The truth behind India's viral photo that got a girl into school

The Indian girl was enrolled in school after a photo of her peeking into a classroom sparked outcry.

The truth behind India's viral photo that got a girl into school

The photo that sparked an outcry

A five-year-old in the southern city of Hyderabad was enrolled in school after a photo of her peeking into a classroom sparked an outcry. BBC Telugu's Deepthi Bathini reports on why the photo doesn't tell the full story.

Divya is something of a local celebrity in the slum where she lives. The shy five-year-old was the subject of a recent photo which went viral - it showed her clutching a bowl and peeking into a classroom at the local government school.

The touching image was published in a Telugu newspaper on 7 November with a caption that translates from the Telugu as "hungry gaze".

It quickly grabbed people's attention: a children's rights activist shared it on Facebook, lamenting that yet another child was being denied the right to food and education.

It had such an impact, the school enrolled Divya the following day. 

But her father, M Lakshman, says the photo and the outcry it provoked was in fact unfair to him and his wife, Yashoda, who works as a sweeper.

The truth behind India's viral photo that got a girl into school

Five-year-old Divya enrolled in school after a photo of her in a newspaper went viral
 

"I felt sad when I saw the photo," he told the BBC. "Divya has parents and we are working so hard to give her a good future - but she was portrayed as a hungry orphan."

Mr Lakshman says he was waiting for Divya to turn six so he could enrol her in a government school where his other two daughters are studying. The couple also have a son, who has finished school and is now applying to college while helping Mr Lakshman, who works as a rag picker.

Breaking the cycle

Divya and her parents live in a one-room hut in a shanty town in the heart of Hyderabad. The slum is about 100 metres from the government school, where Divya was photographed. Most of the 300 families living here are daily wage labourers and their children attend the school nearby.

Divya's home is sparse - plastic and glass are piled outside, ready to be sold for recycling. Mr Lakshman says between him and his wife, they earn about 10,000 rupees ($139; £108) a month, which pays for their food and clothes. Education, however, is free for the children, since they are all enrolled in government-run schools.

Mr Lakshman knows what it is to struggle: he himself grew up without parents and always battled to earn a decent living. "I never wanted my children to have the life I had. So I made sure they all go to school."

The photo, he adds, was especially hurtful because he has also been taking care of his brother's five children.

 
The truth behind India's viral photo that got a girl into school

Divya's father said the outcry over the photo was "unfair" to his family
 

"My brother and sister-in-law passed away sometime ago. I didn't want their five children to grow up as orphans. So, I enrolled all of them in a hostel and I take care of them."

When asked why Divya had gone to the government school with a bowl in hand, Mr Lakshman explains that a lot of the younger children from the slum go there around lunch time to take advantage of the free midday meal - a government programme which provides cooked meals to children in more than a million schools. He said they know about this because their older brothers and sisters are already enrolled.

"Divya doesn't go every day but she happened to go on that day and someone photographed her," he explains.

This was confirmed by teachers at the school who told the BBC that some children brought lunch from home, so they gave the food leftover to the younger children who had not yet joined.

"Children are children. And there is no day-care centre, so a lot of these children hang around the school anyway," says one teacher, who spoke on the condition of anonymity.

The truth behind India's viral photo that got a girl into school

Divya says she's excited to go to school
 

Mr Lakshman and his neighbours acknowledge the lack of an anganwadi, or government-sponsored day-care centre, in the neighbourhood is a major problem as parents have no place to leave their children when they went to work.

The local school inspector, SU Shivram Prasad, says he hopes the attention generated by the photo will hasten the process of setting one up.

"It will help the parents and the children can eat a nutritious meal," he adds.

Teachers at the school also hope that the media spotlight will improve facilities. They say there is an acute shortage of staff and teaching materials, and the school doest not even have a compound wall, which meant they have to constantly watch the children during their breaks.

Divya, however, is excited to be going to school. She insists on taking her school bag with her everywhere, even to the playground. Other than saying her name, she does not answer any questions.

"She is a very calm child," says Mr Lakshman, as his daughter holds his hand and kisses it.

And he admits that despite everything, the photo did do some good.

"Now other children who are Divya's age are also enrolling in school. So that makes me happy." BBC

 
 

Other News

.
Hanoi to pilot rental of e-bike linking with bus system in Q3
Hanoi to pilot rental of e-bike linking with bus system in Q3
SOCIETYicon  02/06/2021 

Hanoi will pilot the rental of electric bicycles to facilitate connection among local bus routes and the bus rapid transit (BRT) system since the third quarter of this year.

Noi Bai, Tan Son Nhat airports continue receiving foreign arrivals
Noi Bai, Tan Son Nhat airports continue receiving foreign arrivals
SOCIETYicon  02/06/2021 

The Noi Bai international airport in Hanoi and Tan Son Nhat international airport in Ho Chi Minh City will continue receiving passengers from abroad.

Children’s social roles promoted through their council
Children’s social roles promoted through their council
SOCIETYicon  02/06/2021 

A Children’s Council gathers outstanding children to periodically express opinions, aspirations, exchange and hold dialogues with representatives of all-level People's Committees and People’s Councils on child-related issues in localities.

Two men buy ambulances to take patients to hospital for free
Two men buy ambulances to take patients to hospital for free
SOCIETYicon  02/06/2021 

Understanding the difficulties of the poor, a car mechanic in Kien Giang and a young man in Can Tho have bought ambulances to take patients to the hospital for free.

Children face a boring summer break due to COVID-19
Children face a boring summer break due to COVID-19
SOCIETYicon  01/06/2021 

More than 2 million children in Hanoi have been stuck at home after the city's schools, parks, zoos and entertainment areas temporarily closed to prevent the spread of COVID-19.

Health Ministry to facilitate firms to import Covid-19 vaccines
Health Ministry to facilitate firms to import Covid-19 vaccines
SOCIETYicon  01/06/2021 

The Ministry of Health will create the most favorable conditions for firms, provinces and cities to import Covid-19 vaccines into Vietnam, Minister of Health Nguyen Thanh Long told a meeting on May 31.

List of medical establishments capable of conducting confirmatory tests
List of medical establishments capable of conducting confirmatory tests
SOCIETYicon  01/06/2021 

The Ministry of Health has made public a list of 141 medical facilities allowed to conduct confirmatory COVID-19 tests.

Hanoi to close airport to int’l arrivals amid resurgence of COVID-19
Hanoi to close airport to int’l arrivals amid resurgence of COVID-19
SOCIETYicon  01/06/2021 

Hanoi’s Noi Bai International Airport will stop welcoming passengers from abroad from June 1 amid rising COVID-19 infections in the capital.

Early practice for IELTS may harm students, say experts
Early practice for IELTS may harm students, say experts
FEATUREicon  01/06/2021 

Beginning study for the IELTS (the International English Language Test) exam in primary school when students don’t have much real-life experience may reduce children's motivation and interest in reading and writing, experts say.

Privacy of Covid-19 patients needs to be protected
Privacy of Covid-19 patients needs to be protected
FEATUREicon  01/06/2021 

A close friend recently showed me a text message of his friend who has been put under quarantine. “I have lost everything. I don’t have the face to see my wife and kids, co-workers and friends anymore,” he wrote.

New laws needed to regulate use of money from charity funds
New laws needed to regulate use of money from charity funds
FEATUREicon  01/06/2021 

Hoai Linh, a famous Vietnamese comedian, has been alleged to have embezzled VND14 billion he raised from the public last October to help people in the central region overcome the tragic floods.

VIETNAM NEWS HEADLINES JUNE 1
VIETNAM NEWS HEADLINES JUNE 1
SOCIETYicon  01/06/2021 

COVID-19: 50 more cases detected in four localities, 32 in Bac Giang hotspot

Vietnam may grant emergency license for locally-made Covid-19 vaccine
Vietnam may grant emergency license for locally-made Covid-19 vaccine
SOCIETYicon  01/06/2021 

Soon after the phase 3 trial, Vietnam may consider emergency licensing for Nanocovax, a made-in-Vietnam Covid-19 vaccine.

Vietnam’s first airline to trial electronic health passports
Vietnam’s first airline to trial electronic health passports
SOCIETYicon  01/06/2021 

Vietnam Airlines has signed an agreement with the International Air Transport Association (IATA) to test the IATA Travel Pass, a type of electronic health passport application.

Ho Chi Minh City streets deserted on first day of social distancing
Ho Chi Minh City streets deserted on first day of social distancing
SOCIETYicon  01/06/2021 

On the first day of social distancing in Vietnam’s biggest city, May 31, the rhythm of life continued but the streets were deserted.

When the going gets tough, it's time to stand strong
When the going gets tough, it's time to stand strong
SOCIETYicon  31/05/2021 

It’s a time of distress. A time of anxiety. A time of exhaustion.

Vietnamese French citizen's long standing battle for justice carries on
Vietnamese French citizen's long standing battle for justice carries on
SOCIETYicon  01/06/2021 

Former war correspondent Tran To Nga will continue her prolonged fight for justice for herself and other Agent Orange victims despite a court in France dismissing her lawsuit earlier this month.

VIETNAM NEWS HEADLINES MAY 31
VIETNAM NEWS HEADLINES MAY 31
SOCIETYicon  31/05/2021 

Vietnam records 82 new domestically-transmitted COVID-19 cases

Zero-dong supermarkets ease hardship for workers in Bac Giang
Zero-dong supermarkets ease hardship for workers in Bac Giang
SOCIETYicon  31/05/2021 

Holding a bag of rice from a zero-dong supermarket brought home by his landlord, Luong Van Han could not hide his joy.

Vietnam’s first cavalry mobile police force
Vietnam’s first cavalry mobile police force
SOCIETYicon  31/05/2021 

Starting as wild, untamed horses, the horses, now after more than a year of training, have mastered the movements of walking, standing and running in order.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN