Content debate piques local interest

Following the ongoing showdown between Australian lawmakers and Google and Facebook, Vietnam aims to devise similar plans and force global tech titans to share some of the profits they make for using and sharing local press articles.

Content debate piques local interest
Ongoing haggles about shared news content could spark a global paradigm shift in content ownership.

As soon as the Australian administration and Facebook cleared a major hurdle in the ongoing dispute a fortnight ago, the Vietnamese Ministry of Information and Communications (MIC) and other relevant entities revealed that they are planning to build a similar code of regulations that requires cross-border social media platforms like Facebook and Google to spare a sizable portion of their profits from using the content of local news publishers.

Previously, Australian lawmakers argued that social media companies like Facebook and Google should pay publishers for the news content that populates their sites. Now, Vietnamese lawmakers are looking to follow this approach.

Le Quoc Minh, deputy general director of the Vietnam News Agency, argued in an interview last month, “We don’t just watch what our neighbours do, but do the same. With that said though, haggling with transnational giants is never easy, but we should still have a route of action.”

However, Facebook and Google both reacted fiercely after being presented with the Australian approach, with the former removing that nation’s news articles for five days and the latter threatening to shut down its services entirely in the country, leading to a dispute that only calmed down last month as both sides decided to take a step towards each other.

Nevertheless, up until now the question whether social media platforms should pay publishers for sharing their content remains partially unanswered, despite the fact that some ideas for long-term solutions may seem more feasible.

In Vietnam, a similar regulation could even come out this year, with the first draft expected to be launched within a short time. “Charging fees from tech giants is inevitable as they have been benefitting from Vietnamese newspapers for a long time,” said Le Quang Tu Do, deputy general director of the Authority of Broadcasting and Electronic Information at the MIC.

However, should Vietnam move towards a similarly harsh regulation as Australia did in the first place, social media platforms could think again about restricting functions or removing their services altogether, only this time in Vietnam.

Both, Google and Facebook argued that they support news publishers by offering an extra channel for their website traffic, and that the idea of requiring fees for displaying news content on their platforms violates the principle of open linking that the world wide web is built on.

Publishers on the other hand said that they have little choice but to play the tech titans’ game as their role in distributing their content is crucial in the modern media landscape.

The discussion is taking place not just in Australia and Vietnam but also several other countries. As someone currently delighted by the ongoing talks, competitors like Microsoft and four of Europe’s biggest news associations launched a joint call last month for the EU to adopt similar reforms to those in Australia.

The focus of all debates lies on two key issues, content sharing, and possible copyright infringements. News agencies and governments argued that social media platforms should share some of the profit they make as they display their content while social media platforms refer back to the open approach to linking and sharing. Another issue relates to possible copyright infringements when sharing parts of articles like their headlines and excerpts on social media.

 

Copyright laws, however, are vastly different in each country. While in the United States, the sharing of headlines and snippets is considered a fair use of content that does not need any negotiation or licensing, other legal frameworks already see an infringement in this.

Deciding what fair use is remains complicated though as it entails weighing whether a snippet on a social media platform could be seen as harmful for the publisher.

Two related legal precedents are a ruling by Australian judge Annabelle Bennet from 2010 who said, “Headlines generally are, like titles, simply too insubstantial and too short to qualify for copyright protection as literary works.”

This ruling, however, still leaves out the snippets that are commonly shared on social media.

In another case from 2007, the pornography publisher Perfect 10 sued Google for indexing thumbnails of its material in the search engine, claiming it would hurt its business. In the recent clash with Australian lawmakers, Google cited this case, among others, to showcase its respect for the copyrights of publishers.

The issues with Facebook and Google in Vietnam have been brought to the table repeatedly yet without any legal steps by the local press as Vietnam’s intellectual property regulations remain vague or miss related clauses.

Commenting on this, lawyer Nguyen Bao Thang, member of the Hanoi Bar Association, said the current intellectual property institutions have yet to clarify possible violations with regards to copyright infringements. Thus, Vietnam’s press has had a hard time bargaining with social media platforms and defending their interests.

“In addition, it is necessary to research related overseas laws, and policymakers should analyse what damage the press really takes if their content is shared on social media and then develop suitable adjustments to the legal framework,” said Thang.

VIR

Facebook, Google, YouTube likely obliged to pay taxes in Vietnam

Facebook, Google, YouTube likely obliged to pay taxes in Vietnam

Foreign tech giants like Facebook, Google, and YouTube will have to pay taxes in Vietnam under a draft circular, after years of invoicing their revenues out of the country.

Where are Vietnam’s social networks in comparison with Facebook, Google?

Where are Vietnam’s social networks in comparison with Facebook, Google?

With the establishment of a series of social networks, Vietnam is one of only a few countries with domestic products that are competitive with cross-border platforms.

 
 

Other News

.
HCM City's new water-drainage plan considers impact of rising sea levels, climate change
HCM City's new water-drainage plan considers impact of rising sea levels, climate change
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  02/04/2021 

A plan for a new water-drainage network in HCM City has been submitted to the Prime Minister for approval.

Vietnam strives to become regional pioneer in reducing ocean plastic waste
Vietnam strives to become regional pioneer in reducing ocean plastic waste
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  02/04/2021 

Vietnam is striving to become a regional pioneer in reducing ocean plastic waste, heard a recent virtual meeting of environmental officials of Vietnam, Germany, Ecuador and Ghana.

Second “Make in Vietnam” Covid-19 test kit to be launched
Second “Make in Vietnam” Covid-19 test kit to be launched
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  02/04/2021 

The second locally-produced Covid-19 test kit is waiting for a license, the Ministry of Science and Technology said at a recent press conference.

Network attacks on Vietnamese systems decrease by 20%
Network attacks on Vietnamese systems decrease by 20%
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  02/04/2021 

In the first quarter of 2021, the Department of Information Security at the Ministry of Information and Communications recorded 1,271 cyber-attacks on information systems in Vietnam, a reduction of 20% compared to the same period last year.

HUST inaugurates AI international research centre
HUST inaugurates AI international research centre
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  02/04/2021 

The Hanoi University of Science and Technology (HUST) has inaugurated its international research centre on artificial intelligence (AI).

ICT can help Vietnam turn into a dragon
ICT can help Vietnam turn into a dragon
FEATUREicon  31/03/2021 

After escaping poverty, we are carrying the aspiration of turning the country into a Dragon and a Tiger. In peacetime, national heroes will be those who bring prosperity and mightiness to the country.

Vietnam’s first autonomous vehicle debuts
Vietnam’s first autonomous vehicle debuts
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  30/03/2021 

Phenikaa Group, a multi-sectoral corporation, has introduced its prototype of a level-4 autonomous vehicle, Vietnam's first smart self-driving vehicle.

Vietnam to have national water resource monitoring system by 2030
Vietnam to have national water resource monitoring system by 2030
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  30/03/2021 

Vietnam has set a goal of building and maintaining a national water resource monitoring system and another system to forecast flooding, drought, saltwater intrusion and rising sea water level by 2030.

Tisco builds dumping ground for hazardous waste in Thai Nguyen
Tisco builds dumping ground for hazardous waste in Thai Nguyen
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  29/03/2021 

Nine days after VietNamNet published an article about the existence of an outdoor furnace dust mountain at Tisco, the waste owner is now hurrying to build a dumping ground.

Vietnam has highest rate of new digital service consumers in SEA
Vietnam has highest rate of new digital service consumers in SEA
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  28/03/2021 

Vietnam had the highest rate of new digital service consumers in the Southeast Asia region last year, it was reported at the recent World Mobile Broadband & ICT 2021 conference in Hanoi.

Land subsidence endangers Mekong Delta
Land subsidence endangers Mekong Delta
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  28/03/2021 

The overexploitation of groundwater in the Cuu Long (Mekong) Delta has contributed to severe land subsidence, which could lead to devastating consequences if the practice continues, experts have said.

Science to be used to ensure food security, nutritional balance
Science to be used to ensure food security, nutritional balance
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  28/03/2021 

A new Government resolution aims to use science and technology to ensure nutritional balance in the Vietnamese diet.

Becoming a cybersecurity power to have peace
Becoming a cybersecurity power to have peace
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  27/03/2021 

A cybersecurity powerhouse is like a military power in the real world. Vietnam must be a power in cybersecurity. 

Vietnam to trial 5G services on a large scale in 2021
Vietnam to trial 5G services on a large scale in 2021
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  26/03/2021 

The Ministry of Information and Communications will take the initiative in the commercialization of 5G in Vietnam.

Vietnamese telecom providers survey users’ satisfaction
Vietnamese telecom providers survey users’ satisfaction
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  26/03/2021 

The survey was conducted with 8,400 personal questionnaires and 300 corporate questionnaires, showing the satisfaction level and habits of users of telecommunications services in Vietnam.

Vietnam’s smartphone brands take different paths on their journey to world market
Vietnam’s smartphone brands take different paths on their journey to world market
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  28/03/2021 

Mobiistar, Vsmart and Bphone in recent years have been trying to enter the world market, but their stories and results have varied.

Made-in-Vietnam AI system detects human face in a second
Made-in-Vietnam AI system detects human face in a second
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  26/03/2021 

The made-in-Vietnam AI system's camera is able to process high-quality images in real-time with 30 frames per second.

EU carbon tax plan compels local suppliers to step up
EU carbon tax plan compels local suppliers to step up
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  25/03/2021 

Vietnamese manufacturing exporters will be under pressure to invest in greener solutions once the European Union adopts a resolution on placing a carbon tax on some products from outside the bloc that do not meet decarbonisation standards.

Hanoi to install nine more free WiFi hotspots
Hanoi to install nine more free WiFi hotspots
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  25/03/2021 

The installation of wifi hotspots by the Hanoi Department of Information & Communications is part of its plan for digital transformation and Tourism improvement in the capital city.

Vietnamese lecturer at Australian university receives $3 million for research
Vietnamese lecturer at Australian university receives $3 million for research
FEATUREicon  29/03/2021 

As the first author of six scientific articles and owner of one patent, Dr Ta Thu Hang has had great opportunities to get a promotion at a leading Australian university.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN