Land ownership for foreigners in Vietnam

The policy on allowing foreigners to own houses associated with land in Vietnam has been studied and considered very carefully.

Land ownership for foreigners in Vietnam

Foreigners in Vietnam can buy houses, including apartments and houses attached with land. Their homeownership right is valid for 50 years, and can be extended for another 50 years if needed

In 2003, the author of this article, in the capacity as a leader of the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment, attended a meeting at the top decision-making level to consider the issue of this policy attached to the 2005 Housing Law.

The conclusion of the meeting was that at that time, it was impossible to allow foreign individuals and organizations to own houses associated with land under any form in Vietnam.

In view of national security, many attendees expressed concern, especially over the possibility of the policy to be taken advantage of and foreigners’ acquisition of houses on a large scale, or the capacity of “invasion” with economic means.

From the economic angle, there were opinions that this policy may cause an imbalance in the real estate market. From the social viewpoint, some said the Government must take care of housing for the people, and need not care for housing for foreigners.

In 2008, the National Assembly issued Resolution 19/2008/QH12 on pilot permission for foreign individuals and organizations to buy and own houses in Vietnam, allowing them to own apartments.

The policy was piloted for only apartments, a housing property with almost no attachment to land ownership. After several years of implementation, reports showed that few foreigners paid attention to this policy.

The author of this article thinks that they have keen interest, but are concerned with asynchronous implementation of policies in Vietnam. First, they fear that whether the legal reform in Vietnam is stable or not while real estate is an asset with high value. Second, they observe that authorities at the high level are “open” but those at the lower level are “close.” It’s risky when the high-level authorities have made a decision but the lower-level authorities are not willing to complete the registration procedure for a property.

In 2013, the issue of this policy attached with the 2014 Housing Law, which took effect on July 1, 2015, was carefully prepared by the Ministry of Construction towards a positive direction: It’s time for Vietnam to issue this policy to create fresh momentum for the development of the real estate market. At that time, in the capacity as an expert, the author strongly supported this new policy.

First, it would be a support for on-site real estate export which would bring about big economic gains during the process of global integration.

Second, it is an obligatory policy when Vietnam participates in new generation free trade agreements, such as the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP) and the Vietnam-EU Free Trade Agreement (EVFTA).

These agreements regulate not only trade relations but also other aspects, such as protection of workers’ rights, including the right to housing.

This housing policy is stipulated in detail in the 2014 Housing Law and the 2014 Real Estate Trading Law. As a result, foreigners in Vietnam can buy houses, including apartments and houses attached with land.

Their homeownership right is valid for 50 years, and can be extended for another 50 years if needed, that is the maximum term of ownership is 100 years. Upon expiration of the ownership term, foreigners can sell their houses to get back the money spent on the house purchase.

Foreign individuals and organizations can buy only houses from housing development projects which are determined and made public, and may not buy houses directly from Vietnamese households and individuals.

They can buy many houses for residence and trading purposes. However, the number of properties sold to foreigners must not exceed 30% of the number of apartments in a condominium or 250 housing units in a population area at the ward equivalent level.

These regulations are quite strict to ensure implementation of the new policy and at the same time to protect national defense and security.

Indifferent

After four years of implementation, reports show that the new policy is still not attractive enough to foreigners. In reality, there is not yet sign of the policy being taken advantage of. There are only comments on the media that it still has loopholes or to a further extent is implemented against the law.

According to a report sent by the Ministry of Construction to the supervision group for “the implementation of policies and laws regarding management of foreigners in Vietnam” under the National Assembly’s Foreign Relations Committee, there are some 800 foreign individuals and organizations who own houses in Vietnam, mainly in Hanoi, HCMC, Danang, Ba Ria-Vung Tau, Binh Duong, Khanh Hoa, Dong Thap, Dong Nai, Can Tho, Binh Thuan, Thua Thien-Hue and Vinh Long.

These foreign individuals and organizations, who are mainly from South Korea, and a few from China, Taiwan, Japan and Russia, have duly observed local regulations. The house buyers are mainly individuals.

 

They buy mainly apartments for residence, barely for lease. The number of 800 foreign buyers of apartments shows that the reality does not meet the initial expectation of the new policy.

The question is why is the result of implementation of this good policy so “poor?” The main reason is the inconsistency between the 2013 Land Law and the 2014 Housing Law. The housing law is very “open” but the land law is still tightly “close.”

The 2013 Land Law does not allow long-term land ownership for local organizations and the ownership of land attached with houses for foreign individuals and organizations.

The land law has not yet been revised over the past four and a half years since the 2014 Housing Law took effect. Legally minded foreigners do not want to put themselves at the risks caused by the 2013 Land Law.

Many comments about this issue blame the confusion between the right of foreign individuals and organizations to access housing and the policy to attract foreign investment for real estate development.

Land access, and implementation and transfer of investment projects attached with land use rights are regulated by the 2014 Investment Law, the 2014 Construction Law and the 2013 Land Law.

Meanwhile, the purchase of houses attached with land for residence and trading is under the scope of the 2015 Civil Code, the 2014 Housing Law, the 2014 Real Estate Trading Law and the 2013 Land Law.

Illegal transactions: The real concern

The media recently reported the transfer of 21 land lots in Danang to joint ventures with the Chinese involvement.

The land in the areas for projects owned by local investors, foreign investors and local-foreign joint ventures was regulated quite strictly in the 1993 Land Law, which was later revised carefully and more strictly in the 2003 Land Law and the 2013 Land Law.

Therefore, the author thinks that there is nothing for concern about land in those areas. 

Anybody, including foreigners, who invest in a project must proceed though a Vietnamese legal entity. They will have different rights depending on whether the capital is local or foreign.

According to Article 39 of Decree 43/2014/ND-CP, foreign-invested enterprises cannot receive the transfer of capital which is the land of households and individuals, and can only receive the transfer of land of enterprises, except for land for farming and forestry production.

This regulation can be used to judge the transfer of 21 land lots in Danang whereby the land transferees are foreign-invested enterprises.

The author believes that access to land and houses by foreigners in Vietnam does not meet the expectation of the Vietnamese authorities as stated in the 2014 Housing Law.

The thing to do is to urgently revise the 2013 Land Law for synchronization so that foreigners could see that Vietnam is earnest in her reform endeavor.

The issue of concern is that foreigners, specifically the Chinese, may employ Vietnamese enterprises and individuals as the front for transactions of high value properties in an unofficial manner with “own” rules.

The author has traveled across many localities that are “hot” in real estate and heard much about this phenomenon.

The existence of a business practice beyond the official law is a real concern for both the economy and national defense and security. SGT

Dang Hung Vo

 
 

Other News

.
Four questions sparked Quang Ninh's awakening 10 years ago
Four questions sparked Quang Ninh's awakening 10 years ago
FEATUREicon  15/04/2021 

A decade ago, the northern province of Quang Ninh faced bottlenecks in infrastructure development. 

Female scientist with PhD in immunology pursues research on rare diseases
Female scientist with PhD in immunology pursues research on rare diseases
FEATUREicon  14/04/2021 

Tran Nguyen Kim Thi is a postdoc majoring in AI usage in medicine at the Huge Kaul Precision Medicine Institute at the University of Alabama in Birmingham (UAB) in the US.

Newly-elected NA Chair faces high expectations to fulfill President Ho Chi Minh's wishes
Newly-elected NA Chair faces high expectations to fulfill President Ho Chi Minh's wishes
FEATUREicon  14/04/2021 

When delivering the closing speech at the NA session, NA Chair Vuong Dinh Hue expressed his belief that newly elected deputies will uphold the spirit of dynamism and creativity, and will dare to think, dare to do, and dare to take responsibility.

What’s behind the 'land fever' phenomenon?
What’s behind the 'land fever' phenomenon?
FEATUREicon  14/04/2021 

The market often cools down when periods of "land fever" end, but then new higher price levels reoccur later.

Vietnam to raise tax on cars with high emissions
Vietnam to raise tax on cars with high emissions
FEATUREicon  13/04/2021 

Experts have suggested imposing high taxes on vehicles and encouraging the use of electric cars.

Government of new term to pursue reform, taking action
Government of new term to pursue reform, taking action
FEATUREicon  13/04/2021 

Former Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc has left an indelible mark on the socio-economic development of the country. The newly-elected Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh will continue that strong reform thinking.

“I was moved after being appointed the first female Minister of Home Affairs”
“I was moved after being appointed the first female Minister of Home Affairs”
FEATUREicon  13/04/2021 

VietNamNet talked with Pham Thi Thanh Tra soon after she was elected Minister of Home Affairs.

Six ultra-wealthy people have combined $17 billion
Six ultra-wealthy people have combined $17 billion
FEATUREicon  13/04/2021 

Six Vietnamese businesspeople have been named in Forbes’ list of the world’s richest billionaires.

Vietnam to become ICT powerhouse in next decade
Vietnam to become ICT powerhouse in next decade
FEATUREicon  12/04/2021 

Emphasizing ICT as the field that will lead Vietnam's digital economy, Minister of Information and Communications Nguyen Manh Hung said that we must become an ICT powerhouse not in 2045 but in the next decade (2021-2030).

Quang Ninh Province awakens
Quang Ninh Province awakens
FEATUREicon  12/04/2021 

From mainly relying on coal mining, Quang Ninh rose to become a rich province through the development of tourism and services. But the Covid-19 pandemic has helped Quang Ninh "wake up" and realize its "Asin's heel".

Battery technology will determine race for electric cars
Battery technology will determine race for electric cars
FEATUREicon  13/04/2021 

Only when fast-charging batteries along with a nationwide system of charging stations will electric cars become popular in Vietnam.

When will Vietnam begin to make electric cars?
When will Vietnam begin to make electric cars?
FEATUREicon  12/04/2021 

On March 24, Vinfast made headlines after releasing its statement about receiving orders for its first electric car model VF e34 for VND690 million (about $32,000), to be delivered in the third quarter of 2021. 

The issues of the new government term
The issues of the new government term
FEATUREicon  12/04/2021 

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh's government has inherited many legacies, but also faces many challenges, especially in institutional reform, to realize the aspirations of taking the country to new heights of development.

Virtual travel one step ahead of real travel
Virtual travel one step ahead of real travel
FEATUREicon  15/04/2021 

The tourism industry is facing post-pandemic recovery challenges, but "virtual tourism" may be a new direction to open up breakthrough opportunities.

Hazardous waste: an increasingly serious problem in large cities
Hazardous waste: an increasingly serious problem in large cities
FEATUREicon  10/04/2021 

A report found that Vinh Phuc province discharges over 800 tons of waste every day, of which 180 tons are from urban areas and 700 tons from rural areas.

Ministry proposes removing regulation on foreign-ownership ratio in petrol trading firms until PM reviews
Ministry proposes removing regulation on foreign-ownership ratio in petrol trading firms until PM reviews
FEATUREicon  13/04/2021 

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MOIT) has proposed removing a tentative regulation in a draft decree that says foreign investors can hold up to 35 percent of shares of petroleum trading companies.

Foreign firms take over petroleum market, Ministry of Industry and Trade anticipates risk
Foreign firms take over petroleum market, Ministry of Industry and Trade anticipates risk
FEATUREicon  09/04/2021 

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) has proposed removing the rule in a decree that says foreign investors are allowed to hold no more than 35% of shares in petroleum trading businesses.

The Prime Minister of drastic actions and breakthrough thinking
The Prime Minister of drastic actions and breakthrough thinking
FEATUREicon  09/04/2021 

Mr. Pham Minh Chinh has taken office as the new Prime Minister of Vietnam. 

Where will costly promotion e-commerce campaigns lead?
Where will costly promotion e-commerce campaigns lead?
FEATUREicon  11/04/2021 

Online sale apps are spending big money on promotion campaigns to retain consumers, but the money seems to have been spent in vain.

BOT projects incur losses, investors and banks worry about bad debts
BOT projects incur losses, investors and banks worry about bad debts
FEATUREicon  09/04/2021 

Investors are worried as their Build-Operate-Transfer (BOT) projects cannot satisfy requirements as revenue has been lower than expected.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN