Proposal to halt M&A a question of fine balance

Just a few days ago, Tiki and Sendo struck a hundred-million dollar deal that could redraw the landscape of the entire e-commerce industry,

highlighting that the mergers and acquisitions market remains vibrant – which the Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry would temper through a new proposal to delay for a while.

1493p9 proposal to halt ma a question of fine balance

Proposal to halt M&A a question of fine balance, illustration photo

Two local e-commerce platforms Tiki and Sendo finally reached the merger deal they have been negotiating for nearly a year, according to newswire DealStreetAsia.

The move comes in the context of powerhouses being born in e-commerce, with Lazada backed by Alibaba and Shopee by Singaporean tech giant SEA Group.

A VIR source revealed that the merger talks have been going since August, but only the leaders of the two companies knew of the details. As a result, the news took most shareholders by surprise.

Tiki and Sendo have yet to issue a public comment about the issue, with Sendo previously even denying the partnership and dismissing it as rumour. “We do not wish to comment on rumours going around in the market,” a company representative said.

Last week, Vietnam saw two deals of undisclosed value, reflecting the continued interest of foreign buyers.

One of the deals was Japanese real estate group Haseko Corporation reaching an agreement to acquire a 36 per cent stake in Vietnam-based construction firm Ecoba. The two sides both hold strong positions in their respective markets and this partnership offers great mutual benefits. Haseko is one of the leading condominium contractors and development corporations in Japan with total assets of up to $6.8 billion, holding 10 per cent of existing apartments in Japan, while Ecoba holds several large projects across Vietnam.

The other deal was announced by Auxesia’s Vietnamese team (the exclusive financial advisor) which successfully closed an M&A deal in the paper sector.

This momentum would be arrested by the Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry’s (VCCI) proposal to halt M&A deals involving foreign buyers for the duration of the health crisis.

Pham Duy Khuong, director at SB Law and ASL Law, told VIR, “There is no legal instrument that allows the state to order private enterprises to stop implementing M&A deals.”

 

“A recommendation that is not based on specific legislation can easily lead to unnecessary complications if the seller is desperate to sell a project and the buyer is just waiting for an opportunity to take over the project,” he added.

The VCCI proposal was made at the recent meeting between the prime minister and the business community. It is aimed to protect domestic companies and aims to increase scrutiny of foreign investments during the crisis as in the first four months of the year 2020, the number of capital contribution deals and share purchases by foreign investors increased by 33 per cent on-year, reaching more than 3,210 instances.

Although a final decision has yet to be passed, it caused concerns among both buyers and sellers over the fate of deals currently being negotiated. In the year so far, the Vietnamese M&A market witnessed steady growth, with foreign investors surging to grab a slice of this market of 96 million.

Samuel Son Tung Vu, lawyer at consultancy firm Bae, Kim & Lee Vietnam, recalled that in the last decade, M&A in Vietnam has been on an upward trend. Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, there were record-breaking deals bringing tremendous foreign capital into the Vietnamese economy, such as KEB Hana Bank’s $880 million investment in BIDV.

Vu is of the opinion that the VCCI’s proposal may not be suitable with Vietnam’s long-term goal of attracting foreign investment. “The legal framework already provides mechanisms for the Vietnamese government to control, approve, and supervise the flow of foreign investment. Such authority and power to review foreign investors have been mandated to specialised ministries and provincial-level departments,” he said

According to Tran Quoc Phuong, Deputy Minister of Planning and Investment, the ministry has cautioned about recent signs of foreign investors buying up well-positioned Vietnamese businesses at the cheap, especially those struggling financially during the crisis. He said that it is difficult to make policy changes to completely block foreign takeovers, which might be against market and business rules as well as Vietnam’s current international commitments.

Vo Ha Duyen - Chairwoman, VILAF

1493p9 proposal to halt ma a question of fine balance

More pressure on the M&A market is more likely to hurt than benefit the economy.

The question is what would be better for business and the economy: allowing troubled businesses to accept capital from larger investors or restricting capital flows and letting them go insolvent.

Three major trading blocs – China, the European Union, and the United States – have recently reacted with protectionist measures due to the COVID-19 pandemic. But this protectionist trend has been apparent for quite some time – the pandemic only pushed that trend up a notch. Unlike the EU and the US, and similar to other emerging Asian countries, Vietnam relies heavily on exports, technology transfer, and inbound investment.

Adopting a protectionist stance goes straight against the trend of international economic integration through the trade agreements which is has adopted or is negotiating.

That being said, there may be benefits to protecting assets which are critical or sensitive from a national security perspective, such as telecommunications systems developed by state-owned enterprises and certain border land and sea areas.

Warrick Cleine - Chairman and CEO, KPMG Vietnam and Cambodia

1493p9 proposal to halt ma a question of fine balance

Vietnam has been on the path of opening up its economy for a long time now. This includes encouraging foreign investment into Vietnam and encouraging Vietnamese companies to invest internationally. Vietnam has also made some commitments in its trade and investment agreements to support these goals. These policies have contributed to Vietnam’s growth, created jobs for Vietnamese people, and generated tax revenues, and so on. We need to make sure any changes made now do not conflict this progress.

Sellers of companies should have the right to sell to the investor that can offer the right price, protect jobs, and ensure the future of the company. This outcome is best for the country. If we restrict the options available to sellers, then we might actually get a worse outcome than we desire. VIR

Van Thu

Will Vietnamese e-commerce platforms Tiki and Sendo soon merge?

Will Vietnamese e-commerce platforms Tiki and Sendo soon merge?

Following the hottest M&A retail deal of Vingroup and Masan in early 2020, the merger of Tiki and Sendo is expected to make the competition in e-commerce industry fiercer.

E-commerce titans step up fake product fight

E-commerce titans step up fake product fight

Overseas e-commerce companies Lazada and Shopee may lose their positions in Vietnam if they keep demonstrating limitations in protecting consumers from low-quality and fake goods.

 
 

Other News

.
Moving from former adversaries to trusting and valued partners
Moving from former adversaries to trusting and valued partners
BUSINESSicon  07/07/2020 

Through candid dialogue, mutual respect, and a strong commitment to succeed by the leadership of both countries, Vietnam and the United States created a comprehensive partnership that identifies areas for both countries to work together.

EVFTA expected to give a lift to real estate sector
EVFTA expected to give a lift to real estate sector
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

Many segments of the real estate market are soon expected to benefit from the EU-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement, which takes effect in August.

Whether Apple to build nest in Vietnam?
Whether Apple to build nest in Vietnam?
BUSINESSicon  07/07/2020 

Foxconn’s rush expansion in Vietnam raise nosy that whether Apple will choose the country as the place to build nest.

American groups make progress across Vietnam
American groups make progress across Vietnam
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

Vietnam, as one of the fastest-growing economies in the ASEAN bloc, is becoming more appealing to American investors.

A dynamic and powerful ASEAN from the German perspective
A dynamic and powerful ASEAN from the German perspective
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

Possessing key features that represent a snapshot of one of the most diverse, fastest-growing, and competitive regions, the ASEAN is an attractive economic region for not only German enterprises but also other European ones to invest in. 

Delving into specifics of amended business laws
Delving into specifics of amended business laws
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

Businesses and investors are expected to access new positive changes when the amended Law on Investment and the amended Law on Enterprises take effect from January 1 next year.

Rays of sunshine in aviation clouds
Rays of sunshine in aviation clouds
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

Amid serious impacts of COVID-19, there are hopeful points for the aviation sector on the back of the EU-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement.

Trade kickstart with distinctive solutions
Trade kickstart with distinctive solutions
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

Vietnam is boosting its diplomatic activities in hope of attracting more investment and expanding its trade in the global market, with many of the country’s major partners about to open their doors to the world again.

EuroCham proposes Gov’t to cut 50 per cent of registration fee for imported cars
EuroCham proposes Gov’t to cut 50 per cent of registration fee for imported cars
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

The European Chamber of Commerce in Vietnam (EuroCham) proposed the Government to apply the 50 percent registration fee reduction to all automotive assembly firms, importers and dealers of new vehicles.

Shares to correct amid lack of positive news
Shares to correct amid lack of positive news
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

The benchmark VN-Index on the Ho Ch Minh Stock Exchange (HoSE) gained 0.62 per cent to close Friday at 847.61 points.

P2P firms in Vietnam waiting for a sandbox
P2P firms in Vietnam waiting for a sandbox
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

Peer-to-peer (P2P) lending companies expect that the sandbox for fintech would eliminate unscrupulous businesses and help the market grow significantly.

Business outlook gloomy for firms based in Old Quarter of Hanoi
Business outlook gloomy for firms based in Old Quarter of Hanoi
BUSINESSicon  06/07/2020 

Many business owners in Hanoi’s famous Old Quarter are becoming increasingly concerned about the decline in customers, causing their revenue to sharply decrease, and resulting in many stores closing their doors following COVID-19 epidemic.

Auto dealers deemed main beneficiaries of registration fee cut
Auto dealers deemed main beneficiaries of registration fee cut
BUSINESSicon  05/07/2020 

Auto dealers have proved to be the biggest beneficiaries of the Government's move to introduce a 50% cut in car registration fees, and not car buyers, as expected, 

Nine more expressway contractors suspected of construction violations
Nine more expressway contractors suspected of construction violations
BUSINESSicon  05/07/2020 

Nine more former contractors have been accused of irregularities in the construction of a 139-kilometer-long expressway whose severe deteriotion was reported shortly after its opening in central Vietnam.

VASEP decries taxes on semi-processed and processed seafood
VASEP decries taxes on semi-processed and processed seafood
BUSINESSicon  05/07/2020 

Tax agencies have slapped many firms with a corporate income tax on semi-processed seafood products at 20%, while their products for exports or domestic consumption that are mainly processed, 

Domestic property market faces uncertainty
Domestic property market faces uncertainty
BUSINESSicon  05/07/2020 

The domestic real estate market is hoped to have growth in the fourth quarter of this year and before the Lunar New Year 2021 if, by this year-end, the domestic economy is restored to levels from before the COVID-19 pandemic.

Hanoi moves towards approving construction of third Aeon Mall
Hanoi moves towards approving construction of third Aeon Mall
BUSINESSicon  05/07/2020 

The proposed construction of a parking lot and the Aeon Mall Hoang Mai Trade centre will soon be decided upon by the Hanoi People's Committee as Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc has approved the adjustment of the city's construction planning.

Pork and oil prices key to keeping inflation in VN under control: experts
Pork and oil prices key to keeping inflation in VN under control: experts
BUSINESSicon  05/07/2020 

With huge inflation pressure on the way in the remaining months of this year, a close watch must be kept on the prices of key products like oil and pork to hit the goal of keeping inflation below 4 per cent, experts have said.

Market stagnant, real estate firms struggle
Market stagnant, real estate firms struggle
BUSINESSicon  07/07/2020 

Real estate firms have had to struggle to survive during the COVID-19 pandemic, which has caused the loss of trillions of dong and job losses to 75-80 percent of workers in the field.

Vietnam’s outward investment rebounds
Vietnam’s outward investment rebounds
BUSINESSicon  07/07/2020 

Outward investments, which fell for a short time because of Covid-19, resumed again after the social distancing policy ended.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN