Solutions for using, managing livestreams

The state needs to resolve disputes about social networks by law. This is the solution of a modern society that respects a rule-of-law culture.

A "war" has broken out on social networks between journalists and supporters of Mrs. Phuong Hang, the CEO and Vice Chair of Binh Duong province-based Dai Nam JSC and the wife of Mr. Huynh Uy Dung, a famous wealthy businessman in Vietnam, who blamed many Vietnamese celebrities for doing charity in the wrong way, advertising products with false information, and revealing personal information of famous people during her livestreams on Facebook and YouTube. Journalists, however, want to prevent the abuse of freedom of expression and infringement on privacy and interests of others.

This article does not attempt to analyze who is right and who is wrong in that “war”, but outlines the legal framework as well as ethical practices to deal with similar cases that are expected to occur in the future, along with the development of social networks.

Background

Solutions for using, managing livestreams

However, this phenomenon should be put in the context that similar acts have happened many times and many people have taken advantage of the media and social networks to smear, attack, and insult others but have not been punished; many celebrities took advantage of social networks to spread false information or entice their fans to buy poor quality medicines, and after offering apology, they were forgiven by the public.

This leads many people to mistakenly believe that it is okay as such acts are a rampant social phenomenon.

In principle, those who commit acts of assault on others must be severely punished under the law, and cannot be excused for any reason.

The behavior of many people who hacked into the Voice of Vietnam (VOV)'s network after VOV posted articles on Phuong Hang on June 12-13 was very serious, possibly committing the crime of obstructing or disrupting the operation of the computer networks, telecommunications networks and electronic means according to Point c, Clause 1, Article 287 of the Penal Code 2015. Those who masterminded, incited, and assisted the perpetrators of the attack will also be handled as an accomplice.

These violations are similar in nature as they all used the same tool - social networks to attack others, but the case of Phuong Hang is widely known.

The state needs to direct disputes on social networks to be resolved by law. This is the solution of a modern society that respects the rule of law culture.

Laws in some countries

Solutions for using, managing livestreams

Many countries are considering handling technology companies such as Facebook, YouTube and Google because of the nature of preventing consequences that are faster than a legal process - because it often takes a long time for the victims to sue the violators and to win the case and when they win the case, they have already suffered from the violation. Forcing technology companies to set up technical barriers to handle the consequences before the proceedings are carried out is necessary.

In Germany, the Network Enforcement Act (Netzwerkdurchsetzungsgesetz, NetzDG; German: Gesetz zur Verbesserung der Rechtsdurchsetzung in sozialen Netzwerken), also known as the Facebook Act (Facebook-Gesetz) was enacted in 2017. The law aimed at combating “hate speech, defamation, malicious gossip, fake news", to force international social media technology companies to censor the content posted on their sites.

Social networks must remove "unlawful content". NetzDG added new requirements to handle information on social networks where the impact of the violation is very damaging and very fast, thanks to the speed of information sharing.

NetzGD requires that social networking service providers with infringing content (pornography, violence, hate speech, misinformation, fake news), upon receipt of a request, remove the infringing content within 24 hours. It may extend processing time to seven days.

These companies are required to assign specialized personnel to work with the German government on supervision and handling such cases. At the same time, every six months they must publish reports on the number of cases that are handled.

If these requirements are not complied with, the sanctions are very strict, with fines of up to 50 million Euro. The law does not force deletion of any copies of the infringing information. The victims can take the author directly to court, and the judge has the right to order the disclosure of the infringer's identity.

This is also consistent with the trend that technology companies are taking to protect users, especially to solve two problems: (1) user privacy, and (2) anti-fake news, disinformation and hateful and divisive statements.

Singapore’s Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act (POFMA) was passed by Parliament in May 2019 with the aim to address concerns about the consequences of fake news, and misinformation on social networks, including intermediaries using accounts originating outside of Singapore but information being circulated in Singapore.

When websites and social networks spread false or untrue information (including fabrications), the Minister issues an Access Block Order, and the Infocomm Media Development Authority (IMDA) may request internet service providers to disable access to an online site claimed in Singapore where false information spreads.

Failure to comply with the Access Block Order will result in the internet service provider (or internet intermediary) being fined up to 20,000 SGD/day (totaling SGD 500,000). For individuals, the fine is up to 50,000 SGD, or imprisonment for up to 5 years. The penalty is two times higher if posting fake news with an unofficial online account; and fake news publishing company will be fined up to 1 million SGD. It is up to the government to determine which news is fake or inaccurate.

Egypt passed the 2018 Law on the Organisation of Press, Media and the Supreme Council of Media and set up an agency to manage social media accounts or websites with more than 5,000 followers. These accounts and websites are considered a form of media, which are placed under the supervision of the Supreme Council of Media.

That agency has the right to block websites and file a complaint to the competent authority against platforms and users whose offenses threaten national security, disrupt public order, and are discriminatory, violent, racist, hateful or intolerant.

 

What can Vietnam learn from these countries?

Preventing and dealing with false information is one of the goals of the Law on Cybersecurity, which took effect on January 1, 2019.

With an open economy, it is necessary to ensure the freedom of information and data flow. However, to reduce public resources needed to follow complicated problems arising from social networks, it is time for the Vietnamese government to issue a document transferring the responsibility of initial handling to technology companies, in order to reduce consequences arising from acts of offending the reputation and honor of individuals and organizations.

The State’s role in social networks

Solutions for using, managing livestreams

It is unfair to say that the state does not handle disorder on social networks, but the handling is not thorough. Particularly, many artists have committed violations but few of them have been fined.

This leads to the arrogance of some artists, who always think of themselves as having the power to dominate society. Thus, many people think that if famous artists are not punished, then it will be fine for ordinary people to commit similar violations.

There is no shortage of legal framework to handle acts of insulting reputation of others, but to enforce these regulations, there are many technical problems, because in many cases when the violators are punished, the consequences are too serious.

It is not easy to handle violations on social networks committed by anonymous accounts or those registered in foreign countries. This is a challenge that the State must solve. The building of a legal framework to promptly deal with this situation is still a big challenge for countries and policy makers.

In many cases, technology has evolved far beyond the law. For content management on the internet, which is considered the most difficult of the three main issues of cybersecurity (cyberattacks; protection of user data; and content), plus the borderless nature of information technology, has made it increasingly difficult to handle acts of offending reputation and posting false news.

If the accounts committing violations are registered in Vietnam, the authorities should punish them drastically to give a warning to violators.

However, it is necessary to consider the relationship between the privacy of celebrities and freedom of speech and press freedom, and punish the violators that have accounts with a lot of followers first to prevent the spread of false and fake news in the community.

Celebrities' right to privacy, freedom of speech

The privacy of celebrities is being violated more than that of ordinary people. In many developed countries, the privacy of celebrities has been one of the most controversial legal topics.

Celebrities lure public attention. Sometimes, like it or not, celebrities are considered by society as a "model" of culture, intelligence, morality, and behavior. Many artists, singers, presenters or scientists become idols of many people.

Thanks to their popularity, they can earn a lot of money. But because of their popularity, celebrities either lose or have to accept the loss of privacy. With the same behavior, an ordinary person in society will be less "scrutinized" than a famous person.

As for celebrities, livestream is a new tool to help their voices and performances be broadcast live to the audience. It is not an illegal act because it's freedom of speech.

But this is a limited right. Speech that offends others is beyond the limits of the right. Freedom of speech does not protect against slander and malicious rumors.

Therefore, in my personal opinion, for the same violations - insulting the reputation, honor and dignity of others - famous people and those with a high number of followers must be punished more severely than ordinary people because they exert more influence. This differentiation takes into account the impact of information and the consequences of behavior.

Dr. Thai Thi Tuyet Dung

University of Economics and Law under the Vietnam National University – HCMC

Cyber trash: livestreamers swear at customers while selling goods

Cyber trash: livestreamers swear at customers while selling goods

Even shop owners, who sell goods to earn their living, have been found cursing at customers when livestreaming.

Unhealthy content on cyberspace threatens Vietnamese users

Unhealthy content on cyberspace threatens Vietnamese users

Many Internet users in Vietnam, especially young people, students and children are negatively affected by unhealthy information and images that are freely distributed in cyberspace.

 
 

Other News

.
Hanoi mulls solutions to stay safe when social distancing rules end
Hanoi mulls solutions to stay safe when social distancing rules end
FEATUREicon  21/09/2021 

Hanoi needs to find solutions to prevent the coronavirus from spreading and causing overloading of the healthcare system.

New mindset needed to reverse production stagnation
New mindset needed to reverse production stagnation
FEATUREicon  21/09/2021 

“Localities should not always count plants and livestock in their reports. We need to change the way of thinking to improve the situation,” said Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development Le Minh Hoan.

Government urged to act promptly to both save businesses and protect people's health
Government urged to act promptly to both save businesses and protect people's health
FEATUREicon  21/09/2021 

Actions are needed now to save businesses, or it will be too late, enterprise associations say.

Covid-19 pandemic and the golden season of digital transformation
Covid-19 pandemic and the golden season of digital transformation
FEATUREicon  20/09/2021 

On September 5, when the Covid-19 outbreak was still rampant, the new school year started online for millions of students. 

Alarming rise in cases of depression in Vietnam
Alarming rise in cases of depression in Vietnam
FEATUREicon  20/09/2021 

According to a report on mental health by the Lancet Commission, mental disorders are on the rise in every country in the world and will cost the global economy $16 trillion by 2030.

Vietnamese can create Metaverse virtual universes
Vietnamese can create Metaverse virtual universes
FEATUREicon  19/09/2021 

Anyone can have another life inside a virtual world: what seemed like sci-fi movies only is coming very close.

Mobile Money paves way to apply 'sandbox' for new services
Mobile Money paves way to apply 'sandbox' for new services
FEATUREicon  19/09/2021 

The trial Mobile Money service allowed by the Prime Minister will set a precedent for applying a "sandbox" scheme for new services and professions in digital society.

Businesses propose new regulations to replace Directives 15, 16
Businesses propose new regulations to replace Directives 15, 16
FEATUREicon  18/09/2021 

Associations of businesses have asked the Prime Minister to issue new directives on pandemic prevention and control to replace Directives 15 and 16 with regulations that fit the new circumstances.

Businesses struggle with increased costs, impact from Covid-19
Businesses struggle with increased costs, impact from Covid-19
FEATUREicon  19/09/2021 

According to the Vietnam Association of Beer, Wine and Beverage (VBA), more than 85 percent of drink manufacturers have had difficulties in product distribution.

Companies reporting profits actually incurred losses, audits show
Companies reporting profits actually incurred losses, audits show
FEATUREicon  19/09/2021 

A difference in profits of listed companies before and after auditing has left investors worried about the accuracy of finance reports.

Extending lockdown, HCMC adjusts social, business activities
Extending lockdown, HCMC adjusts social, business activities
FEATUREicon  17/09/2021 

HCM City authorities are planning to grant green cards associated with personal QR Codes in certain districts; amend regulations on goods delivery and receipt; and allow more business fields to operate, commencing from September 16.

Airfare scheme may deprive 43 million passengers of opportunity to fly at low cost
Airfare scheme may deprive 43 million passengers of opportunity to fly at low cost
FEATUREicon  17/09/2021 

If a proposed airfare scheme is applied, the fees will make it impossible for low-income earners to travel by air.

Vietnam builds ‘fortress’ to fight pandemic, not the economy
Vietnam builds ‘fortress’ to fight pandemic, not the economy
FEATUREicon  18/09/2021 

The economy reflects the operation of all 13 southern cities and provinces, and different behaviors of each is hindering economic development.

Hanoi, HCM City to loosen social distancing, prepare for reopening
Hanoi, HCM City to loosen social distancing, prepare for reopening
FEATUREicon  15/09/2021 

Hanoi leaders have mentioned the possibility of loosening social distancing from September 15 if the spread of the coronavirus can be curbed. HCM City is also considering loosening social distancing regulations two weeks after September 15.

Local specialties plummeting in price
Local specialties plummeting in price
FEATUREicon  16/09/2021 

While Phu Yen lobster prices are surging, VND100,000 per kilogram more expensive than the previous crop, other aquatic specialties including ca lang (hemibagrus) and hau sua (oyster milk) have seen prices plummet, causing big losses for farmers.

Hope rests on economic recovery plan
Hope rests on economic recovery plan
FEATUREicon  16/09/2021 

Hopes for the ease of social distancing measures and recovery of the economy are rising along with the decrease in the nber of new cases.

Hanoi after nearly two months of social distancing
Hanoi after nearly two months of social distancing
FEATUREicon  15/09/2021 

The number of Covid-19 cases is gradually decreasing, medical capacity has improved, the "green zone" has expanded, and the "red zone" has gradually narrowed. 

When the two 'locomotives' restart at the same time
When the two 'locomotives' restart at the same time
FEATUREicon  14/09/2021 

Contributing about 45% of the country’s GDP, HCM City and Hanoi are considered the two engines pulling the national economy. Both must be healthy and go hand in hand to revive the pandemic-hit economy.

How long will social distancing last?
How long will social distancing last?
FEATUREicon  16/09/2021 

Receipts from taxes are on the decrease, which show that goods consumption and production of enterprises have been hit hard by the Covid-19 crisis.

HCM City begins two trial ‘buffer’ weeks before reopenng
HCM City begins two trial ‘buffer’ weeks before reopenng
FEATUREicon  15/09/2021 

A trial reopening in HCM City will be implemented on September 16-30 in districts 7, Cu Chi and Can Gio before following steps are taken.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN