Is it time to remove schools for the gifted in Vietnam?

Dr Nguyen Duc Thanh believes that the Hanoi-Amsterdam High School for the Gifted should be closed down or sold to private investors.

Thanh’s proposal has stunned the public for several reasons. First, Thanh is a respected economist and former director of the Vietnam Institute for Economic and Policy Research (VEPR).

Is it time to remove schools for the gifted in Vietnam?



Second, Thanh was an Amser, the name the students at the school call themselves. He was a physics major student at the school in 1992-1995.

And third, the Hanoi-Amsterdam High School for the Gifted, which is 35 years old, is one of the most prestigious high schools in Vietnam. Its students gain great achievements at international competitions and their qualifications are highly appreciated by employers.

Thanh believes that the existence of the school is ‘useless, outdated and unjust’.

“My belief about the uselessness, obsolescence and injustice of the school model is reflected in the fact that I never intend to send my children to that school,” Thanh said.

What do Hanoi-Amsterdam and other schools for the gifted use the state’s financial resources for?

It would be acceptable for Hanoi-Amsterdam to be a private school, where wealthy parents pay high fees for high-quality education services, or to be a normal state-owned school, which receives funding from the state like all other state-owned schools and provides outstanding education services, he believes. 

It would be acceptable for Hanoi-Amsterdam to be a private school, where wealthy parents pay high fees for high-quality education services, or to be a normal state-owned school, which receives funding from the state like all other state-owned schools and provides outstanding education services, he believes.

The problem is that schools for the gifted receive 2.5-2.7 times more money from the state than other state-owned schools.

 


What do schools for the gifted do with the state’s big resources?

Some people say the function of these schools is training outstanding people who attend international competitions to bring fame to Vietnam. However, Thanh believes there is no need to develop a large network of schools for the gifted in the country just to serve this goal.

Others say the purpose of the schools is producing talented people. But Thanh has doubts about this purpose.

He argues that if the state spends money to foster the growth of talented students, these students have the later responsibility of serving people who pay taxes to fund their studies.

Students only choose to study at Hanoi-Amsterdam because the school provides high quality education at a low cost. As such, the purpose of ‘producing talents’ cannot be implemented.

“I myself once studied at the Hanoi-Amsterdam High School for the Gifted and the school did not achieve any of these above mentioned aims when training me. However, I still enjoyed a good education at low costs, and the costs were paid by other people whose children did not study at the school,” Thanh said. 

Le Huyen

In Vietnam, ‘schools for the gifted’ mean 'schools for the rich’?

In Vietnam, ‘schools for the gifted’ mean 'schools for the rich’?

Whether to maintain schools for the gifted is an annual topic of discussion among many parents.

Ministry of Education and Trainning develops standard for universities

Ministry of Education and Trainning develops standard for universities

The Ministry of Education and Training is to implement the Vietnam National Qualifications Framework (VQF).

 
 

Other News

.
Chinese students in Australia targeted in virtual kidnapping scam
Chinese students in Australia targeted in virtual kidnapping scam
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

Students in Australia are coerced into faking their own kidnappings in the extortion scheme.

Coronavirus: Swimming defector was not infected, says S Korea
Coronavirus: Swimming defector was not infected, says S Korea
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

The suspected patient crawled through a drain then swam to North Korea, the South says.

Hanoi shakes after strong earthquake hits Son La Province
Hanoi shakes after strong earthquake hits Son La Province
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

Tall buildings in Hanoi shook as a 5.3-magnitude earthquake hit Son La Province at around 12.14pm local time on Monday.

Vietnam to issue E-VISA to citizens from 80 countries since July
Vietnam to issue E-VISA to citizens from 80 countries since July
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

The Government has issued e-visa to citizens from 80 countries since July 1 this year, according to its latest Resolution No. 79/NQ-CP.

Vietnamese team enjoy big win at European Physics Olympiad 2020
Vietnamese team enjoy big win at European Physics Olympiad 2020
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

A team made up of Vietnamese students achieved success at the European Physics Olympiad 2020 in Satu Mare, Romania, winning one gold, one silver, and two bronze medals.

Hanoi tops nation in literate rate among people aged above 15
Hanoi tops nation in literate rate among people aged above 15
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

Up to 99.2 percent of Hanoians aged above 15 are literate, the highest level among the country’s 63 provinces and cities, according to a report of the municipal Party Committee on the city’s education and training.

Vietnam hailed for wise investment in health care
Vietnam hailed for wise investment in health care
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

Wise investment in health care is one of the factors leading to Vietnam’s spectacularly effective COVID-19 response, said an article published on the Japan Times on July 26.

Nearly 80,000 tourists remain stranded in Da Nang
Nearly 80,000 tourists remain stranded in Da Nang
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

It is estimated that there are roughly 80,000 passengers traveling to and from the central city of Da Nang, 

Hundreds donate blood to save Quang Binh accident victims
Hundreds donate blood to save Quang Binh accident victims
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

Hundreds of volunteers have come to a hospital in the central province of Quang Binh to donate blood to save victims of a tragic traffic accident.

12 more people suspected of having covid-19 in Danang
12 more people suspected of having covid-19 in Danang
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

Danang has recorded 12 new suspected cases of Covid-19 infection, according to acting Minister of Health Nguyen Thanh Long.

Hanoi tightens foreign entry as community coronavirus infections found
Hanoi tightens foreign entry as community coronavirus infections found
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

People upon entry will have to be quarantined and tested for SARS-CoV-2 at least twice.

Vietnam to set up at least 10,000 more quarantine rooms
Vietnam to set up at least 10,000 more quarantine rooms
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

Following the prime minister’s directive over the need to set up at least 10,000 more quarantine rooms,

HCMC accelerates site clearance for second metro line project
HCMC accelerates site clearance for second metro line project
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

As the site clearance for HCMC’s second metro line project has fallen behind schedule, districts covered under the project such as Tan Binh, 10 and 12 have now begun accelerating the process.

Chinese national arrested for illegally bringing foreigners to Vietnam
Chinese national arrested for illegally bringing foreigners to Vietnam
SOCIETYicon  26/07/2020 

A Chinese national was arrested in Da Nang City as he brought foreigners to Viet Nam illegally, confirmed Major General Vu Xuan Vien, Director of the Da Nang Municipal Police Department.

How a Chinese agent used LinkedIn to hunt for targets
How a Chinese agent used LinkedIn to hunt for targets
SOCIETYicon  27/07/2020 

Dickson Yeo, a PhD student-turned-agent, targeted Americans that had access to private information.

North Korea on alert over 'first suspected coronavirus case'
North Korea on alert over 'first suspected coronavirus case'
SOCIETYicon  26/07/2020 

State media say a defector who returned from South Korea has Covid-19 symptoms.

Airlines to increase flights departing from Da Nang: CAAV
Airlines to increase flights departing from Da Nang: CAAV
SOCIETYicon  26/07/2020 

The Civil Aviation Authority of Vietnam (CAAV) will soon grant permission to airlines to maximise number of flights leaving the central city of Da Nang amid new developments of the COVID-19 pandemic, 

Vietnam: Two more found positive for coronavirus, taking total count to 420
Vietnam: Two more found positive for coronavirus, taking total count to 420
SOCIETYicon  26/07/2020 

Two more people, one from Quang Ngai and another from Da Nang, were found infected with the novel coronavirus on July 26 afternoon, raising the nation's total COVID-19 infections to 420, the Ministry of Health announced.

Road accident in Quang Binh province kills at least 13
Road accident in Quang Binh province kills at least 13
SOCIETYicon  26/07/2020 

At least 13 people have been killed and dozens injured after a coach overturned in the central province of Quang Binh.

Hanoi requires face mask wearing in public places
Hanoi requires face mask wearing in public places
SOCIETYicon  26/07/2020 

The city has reported no local transmission of the novel coronavirus for the past three months.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN