Fairness must be guaranteed in use of natural resources

Dang Hung Vo, former Deputy Minister of Natural Resources and Environment, talks about solutions to unleash the private sector’s potential.

Fairness must be guaranteed in use of natural resources
Dang Hung Vo, former Deputy Minister of Natural Resources and Environment. Photo VGP


How much does unleashing the potential and fully utilising the country’s resources matter to Vietnam?

Utilising resources – including land, human resources, financial resources and technology – determines the speed and quality of economic growth in all countries.

Take land for example. Land fee collections in Vietnam only account for 20 per cent of local governments’ revenues, while the rate in industrialised nations can go up to 50-90 per cent.

Vietnam’s use of financial capital also needs to improve. The country’s incremental capital-output ratio (ICOR) since 2010 averages a little higher than 5, or only one third of Thailand’s. Our labour productivity is also only half that of Thailand and Indonesia.

In recent years, Vietnam’s indicators regarding efficiency in the use of resources have been improving but these are barely registered on a worldwide scale.

The Vietnam 2035 Report, a joint effort by the Government of Vietnam and the World Bank Group, emphasised the biggest weakness Vietnam needed to address was efficiency. This recommendation has been incorporated in the Prime Minister’s plan to transform the country's economic growth model.

In the PM's article, one of the four major orientations is to remove bottlenecks to make sure natural resources (land, water, minerals, etc.) are appropriately distributed and effectively utilised in the market economy. What are your comments on this issue?

The Prime Minister has stated that the current mechanism for resource allocation is filled with problems, resulting in a paradox where people who could effectively make use of the resources are held back from gaining access to them, while those assigned with the management of these resources fail to utilise them, or even worse, cause severe losses. This paradox is one that must be addressed soon.

According to the Government leader, all mechanism- or policy-related bottlenecks that hinder the effective use and capitalisation of resources must be resolved to make sure market demands will be the “decider” in allocating and mobilising resources, and that equal access will be guaranteed between players in our socialist-oriented market economy.

I think to realise the goals that PM Phuc stated will need studies and research to come up with practical initiatives. The biggest challenge at the moment is that the law has not provided a detailed working framework on the conversion of natural resources to the properties of different players in the market economy.

Regarding land, our law has started to switch to “land use rights” – in lieu of our previous principle that “land belongs to the entire people” but represented and managed by the State, or basically no private ownership of land – to make land truly a resource that can be utilised in line with market mechanisms, which concerns the idea of private ownership of land.

This workaround is certainly not a bad idea, but the details need to be refined to avoid ineffective capitalisation of land, which usually involves regrettable losses and corruption.

 

Natural forest and preservation vs. development issues are even more intricate than land issues since we cannot just convert natural forestland into properties of the one assigned with the management or use of them, which also means that there is a lack of motivation to continue taking care or enriching of poor forests.

Regarding water and minerals, the conversion of natural resources into assets has become easier since they can be exploited for commercial products. The problem with these types of resources is ensuring effective and strict State management to prevent losses.

To ensure corruption-free capitalisation of resources, the importance of transparency, public supervision and accountability cannot be stressed enough.

A State agency decision to allocate land – or any type of natural resource like a mineral mine or a piece of forest – to a private investor should always be questioned. The risks of corruption could always emerge from the difference between the State’s valuation of the land in question and its actual market value.

In this new age, highly developed nations have already applied Artificial Intelligence, Big Data and remote sensing to modernise the management of large-scale and complicated resources and to avoid corruption and losses.

What do you consider the biggest constraints over the utilisation of land, arguably the most important natural resource in the country?

The biggest issue is to ensure fairness in the conversion of low-yielding areas to development projects that are supposed to bring higher value. It doesn’t sound too much of a problem on paper but in reality, to properly and transparently assess the value of any land is difficult. As we have seen, many high-profile corruption cases have involved the illegal conversion and trade of supposedly low-value land.

Another problem is that during the conversion process, the State usually has to expropriate people’s land and transfer it to investors. Those who have their land taken are heavily affected. The National Assembly said 70 per cent of complaints it received were land-related.

Petty corruption is also something we need to worry about. Take for example rampant bribery demands or extortion in the implementation of land administrative procedures, especially at local levels.

The basic problem lies in the approach to amending the law, which really should follow a market mechanism. We should let the market do what it does well and be legally responsible for it. Government officials’ should be monitoring and planning, rather than dealing directly with mundane tasks that are fertile breeding grounds for graft and malfeasance. — VNS

Vietnam under pressure to address corruption in private sector: UNDP

Vietnam under pressure to address corruption in private sector: UNDP

Corruption increases the cost of doing business, distorts the competitive environment, limits opportunities for investment and widens the growing social inequality, according to a UNDP expert.

Private firms confused about anti-corruption law

Private firms confused about anti-corruption law

Private businesses have said they were unsure about how to implement the 2018 Law on Anti-Corruption that came into effect on July 1.

Experts gather in Hanoi to discuss anti-corruption

Experts gather in Hanoi to discuss anti-corruption

The enormous demand for infrastructure investment across Asia-Pacific had led to greater risks of corruption, Deputy Inspector General Tran Ngoc Liem said yesterday.

 
 

Other News

.
Hanoi now at “very high” risk of COVID-19 transmission: chairman
Hanoi now at “very high” risk of COVID-19 transmission: chairman
SOCIETYicon  06/08/2020 

Hanoi has raised its COVID-19 alert level as it is currently at “very high” risk of coronavirus transmission, according to Chairman of the municipal People’s Committee Nguyen Duc Chung.

Vietnamese, Lao localities jointly bust cross-border drug trafficking ring
Vietnamese, Lao localities jointly bust cross-border drug trafficking ring
SOCIETYicon  06/08/2020 

The Border Guard in the central province of Quang Tri worked with security forces in Laos’ Savannakhet province to arrest five Lao suspects as a result of an expanded investigation into a ring trafficking drugs from Laos to Vietnam.

Region-based minimum wage likely to remain unchanged in 2021
Region-based minimum wage likely to remain unchanged in 2021
SOCIETYicon  06/08/2020 

The region-based minimum wage will not be adjusted in 2021, said Deputy Minister of Labour, Invalids and Social Affairs Le Van Thanh, Chairman of the National Wage Council, at a meeting in Hanoi on August 5.

Coronavirus strain in Da Nang outbreak more infectious, but not deadlier: experts
Coronavirus strain in Da Nang outbreak more infectious, but not deadlier: experts
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

The new outbreak has caused public concern after causing eight deaths in a week, Vietnam's first since the onset of the pandemic.

Energy sector to go on recruitment drive this year: report
Energy sector to go on recruitment drive this year: report
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

The energy sector is likely to see a sharp increase in hiring during the rest of the year, recruitment company Navigos Group has said in a report released recently.

Planning on Red River banks need pushing up
Planning on Red River banks need pushing up
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

Hanoi has created urban development plans for the banks of the Hong (Red) River, yet problems remain due to lack of flood and dyke planning.

HCM City prepares scenario for 50 new COVID-19 cases
HCM City prepares scenario for 50 new COVID-19 cases
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

The city must prepare facilities and human resources for at least 50 new COVID-19 cases, HCM City Party Committee secretary Nguyen Thien Nhan said at a recent meeting  with the Steering Board for COVID-19 prevention and control.

Brave doctors head to Da Nang to fight outbreak
Brave doctors head to Da Nang to fight outbreak
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

As thousands of tourists fled Da Nang after the COVID-19 outbreak sprang up in the central city, dozens of leading doctors went in the opposite direction, towards the danger.

Latest Coronavirus News in Vietnam & Southeast Asia August 5
Latest Coronavirus News in Vietnam & Southeast Asia August 5
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

PM encourages “soldiers in white coats” in COVID-19 fight

Illegal immigration organisers sent to prison
Illegal immigration organisers sent to prison
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

The People’s Court of the northern province of Quang Ninh on August 4 sentenced Voong A Sui and five accomplices to a total of 25 years in prison for organising illegal immigration.

HCM City issues work permits to 5,370 foreigners since year's beginning
HCM City issues work permits to 5,370 foreigners since year's beginning
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

Ho Chi Minh City has issued work permits to 5,370 foreigners, including over 2,400 new ones, since the beginning of this year.

Coffee shoes help entrepreneurs tread new ground
Coffee shoes help entrepreneurs tread new ground
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

Two young Vietnamese entrepreneurs have developed a unique way to make sneakers, and they hope their idea be a wake-up call for the training shoe industry.

Young people found 'seed library'
Young people found 'seed library'
SOCIETYicon  06/08/2020 

Hai Dang, 27, and Minh Thu, 34, and their group members have spent many months connecting gardens to create a “seed library”.

Congested, dangerous HCM City street to be widened
Congested, dangerous HCM City street to be widened
SOCIETYicon  05/08/2020 

HCM City plans to widen a section of Nguyen Duy Trinh Street in District 9, one of the city’s accident hotspots, to 30m at a cost of more than VND800 billion (US$34.5 million).

Strict measures to limit COVID-19 spread in central region's hot spots
Strict measures to limit COVID-19 spread in central region's hot spots
SOCIETYicon  04/08/2020 

The central province of Quang Ngai has reopened its General Hospital after a week under lockdown, the provincial heath department said on Monday.

Vietnam rules out Hydroxychloroquine, uses convalescent plasma in COVID-19 treatment
Vietnam rules out Hydroxychloroquine, uses convalescent plasma in COVID-19 treatment
SOCIETYicon  04/08/2020 

Vietnam has completely halted the use of Hydroxychloroquine, the controversial antimalaria drug touted by US President Donald Trump, in its treatment of COVID-19 patients and instead opted for plasma from recovered cases.

HCM City warns unmasked residents of fines starting tomorrow
HCM City warns unmasked residents of fines starting tomorrow
SOCIETYicon  04/08/2020 

As residents have recently been giving little heed to the health authority’s advice to wear masks in public amid the surge in new Covid-19 cases,

Japanese exec infected with Covid-19 interacted with 28 people in HCMC
Japanese exec infected with Covid-19 interacted with 28 people in HCMC
SOCIETYicon  04/08/2020 

During a two-day stay in HCMC, a Japanese business executive who had been confirmed positive for the new coronavirus by the Japanese authorities while returning to Tokyo from Vietnam’s Lam Dong Province on July 31 interacted with 28 people

Four investigated for selling fake medical clothing
Four investigated for selling fake medical clothing
SOCIETYicon  04/08/2020 

Prosecutors in Hanoi have prosecuted four people for selling sub-standard counterfeit medical suits.

Young people involved in Vietnam’s fight against COVID-19
Young people involved in Vietnam’s fight against COVID-19
FEATUREicon  04/08/2020 

Young Vietnamese at home and abroad are striving to contribute to the country’s fight against COVID-19 in their own way, believing that everyone has a role to play for the sake of their homeland.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN