Government officials convicted of public land violations, why?

Land scandals like Thu Thiem (HCM City) have revealed distorted land values caused by decisions of officials on authority, Mr. Dang Hung Vo told VietNamNet.

What’s your view about public land acquisitions in such scandals as the Phan Van Anh Vu case and Thu Thiem?

As I said earlier, the law regulates the people’s ownership over public land but assigns the decision power to some people in authority.

In theory and practice, corruption always occurs whenever the decision power is not controlled, especially when the realization of that power certainly brings benefits for those with vested interests.

As such, the administrative agencies are affected as realizing their rights over public land and land value. We can only expect their decision based on ethics.

In reality, public ownership of all land should be considered a political direction. Once the public land is for sale, it must be based on the value of land-use rights of land owners.

Vì sao quan chức vướng vòng lao lý liên quan đến đất vàng công sản?

Phan Van Anh Vu.

Huge gaps in regulations came from the coexistence of political direction and land solutions, incentivizing corruption. Besides, Land Law 2013 created a management mechanism over some types of land which have not been under specific management of the administration. They consist of land for public security, commercial land, land for high technology, and land for airports. Provincial people’s Committees handed them to state organizations which then assigned them to other contractors and individuals. Under this mechanism, former Navy Admiral Nguyen Van Hien could use his rights on public land sales, and after that say he hadn’t fully understood the law.

Other public land sale scandals, namely “Phan Van Anh Vu” and Thu Thiem, have shown the gap in land value due to decisions made by officials in authority.

Under Articles 199 and 200 of the Land Law, there were regulations about setting up a proper management mechanism to monitor and control decisions on public land. However, they have yet to be realized since Land Law took effect. So it is easy to understand if there more public land scandals occur.

Different process between public and private land

At the court, former Deputy Minister of Defense Nguyen Van Hien blamed his shortcomings on his lack of knowledge about the economy and economic management. Phan Van Anh Vu also explained his land acquisition through trading, not just requesting it from officials. What do you think?

Vì sao quan chức vướng vòng lao lý liên quan đến đất vàng công sản?

Thu Thiem urban area.

It is necessary to review the management mechanism. A large piece of land was under the management of the Ministry of National Defense and its officials. They are allowed to decide the land areas and their usage. Hence, it’s easy for them to make illegal decisions.

In the case of Phan Van Anh Vu, his explanation is a fallacy. In many countries, the regulations are different between public and private land sales. The process to acquire public land is strictly regulated and monitored by the people.

 

In Vietnam, the transfer of public land to the market must be done through auction. It must not be done as a secret deal between the person in authority and the business. Doing so is considered illegal. All related parties have to bear the responsibility over the loss of State property.

Land law needs to be amended

We have lost both government officials and public property. What can we learn from it?

Vì sao quan chức vướng vòng lao lý liên quan đến đất vàng công sản?

In the amended law, the benefits of the people are considered a top priority. Some shortcomings in the legal system can be seen.

Thanks to our strong fight against corruption in recent years, many public land scandals have been brought to light. Consequently, a number of central and local leaders have been convicted.

Firstly, there remain huge gaps in the land law, causing weak land management. The public ownership of all land in the country means all land as public assets. It is not distinguished between public and private land as in other countries.

For better management, it is necessary to be clear on two different land use rights, public vs private.

Secondly, there remains conflicts between land law and other laws such as investment, construction, and planning. This has caused “too tight” or “too loose” attitudes toward regulations related to public land.

Thirdly, the management mechanism fails to meet the demand of the market. The local People’s Committees are assigned powerful rights in administrative decisions, planning, and finance. Their powers are uncontrolled, paving the way for corruption. In other countries, administrative agencies are responsible for administrative tasks. Planning and finance are under other agencies’ authority.

Fourthly, people with professional knowledge and ethical behaviors have not been recruited. This is the main cause in transforming public assets to private hands.

Thus, the Land Law should be amended so it can become practical and effective.

Kien Trung

Public land management and the Land Law

Public land management and the Land Law

In 2020, a number of public land scandals were brought to court and numerous government officials were found guilty.

 
 

Other News

.
Bach Mai Hospital: staffers’ departure is the price of reshuffling
Bach Mai Hospital: staffers’ departure is the price of reshuffling
FEATUREicon  19/04/2021 

Bach Mai Hospital Director Nguyen Quang Tuan has affirmed that the departure of 28 doctors will not affect the hospital's operations.

5G: an opportunity to develop the ICT industry
5G: an opportunity to develop the ICT industry
FEATUREicon  19/04/2021 

Minister of Information and Communications Nguyen Manh Hung said that 5G is not just an opportunity to improve connection services and change Vietnam's telecommunications rankings, but also an opportunity to develop the country's ICT industry.

Vietnam in good position to start electric-car industry
Vietnam in good position to start electric-car industry
FEATUREicon  19/04/2021 

Vietnam has the opportunity to manufacture electric cars more easily than other countries with already well-established auto industries because Vietnam has no auto industry that would need to to sacrificed, experts have said.

When Party documents mention the concept of 'national governance’
When Party documents mention the concept of 'national governance’
FEATUREicon  19/04/2021 

One of the new features of the documents of the 13th National Party Congress is the emergence of the concept of "national governance".

Buyers of phony ‘mutant orchids' from disreputable sellers lose huge sums of money
Buyers of phony ‘mutant orchids' from disreputable sellers lose huge sums of money
FEATUREicon  18/04/2021 

What are some of the most popular investment channels in Vietnam? Real estate, securities, cryptocurrency and ... mutant orchids.

Special lessons given at border markers to local students
Special lessons given at border markers to local students
FEATUREicon  18/04/2021 

At 5 am, the fog still covered the mountain surrounding the Huong Lap Frontier Post. But the teacher, a border officer, was already correctly dressed in uniform, reviewing the lesson plan in a preparation for his teaching period in the field.

Investors in land, securities see high profits as prices rise
Investors in land, securities see high profits as prices rise
FEATUREicon  19/04/2021 

Realtors and securities investors have been pocketing big money in recent months.

The twins who built a sharing platform for young people
The twins who built a sharing platform for young people
FEATUREicon  17/04/2021 

Having experienced a difficult period of time finding directions for the future, a pair of twin sisters decided to establish an online platform to advise and troubleshoot problems for young people who are struggling to find goals for life.

Race for digital transformation: now or never
Race for digital transformation: now or never
FEATUREicon  16/04/2021 

The rules of the game in the future will be "quick fish eats slow fish". Even “giants,” without timely performing digital transformation, may lose ground to “rookies” that are young and agile in the 4.0 technological revolution.

Bach Mai Hospital faces mass resignation of staff
Bach Mai Hospital faces mass resignation of staff
FEATUREicon  16/04/2021 

More than 200 workers at Hanoi-based Bach Mai Hospital, the country’s leading hospital, have resigned from their posts. Some practitioners said they had left because of unreasonable changes in management.

Apartments sales drop, but developers still setting high prices
Apartments sales drop, but developers still setting high prices
FEATUREicon  17/04/2021 

No longer seen as a profitable investment segment, apartments are not selling well as investors have shifted to buy land instead.

Fintechs to partner with telecom carriers to offer Mobile Money
Fintechs to partner with telecom carriers to offer Mobile Money
FEATUREicon  16/04/2021 

The pilot program on providing the Mobile Money service is expected to increase non-cash transactions, especially in remote areas. To improve users' experience, fintechs should work with network operators, experts say.

Digital academy takes shape
Digital academy takes shape
FEATUREicon  17/04/2021 

The initial ecosystem for a digital school is taking shape at the Posts and Telecommunications Institute of Technology (PTIT).

Vietnam aims to be world's top exporter of quality rice
Vietnam aims to be world's top exporter of quality rice
FEATUREicon  19/04/2021 

In August 2020, when the Vietnam - EU Free Trade Agreement (EVFTA) took effect, Trung An High-tech Agriculture JSC exported about 150 tons of rice to the European Union. 

How can 'land fever' outbreaks be stopped?
How can 'land fever' outbreaks be stopped?
FEATUREicon  20/04/2021 

A “land fever” is spreading throughout the country, from the North to the South, from the lowlands to the mountains. Everywhere, the price for land of all kinds, from housing to industrial to farming land is increasing.

Four questions sparked Quang Ninh's awakening 10 years ago
Four questions sparked Quang Ninh's awakening 10 years ago
FEATUREicon  15/04/2021 

A decade ago, the northern province of Quang Ninh faced bottlenecks in infrastructure development. 

From failed college candidate to physics professor in the US
From failed college candidate to physics professor in the US
FEATUREicon  16/04/2021 

Dr. Nguyen Dong Hai spoke with VietNamNet about his path from a student who failed the university entrance exam in Vietnam to a professor of physics at Tennessee Wesleyan University in the US and his thoughts on pedagogical student training.

Female scientist with PhD in immunology pursues research on rare diseases
Female scientist with PhD in immunology pursues research on rare diseases
FEATUREicon  14/04/2021 

Tran Nguyen Kim Thi is a postdoc majoring in AI usage in medicine at the Huge Kaul Precision Medicine Institute at the University of Alabama in Birmingham (UAB) in the US.

Newly-elected NA Chair faces high expectations to fulfill President Ho Chi Minh's wishes
Newly-elected NA Chair faces high expectations to fulfill President Ho Chi Minh's wishes
FEATUREicon  14/04/2021 

When delivering the closing speech at the NA session, NA Chair Vuong Dinh Hue expressed his belief that newly elected deputies will uphold the spirit of dynamism and creativity, and will dare to think, dare to do, and dare to take responsibility.

What’s behind the 'land fever' phenomenon?
What’s behind the 'land fever' phenomenon?
FEATUREicon  14/04/2021 

The market often cools down when periods of "land fever" end, but then new higher price levels reoccur later.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN