Why foreign retailers withdraw from Vietnam?

Capital withdrawals of foreign retailers in Vietnam have fielded a number of queries on whether the firms had sustained losses or if the local business climate lacked enough incentives.

question marks remain as foreign retailers withdraw from vietnam hinh 0
French retailer Auchan makes headlines in mid-May when confirming its withdrawal from the Vietnamese market. (Photo: Auchan)

Former chairman of the Hanoi Supermarket Association Vu Vinh Phu claimed there are many factors causing the withdrawal of foreign retailers from the Vietnamese market. Many failed to seek a proper consumer segment and suffered losses due to high costs and poor administration.

Phu said that Auchan is a multinational corporation with a business network of 4,000 locations across 17 countries and territories worldwide.

Since its inception in 2015, the French retailer has spread its arms to 18 locations, primarily in Hanoi, Ho Chi Minh city, and the southern province of Tay Ninh.

Local media reported that Edgar Bonte, CEO of the supermarket group Auchan Retail has decided to sell 18 loss-making stores in Vietnam. These outlets reaped some EUR45 million (US$50.4 million) in revenue in 2018 and are still suffering losses.

It comes as no surprise that retailers suffer losses during their operations and eventually choose to close down. Phu, however, urged the publication of relevant information on the retailers from state management agencies such as the State Audit Office, and tax and customs authorities.

In fact, the country has been offering a string of incentives to foreign direct investment retail firms, he said.

They are entitled to pay 50 percent of the current corporate income tax rate within their first two years of operation while they are leveraged to select good locations for business.

Additionally, foreign retailers operating in the country have decisive advantages in terms of brand and scale when it comes to negotiations with local suppliers.

He exemplified his stance by the fact that many local suppliers and producers reportedly have to provide foreign retailers with a 30 - 40 percent discount per product which they want to put on shelves at foreign-invested distribution chains. This puts domestic firms at a considerable disadvantage, he claimed.

 

Despite this, several foreign retailers such as METRO Cash & Carry, BigC, and others have still reported losses and even METRO Cash & Carry and BigC have been acquired by Thailand’s retail giants.

This is an unusual development as foreign retailers have been provided with such incentives and discounts, Phu stressed, noting that Germany’s METRO Cash & Carry had been asked by local competent agencies to pay VND500 billion (US$21.5 billion) in tax arrears.

This case serves as a good lesson for state agencies that are in charge of managing the retail and financial sectors, the expert said. State agencies must work on developing a more favorable business climate for retailers towards fairer treatment and transparency.

METRO Cash & Carry was acquired by Thailand’s TCC Group in 2014, after the former suffered consecutive years of losses.

Local media reported that during 12 years of operation in Vietnam, METRO Cash & Carry only enjoyed profits of VND116 billion (US$4.98 million) in 2010 while reporting losses in the remaining years, ranging from VND89 billion (US$3.82 million) to VND160 billion (US$6.88 million).

Moreover, amid thriving development of the Vietnamese retail market, Parkson retail chain in Vietnam, a subsidiary of the Parkson Holdings Berhad, has reportedly made poor performance in the country in comparison with regional peers.

In early 2018, Parkson shut down its final shopping mall in the country, thus putting an end to its business in the Vietnamese market after 13 years of operation. The retail chain had previously planned to open additional shopping centers in major cities nationwide, but it halted the scheme in 2014.

France retailer Auchan’s exit from Vietnam draws interest from potential buyers

France retailer Auchan’s exit from Vietnam draws interest from potential buyers

French supermarket group Auchan Retail’s plans to sell its loss-making business in Vietnam are already drawing interest from potential buyers, Reuters reported.  

Convenience stores help domestic retailers compete with foreign rivals

Convenience stores help domestic retailers compete with foreign rivals

With certain advantages, convenience stores have been an increasingly popular shopping destination for customers, and they have also become a choice for domestic retailers to compete with foreign rivals.  

Retailers seek workers for expansion plans

Retailers seek workers for expansion plans

Some retail chains are seeking hundreds of workers as they plan to open more shops to scale up their business.

 
 

Other News

.
US newspaper: US, Vietnam working to resolve trade issues
US newspaper: US, Vietnam working to resolve trade issues
VIETNAM & WORLDicon  11/01/2021 

The Inside US Trade has published an article entitled “US, Vietnam working to avoid imposition of Section 301 tariffs”.

Shrimp exporters bring home 3.85 billion USD in 2020
Shrimp exporters bring home 3.85 billion USD in 2020
BUSINESSicon  10/01/2021 

Earnings from shrimp exports reached 3.85 billion USD last year, up 15 percent year-on-year despite difficulties caused by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Flexible, cautious monetary policy management bears fruit
Flexible, cautious monetary policy management bears fruit
BUSINESSicon  10/01/2021 

Vietnam’s economy was adversely affected by the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, along with natural disasters and the impact of trade conflicts.

Government to have new policy on purchase of solar power soon
Government to have new policy on purchase of solar power soon
BUSINESSicon  10/01/2021 

At present, the cost of solar power panels has cooled down, so shortly, the MoIT would suggest the purchasing price of solar power without using feed-in tariffs (FITs).

Lotus silk in fight for survival as cost becomes King
Lotus silk in fight for survival as cost becomes King
BUSINESSicon  10/01/2021 

The year 2020 will go down in history for a host of reasons, one being that the COVID-19 pandemic shut borders that had long been open wide for trade.

VNR concerned over loss of entire equity
VNR concerned over loss of entire equity
BUSINESSicon  10/01/2021 

The Vietnam Railway Corporation (VNR) incurred losses of some VND1.3 trillion last year due to Covid-19 and continuous storms in the central region.

Runway upgrade at TSN airport completed
Runway upgrade at TSN airport completed
BUSINESSicon  10/01/2021 

The runway renovation project commenced on June 29 last year, with a total investment of some VND2 trillion.

For the sake of sustainable fish export
For the sake of sustainable fish export
BUSINESSicon  10/01/2021 

The price of tra (pangasius) fish has experienced one fluctuation after another. This year is forecast to be a recovery time for the fish.

Minister urges quick building of project on natural forest protection
Minister urges quick building of project on natural forest protection
BUSINESSicon  10/01/2021 

The forestry sector should take swift action to build a project on zoning off and protecting natural forests in the time to come, said Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development Nguyen Xuan Cuong.

Resilience helps Vietnam overcome year of COVID-19
Resilience helps Vietnam overcome year of COVID-19
FEATUREicon  09/01/2021 

Though COVID-19 has sent the global economy into one of its worst recessions ever, Vietnam posted GDP growth of 2.91 percent in 2020 thanks to its solid control of outbreaks and timely support to both enterprises and local people.

Construction of T&T Group’s modern trade center commences in Dak Nong Province
Construction of T&T Group’s modern trade center commences in Dak Nong Province
BUSINESSicon  09/01/2021 

The construction of the VND645 billion Dak Mil Trade Center was kicked off in the Central Highlands province of Dak Nong on January 6 by the Vegetable Import and Export Joint Stock Company (a member of T&T Group).

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS JANUARY 10
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS JANUARY 10
BUSINESSicon  10/01/2021 

VNR500, top 10 prestigious companies honoured

Vietnamese, US officials talk economic, trade issues
Vietnamese, US officials talk economic, trade issues
BUSINESSicon  08/01/2021 

Minister of Industry and Trade Tran Tuan Anh has held phone talks with US Trade Representative (USTR) Robert Lighthizer to discuss bilateral economic and trade issues.

Opportunities opened for food processing industry
Opportunities opened for food processing industry
BUSINESSicon  08/01/2021 

According to Vietnamese trade counselors, in 2021, Vietnamese goods, in general, have a great opportunity to export to Europe, Northern Europe, the US, the Eurasian Economic Union, Japan, South Korea, and China.

Vietnam vows to develop support industries for automobile industry
Vietnam vows to develop support industries for automobile industry
FEATUREicon  10/01/2021 

Current policies have not been attractive enough to persuade investors to pour money into support industries for the automobile industry.

Insurance groups signal intent to raise funds for stock boost
Insurance groups signal intent to raise funds for stock boost
BUSINESSicon  08/01/2021 

Insurance companies in Vietnam are lifting the curtains on their public fundraising plans, seen as a step towards luring more cash in the promising insurance and reinsurance market.

Vietnam to be among top growth performers again in 2021: HSBC
Vietnam to be among top growth performers again in 2021: HSBC
BUSINESSicon  09/01/2021 

Vietnam posted the fastest growth in Asia in 2020 and will once again be among the most outstanding performers in the region this year, according to the Hong Kong Shanghai Banking Corporation (HSBC).

FDI enterprises increase but more losses reported
FDI enterprises increase but more losses reported
BUSINESSicon  08/01/2021 

The number of foreign direct investment (FDI) enterprises continues to increase in Vietnam, but more are reporting losses. 

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS JANUARY 9
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS JANUARY 9
BUSINESSicon  09/01/2021 

Credit growth forecast to reach 13-14 percent this year: SSI

Vietnam imports rice from India for first time
Vietnam imports rice from India for first time
BUSINESSicon  08/01/2021 

Vietnam’s rice output is more than enough to satisfy domestic demand, but country is importing rice from India to use mostly for animal feed.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN