Legal stability required for condotel investment

In recent years, the concept of the condotel has dominated the real estate market in Vietnam, and generated a wave of interest in this type of real estate investment.

Legal stability required for condotel investment
Only experienced and thorough investors will be able to avoid confusion in the current condotel-buying arena

The term, a combination of condominium and hotel, is used to indicate a building that is owned like a condominium but operated like a hotel.

To be more specific, a more international understanding is that the owner of a condotel can either operate it by themselves or leave it under the management of the developer (or any other property management company) and receive profit. In the former option, the owner may use their condotel as their own tourist accommodation or rent it out as any hotel room. In the latter situation, the authorised manager will lease it as a hotel room, generate profit from the rental, and receive a management fee.

The initial driving forces behind the condotel form were developers who lacked financial funding during the construction stage of the project. These developers would pre-sell units in the project, and then use the money from buyers to complete the project construction. These developers in turn promised buyers a substantial profit for leasing the units as hotel rooms in order to make it an attractive investment.

However, the legal system in Vietnam has not provided a definition of condotel or set forth any provision to regulate this type of hybrid real estate investment. While there are various permutations of the concept, it generally boils down to two competing concepts.

The first is that the condotel is a residential unit being constructed by a developer on residential land with the right to sell such units as residential units, and which units are then offered for the buyer to participate in a rental pool which is operated as a hotel. This is the first scenario, which matches the international understanding.

The second scenario is that the condotel units are constructed in connection with the construction of a licensed hotel or resort project on commercial land, and such units are sold to buyers for residential purposes and for participation in hotel operation.

The problem with the first scenario is that the function of condotels is both residential and commercial, but the function of the project building must be in accordance with the land-use purpose. Even though buyers are entitled to a red book, the certificate of land-use rights, ownership of residential house, and other assets attached to land, operation of the condotel as a hotel while it is built on residential land is prohibited.

The issue with the second scenario is that the construction of residential housing in ­general, whether it is separate house or condominium, or on non-residential land such as commercial land, is prohibited under the Law on ­Residential Housing.

Therefore, a buyer of a condotel unit in the second scenario will not be granted with a red book. Furthermore, ­according to Article 126.3 of the Land Law, the duration of lease of commercial land to implement investment projects in Vietnam must not exceed 50 years for usual projects and 70 years for projects with ­significant ­investment capital.

Therefore, a buyer of a unit in the second scenario is not entitled to obtain land use rights for the condotel on a stable and long-term basis. This has a chilling effect for investors and buyers resulting in a downward track for such purchases in Vietnam.

Since there is no definition for this new type of real estate under Vietnamese laws, potential buyers are likely to be confused. Buyers who are unfamiliar with the distinction may mistake a condotel for a condominium, which can be used for permanent residence because the pre-sale of condotels resembles the sale of a residential house to be formed in the future. Another potential harm for buyers, as mentioned above, stems from the developers of condotel projects offering buyers high profits for the rental pool programme.

 

Nonetheless, some experts are doubtful of developers’ profit claims on the grounds that tourism is a seasonal industry with fluctuations in revenue and, more significantly, the lack of any regulation requiring developers to set aside such payments to buyers in some form of escrow account or otherwise provide a guarantee for such payment.

Developers often hold the view that land used for construction of a condotel project should be considered as “residential land with no residential unit formed”, and owners of such units should be granted with a long-term red book to acknowledge their ownership of the unit. Developers argue that such an interpretation is necessary in order for the condotel real estate sector to develop.

Having the contrary view are those with the opinion that a condotel should not be considered as property for residential purpose because it will impact on related ­concerns such as land use and urban planning. In some ­jurisdictions, such as the south-central province of Binh Dinh, its Department of Natural Resources and Environment granted long-term red books to ­several condotel projects built on residential land with the explanation that the concept is still associated with a residential purpose.

There are even differences within governmental agencies regarding a solution for this dilemma. The Ministry of Construction (MoC) favours the idea of keeping only residential real estate for sale, and that condotels must be treated as investments and their owners are not entitled to land-use rights. Another solution, which is not endorsed by the MoC, is to give developers of the resort properties the right to sell them as residential units.

Although there is no agreement on the correct ­approach, local authorities, ­developers, and legal experts at least concur that a proper legal framework for condotels is required in order to resolve the controversy.

As it currently stands, the development and operation of condotels attempt to find legal basis in no less than four relevant laws, including the Law on Real Estate Business, the Law on Housing, the Land Law and the Law on Construction, but none of these laws provide the clear framework that is needed.

Complicating the legal situation are the various authorities that also claim some level of oversight for condotels, such as the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment (MoNRE), the Ministry of Culture, Sports, and Tourism (MoCST), and the MoC. Noting the concerns raised by this issue, the prime minister has issued Directive No.11/CT-TTg dated April 23 on certain solutions for fostering stable and sound development of the real estate market. In the directive, the prime minister assigned the MoC to “issue amendments to regulations and standards for construction of various types of apartments, condotels, resort villas, and officetels.”

The directive further assigned the MoNRE the obligation to “issue documents providing guidance on land-use” and “conduct a study on amendments to land-use regime, and issue certificates of land-use rights and ownership of other property on land” applied to certain new types of real estate such as condotels, resort villas, and officetels.

In the meantime, the directive assigned the MoCST to “enact regulations on management and sale of ­condotels and resort villas”. All of the aforementioned ­assignments are to be ­completed within the third quarter of 2019, which means drafts of regulations are ­expected to be published sometime before the end of this year. VIR

Kevin Hawkins - Co-executive partner, ZICO Law Vietnam

Detailed condotel rules still required

Detailed condotel rules still required

Due to lack of a legal framework, the condotel market remained tight through the first half of the year.  

 
 

Other News

.
COVID-19: Mong Cai completes preparations to resume border trade
COVID-19: Mong Cai completes preparations to resume border trade
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Mong Cai city in Quang Ninh has basically completed preparations to resume trade through the Mong Cai International border gate, after a suspension due to the outbreak of coronavirus (COVID-19).

EVFTA, EVIPA unleash market potential for European firms
EVFTA, EVIPA unleash market potential for European firms
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The EU-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement and the EU-Vietnam Investment Protection Agreement offer significant business opportunities for European enterprises, German Federal Minister for Economic Affairs and Energy Peter Altmaier said.

VN’s GDP growth to reach 6.25 percent if COVID-19 outbreak is contained in Q1
VN’s GDP growth to reach 6.25 percent if COVID-19 outbreak is contained in Q1
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Vietnam’s gross domestic product (GDP) growth is expected to reach 6.25 percent in 2020 if the outbreak of coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is contained within the first quarter of this year, according to the Ministry of Planning and Investment.

WB’s new strategy helps Vietnam better utilise solar power
WB’s new strategy helps Vietnam better utilise solar power
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The World Bank (WB)’s new approaches to bidding and deployment for solar projects will help Vietnam substantially boost and effectively manage its abundant solar energy resources.

Local airlines sustain coronavirus-triggered loss of VND10 trillion
Local airlines sustain coronavirus-triggered loss of VND10 trillion
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Local carriers had incurred total losses of over VND10 trillion as of February 10, Tuoi Tre reported, citing the head of the Civil Aviation Authority of Vietnam (CAAV) Dinh Viet Thang.

Foreign ownership cap yet to be applied at payment intermediaries
Foreign ownership cap yet to be applied at payment intermediaries
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has removed a regulation capping foreign ownership at 49% for local payment intermediaries from a draft decree on noncash transactions.

Over 36 tons of masks exported amid local virus scare
Over 36 tons of masks exported amid local virus scare
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

More than 36 tons of face masks was shipped overseas from HCMC within one week even though the domestic market is falling short of the product and the Government is finding ways to shore up mask supplies.

Prices of goods under State watch should be kept unchanged to curb inflation: GSO
Prices of goods under State watch should be kept unchanged to curb inflation: GSO
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The Government should not raise the prices of any products under its management, especially medicines, fuels and electricity, in the first half of 2020 to keep the full-year inflation rate under control, stated the General Statistics Office.

EU lawmakers approve free trade deal with Vietnam
EU lawmakers approve free trade deal with Vietnam
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

The European Parliament (EP) on February 12 ratified the EU-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement (EVFTA) and the EU-Vietnam Investment Protection Agreement (EVIPA).

Produce 'rescue' campaigns help farmers amid export decline to China due to coronavirus outbreak
Produce 'rescue' campaigns help farmers amid export decline to China due to coronavirus outbreak
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Mekong Delta farmers are facing natural calamities and saline intrusion, as well as the decline of the Chinese market amid the coronavirus outbreak.

Coronavirus outbreak hits aviation industry hard
Coronavirus outbreak hits aviation industry hard
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Flying an empty aircraft for the second time in one week, Hoang, a captain working for a Vietnamese airline, has heard that the airline is incurring big losses because of nCoV.

BUSINESS NEWS HEADLINES FEB. 12
BUSINESS NEWS HEADLINES FEB. 12
BUSINESSicon  12/02/2020 

Vietnam holds key to expediting infrastructure investment: Moody’s

Investment in Vietnam-based start-ups grows sharply in 2019
Investment in Vietnam-based start-ups grows sharply in 2019
BUSINESSicon  12/02/2020 

Investment in Vietnam-based start-ups grew sharply in 2019, according to Singapore-headquartered venture capital firm Cento Ventures.

Traders, exporters advised not to transport produce to northern border gates
Traders, exporters advised not to transport produce to northern border gates
BUSINESSicon  12/02/2020 

The Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development has asked local exporters to suspend the transport of farm produce to the northern border gates.

Pork supply expected to recover from this month: MARD
Pork supply expected to recover from this month: MARD
BUSINESSicon  12/02/2020 

The Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development (MARD) said that the domestic pork supply is forecast to increase from February.

Banks assist firms affected by nCoV outbreak
Banks assist firms affected by nCoV outbreak
BUSINESSicon  12/02/2020 

In response to the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV)’s appeal, a number of credit institutions have announced plans to support businesses affected by the novel coronavirus (nCoV) epidemic.

SBV removes foreign ownership limit in payment firms
SBV removes foreign ownership limit in payment firms
BUSINESSicon  12/02/2020 

The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has announced it would remove regulations limiting foreign ownership in local intermediary payment firms from its draft Decree No 101.

Transport firms face huge losses from coronavirus outbreak
Transport firms face huge losses from coronavirus outbreak
BUSINESSicon  12/02/2020 

Many transportation firms reported that they are incurring huge losses and slow business due to the coronavirus outbreak.

Property market in 2020 may heat up thanks to new policies
Property market in 2020 may heat up thanks to new policies
BUSINESSicon  13/02/2020 

Many new policies will take effect in 2020 which aim to warm up the housing market segment for those with real accommodation demand.

Nissan to shut Japan factory due to shortage of Chinese parts
Nissan to shut Japan factory due to shortage of Chinese parts
BUSINESSicon  11/02/2020 

The Japanese car maker shuts a factory for two days due to a shortage of parts from China.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN