NA Deputy complains about ‘ask-and-grant’ in public investment activities

Some officials tasked to allocate public investment capital give themselves the right to "grant favors" to agencies and businesses.

NA Deputy complains about ‘ask-and-grant’ in public investment activities

Deputy Chair of the NA’s Finance and Budget Committee Vu Thi Luu Mai

The National Assembly on July 27 afternoon discussed the national 5-year finance plan for 2021-2025, borrowing and repayment, and medium-term public investment plans.

Deputy Chair of the NA’s Finance and Budget Committee Vu Thi Luu Mai said that some localities don’t strictly observe procedures and follow priority orders when implementing the Law on Public Investment.

In February 2020, some projects were allocated contingency resources as they were labeled urgent projects. However, just six months later, when building a medium-term public investment plan, they were no longer listed as ‘urgent’.

“In many cases, the list of projects is not based on practical needs, but is done subjectively,” she said.

Of the 3,476 transitional projects, more than 1,000 still don’t have detailed capital allocation plans.

This leads to a waste of resources and poor financial discipline, while putting pressure on the budget as many new projects are added.

“The capital for public investment must be understood as money from the taxes paid by people. The money is not the property of any agency, institution and individual. However, some officials who are assigned to allocate the capital give themselves the right to ‘grant’ the capital. It’s not clear when the ‘ask-and-grant’ scheme will end,” she said.

The NA Deputy from Hanoi asked for more publicity and transparency during the process of implementation. The localities which strictly observe regulations need to be encouraged and praised. Meanwhile, cases of violations of public service ethics must be stictly handled.

Nguyen Quoc Han from Ca Mau, commenting about the public investment plan in 2016-2020, pointed out that some tasks and goals shown in Resolution 26 were not satisfactory.

Some national key projects went slowly. The projects on building road sections of the North-South Expressway is a typical example. Under the plan, the sections need to be completed in 2021. However, to date, the bidding has not been completed in some component projects. The Trung Luong – Can Tho project has been going very slowly.

Han pointed out that in many cases, the principle of concentrated investment capital allocation was not observed. Many new investment projects kicked off, while existing projects, which started from previous periods still did not get enough capital to continue.

The project on upgrading Highway 63 was approved by Ministry of Transport in 2010, but it was delayed many times. In 2014 the decision on implementing the Belt Road No 2 was released. To date, 80 percent of the works of the bid package have been implemented. The project still needs VND261 billion more, but the capital has not been arranged.

Some officials tasked to allocate public investment capital give themselves the right to "grant favors" to agencies and businesses.

The remaining section of the road has heavy traffic, while the road width is just 5.5 meters. As a result, traffic congestion occurs regularly and many traffic accidents have been reported. Han has asked to arrange enough capital for the project in 2021-2025.

 

Decentralization

In reply, Ministry of Planning and Investment Minister Nguyen Chi Dung said public investment has relations to many agencies, branches, institutions and individuals, from central to local government to contractors, consultants and supervisors.

Mentioning decentralization, Dung said current laws has very clear provisions, but many localities still repeatedly ask the central government about issues which are very clear, which is a waste of time.

“All the stages of public investments, from project planning, selection, inspection, adjustment and implementation to yearly capital allocation are now undertaken by local authorities, ministries and branches, not the central government,” Dung said.

According to Dung, the central government only allocates capital to localities in accordance with criteria set by NA. Meanwhile, localities take the initiative in allocating capital to projects. The only thing MPI does is review and report to the Government and NA.

The problem lies in localities, in unreasonable selection of projects, slow capital arrangement, and tardiness in following procedures.

Dung also pointed out that localities don’t thoroughly consider planning and practical needs, or demand for development and reciprocal capital arrangement capability in choosing projects to be implemented.

In some cases, local authorities propose projects stemming from the so-called ‘achievement disease’ and the ‘term of office’ thinking, or follow the crowd and investors’ requests.

There have been many airport, seaport, highway, BT (build, transfer), BOT (build, operation, transfer) and Industrial Zone projects proposed recently, while there were many sugar mill, paper and cement plant projects proposed in the past.

Since local authorities propose projects not based on practical needs and local capital arrangement capability, many projects don’t have enough capital to be developed. The unreasonable choice of projects also leads to slow implementation, a waste of resources and loss of capital.

According to Dung, unnecessary projects are also proposed. Many projects are designed to have a very large scale, but should be smaller.

Meanwhile, local authorities control the unit price norms, and as a result, the total investment capital is artificially pushed up, which goes beyond the localities’ capital arrangement capital. 

Thu Hang - Tran Thuong

Huge public investment in industries and regions

Huge public investment in industries and regions

According to the public investment plan in the period 2021-2025, the total state budget capital allocated for this period is VND2.87 quadrillion, not VND2,750 trillion as being reported to the 10th session of the 14th National Assembly.

Making public investment a driving force of Vietnam’s economy

Making public investment a driving force of Vietnam’s economy

Public investment will focus on important and key industries and sectors of the economy, of which economic sectors account for more than 71%.

 
 

Other News

.
America has returned to Southeast Asia
America has returned to Southeast Asia
FEATUREicon  01/09/2021 

With the official visit to Singapore and Vietnam of US Vice President Kamala Harris, the White House has sent a message to Southeast Asia. It is “America is back” in a region that plays an increasingly important role in US strategy.

Overseas arrivals at airports confused about quarantine rules
Overseas arrivals at airports confused about quarantine rules
FEATUREicon  01/09/2021 

A few days ago, Chien Nguyen took a commercial flight from the US to Vietnam with transit in South Korea.

Should private hospitals be allowed to provide treatment to Covid-19 patients?
Should private hospitals be allowed to provide treatment to Covid-19 patients?
FEATUREicon  31/08/2021 

HCM City authorities have recently asked the Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Finance to consider permitting private healthcare facilities to provide Covid-19 treatment services to patients on demand. 

Business stories of the week
Business stories of the week
FEATUREicon  31/08/2021 

News highlights of last week included the arrest of a major owner of mutant orchids, the capital contribution from the owner of a super-business with huge registered capital, and the 'hidden' person behind the Quang Ninh Coal Football Club.

4-member family defeats Covid-19 after 10 days of self-treatment at home
4-member family defeats Covid-19 after 10 days of self-treatment at home
FEATUREicon  31/08/2021 

Despite being very tired, Huan never dared to sleep all night. He woke up at midnight and 4am to measure the oxygen saturation levels (SpO2) of his family members.

Music heals people's spirits during pandemic
Music heals people's spirits during pandemic
FEATUREicon  29/08/2021 

Social distancing requires the suspension of cultural and entertainment services; however, this does not hinder artists from unwinding.

71-year-old woman with Covid-19 willing to give up her life to save her husband
71-year-old woman with Covid-19 willing to give up her life to save her husband
FEATUREicon  29/08/2021 

In a state of severe respiratory failure, Mrs. Hanh still tried to get up and whisper to the doctor, asking to give up her ventilator to her husband...

Idle footballers do other jobs after V-league canceled
Idle footballers do other jobs after V-league canceled
FEATUREicon  28/08/2021 

After V-League 2021 was canceled, the players now have to turn to all kinds of jobs to have enough money to cover family life.

Three busy days of US Vice President Kamala Harris in Vietnam
Three busy days of US Vice President Kamala Harris in Vietnam
FEATUREicon  28/08/2021 

US Vice President Kamala Harris, the first US Vice President to visit Vietnam, had three busy days in Hanoi, with a packed schedule.

Apartment prices keep escalating despite pandemic
Apartment prices keep escalating despite pandemic
FEATUREicon  30/08/2021 

Contrary to all predictions, the real estate market has been hot during the pandemic. People are rushing to buy apartments for fear that prices will escalate after the pandemic ends.

Teachers complain about problems in online teaching, ask for guidance
Teachers complain about problems in online teaching, ask for guidance
FEATUREicon  28/08/2021 

After one year of teaching online, Vietnamese schools and teachers have become familiar with the new teaching mode.

The sleepless nights of doctors of the ‘Companion Physicians’ network
The sleepless nights of doctors of the ‘Companion Physicians’ network
FEATUREicon  28/08/2021 

On August 17, when hearing from a volunteer that two members of a family with four Covid patients were getting worse, Nguyen Van Chanh of the ‘Thay thuoc dong hanh’ network (Companion Physicians) immediately picked up the phone.

Enterprising leaders need to be protected by the law
Enterprising leaders need to be protected by the law
FEATUREicon  31/08/2021 

More than 87,000 Party members have been disciplined over the last five years, possibly the highest number of violations committed by Party members through the Party’s tenures.

Hanoi Mayor orders closer inspection of high-risk zones
Hanoi Mayor orders closer inspection of high-risk zones
FEATUREicon  27/08/2021 

“All the people in isolated areas must be considered F1 cases (contacts of infected people) and they must be tested. Those who refuse testing must be taken away to concentrated quarantine,” said Hanoi Mayor Chu Ngoc Anh.

Price storms sweep through Vietnamese businesses
Price storms sweep through Vietnamese businesses
FEATUREicon  30/08/2021 

According to Vietnamese businesses, the Covid-19 epidemic has made it difficult for them to maintain production and ensure on-time delivery. The higher transportation cost is "another hit".

Fourth Covid-19 wave still raging, 80,000 businesses leave market
Fourth Covid-19 wave still raging, 80,000 businesses leave market
FEATUREicon  27/08/2021 

The Ministry of Planning and Investment's latest report found that production and business activities have been seriously affected by the Covid-19 pandemic.

Fighting the epidemic based on science
Fighting the epidemic based on science
FEATUREicon  27/08/2021 

At the national level, much more data in the health, economic and social fields is needed to make science-based rather than sentimental decisions for anti-epidemic and economic fronts.

Latest drastic moves in Vietnam’s vaccine diplomacy strategy
Latest drastic moves in Vietnam’s vaccine diplomacy strategy
FEATUREicon  26/08/2021 

Through vaccine diplomacy, Vietnam has so far received millions of vaccine doses from the support of the international community.

Vietnam-US relationship: comprehensive and strategic
Vietnam-US relationship: comprehensive and strategic
FEATUREicon  26/08/2021 

This is the time to review the relationship between Vietnam and the US, 

Hotels, private hospitals join fight against Covid-19
Hotels, private hospitals join fight against Covid-19
FEATUREicon  26/08/2021 

Many resources in society have been mobilized for testing, vaccination and medical quarantine, which has improved service quality and helped businesses earn revenue.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN