Aligning transfer pricing with international norms

The growth of FIEs in Vietnam has recently raised increasingly complicated tax concerns. These problems arise primarily from the practical issues of determining the transaction price between FIEs and their related parties.

aligning transfer pricing with international norms

Le Khanh Lam - Partner and head of Tax and Consulting Services RSM Vietnam

Due to affecting the tax base and the tax amount payable, the establishment of appropriate prices for transfer of goods, intangibles, and services between FIEs and their related parties, commonly referred to as transfer pricing (TP), is a great concern for both tax authorities and the enterprises themselves.

In the meantime, many FIEs have reported continued losses while still carrying out business expansions. This has aroused suspicions that they have been involved in TP.

However, FIEs may sustain genuine losses due to many business reasons such as heavy startup costs, unfavourable economic conditions, poor management, deliberate business strategies, and more. For example, they may follow their groups’ business strategies by setting their prices especially competitive for market penetration, in order to increase their market share, and expect to earn potential profits in the foreseeable future.

Generally, other independent enterprises are also expected to carry out the same strategies in comparable circumstances. According to United Nations Practical Manual on Transfer Pricing for Developing Countries 2017, and Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) Transfer Pricing Guideline for Multinational Enterprises and Tax Administrations, such strategies may be acceptable if the business and economic circumstances require the FIEs and other independent enterprises to determine prices in the same comparable manner.

Therefore, tax authorities should not automatically assume that FIEs with related party transactions were planning to manipulate their profits, especially in the case of these enterprises incurring losses that continue for a long period of time.

Maintaining updates

Given this, proper TP regulations are crucial in dealing with problems for both tax authorities and taxpayers. In the case of taxpayers, they need to comply with regulations and administrative reporting requirements. For tax authorities, specific matters arise at both policy design and practical implementation.

In Vietnam, TP guidance was written in tax regulations starting from 1997 by the Ministry of Finance (MoF), with simple terms to define the related parties. Today, due to the great public concern, these TP regulations have become more complex and included a large number of reporting requirements.

With the efforts to tackle tax evasion and implement international best practices, in early 2017, the Vietnamese government released Decree No.20/2017/ND-CP on providing tax administration applicable to enterprises with related party transactions. It introduced new concepts and principles from the OECD’s TP guideline, as well as implemented certain actions from the Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) Action Plans.

Through this decree, Vietnam has taken a significant step forward in dealing with TP issues in line with international practice.

From 1997 to the present, the designing of a legal framework and formulating regulations on TP have been improved strongly. During this period, it has been observed that there are two major issues in designing TP regulations in Vietnam.

Firstly, regulations were designed with the ability to apply to all types of enterprises. However, in reality, these regulations are not suitable to a number of enterprises in some specific industries.

For example, many enterprises in capital-intensive industries such as real estate or construction have given comments to the Vietnamese government that they are facing difficulties with the regulation on the 20 per cent cap on earnings before interest, tax, depreciation, and amortisation, on the tax deductibility of total interest expenses written in Decree 20.

Therefore, last December, the MoF circulated a draft decree to amend and supplement this regulation, and will seek public and specific comments from the affected entities.

Secondly, the pace of regulation update is not in line with the speed of the transformation of the economy, which creates new issues that cannot adopt the current regulations in many cases. Therefore, it is not surprising to see that the prevailing regulations shall be regularly updated to deal with new issues that arise.

To keep TP regulations updated and comparable with the latest development of international tax practice, the Vietnamese authorities should closely watch the development of TP rules elsewhere in the world.

According to the aforementioned 2017 UN practical manual, it also provides guidance on the mechanisms available for developing countries to obtain training and information updates, and to engage in international tax dialogue as below:

 

- Regional co-ordination through existing intergovernmental agencies such as the International Organization of Tax Administrations, Inter-American Centre of Tax Administrations, the African Tax Administration Forum, Study Group on Asian Tax Administration and Research, and the Commonwealth Association of Tax Administrators;

- Engage with institutional stakeholders such as the UN, the OECD, the World Bank, and the International Monetary Fund;

- Create a clearing house for information and capacity development with like-minded countries;

- Participate in the south-south dialogue for capacity development.

Vietnam should, through participation in regional and global dialogues, be able to benefit from the use of existing consultancy bodies, used by countries with similar legislation, or countries located within the same geographic region.

Considering outside funds

As a developing country, overseas investments are important and integral to the Vietnamese economy. These funds have contributed to boosting technological transformation, improving the quality of human resources, increasing product quality, and maintaining economic growth in the country. Therefore, the consideration of continuously attracting foreign investment is one of the key concerns for the government.

In respect to this, TP rules which have significant impacts on the activities of multinational enterprises may act as barriers for such investment. Before the government released Decree 20, the concerns from enterprises on TP requirements were not high. But currently, FIEs intending to invest into Vietnam need to pay high attention to, and be in compliance with, the stricter requirements laid out in Decree 20. In other words, the stricter control in TP will create hindrances to attract the flow of foreign investment.

With the beneficial effects of international investment on the efficiency and growth of the Vietnamese economy, the government should consider updating TP rules to control, but also attract, such funding. Besides this, the rules are necessary to compare with neighbouring competitors and international standards.

Unreasonable corporate income tax rates, high compliance costs, and uncertainty in TP rules could discourage foreign investors from pouring money into one country, redirecting the flow of that investment to other nearby nations.

The next step

The fast and wide spread of digitalisation, and development of the liberation in trade policy, have advanced the pace of globalisation and created the continuing transformation of the global economy. As a result of digital transformation, customer-facing and/or user-facing activities will be carried out by more and more enterprises from a remote location, with zero or minimal physical presence in the market.

The challenges of how taxing rights on income generated from cross-border activities should be allocated among jurisdictions are of high concern.

To resolve these problems, the OECD has recently suggested many new proposals which could lead to important changes in fundamental international principles in TP rules.

In a statement released after a meeting held on January 29–30, member countries joining the inclusive framework on BEPS also adopted the OECD’s proposed unified approach. Therefore, it is also expected that domestic TP regulations in these countries, of which Vietnam is one, will be updated soon to reflect the changes.

New amendments to the Law on Investment 2014

Last week, the National Assembly’s Economic Committee held a meeting to discuss the latest draft amendments to the Law on Investment 2014 to reach an agreement on some issues before submitting it to the legislature for approval in May.

According to these amendments, the government could work with independent consulting units to assess and appraise foreign-invested projects, in addition to the banned business lines and the list of conditional business lines. Under the resolution, Vietnam will deny proposals to expand or extend operation schedules of projects using outdated technology that constitute risks to the environment or waste natural resources. Projects with a high possibility of transfer pricing (TP) or illegal investment will be dealt with comprehensively.

The resolution urges to add a regulation on appraising investment capital of foreign-invested enterprises (FIEs) when necessary as a foundation for tax assessment, thus preventing TP and tax evasion. It is expected to be implemented as soon as Vietnam this month issues the action plan to implement the Politburo’s Resolution 50 on the directions to complete the legal framework to increase the quality of foreign direct investment attraction towards 2030, with a number of concrete solutions and tasks for ministries and agencies to sustainably improve the business climate, and also to fight against TP.

Accordingly, the Ministry of Finance (MoF) is tasked to build a mechanism to apply investment incentives, with requirements to meet concrete conditions and commitments as well as post-inspection to be integrated. Moreover, the regulation should amend and supplement the regulations on anti-TP in the Law on Tax Administration and its guiding decrees. The MoF will also assess the efficiency of double taxation avoidance agreements and their impacts on Vietnam’s tax policies to suggest possible adjustments.

Vietnam has introduced a simple guidance of TP in tax regulations starting from 1997. In the wake of tax evasions and international best practices, in early 2017, the Vietnamese government issued Decree No.20/2017/ND-CP on providing tax administration applicable to enterprises with related party transactions. Since then, the country’s legal framework on TP has been much improved. However, it proves unsuitable to a number of enterprises in some specific industries and is yet to keep up with the economical transformation. To this end, the MoF in late 2019 introduced a draft decree to amend and supplement some regulations in Decree 20, and will seek comments soon from related parties. Over the past 30 years, FIEs have greatly contributed to Vietnam’s socio-economic development. However, problems still remain, including TP, tax evasion, and the application of outdated technology, among others.

Coca-Cola, Metro Vietnam, and Adidas are brands that are suspected of TP activities. Coca-Cola was once named on top of the list of suspects by Ho Chi Minh City Taxation Department. By 2012, the company continuously reported losses but still expanded its operations. As a result, in late 2019, Coca-Cola Vietnam was fined over VND821 billion ($36 million). Suntory PepsiCo Vietnam is also suspected of TP. Since 1991, PepsiCo has continuously reported losses to not pay corporate income tax. Meanwhile, it invested in new factories to increase its local market share. Metro Vietnam started its business in Vietnam in 2002 with an initial investment sum of $120 million. After 12 years of operation, the company has changed its business licence six times, thus increasing its total investment to over $301 million and expanding its operation nationwide. In spite of this, Metro Vietnam constantly announced losses, except for 2010 when it made a profit of VND173 billion ($7.52 million).

In a move to prevent tax losses, local tax agencies including Hanoi Taxation Department and Ho Chi Minh City Taxation Department have announced to intensify activities to fight against TP this year, considering it a focus in their tasks. Accordingly, the agencies will concentrate their investigations into FIEs that have reported losses for years but still expanded their operations, as well as any others with suspicious transactions. VIR

Transfer pricing in FDI sector raises concerns: ministers

Transfer pricing in FDI sector raises concerns: ministers

The ministers of Finance and of Planning and Investment have expressed concern over the increasingly complicated developments of transfer pricing among enterprises receiving FDI, the local media reported.  

 
 

Other News

.
Stocks fall as nations take coronavirus action
Stocks fall as nations take coronavirus action
BUSINESSicon  23/03/2020 

Shares in Asia slide on Monday as more drastic action is taken by governments to stop virus spreading.

Vietnam imposes anti-dumping measures on Chinese, Indonesian MSG
Vietnam imposes anti-dumping measures on Chinese, Indonesian MSG
BUSINESSicon  23/03/2020 

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) has imposed provisional anti-dumping measures on some monosodium glutamate (MSG) products from China and Indonesia.

ACV reduces airline service fees for next six months
ACV reduces airline service fees for next six months
BUSINESSicon  23/03/2020 

The Airports Corporation of Vietnam (ACV) has announced it will reduce airline service fees for six months from March to August to support airlines suffering from the COVID-19 pandemic.

EVFTA poses challenges to Vietnamese agricultural products
EVFTA poses challenges to Vietnamese agricultural products
BUSINESSicon  23/03/2020 

Since the EVTFA was approved, experts have been analysing the opportunities for Vietnam to penetrate deeper into the high-value foreign markets. 

4.0 offers opening up for foreign tech transport firms
4.0 offers opening up for foreign tech transport firms
BUSINESSicon  23/03/2020 

Digital transformation is bringing about significant changes in the transport sector, and the upcoming launch of the new 5G network standard will further power new breakthroughs. 

Pandemic has little impact on Vietnam’s shrimp exports
Pandemic has little impact on Vietnam’s shrimp exports
BUSINESSicon  23/03/2020 

The domestic shrimp industry has not faced a great impact from the COVID-19 because now this industry is under production and Vietnam will enter its shrimp harvesting crop in August.

COVID-19 threatens property brokers with unemployment
COVID-19 threatens property brokers with unemployment
BUSINESSicon  22/03/2020 

The COVID-19 pandemic has become a new challenge for property brokers who have been facing many since last year due to the low supply in the market.

Commercial centres deserted in Hanoi amidst COVID-19 fears
Commercial centres deserted in Hanoi amidst COVID-19 fears
PHOTOSicon  22/03/2020 

With fears surrounding the potential spread of COVID-19 gripping Hanoi, the majority of commercial centres located in the capital have been increasingly quiet in recent days with local people cautious about going outside.

VN shrimp segment above water
VN shrimp segment above water
FEATUREicon  22/03/2020 

Despite the complexities of COVID-19, shrimp exporters and processors still see a bright future ahead thanks to new markets, and boosting exports to traditional markets which have cut imports from China.

Vietnam makes it into top 5 economic freedom gainers in Asia-Pacific region
Vietnam makes it into top 5 economic freedom gainers in Asia-Pacific region
BUSINESSicon  22/03/2020 

With the strides in opening its economy, Vietnam has improved its ranking to 105th on the 2020 Index of Economic Freedom by The Heritage Foundation.

Firms to adhere to anti-dumping law
Firms to adhere to anti-dumping law
BUSINESSicon  22/03/2020 

Pham Duy Khuong, managing director of ASL Law, talked about some important contents related to anti-dumping laws that foreign companies should pay attention to when digging into the Vietnamese market.

VN firms resolute in business goals despite COVID-19 impacts
VN firms resolute in business goals despite COVID-19 impacts
BUSINESSicon  22/03/2020 

Many companies have performed well in the first two months of the year despite the COVID-19 outbreak and insist on keeping business targets unchanged.

VN rail sector finding way back on track
VN rail sector finding way back on track
BUSINESSicon  22/03/2020 

Despite strong efforts, state-owned Vietnam Railways may face a downturn this year due to the COVID-19 pandemic and challenges from legal barriers. 

State capital commission to work with struggling mega-projects
State capital commission to work with struggling mega-projects
BUSINESSicon  21/03/2020 

The Commission for the Management of State Capital at Enterprises (CMSC) must continue to support managers of 12 struggling mega-projects under the Ministry of Trade and Industry with the State’s capital investment.

Real estate firms calls for Government support
Real estate firms calls for Government support
BUSINESSicon  21/03/2020 

The HCMC Real Estate Association has urged the Government to add the property industry to the list of those affected by the COVID-19 outbreak and are eligible for a five-month postponement of VAT and land-use fee payments.

EU, US yet to limit garment imports from Vietnam due to COVID-19
EU, US yet to limit garment imports from Vietnam due to COVID-19
BUSINESSicon  22/03/2020 

Minister of Industry and Trade Tran Tuan Anh said on March 20 that EU and US authorities have yet to limit the import of garment products from Vietnam.

Textile and footwear firms go local to survive pandemic
Textile and footwear firms go local to survive pandemic
BUSINESSicon  21/03/2020 

While most textile and footwear enterprises in Vietnam struggled to find alternative sources of raw materials to maintain production, some with local sources have survived during the COVID-19 pandemic.

US has no plan to suspend import of Vietnamese garment-textiles: ambassador
US has no plan to suspend import of Vietnamese garment-textiles: ambassador
BUSINESSicon  21/03/2020 

The US Government has no plan to suspend the import of Vietnamese garments-textiles, said Vietnamese Ambassador to the US Ha Kim Ngoc.

Covid-19 crisis can offer opportunity for Vietnam to expand role in global supply chain
Covid-19 crisis can offer opportunity for Vietnam to expand role in global supply chain
BUSINESSicon  22/03/2020 

The difficulties in the global pandemic are opportunities for Vietnam to expand its role in the global supply chain.

Vietnam’s fish, shrimp exports no longer can enjoy preferences from the US
Vietnam’s fish, shrimp exports no longer can enjoy preferences from the US
BUSINESSicon  23/03/2020 

Vietnam’s seafood industry has received bad news: it can no longer enjoy the preferences offered by the US to developing countries.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN