Coronavirus: Are mutations making it more infectious?

While there have been thousands of changes to the virus only one is seen as possibly altering its behaviour.

The coronavirus that is menacing the world right now is not the same as the coronavirus that first emerged in China.

Sars-Cov-2, the official name of the virus that causes the disease Covid-19, and continues to blaze a path of destruction across the globe, is mutating.

But, while scientists have spotted thousands of mutations, or changes to the virus's genetic material, only one has so far been singled out as possibly altering its behaviour.

The crucial questions about this mutation are: does this make the virus more infectious - or lethal - in humans? And could it pose a threat to the success of a future vaccine?

This coronavirus is actually changing very slowly compared with a virus-like flu. With relatively low levels of natural immunity in the population, no vaccine and few effective treatments, there's no pressure on it to adapt. So far, it's doing a good job of keeping itself in circulation as it is. 

The notable mutation - named D614G and situated within the protein making up the virus's "spike" it uses to break into our cells - appeared sometime after the initial Wuhan outbreak, probably in Italy. It is now seen in as many as 97% of samples around the world.

Evolutionary edge

The question is whether this dominance is the mutation giving the virus some advantage, or whether it's just by chance.

Viruses don't have a grand plan. They mutate constantly and while some changes will help a virus reproduce, some may hinder it. Others are simply neutral. They're a "by-product of the virus replicating," says Dr Lucy van Dorp, of University College London. They "hitch-hike" on the virus without changing its behaviour.

The mutation that has emerged could have become very widespread just because it happened early in the outbreak and spread - something known as the "founder effect". This is what Dr van Dorp and her team believe is the likely explanation for the mutation being so common. But this is increasingly controversial.

A growing number - perhaps the majority - of virologists now believe, as Dr Thushan de Silva, at the University of Sheffield, explains, there is enough data to say this version of the virus has a "selective advantage" - an evolutionary edge - over the earlier version.

Though there is still not enough evidence to say "it's more transmissible" in people, he says, he's sure it's "not neutral".

When studied in laboratory conditions, the mutated virus was better at entering human cells than those without the variation, say professors Hyeryun Choe and Michael Farzan, at Scripps University in Florida. Changes to the spike protein the virus uses to latch on to human cells seem to allow it to "stick together better and function more efficiently".

But that's where they drew the line.

Prof Farzan said the spike proteins of these viruses were different in a way that was "consistent with, but not proving, greater transmissibility".

 

Lab result proof

At the Genome Technology Center at New York University, Dr Neville Sanjana, who normally spends his time working on gene-editing technology Crispr. has gone one step further.

His team edited a virus so that it had this alteration to the spike protein and pitted it against a real Sars-CoV-2 virus from the early Wuhan outbreak, without the mutation, in human tissue cells. The results, he believes, prove the mutated virus is more transmissible than the original version, at least in the lab.

Dr van Dorp points out "it is unclear" how representative they are of transmission in real patients. But Prof Farzan says these "marked biological differences" were "substantial enough to tilt the evidence somewhat" in favour of the idea that the mutation is making the virus better at spreading.

Outside a Petri dish, there is some indirect evidence this mutation makes coronavirus more transmissible in humans. Two studies have suggested patients with this mutated virus have larger amounts of the virus in their swab samples. That might suggest they were more infectious to others.

They didn't find evidence that those people became sicker or stayed in hospital for longer, though.

In general, being more transmissible doesn't mean a virus is more lethal - in fact the opposite is often true. There's no evidence this coronavirus has mutated to make patients more or less sick.

But even when it comes to transmissibility, viral load is only an indication of how well the virus is spreading within a single person. It doesn't necessarily explain how good it is at infecting others. The "gold standard" of research - a controlled trial - hasn't yet been carried out. That might involve, for example, infecting animals with either one or the other variant of the virus to see which spreads more in a population.

One of the studies' leads, Prof Bette Korber, at Los Alamos National Laboratory in the US, said there was not a consensus, but the idea the mutation increased patients' viral load was "getting less controversial as more data accrues".

The mutation is the pandemic

When it comes to looking at the population as a whole, it's difficult to observe the virus becoming more (or less) infectious. Its course has been drastically altered by interventions, including lockdowns.

But Prof Korber says the fact the variant now appears to be dominant everywhere, including in China, indicates it may have become better at spreading between people than the original version. Whenever the two versions were in circulation at the same time, the new variant took over.

In fact, the D614G variant is so dominant, it is now the pandemic. And it has been for some time - perhaps even since the start of the epidemic in places like the UK and the east coast of the US. So, while evidence is mounting that this mutation is not neutral, it doesn't necessarily change how we should think about the virus and its spread.

On a more reassuring note, most of the vaccines in development are based on a different region of the spike so this should not have an impact on their development. And there's some evidence the new form is just as sensitive to antibodies, which can protect you against an infection once you've had it - or been vaccinated against it.

But since the science of Covid-19 is so fast-moving, this is something all scientists - wherever they stand on the meaning of the current mutations - will be keen to keep an eye on. BBC

 
 

Other News

.
Many Facebook accounts in Vietnam may become permanently locked
Many Facebook accounts in Vietnam may become permanently locked
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  19/08/2021 

Many Facebook accounts in Vietnam have received notices of suspension due to violations of community policy. If the users do not give a compelling reason, their accounts will be permanently locked.

40% of Covid-19 cases in Hanoi found through electronic medical declaration screening
40% of Covid-19 cases in Hanoi found through electronic medical declaration screening
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  18/08/2021 

As many as 13,579 people reporting coughing and high temperature on medical declarations turned out to be positive cases, amounting to 40 percent of total cases of the city.

Vietnam's NanoDragon satellite to be launched before March 2022
Vietnam's NanoDragon satellite to be launched before March 2022
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  18/08/2021 

The Vietnam Space Center (VNSC) has handed over its NanoDragon satellite to the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) at the Uchinoura Space Center’s launch site in Kagoshima Prefecture in southern Japan.

Vietnam reports over 3,900 cyberattacks in seven months
Vietnam reports over 3,900 cyberattacks in seven months
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  18/08/2021 

Vietnam recorded more than 3,900 cyberattacks in the first seven months of 2021, according to the Authority of Information Security (AIS) under the Ministry of Information and Communications.

Infrastructure ready for digital economy, society: Minister
Infrastructure ready for digital economy, society: Minister
FEATUREicon  18/08/2021 

Green and digital development is the main development trend in the first half of the 21st century.

Technology to support fight against COVID-19
Technology to support fight against COVID-19
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  17/08/2021 

Technology is a supportive tool of the health sector in COVID-19 prevention and control, and is a means for people to cooperate with the health sector, experts have said.

Hanoi cleans up its pond life
Hanoi cleans up its pond life
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  16/08/2021 

Rapid urbanisation have led to increasing demand for housing and infrastructure. Consequently, ponds and lakes across the city have been filled to make room for construction.

People in need and benefactors find each other on Made-in-Vietnam app
People in need and benefactors find each other on Made-in-Vietnam app
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  16/08/2021 

Zalo CONNECT, one of the important technology platforms to support Covid-19 affected people, is managed by the National Technology Center for Covid-19 Prevention and Control.

Australia and Vietnam bolster ICT cooperation
Australia and Vietnam bolster ICT cooperation
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  15/08/2021 

It is an opportunity for Vietnamese IT companies to strengthen their connection with Australian pairs and vice versa.

Quality of Vietnam's Internet to be tested weekly
Quality of Vietnam's Internet to be tested weekly
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  15/08/2021 

From August 2021, the Vietnam Telecommunications Authority (Ministry of Information & Communications) will announce the weekly test results of Vietnam's Internet quality based on user experience.

First report on maritime environment, national islands completed
First report on maritime environment, national islands completed
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/08/2021 

The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment (MoNRE) has completed a report on maritime environment and national islands in the 2016-20 period, Director General of the Vietnam Administration of Seas and Islands Ta Dinh Thi said on August 13.

Vietnam integrates databases for Covid-19 prevention, control tasks
Vietnam integrates databases for Covid-19 prevention, control tasks
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/08/2021 

Along with the active work of the medical staff, the technology human resources are trying to develop useful software pieces to serve Covid-19 prevention and control tasks in hope of putting the latest outbreak under control at the earliest time.

Vietnam vows to place 5 million farming households on e-commerce sites
Vietnam vows to place 5 million farming households on e-commerce sites
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  15/08/2021 

Deputy Minister of Information and Communications Pham Anh Tuan has urged creating detailed plans on putting farming households on e-commerce sites.

Quang Ninh to implement solutions for garbage crisis
Quang Ninh to implement solutions for garbage crisis
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/08/2021 

Ha Long City, a popular tourist destination in the northern coastal province of Quang Ninh, will implement a series of measures to classify, collect, transport and treat domestic and construction waste from early next year.

Vietnam's NanoDragon microsatellite to be launched in Japan
Vietnam's NanoDragon microsatellite to be launched in Japan
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/08/2021 

Vietnam has sent NanoDragon satellite to Japan to hand over to the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) to launch into space.

Axie Infinity capitalizes at US$4.4 billion
Axie Infinity capitalizes at US$4.4 billion
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/08/2021 

The virtual currency in the Vietnamese blockchain game Axie Infinity - Axie Infinity Shards (AXS) - has hit a new peak of $71, setting a record capitalization of $4.4 billion.

Project to develop human resources for information security kicks off
Project to develop human resources for information security kicks off
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/08/2021 

The 23-member executive board of a project on training and developing human resources for information security for the 2021 - 2025 period has been established, led by Deputy Minister of Information and Communications Nguyen Huy Dung.

Nationally shared digital platforms will create a unified Vietnam: Minister
Nationally shared digital platforms will create a unified Vietnam: Minister
FEATUREicon  14/08/2021 

This is the message the Minister of Information and Communications Nguyen Manh Hung conveyed when delivering a speech at a ceremony launching Telehealth, the platform that allows medical examinations to be conducted from a distance.

Monkeys cause chaos during social distancing orders on Cham Islands
Monkeys cause chaos during social distancing orders on Cham Islands
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  12/08/2021 

Experts from the Cham Island Maritime Protected Area (MPA) and Hoi An are looking to drive monkeys back to the forest after the animals broke into houses.

Crafting regulations to build a digitalised future
Crafting regulations to build a digitalised future
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  12/08/2021 

With the appearance of Industry 4.0 and the huge impact of the global health crisis, the world is in the breakthrough stage of digital transformation. This is the opportunity for Vietnam to realise its aspiration of prosperity.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN