bank interest rates, foreign exchange rates and thousands of formalities and procedures.”

Discrimination does not exist in the words and phrases of laws and regulations but in the mindset and relationship between management agencies and private enterprises, according to Dien Quang Hiep, chairman of the Binh Duong Wood Association and chairman of Minh Phat 2 Company.

“When shifting from a planned economy to a market one, Vietnam’s laws were changed fast because they are only written documents,” Hiep said. “But the most difficult change is what people often think, which is deep inside personal relations. And as far as relations are concerned, regulations are easily ignored.” 

Transparent and nonarbitrary policies needed

To promote equality among economic sectors, Nguyen Trong Dieu, chairman of the Vietnam Private Business Association, argued that the State should build a legal system applicable to business, which needs to embrace transparency, equality, clarity and simplified procedures. “We’re in need of fairness, transparency and healthiness,” said Dieu.

And to realize this target, management agencies have to put into use technology in their activities, and remove inappropriate conditions for market entry and sublicenses. A more favorable environment for manufacturing and services must be created for the sake of the private economic sector.

Furthermore, the State should formulate policies applicable universally to all categories of entities doing business in Vietnam. Mechanisms must be activated to enable the private sector to better access resources, such as land, finance, human resources and technology.

In the long run, the business environment is to become fairer when Vietnam signs more new-generation free trade agreements, such as the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership or the European-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement, according to Le Xuan Sang, deputy director of the Vietnam Institute of Economics.

“There will be programs in the frameworks of these agreements, which are specially designed to support the private sector,” Sang said. However, to effectively help local enterprises improve their product quality and managerial skills, it is necessary as well to connect the domestic economic sector with their foreign counterpart. This requires excellent supporting polices, in particular, policies on supporting industries.

Cuong from the ADB contended that in the coming time, foreign investment will continue to arrive in Vietnam as a result of the country’s deeper integration into the global economy. What makes or breaks is how to bolster the competitiveness of the private sector and cement the bond between Vietnam’s private enterprises with FIEs to enable the former to involve in global supply chains. SGT

Vu Dung

 
 

Other News

.
"Passion - The Mother of Invention", says Vietnamese scientist
"Passion - The Mother of Invention", says Vietnamese scientist
FEATUREicon  02/06/2020 

No half measures. That’s the one thing that has stood out about Vu Ngoc Tam since he was a kid.

An initiative of national strategic importance
An initiative of national strategic importance
FEATUREicon  01/06/2020 

HCMC authorities put forward a proposal to develop the Eastern Creative City during a working session with the Prime Minister early this month. 

Four key measures help Vietnam control coronavirus
Four key measures help Vietnam control coronavirus
FEATUREicon  29/05/2020 

Vietnam did not shy away from broadcasting the seriousness of Covid-19.

What foreign ambassadors say about Vietnam's coronavirus fight?
What foreign ambassadors say about Vietnam's coronavirus fight?
FEATUREicon  29/05/2020 

It seems that Vietnam has adapted to a "new normal" state after it reopened the economy in late April.

Vietnam to study health standard validation before reopening to foreign tourists
Vietnam to study health standard validation before reopening to foreign tourists
FEATUREicon  27/05/2020 

With the Covid-19 pandemic under control in Vietnam, the country now seeks to breathe life back into its tourism industry.

The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 6)
The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 6)
FEATUREicon  26/05/2020 

Despite the best scenario, the consequences that the invisible Covid-19 enemy has caused to nations and international relations are severe, which will affect the world decades later.

Child-like man in Ly Son finds success in tourism
Child-like man in Ly Son finds success in tourism
FEATUREicon  25/05/2020 

A 34-year-old man with childlike appearance is a the successful investors in tourism in Ly Son District, Quang Ngai Province.

Covid-19 pandemic: Policy responses to stop shutdowns
Covid-19 pandemic: Policy responses to stop shutdowns
FEATUREicon  25/05/2020 

The pandemic and the healthcare crisis it triggers have ignited an economic storm in many countries. If the economic turbulence is not managed well, it will lead to a financial crisis and/or a debt crisis. 

Researcher devotes 30 years to preserving Raglai ethnic language
Researcher devotes 30 years to preserving Raglai ethnic language
FEATUREicon  26/05/2020 

Mau Thi Bich Phanh has spent nearly 30 years of her life researching the value of the ethnic Raglai language.

Vietnam’s automation future at work
Vietnam’s automation future at work
FEATUREicon  25/05/2020 

Are robots coming to take Vietnamese jobs? Are iPads invading Vietnamese workplaces? 

The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 5)
The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 5)
FEATUREicon  23/05/2020 

Science and technology help people cope with pandemics like Covid-19 and help society adapt to pandemics.

The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 4)
The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 4)
FEATUREicon  22/05/2020 

American scholar Stephen Walt, a realist and an ardent supporter of nationalism, said the post-epidemic world is a world that is less open, less prosperous and less free.

From small teen to “natural born killer”: A Vietnamese boxer’s journey to Tokyo Olympics
From small teen to “natural born killer”: A Vietnamese boxer’s journey to Tokyo Olympics
FEATUREicon  23/05/2020 

Boxer Nguyen Van Duong is proud to be heading to Tokyo next year after defeating the renowned Chatchai-decha Butdee from Thailand in the Olympics qualifiers in Jordan in March, 

Cuban photographer yearns to return to Hanoi
Cuban photographer yearns to return to Hanoi
FEATUREicon  23/05/2020 

Neither the great distance nor the spread of the novel coronavirus stopped Cuban photographer Eloy Rodriguez’s from visiting Vietnam for a few weeks in early March.

Vietnam stands firm amid Covid-19 outbreak
Vietnam stands firm amid Covid-19 outbreak
FEATUREicon  20/05/2020 

Vietnam has recorded no new cases of COVID-19 infections in the community for more than 30 days. Quarantine has been lifted in high-risk areas and social distancing measures relaxed. 

The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 3)
The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 3)
FEATUREicon  21/05/2020 

Originally regarded as a "savior", the Covid-19 pandemic has created new skepticism, considering globalization as a "criminal" that spread the coronavirus epidemic across the globe and caused the current disaster.

The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 2)
The world in the post-Covid-19 era (Part 2)
FEATUREicon  20/05/2020 

Some questions must be answered clearly: Where and in what context did Covid-19 appear? Were the World Health Organization's (WHO) detection and warnings timely enough in preventing the pandemic outbreak?

Cooperation - key in Vietnam’s fight against COVID-19
Cooperation - key in Vietnam’s fight against COVID-19
FEATUREicon  19/05/2020 

The international community has attributed Vietnam’s remarkable achievements in taking on COVID-19 to the close cooperation between the country’s Government and its people.

President Ho Chi Minh lives on through the lives he touched
President Ho Chi Minh lives on through the lives he touched
FEATUREicon  19/05/2020 

It's been more than 50 years since President Ho Chi Minh passed away and school children still learn his poems, his biography and about his minimalist lifestyle. 

The world in the post-Covid-19 era
The world in the post-Covid-19 era
FEATUREicon  19/05/2020 

The coronavirus pandemic has not passed, but it has been and will leave severe consequences in all aspects of human life, as well as international relations.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN