Coronavirus: Six of President Trump's claims fact-checked

The US president has questioned WHO data and taken credit for reducing the number of cases. Is he right?

President Donald Trump has been defending his handling of the coronavirus outbreak in the United States and has now introduced travel restrictions on most of Europe.

We've fact-checked some of the president's recent claims.

Claim 1

"The US has done a very good job on testing. When people need a test they can get a test."

In early March, the White House conceded that the United States did not have enough testing kits. Some health centres have also reported difficulties using them. The government says more than one million have now been distributed, with more on the way.

But the US has carried out far fewer tests than other countries - 26 per million people between 3 January and 11 March compared with South Korea's 4,000. The UK has carried out 400 tests per million and Italy 1,000 as of 10 March. Health experts fear the virus may have spread undetected in US communities because few tests were carried out.

Claim 2

"We made a life-saving move with early action on China. Now we must take the same action with Europe."

President Trump has often cited travel restrictions as the reason the number of coronavirus cases is relatively low in the US and says many lives have been saved. On 31 January, any foreign national who had been to China within the previous 14 days was barred from entering the US. Three major US airlines operating flights to China had already stopped flying.

Later in February, restrictions were placed on foreign nationals who had been in Iran - which was already under a travel ban - in the previous 14 days. Non-US citizens from 26 European countries are now banned from entering the US.

US citizens and their families are largely exempt from all these restrictions. Experts believe the US action bought the government time to prepare and reduced the number of cases, but we don't know whether it saved lives. The World Health Organization (WHO) has said travel restrictions can be harmful "by hindering info-sharing, medical supply chains and harming economies".

Claim 3

 

When asked about WHO data on the virus's death rate: "I think the 3.4% is really a false number... Personally, I think the number is way under 1%."

In a telephone interview on Fox News, President Trump said a WHO figure of 3.4% for the coronavirus death rate was "false". WHO reported this figure on 3 March and said it was based on all the confirmed coronavirus cases that had resulted in death.

Mr Trump said he thought the true death rate, based on "my hunch", was "way under 1%". He said the death rate appeared higher because many people who caught a mild form of the virus did not report it to the doctor and therefore did not end up as confirmed cases.

At the moment we don't know how likely you are to die from coronavirus, mainly because of the lack of data on infections. However, scientists' current best guess is about 1%.

Claim 4

On 9 March: "Last year 37,000 Americans died from the common flu. Nothing is shut down, life and the economy go on... Think about that."

This statement from the president requires context. We don't know exactly how many Americans' deaths there have been linked to flu. But estimates from the US Centers for Disease Control (CDC) give a range between 26,339 and 52,664 flu deaths last winter (between October 2019 and February 2020), with a best estimate of 34,157. So a lot of people die from flu each year, as Mr Trump points out.

However, unlike most strains of flu, the spread of new coronavirus has not yet been contained by vaccines or immunity from previous outbreaks, and scientists (including those from the WHO) believe it has a significantly higher death rate than that of seasonal flu (which, on average, is about 0.1%).

Claim 5

On 7 March: "Very soon, we're going to come up [with a vaccine]."

Currently there is no vaccine for this new coronavirus, although scientists in many countries are working hard to develop one. Scientists say realistically, one won't be ready until at least the middle of next year. Testing of vaccines on animals has already started and if that goes to plan, there could be human trials later in the year.

Claim 6

On 29 February: "We've taken the most aggressive actions to confront the coronavirus. They are the most aggressive taken by any country."

As we know, the US has imposed travel restrictions and quarantine measures but to suggest that the US has taken the most aggressive measures to counter the virus is not right. China and Italy, for example, have introduced widespread quarantining, affecting millions of people. The United States has not adopted anything remotely similar. BBC

 
 

Other News

.
Looking back on glorious Battle of Dien Bien Phu
Looking back on glorious Battle of Dien Bien Phu
YOUR VIETNAMicon  07/05/2020 

In 1953, eight years after reinvading Indochina, despite having mobilised huge economic and military resources, the French colonialists failed to achieve their purpose of destroying the revolutionary government

Vietnam must reach GDP growth of 5 per cent this year: PM
Vietnam must reach GDP growth of 5 per cent this year: PM
POLITICSicon  07/05/2020 

Vietnam’s GDP growth in 2020 must reach 5 per cent, higher than the 2.7 per cent the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has forecast, Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc has said.

Arrest warrant issued for Binh Dinh former official
Arrest warrant issued for Binh Dinh former official
POLITICSicon  07/05/2020 

The Investigation Police Agency in central Binh Dinh Province has issued an arrest warrant for Truong Hai An, a former official of the province, on charges of abuse of trust and property appropriation.

COVID-19: Laos agrees to facilitate repatriation of Vietnamese citizens
COVID-19: Laos agrees to facilitate repatriation of Vietnamese citizens
POLITICSicon  07/05/2020 

Lao authorities have agreed to allow Vietnamese citizens living and working in Laos to return to Vietnam via international border gates, the Vietnamese Embassy in Laos said on Tuesday.

Anti-corruption charge in Vietnam commended
Anti-corruption charge in Vietnam commended
POLITICSicon  06/05/2020 

Vietnam’s intensified crackdown on corruption has continued to draw praise from the international community.

Coronavirus: White House plans to disband virus task force
Coronavirus: White House plans to disband virus task force
POLITICSicon  06/05/2020 

US President Donald Trump has confirmed the White House coronavirus task force will be winding down, with Vice-President Mike Pence suggesting it could be disbanded within weeks.

PM urges efforts to revitalize socioeconomic development
PM urges efforts to revitalize socioeconomic development
POLITICSicon  06/05/2020 

As the coronavirus outbreak is mostly under control in Vietnam, it is necessary for the country to take decisive action to revive the local economy while ensuring measures to safeguard public health remain in place.

Vietnam to better protect citizens in local countries
Vietnam to better protect citizens in local countries
POLITICSicon  05/05/2020 

Vietnam will continue to offer support to overseas Vietnamese communities in a timely manner, an official has said.

Vietnam calls for stronger NAM cooperation in COVID-19 combat
Vietnam calls for stronger NAM cooperation in COVID-19 combat
POLITICSicon  05/05/2020 

Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc has suggested member countries of the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) step up cooperation and share experience at all levels and in all spheres during the fight against the COVID-19 pandemic.

HCM City, Australia’s Victoria state step up cooperation
HCM City, Australia’s Victoria state step up cooperation
POLITICSicon  05/05/2020 

Ho Chi Minh City and Australia’s Victoria state held a teleconference on May 4 to accelerate the signing of a memorandum of understanding (MoU) on their twining relationship.

PM Nguyen Xuan Phuc holds phone talks with Japanese counterpart
PM Nguyen Xuan Phuc holds phone talks with Japanese counterpart
POLITICSicon  05/05/2020 

PM Nguyen Xuan Phuc held phone talks with his Japanese counterpart Abe Shinzo on May 4, during which they exchanged views on the prevention and control of COVID-19 in their respective countries.

Fisheries Society opposes Chinese fishing bans in East Sea
Fisheries Society opposes Chinese fishing bans in East Sea
MARITIME SOVEREIGNTYicon  05/05/2020 

The Vietnam Fisheries Society (VINAFIS) released a document on May 4 opposing China’s issuance of regulations banning fishing in the East Sea this year.

Former deputy defense minister faces expulsion from Party
Former deputy defense minister faces expulsion from Party
POLITICSicon  03/05/2020 

The Party Central Committee’s Inspection Commission has proposed the Politburo and the committee expel Nguyen Van Hien, former Deputy Minister of Defense, from the Party.

Vietnam actively trying to bring citizens in US back home: Foreign Ministry
Vietnam actively trying to bring citizens in US back home: Foreign Ministry
POLITICSicon  03/05/2020 

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Transport and Vietnam’s representative offices in the US are actively joining hands to assist the Vietnam Airlines in clearing necessary procedures

North and South Korea exchange gunfire at border
North and South Korea exchange gunfire at border
POLITICSicon  03/05/2020 

Multiple shots were fired by North Korea towards the South in the Demilitarised Zone, South Korea says.

Kim Jong-un appears in public, North Korean state media report
Kim Jong-un appears in public, North Korean state media report
POLITICSicon  02/05/2020 

North Korea's Kim Jong-un makes his first public appearance for 20 days, state media report, amid speculation about his health.

Coronavirus: Trump seems to undercut US spies on virus origins
Coronavirus: Trump seems to undercut US spies on virus origins
POLITICSicon  01/05/2020 

US spies said it was not yet clear how the outbreak began, but Mr Trump suggests it came from a lab.

Vietnam attends ASEAN-US health ministers' meeting
Vietnam attends ASEAN-US health ministers' meeting
POLITICSicon  01/05/2020 

Vietnamese Deputy Minister of Health Nguyen Thanh Long on April 30 joined health officials of other ASEAN member nations and the US in the ASEAN-US Health Ministers Meeting via video conference.

ASEAN seeks solutions to ease COVID-19 impacts on tourism
ASEAN seeks solutions to ease COVID-19 impacts on tourism
POLITICSicon  01/05/2020 

ASEAN member nations have agreed to commit to a prevention plan as well as seeking cooperation from international organizations to together to revive travel confidence following the pandemic.

VN to adopt anti-forced labour convention, extend agricultural land use tax incentive: NA
VN to adopt anti-forced labour convention, extend agricultural land use tax incentive: NA
POLITICSicon  30/04/2020 

Vietnam plans to join the Convention 105 (C105) on the abolition of forced labour developed by the International Labour Organisation (ILO), the National Assembly (NA) Standing Committee concluded at its 44th session on Tuesday. 

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN