China's deliberate ambiguity in the East Sea

Chinese officials said on August 29 that they would require a series of vessels to "report information" when passing through the area they consider to be their "territorial waters" from September 1, 2021.

Earlier this year, when China passed the revised Coast Guard Law, the world was worried, especially when the wording in this law was ambiguous.

"This law shall apply to coast guard organizations carrying out maritime rights enforcement activities in and above the sea areas under the jurisdiction of the People’s Republic of China," it said. In the draft law published in November 2020, in article 74, “the sea areas under jurisdiction” are explained as “internal waters, territorial sea, contiguous zone, exclusive economic zone, continental shelf and other sea areas under the jurisdiction of the People's Republic of China."

Ambiguous sentences

Sự mập mờ cố tình của Trung Quốc ở Biển Đông

Chinese Coast Guard vessels. Photo: Sino Defense

However, when the Coast Guard Law was officially adopted, the interpretation of "the sea areas under the jurisdiction of the People's Republic of China" disappeared. This leaves the term "sea areas under the jurisdiction of the People's Republic of China" undefined. And China will be free to interpret this matter.

China also vaguely referred to its claim of jurisdiction over 3 million square kilometers of maritime space, often referred to as its "green national territory". This area includes Bohai Bay; a large part of the Yellow Sea; the East China Sea to the east of Okinawa Trough, including the waters surrounding the disputed Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands; and all waters within the “nine-dash line” in the East Sea.

According to Beijing's calculations, "more than half" of this space is disputed by other countries.

This ambiguity of China is not only related to the Coast Guard Law, but also in many other legal documents.

According to the media, Chinese officials said on August 29 that they would ask a series of ships to "report information" when passing through the areas that China considers to be its "territorial waters", starting from September 1, 2021.

This announcement is related to the Maritime Traffic Safety Law that China passed this April.

Article 54 of this law is completely new compared to the previous drafts. It clearly stipulates that “submarines, nuclear ships, ships carrying radioactive materials and ships carrying oil, chemicals, liquefied gas and other hazardous substances must report detailed information upon arrival in the territorial waters of the Republic of China".

The regulation restricts vehicles from entering China's territorial waters. However, Article 117 explaining the terms of this law, does not clearly explain how China's "territorial waters" is defined, and whether it is based on the provision of "territorial waters" as the waters of 12 nautical miles from the baselines as defined in the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) or not.

What is worrying is that when answering the media, expert Song Zhongping from the Chinese military said: "This advance notice requirement will standardize the management of the country's territorial waters, improve the ability to protect China's sovereignty and security."

Song Zhongping also said the new regulation applies to China's territorial waters - including the East China Sea, the East Sea and China's islands and reefs - to regulate China's management of those territorial waters.

In addition, this law also stipulates that any ship deemed "dangerous to the safety of China's maritime traffic" will also be required to report information, including name, signs, current position, next port of destination and estimated time of arrival. Vessels will also be required to provide cargo and tonnage information.

The Chinese media noted that the Maritime Safety Administration of China "has the right to expel or refuse to allow a ship to enter China's waters if it is deemed to pose a threat to national security".

 

Biggest ambition

The question is: Why does China maintain ambiguity in these legal documents?

We all know that China's biggest ambition is to monopolize the East Sea. However, they do not have any legal basis to support this ambition. China cannot use force to seize the East Sea because they face many disadvantages.

Therefore, China has applied what Western researchers call "gray zone tactics", that is, using methods of intimidation, coercion, even attack, but not directly using the Navy. Because according to international law, when using the military, it will be considered
an “invasion by force”, or violation of the UN Charter and will be condemned by the international community.

China must also find reasons for its “gray zone activities”, and because there is no basis in international law, it must make its own rules in domestic law. Therefore, China has deliberately maintained ambiguity in its legal documents, to have an excuse for aggressive actions.

Strategic response

To protect its maritime interests against China's gray zone tactics, Vietnam needs to use integrated measures, diplomatically, legally, and on the ground, specifically:

Vietnam needs to continue to clearly show its active role in ASEAN to promote the negotiation process for the Code of Conduct (COC) for the East Sea, towards an effective and substantive COC in compliance with international law. The COC must be legally binding, which should clearly state that countries are not allowed to build artificial islands, to militarize island features, to block ships carrying supplies or rotating personnel, to establish an air defense identification zone (ADIZ), or to threaten to use force when settling disputes in the East Sea.

At the same time, Vietnam needs to strengthen cooperation with major powers in the region and the world, especially in the field of sharing intelligence, providing means and equipment to protect sovereignty over seas and islands. Naval forces should expand their participation in international exercises (RIMPAC) for deeper integration as well as build partner networks in the region.

In addition, Vietnam needs to take advantage of international and regional forums to protect its maritime interests, analyze clearly the intentions in the "gray zone strategy", and clarify the risks that make the East Sea tense from China's actions.

The functional forces, especially the navy, air force, coast guard, fishery control... need to invest more resources to modernize equipment, so that we are not passive in the field.

We also need to maintain the presence of labor forces at sea, to contribute to firmly asserting our sovereignty. And law enforcement agencies are always ready to support and protect people when necessary.

The most solid strategy to protect the sovereignty of the sea and islands is to develop Vietnam into a country with a rich and strong marine economy.

Viet Hoang

The essence of China's 'soft power'

The essence of China's 'soft power'

American expert on international relations Joseph Nye said that the power of a country, besides "hard power" including military force, population, geography, and strategic resources, also includes "soft power".

 
 

Other News

.
Australia, US stress importance of ensuring freedoms in East Sea
Australia, US stress importance of ensuring freedoms in East Sea
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  17/09/2021 

Australia and the US underlined the importance of countries’ ability to exercise their maritime rights and freedoms in the East Sea, consistent with the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS),

Stamps of “General of Truong Sa” Giap Van Cuong issued
Stamps of “General of Truong Sa” Giap Van Cuong issued
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  16/09/2021 

A set of postage stamps to celebrate the 100th birth anniversary of Giap Van Cuong (1921-1990) - the first admiral of the Vietnam Navy – known as the "General of Truong Sa (Spratly)”, has been issued by the Ministry of Information and Communications.

Treasured maps show Paracels and Spratlys belong to Vietnam
Treasured maps show Paracels and Spratlys belong to Vietnam
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  13/09/2021 

The Hoang Sa Museum, on the coast of Son Tra peninsula, Da Nang City, is a unique site preserving documents and other artefacts about Vietnam’s sovereignty over the Hoang Sa (Paracel) and Truong Sa (Spratly) archipelagos.

Australia, France oppose actions increasing tensions in East Sea
Australia, France oppose actions increasing tensions in East Sea
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  02/09/2021 

Australia and France ministers have voiced serious concerns about the situation in the East Sea and called for all disputes to be resolved in a peaceful manner in accordance with international law,

VN resolutely protects sovereignty over islands: Foreign Ministry spokesperson
VN resolutely protects sovereignty over islands: Foreign Ministry spokesperson
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  01/09/2021 

Vietnam resolutely and persistently takes measures in accordance with international law to exercise and protect its sovereignty over Hoang Sa (Paracel) and Truong Sa (Spratly) archipelagoes.

PM: Maritime security issue needs global solution
PM: Maritime security issue needs global solution
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  10/08/2021 

PM Pham Minh Chinh raised proposals to effectively tackle challenges to maritime security while addressing the high-level open debate on “Enhancing Maritime Security – A Case for International Cooperation” of the UNSC, held virtually on August 9.

China’s military drill in Hoang Sa violates Vietnam's sovereignty: Spokeswoman
China’s military drill in Hoang Sa violates Vietnam's sovereignty: Spokeswoman
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  06/08/2021 

China’s military exercise in the Hoang Sa (Paracel) archipelago area violated Vietnam’s sovereignty over the islands and went counter to the spirit of the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the East Sea (DOC),

ASEAN affirms peaceful resolution of East Sea disputes based on int’l law
ASEAN affirms peaceful resolution of East Sea disputes based on int’l law
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  05/08/2021 

The 54th ASEAN Foreign Ministers’ Meeting (AMM-54), which took place recently via videoconference, issued a joint communiqué highlighting the East Sea (South China Sea) situation.

Japanese minister stresses importance of navigation freedom in East Sea
Japanese minister stresses importance of navigation freedom in East Sea
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  04/08/2021 

Foreign ministers of ASEAN countries and Japan agreed on the importance of freedom of navigation in the East Sea (internationally known as South China Sea) during their virtual meeting on August 3.

Vietnam among first members of UNCLOS 1982
Vietnam among first members of UNCLOS 1982
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  02/08/2021 

Among international legal documents signed since World War 2, the 1982 Convention on the Law of the Sea is considered the second-most important, following only the United Nations Charter.

Vietnam chairs meeting of Group of Friends on 1982 UNCLOS
Vietnam chairs meeting of Group of Friends on 1982 UNCLOS
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  22/07/2021 

On July 21 (New York time), the Vietnamese mission to the United Nations (UN) hosted an online meeting of the Group of Friends on the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).

Chinese book recognises Vietnam’s sovereignty over archipelagos
Chinese book recognises Vietnam’s sovereignty over archipelagos
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  19/07/2021 

Many ancient writings, recorded by foreigners themselves, directly or indirectly recognise Vietnam’s sovereignty over the two archipelagos of Hoang Sa (Paracel) and Truong Sa (Spratly). 

Vietnam stresses COVID-19 recovery, East Sea stability in US-ASEAN foreign ministers' meeting
Vietnam stresses COVID-19 recovery, East Sea stability in US-ASEAN foreign ministers' meeting
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  14/07/2021 

Minister of Foreign Affairs Bui Thanh Son attended a video conference between his counterparts in ASEAN and US Secretary of State Antony Blinken on Wednesday, with issues on the agenda ranging from COVID-19 to the East Sea and Myanmar.

Int’l community calls for law abidance in settling East Sea issue
Int’l community calls for law abidance in settling East Sea issue
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  13/07/2021 

The international community has continuously called on parties concerned to follow international practices and rules, especially the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) amid the complicated developments in the East Sea.

Vietnam affirms clear, consistent stance on settlement of East Sea disputes
Vietnam affirms clear, consistent stance on settlement of East Sea disputes
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  13/07/2021 

Vietnam’s stance on the settlement of disputes in the East Sea is clear and consistent, spokeswoman of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs Le Thi Thu Hang on July 12.

Japan, Canada call for compliance to UNCLOS in resolving East Sea issues
Japan, Canada call for compliance to UNCLOS in resolving East Sea issues
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  13/07/2021 

Japanese Foreign Minister Motegi Toshimitsu on July 12 issued a statement calling on relevant sides to comply with the Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA)’s ruling in settling disputes in the East Sea.

Top US diplomat emphasises need to ensure rules-based maritime order
Top US diplomat emphasises need to ensure rules-based maritime order
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  13/07/2021 

The international community has long benefited from the rules-based maritime order, where international law, as reflected in UNCLOS, sets out the legal framework for all activities in the oceans and seas, US Secretary of State Antony Blinken said.

Australia calls for compliance with international law in East Sea issue
Australia calls for compliance with international law in East Sea issue
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  13/07/2021 

Australian Minister for Foreign Affairs Marise Payne has affirmed Australia’s position which is guided by principled support for international law and the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).

Law on Vietnam Coast Guard – ‘sharp tool’ in law enforcement at sea
Law on Vietnam Coast Guard – ‘sharp tool’ in law enforcement at sea
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  13/07/2021 

Over the two years of enforcement, the Law on the Vietnam Coast Guard has proved to be a “sharp tool” for implementing law at sea.

Int’l researchers reaffirm value of PCA ruling on East Sea
Int’l researchers reaffirm value of PCA ruling on East Sea
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  12/07/2021 

International researchers and experts while attending a recent teleconference reaffirmed the value of the 2016 ruling on the East Sea by the Permanent Court on Arbitration (PCA).

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN