Wood exporters face array of obstructions

An oversupply of undervalued certified timber and a lack of interest from local wood processors currently stand in the way of Vietnam’s export plans to increase its foothold in Western markets.

 However, German assistance might help solve some of the issues that forest growers are facing.

Wood exporters face array of obstructions
Wood exporters face array of obstructions. Photo: Le Toan/VIR

Data from associations like VIFOREST, FPA Binh Dinh, HAWA, BIFA, and Forest Trends shows that Vietnam’s import value of timber and its products reached about $2.55 billion in 2020, with a turnover similar to 2019. Logs, sawn timber, and artificial boards were the main groups imported into Vietnam to serve the processing needs of domestic consumption and for exports.

The five main supply markets for Vietnam are China, the United States, Cameroon, Thailand, and Chile. The import value from these five markets reached $1.57 billion, accounting for over 61 per cent of the total import value into Vietnam. China’s import turnover reached $846 million, accounting for 33 per cent of total imports into Vietnam, up 28 per cent compared to 2019.

In 2020, Vietnam imported over 214,000 cubic metres of timber worth $71.6 million and 597,500cu.m of sawn timber worth $221.8 million from the US. Meanwhile, imports from Cameroon reached $215.96 million, down 24 per cent compared to 2019. Vietnam’s imports from Thailand reached $120.43 million, up 9 per cent compared to 2019. Imports from Chile meanwhile reached $66.78 million, down 17 per cent compared to 2019.

One of the most important timber policies to be issued by the government in 2020 was the decree regulating the Vietnam Timber Legality Assurance System (VNTLAS). Imported timber control is one of the central parts of the decree, where the management of imported timber is carried out according to criteria that identify whether a country is in a positive or negative geographic area, and which type of timber is risky.

To realise the provisions of this decree, in November, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development announced a list of wood types imported into Vietnam and another list of active geographical regions for wood exports to Vietnam.

Accordingly, 322 species of wood were identified for import into Vietnam and 51 countries were identified in active geographical areas. Timber species and supplying countries not on this list will be considered as risky. According to the VNTLAS, enterprises importing risky timber into Vietnam need to perform due diligence, with legal evidence proving the legality of imported timber. 

Thanh Hoa Co., Ltd., one of the largest wood material suppliers in Vietnam, has no way of purchasing timber certified by the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) – an international non-profit, multi-stakeholder organisation established in 1993 that promotes responsible management of the world’s forests – from northern provinces due to problems with regulations and high freight rates.

Vietnam owns nearly 300,000 hectares of FSC wood, but “the surplus of such wood is a big problem,” commented Tran Thien, director of Thanh Hoa. He calculated that the export of outdoor wood products accounts only for about $300 million, about 12,000 FSC wood blocks, equivalent to about 100,000ha of plantation. Meanwhile, most wood furniture processors do not buy FSC wood.

For many years, Vietnam has been developing a certified wood material zone with international support. However, FSC afforestation is losing its sense of sustainability as forest owners cannot get any money from their FSC timber. The actual value of FSC timber is falling sharply, down to 5 per cent of previous prices, and even continues its downward trend to a lower level, with half of forest owners only getting about 3 per cent.

Thien said that for FSC, the evaluation cost for foreign organisations is very high, with cost for initial evaluations coming close to $100,000, and the annual assessment also amounting to over $5,000 – a huge expense for forest growers in the context of a shrinking income.

In the central province of Quang Ngai, the FSC reforestation area has been following the World Bank’s international standards since 2005, and many growers have dropped the annual FSC assessment to save money.

Thien commented. “Forest owners are often too small in the whole chain to profit from FSC timber.”

Meanwhile, the sustainability of the wood production, processing, and export chain only functions when processors prioritise FSC timber. However, they have to pay at least 2-3 per cent of the product value upfront. Afterwards, FSC growers have to also afford the rest of the cost, such as assessing and transporting the timber to factories.

The waste of FSC raw materials is occurring while Vietnam has been warned about issues in legal timber supply from countries that import wood products. Meanwhile, FSC timber is believed to be an effective solution to deal with risks of wood origin. 

The right mechanism

Vietnam’s major goal is to manage forests sustainably and harmonise international regulations on legal timber sourcing. Do Quang Tung, head of the Forestry Project Management Unit under the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, admitted that “area fragmentation is one of the reasons that the country faces difficulties in applying international experience for greater benefits and to reduce the cost of the FSC assessment for growers.”

 

Tung realised that for years Vietnam has been moving towards sustainable forest management, but still mainly relies on the support of international organisations. Planted forests in several provinces, including in the Central Highlands province of Kon Tum, were abandoned after their funding ended. The lack of a master plan for the development of certified raw materials, as well as the intensification of large timber material afforestation, has caused unmet demand for raw materials for the wood processing and export industry.

Global environmental pressure forces large corporations to spend money on FSC, though without much economic significance. In Vietnam, the value is declining, but Tung said FSC is still “one of the criteria to determine legality in Vietnam’s wood import markets, including the European Union and the United States.”

Hoang Thanh, agricultural programme manager for the EU Delegation to Vietnam, said that the EU’s timber regulations recognise the legality of timber and its products with Forest Law Enforcement, Governance and Trade licences that have been verified through control systems of several partner countries who agreed upon the same standards with the EU. Thanh said, “Licensed timber and products thereof are not subject to the accountability under the EU timber regulations.” 

Outside support

To counter some of the issues, the German government is supporting Vietnam with around $47 million, including commercial loans and grants, for certified afforestation. The Vietnam Administration of Forestry, which is profiting from the support, is now expected to operate in the four central provinces of Binh Dinh, Thua Thien-Hue, Quang Nam, and Quang Ngai, which are all supplying wood and timber materials.

Similar to other international support, the German government can help Vietnam expand the area of certified forests, but several issues need to be addressed.

“This time, it is advisable to choose a province surrounding the wood consuming provinces, such as Dong Nai, Binh Duong, Binh Phuoc, Long An, and Ca Mau, which are reasonable for timber transportation to Ho Chi Minh City,” Thien of Thanh Hoa commented.

Tung said, “The hardest thing right now is to decide which province borrows and has to pay following the new official development assistance mechanism.”

Provinces can borrow about $12 million from this source to improve the capacity of FSC growers through appropriate mechanisms, something that all provinces want to do but many remain concerned about. 

Ha Cong Tuan - Deputy Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development

 
The export target for this year stands at $15 billion, with the turnover expected to increase by 14-15 per cent compared to 2020, but the problem of raw materials must be solved first.

Currently, domestic timber sources are speeding up their FSC certifications. As the origin of imported wood is strictly regulated in foreign markets, this process must be strictly controlled to ensure the legal origin of wood and timber.

The income per unit of planted forest has tripled over the past 15 years thanks to the development of the wood processing industry. At that time, plantation timber was valued at only $17.40 per cubic metre. Now, the minimum value reaches about $43 per cu.m – which represents one of the achievements of the wood processing industry.

Some producers are willing to share their benefits through investments in raw material areas, the assessment of sustainable forests, and a commitment to product sales. However, wood processors are never willing to share more profits for growers, apart from certain price mechanisms.

The country’s policy regime is appropriate and has been increasing both forest area and productivity. People ask for more land to plant forests, which means that they are satisfied with the mechanism. Of course, in some places, the life of forest planters is still difficult, but this is a general issue of the entire economic system, not just the forestry sector.

 VIR

Lack of raw materials threaten wood prices

Lack of raw materials threaten wood prices

Input material prices for Vietnamese wood exporters have risen sharply, but most of them are stuck in the mud as there seems no suitable way to increase their selling prices accordingly.

New strategies required to set deeper roots for wood industry

New strategies required to set deeper roots for wood industry

To expand Vietnam’s wood industry sustainably, its development strategy must not only focus on the policies of importing countries but also domestic priorities.

 
 

Other News

.
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS APRIL 30
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS APRIL 30
BUSINESSicon  30/04/2021 

Central province debuts first Ngoc Linh ginseng plant

Association calls for national gold exchange
Association calls for national gold exchange
BUSINESSicon  30/04/2021 

The Vietnam Gold Trading Association (VGTA) has proposed the establishment of a national gold exchange in Hanoi or Ho Chi Minh City.

Restaurant chains fall into crisis amid pandemic
Restaurant chains fall into crisis amid pandemic
FEATUREicon  30/04/2021 

The Tokyo Deli Restaurant on Nguy Nhu Kon Tum Street in Hanoi closed its doors two months ago for the Tet holiday, but it has now decided to never open again. The long Covid-19 pandemic has hit many restaurants hard.

Amid 'land fever', Can Gio district prohibits civil servants from working as land brokers
Amid 'land fever', Can Gio district prohibits civil servants from working as land brokers
FEATUREicon  30/04/2021 

Land prices in the HCM City suburban district of Can Gio have been soaring following the news that Can Gio will become an inner city district, or a city in the future. The local authorities have prohibited civil servants from acting as land brokers.

Multinational supply chain evades small industry
Multinational supply chain evades small industry
BUSINESSicon  29/04/2021 

Foreign investments in Vietnam have the ability to change the economics of many of the country’s support industries, who are continually struggling to be part of the larger supply network.

Four-month FDI totals $12.25 billion
Four-month FDI totals $12.25 billion
BUSINESSicon  29/04/2021 

In the first four months to April 20, foreign investors pumped 12.25 billion USD in Vietnam, equal to 99.3 percent of the amount recorded in the same period last year.

Hanoi developments induce delay fluster
Hanoi developments induce delay fluster
BUSINESSicon  30/04/2021 

Tens of millions of dollars poured into infrastructure together with new planning projects have added vibrancy to Hanoi’s real estate market, 

Construction firms face bankruptcy as steel prices soar
Construction firms face bankruptcy as steel prices soar
BUSINESSicon  29/04/2021 

Local construction firms face the risk of bankruptcy as the price of steel has soared 40 percent recently.

Vietnam looks to promote issuance of Gov’t bonds on int’l market
Vietnam looks to promote issuance of Gov’t bonds on int’l market
BUSINESSicon  29/04/2021 

Experts and economists have proposed to expand the issuance of Government bonds to the international market, 

Billionaire Pham Nhat Vuong builds 'entertainment city', considers billion-dollar deal in the US
Billionaire Pham Nhat Vuong builds 'entertainment city', considers billion-dollar deal in the US
BUSINESSicon  29/04/2021 

Billionaire Pham Nhat Vuong's company has recorded impressive business results despite the Covid-19 pandemic. 

Flower and ornamental plant production on the rise
Flower and ornamental plant production on the rise
BUSINESSicon  28/04/2021 

Flower and ornamental plant production has dramatically developed in recent years, bringing high economic value.

Contract enforcement, bankruptcy filings stall because of lack of regulations
Contract enforcement, bankruptcy filings stall because of lack of regulations
FEATUREicon  29/04/2021 

Vietnam’s judicial agencies seemingly cannot catch up with business environment reform. Two judicial indicators – contract enforcement and business bankruptcy – have not seen considerable improvement.

ST25 is a generic rice variety, not a brand: NOIP
ST25 is a generic rice variety, not a brand: NOIP
FEATUREicon  28/04/2021 

The National Office of Intellectual Property (NOIP) says the ST25 rice variety has been granted a Protective Certificate No 21.VN.2020 under Decision No 45/QD-TT-VPBH dated March 6, 2020 by the director of the Department of Crop Production.

49% of Vietnamese delete shopping apps on mobile devices
49% of Vietnamese delete shopping apps on mobile devices
BUSINESSicon  28/04/2021 

The increase in app deletions shows that Vietnamese e-commerce platforms need to improve the quality of services in order to retain customers.

Listed companies look to tap real estate segment
Listed companies look to tap real estate segment
BUSINESSicon  27/04/2021 

A series of listed businesses on the stock market have announced plans to expand and tap real estate investment.

More farming products sold on e-commerce sites
More farming products sold on e-commerce sites
BUSINESSicon  27/04/2021 

The e-commerce sites of Vietnam Post and Viettel Post saw 33 more suppliers of agricultural products and regional specialities open new booths in the first 10 days of April.

Recruitment demand soars in textile & garment, IT sectors
Recruitment demand soars in textile & garment, IT sectors
BUSINESSicon  27/04/2021 

The effectiveness of free trade agreements, especially the EU– Vietnam Free Trade Agreement, has helped to increase export orders for textile and garment enterprises in Vietnam, 

HCM City taxman wants to tax apartments for lease
HCM City taxman wants to tax apartments for lease
BUSINESSicon  27/04/2021 

The HCMC Tax Department has proposed piloting a plan to tax apartments for lease in five residential blocks in District 11.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS APRIL 29
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS APRIL 29
BUSINESSicon  29/04/2021 

Fruit exports to the US thrive

Local banks target high profits
Local banks target high profits
BUSINESSicon  27/04/2021 

During the “season” of shareholders’ meetings, Vietnamese banks are confident about their plans to increase profits by several trillion dong in 2021. Several banks have set a record growth target of up to 30%-50%.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN