Deeper look into ecological costs of coal-fired power in Mekong Delta needed: expert

Ecological expert Nguyen Huu Thien speaks on the need for clearer environmental regulations for thermopower plants in the Mekong Delta to reduce risks to the region’s aquatic resources.

Deeper look into ecological costs of coal-fired power in Mekong Delta needed: expert

Ecological expert Nguyen Huu Thien. — Photo nongnghiep.vn

What are the notable characteristics of the Mekong Delta's fish resources?

The area we need to focus on the most is where the Mekong River tributaries meet the sea, including the river basin and the coastal waters, as these areas are rich in diversity.

Anadromous species, those that live most of their lives in the sea but migrate into freshwater areas to spawn; catadromous are the opposite, meaning they live in freshwater but spawn in the sea; potamodromous species are those living entirely in freshwater but have to migrate long distances through river networks to spawn or hunt.

Take pangasius krempfi (cá bông lau) for example, it’s a freshwater fish but it migrates to the sea in certain phrases of its life. After spawning in the waterfalls of the mid-stream Mekong, the eggs will go along with the water downstream and the baby fish live in the sea until they reach a certain size, then they will swim up the Mekong River to get to southern Laos in May or June to spawn.

This is one of the fish species with the longest migration distance in Mekong River. The species is a major catch for communities living on the Tien and Hau rivers of the Mekong Delta.

What are the consequences of coal-fired thermal power plants in the Mekong Delta?

The first impact is to the water environment. As thermal power plants draw water from the Hau and Tien rivers for cooling, the discharged water – which is usually about 7 degrees Celsius hotter than the ambient water, causes thermal pollution and degradation of water quality.

This leads to a thermal shock for the species as most of them live comfortably only within a narrow temperature range, and if the ambient temperature rises or decreases to a level beyond their tolerance they could weaken and die.

According to the Revised Power Development Master Plan for 2011-20 with a vision to 2030, 12 coal-fired power plants with a total capacity of 15,780MW are planned for the Mekong Delta region. Has your research looked into the thermal pollution level if these plants are built?

According to our calculations, if the input water’s temperature is about 25-27 Celsius degrees (or up to 32 Celsius degrees in the summer), and the discharged cooling water is about 7 degrees higher, then several sections of the Mekong River will suffer from thermal pollution.

If all the plants are built, the total volume of discharged cooling water from them would reach 21.8 billion cu.m per year in 2020-50.

Against the total volume of water that the Mekong River discharges into the sea at about 475 billion cu.m a year, the cooling water volume would be equal to 4.5 per cent, quite a significant amount.

These are our calculations in a normal weather setting, in abnormal cases such as heavy drought in 2016, the impact of cooling water discharge would be even greater. With that said, as these figures are derived from many hypothetical assumptions, they should be for reference only.

Thermal pollution will surely happen, but the extent of the phenomenon remains hard to say to sure. Tides could also impact the heat transfer process, making for inconsistent thermal pollution across the length of the stream. We also expect that the temperature increase might be lower than our projections but the river’s water might retain heat for longer due to alluvium content.

 

In addition, coal-fired thermal power plants also emit polluting gases like sulfur oxides (SOx) and nitrogen oxide (NOx), which could cause acid rain, which would ultimately pollute the land and water and ecological system of a wider region than where the plants are situated.

Do all the planned thermal power plants need environmental impact assessments approved by agencies?

Usually, a project’s impact is assessed only in a limited geographical region surrounding the project. So when it comes to a cluster of plants along a river, the separate assessment approach would not give a comprehensive judgement of the combined impacts of all the plants on said river.

The interdependent relations between habitats – for example, species that move between the sea and the river water regions in different stages of their lives – should also be taken into account. Impacts from the coal-fired thermal power plants in one place could result in knock-on impacts in a wider region, even beyond our borders.

What are your recommendations?

I have five recommendations.

First, for agencies to make the right decision regarding power development plans, a strategic environmental assessment should be done for the Mekong Delta region. There has already been one assessment like that for the National Power Development Plan VII but the scope of it is the entire country, so there should be one focusing on the particulars of the Mekong Delta.

Second, thermal pollution should be an issue that needs much more attention as aquatic resources in the Mekong River are an important pillar of the region’s ecology, economy, culture and livelihood.

Third, strategic environmental assessments for a project must be conducted before the approval in principle for said project is given, and combined impacts of all projects in the region must also be looked at.

Fourth, the consideration of costs and benefits of power plans cannot only be based on investment and financial rewards but also the ecological and social costs that are fully and appropriately calculated.

Finally, the use of more modern technologies in coal-fired power plants – namely, supercritical (SC) and ultra-supercritical (USC), which are supposed to generate less ash and slag or dust – is important but regulators must set out a limit on emissions or water temperature increases, especially in areas like river mouths. I cannot stress enough the importance of these areas. — VNS

Will the Mekong Delta have fewer coal-fired power plants?

Will the Mekong Delta have fewer coal-fired power plants?

Ecology expert Nguyen Huu Thien has warned about a series of problems that coal-fired power plants may cause to the Mekong Delta, especially the impact on the ecosystem.

Coal-fired thermopower may kill aquaculture in Mekong Delta

Coal-fired thermopower may kill aquaculture in Mekong Delta

Aquaculture is one of the economic pillars and important livelihoods of the Mekong Delta. However, it is threatened by coal-fired thermopower plants.

 
 

Other News

.
VN government decree to sweep away spam calls
VN government decree to sweep away spam calls
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  22/08/2020 

Businesses in the fields of real estate, insurance and education will bear the biggest influences from the newly released decree on preventing spam messages and calls.

Flood season coming late, drought may hit Mekong Delta again next year
Flood season coming late, drought may hit Mekong Delta again next year
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  21/08/2020 

This year’s flood season in the Mekong Delta is likely to arrive late and if there is insufficient rain in the months to come, drought and saltwater intrusion may plague the region again during the next dry season, experts have warned.

Bluezone Covid-19 tracking app downloaded 20 million times
Bluezone Covid-19 tracking app downloaded 20 million times
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  21/08/2020 

Bluezone, a Bluetooth-based app that helps determine if a person has come in contact with a COVID-19 patient, has tracked 1,391 cases of people having close contact with an infected or suspected Covid-19 infection.

Hanoi river water remains polluted
Hanoi river water remains polluted
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  22/08/2020 

The quality of surface water in many lakes and rivers in the north has improved, but 15 monitoring areas of 185 that have been monitored remain heavily polluted, mainly on the Cau and Nhue-Day rivers.

Air quality improving in northern region
Air quality improving in northern region
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/08/2020 

Air quality in the north of the country is improving, according to the Vietnam Environment Administration.

“Make in Vietnam” Awards to honor VN digital technology solutions
“Make in Vietnam” Awards to honor VN digital technology solutions
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/08/2020 

The Ministry of Information and Communications (MIC) and the Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry (VCCI) on August 19 launched the “Make in Vietnam” Awards. 

Dialogue looks at Vietnam - EU maritime economic cooperation
Dialogue looks at Vietnam - EU maritime economic cooperation
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/08/2020 

A dialogue with the theme “Sustainable Maritime Development: Sharing Vietnam and EU’s Perspectives” took place in Hanoi on August 19 with over 150 in attendance.

Information and Communications Ministry sets eight key programs for the new period
Information and Communications Ministry sets eight key programs for the new period
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  19/08/2020 

“The ICT industry can create a pair of wings for the country to fly. One wing is digital technology and the other is communication," Information and Communications Minister Nguyen Manh Hung said.

HCM City to charge fee for sewerage to reduce flooding
HCM City to charge fee for sewerage to reduce flooding
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  21/08/2020 

HCM City Department of Construction has proposed to collect fees on discharged water in an effort to deal with the severe flooding problem in the area.

Western sea dyke needs urgent protection
Western sea dyke needs urgent protection
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  19/08/2020 

Many sections of the western sea dyke in Ca Mau and Kien Giang provinces in the Mekong Delta have seriously eroded and could collapse at any time if prompt protective measures are not taken.

High-tech trash bins wow Hanoians
High-tech trash bins wow Hanoians
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  22/08/2020 

If they were to ever think about trash, most people would picture a load of waste thrown. New style trash bins, developed from human creativity, can also be used for storage and contribute to beautifying city streets.

Vietnam takes the lead in ASEAN’s digital evolution
Vietnam takes the lead in ASEAN’s digital evolution
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  19/08/2020 

With its great potential in IT, Vietnam as ASEAN chair has been making efforts together with other member states in boosting the application of high technologies to adapt to the Fourth Industrial Revolution, which is sweeping regionwide.

Time to ensure security of water sources, safety of dams and lakes: experts
Time to ensure security of water sources, safety of dams and lakes: experts
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  20/08/2020 

Vietnam has recorded outstanding socio-economic development and has been lauded for it by the international community, but along with progress, the country is facing challenges with water management and security, an official has said.

Food donated to save zoo animals in HCM City
Food donated to save zoo animals in HCM City
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  18/08/2020 

Saigon Zoo has received tonnes of fruits and vegetables from donors across the country to feed the zoo animals after a recent plea from the managers.

Vietnam aims to be among top 30 countries for Global Cybersecurity Index
Vietnam aims to be among top 30 countries for Global Cybersecurity Index
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  17/08/2020 

By 2030 Vietnam will be listed as one of the top 30 countries for the International Telecommunication Union’s (ITU) Global Cybersecurity Index, targeted the national digital transformation program. 

Ben Tre province repairs eroded riverbank section
Ben Tre province repairs eroded riverbank section
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  16/08/2020 

The Mekong Delta province of Ben Tre is restoring a section along the banks of Ba Lai river that eroded when a temporary dam was removed along the banks.

Bluezone helps saves resources to fight against Covid-19
Bluezone helps saves resources to fight against Covid-19
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  16/08/2020 

If this app is deployed on a large scale enough, Bluezone will help save huge social resources and cost to fight Covid-19 epidemic in Vietnam, as well as help the economy resume operation under the new normal state.

5G network testing licences for Viettel, VNPT and MobiFone extended
5G network testing licences for Viettel, VNPT and MobiFone extended
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  16/08/2020 

The Telecommunications Department said that the Vietnam Post and Telecommunications Group’s (VNPT) license to test the 5G technology has expired and it has asked for extension. 

Ministry proposes solutions to raise Vietnam’s e-Government rankings
Ministry proposes solutions to raise Vietnam’s e-Government rankings
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  14/08/2020 

In its recent report on the UN’s e-government rankings, the Ministry of Information and Communications has proposed that Prime Minister direct and assign key tasks to ministries, branches and localities to implement a number of solutions

Make-in-Vietnam blockchain platform debuts to assist digital transformation
Make-in-Vietnam blockchain platform debuts to assist digital transformation
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  14/08/2020 

The Ministry of Information and Communications, on August 13, held a ceremony to debut the akaChain blockchain platform, as part of a programme introducing “Make in Vietnam” digital platforms.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN