Public land management and the Land Law

In 2020, a number of public land scandals were brought to court and numerous government officials were found guilty.

After 10 years in effect, the Land Law 2013 has revealed shortcomings which require further consideration and revision.

VietNamNet talks with Prof. Dang Hung Vo, former Deputy Minister of Natural Resources and Environment about this.

According to Prof. Vo, the Law regulates that the ownership of public land and public property belong to the people but assigns the decision on land-use rights to officers in authority.

“When the government officers have the right to decide land and land value, it is easy for them to do for their own benefit. We can only count on their ethics. Both in theory and reality, there is always corruption risk whenever someone with power is not controlled, especially when it is just to serve a group with a vested interest.”

Những đại án đất công sản và chuyện luật Đất đai trước thềm sửa đổi

Prof. Dang Hung Vo: It is necessary to improve the legal framework on building, investigating, and approving build-transfer projects based on the “land exchanged for infrastructure” scheme.

Two foreseen consequences

How has the public land been managed in recent years?

In countries with private land ownership, the law is very clear about private land and public land. The public land belongs to state ownership. The private land belongs to economic entities, households, individuals or a community. As such, their land management is quite straightforward.

For public land, the law legislates when States can sell public land. The market price is used as a lead price to identify the value of land. The sale of public land happens when there is a real estate bubble. States have to increase land supply to reduce demand or to meet development demand.

On the other hand, they regulate the conversion of private land into public land, if they need them for public purpose and for the benefits of their people. Their land management is mainly about providing public administration for land transactions such as transfers, gifts, inheritance, leasing, mortgage, and capital contribution.

Những đại án đất công sản và chuyện luật Đất đai trước thềm sửa đổi

After 10 years, the Land Law 2013 has revealed weaknesses.

In our country, land is considered a public asset, land-use right is also land property right. There is no clear line between public land use rights and private land-use rights. Besides, our current regulations are to empower administrative authorities in land and natural resource management.

Once an authority has more power on land decisions, two consequences occur. Firstly, there is higher corruption risk as the result of uncontrolled power. Secondly, the authority can be found guilty of and convicted of land fraud.

Hence, it is necessary for us to review and amend our land law to clarify the private land-use right and the public land-use right. It is easier to manage these two land use rights separately. Then, we shall set up a proper system to control the power of authorities over land.

Improve the legal framework

Some localities have taken advantage of Public Private Partnership (PPP) in the form of exchanging land for infrastructure. Some of them trade “golden land” for infrastructure. So, what to do to bring the most for the State?

 
Những đại án đất công sản và chuyện luật Đất đai trước thềm sửa đổi

Former Deputy Minister of Defense Nguyen Van Hien appears at court for land-related violations during his tenure.

Prior to 2007, it was named “utilize public land for infrastructure development” or “land exchanged for infrastructure.” In 2007, PPP came to Vietnam. Contractors and local authorities have continued to carry out “land exchanged for infrastructure” under a new concept “Building – Transfer” (BT).

Under this mechanism, contractors set up infrastructure projects in exchange for a specified land. In many cases, the value of land is much higher than that of infrastructure. This has caused public concerns.

The State suffers loss in the exchange, especially when the land price has increased against the value of infrastructure. The Government Inspectorate and the State Audit Office of Vietnam have inspected and audited numerous BT projects. Fraud and errors have been found in all of them.

Even though “land exchanged for infrastructure” model has been implemented since 1992, there are no sufficient regulations about it.

Những đại án đất công sản và chuyện luật Đất đai trước thềm sửa đổi

Violations related to the land allotment at 67 Ngo Thi Nham, Hanoi, are under investigation. (Photo: Doan Bong)

Therefore, what needs to be done is to improve the legal framework for BT projects under the “land exchanged for infrastructure” model.

Good practice from public officers

Many localities namely Thai Nguyen, Cao Bang and others relocated their administrative centers. The former headquarters are converted into commercial area. In many localities, these “golden lands” were acquired by private contractors. So what needs to be done to manage and monitor this well?

One important aspect is to re-arrange public assets in the form of administrative headquarters. As for finance, it is to capitalize public land by making the most of the land with minimum cost and selling the unused to raise capital for the State budget. The re-arrangement of urban public land is an appropriate policy.

However, there remains huge gaps in the legal system. Some ministries have already relocated but did not return their former headquarters to the State. Some public agencies still keep their land to rent out unused area for their own benefits. 

The re-arrangement and re-adjustment of public land under current insufficient regulations require good practices and morality of public officers.

Kien Trung

SOE equitization: investors attracted by ‘golden land’ holdings

SOE equitization: investors attracted by ‘golden land’ holdings

Vu Dinh Anh, a respected economist, has pointed out that in many cases, investors decide to buy shares of equitized enterprises because the enterprises have many land plots in advantageous positions, or ‘golden land’.

 
 

Other News

.
Farmer looks to the internet to improve skills, income
Farmer looks to the internet to improve skills, income
FEATUREicon  08/04/2021 

Phan Van Hung now earns half billion dong a year after studying farming techniques on the Internet.

The politician who goes to wholesale market, wades in water to visit people
The politician who goes to wholesale market, wades in water to visit people
FEATUREicon  08/04/2021 

President Nguyen Xuan Phuc, 67, on April 5, took the oath of office before the National Assembly, people, and voters. This is the first time that an incumbent Prime Minister was elected State President.

Vietnamese enjoy high-end tours at surprisingly low fees
Vietnamese enjoy high-end tours at surprisingly low fees
FEATUREicon  07/04/2021 

Travel firms have been advised to focus on the domestic market for the immediate time. However, they also need to draw up new strategies and new programs to conquer this group of travelers.

Hybrid electric vehicles to account for 30% of market by 2030
Hybrid electric vehicles to account for 30% of market by 2030
FEATUREicon  07/04/2021 

Hybrid electric vehicles (HEV), which have maximum fuel economy, low emissions and smooth operation, are suited to Vietnam’s climate and transport conditions, experts say.

Sai Gon’s ‘knights' offer aid to people in distress
Sai Gon’s ‘knights' offer aid to people in distress
FEATUREicon  07/04/2021 

The kindness of "night-road knights" has made a massive contribution to reducing traffic accidents, and has won acclaim from the people and the government of Binh Tan District, HCM City.

ICT Minister answers key questions about digital transformation
ICT Minister answers key questions about digital transformation
FEATUREicon  06/04/2021 

Minister of Information and Communications Nguyen Manh Hung posed key questions and outlined solutions to digital transformation issues at a recent meeting with officials of the southern province of Ba Ria - Vung Tau.

National Assembly - Highest organ of State power, highest representative body of the people
National Assembly - Highest organ of State power, highest representative body of the people
FEATUREicon  06/04/2021 

Within the State apparatus of Vietnam, the National Assembly (NA) is the highest representative body of the people and the highest organ of State power of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam.

Vietnamese engineers register inventions in the US
Vietnamese engineers register inventions in the US
FEATUREicon  06/04/2021 

The strategy of mastering the high-tech industry at a world-class level has been the foundation for Viettel Group’s engineers to now have four patents protected as intellectual property in the US.

Prices surge on stock market, VN Index reaches record high
Prices surge on stock market, VN Index reaches record high
FEATUREicon  05/04/2021 

Many new investors have made high profits after the stock market reached a record high.

From Tho Nguyen to Ryan Kazy: high profits are made from YouTube content for children
From Tho Nguyen to Ryan Kazy: high profits are made from YouTube content for children
FEATUREicon  06/04/2021 

Developing content on YouTube has proven to be very profitable for young creators, from a 29-year-old Vietnamese girl to a 9-year-old boy from Texas.

Wind power: investors wait for PM’s decision on Feed-in-Tariff price
Wind power: investors wait for PM’s decision on Feed-in-Tariff price
FEATUREicon  06/04/2021 

The Feed in Tariff (FIT) price of VND2,000 per kwh will expire in seven months, but the price for the next period has not been fixed yet.

"VietNamNet has a great opportunity to take the lead in digital technology"
"VietNamNet has a great opportunity to take the lead in digital technology"
FEATUREicon  05/04/2021 

Minister of Information and Communications Nguyen Manh Hung said that the digital age is coming and it will fundamentally change our lives. VietNamNet should be a newspaper that applies the most of the new technology.

Local authorities struggle to stop real estate bubble
Local authorities struggle to stop real estate bubble
FEATUREicon  03/04/2021 

The real estate market remains feverish not because of high demand and short supply, but because of speculation, experts have said.

Will Vietnam compete with Thailand, Indonesia to manufacture electric cars?
Will Vietnam compete with Thailand, Indonesia to manufacture electric cars?
FEATUREicon  04/04/2021 

In Southeast Asia, Thailand and Indonesia are running a race to become electric car manufacturing centers of the region and the world. Will Vietnam join the race?

Vuong Dinh Hue held many midnight meetings before becoming NA chair
Vuong Dinh Hue held many midnight meetings before becoming NA chair
FEATUREicon  02/04/2021 

Having "gone through the mill" when he was Minister of Finance, Deputy PM, and Hanoi Party Committee Secretary, Vuong Dinh Hue has left an impressive legacy as a leader who took serious action on many matters.

Intensive-care physician faces daily 'battle of wits' with critical Covid-19 cases
Intensive-care physician faces daily 'battle of wits' with critical Covid-19 cases
FEATUREicon  02/04/2021 

Dr Pham Van Phuc has been honored as one of the 10 outstanding young faces of Hanoi in 2021.

Students fascinated by traditional music instruments after schools introduce new lessons
Students fascinated by traditional music instruments after schools introduce new lessons
FEATUREicon  02/04/2021 

Tran Hai Dang, deputy director of the Vietnam Institute of Musicology, says that many students are familiar with the western guitar, violin and piano but lack knowledge about traditional Vietnamese instruments.

Big businesses pour billions of dong into land purchases in Da Nang
Big businesses pour billions of dong into land purchases in Da Nang
FEATUREicon  01/04/2021 

While other land markets are hot, Da Nang remains very quiet, prompting many investors from Hanoi and HCM City to collect land plots in advantageous positions in "bottom fishing" deals.

More than 10 sugar mills shut down because of big losses
More than 10 sugar mills shut down because of big losses
FEATUREicon  01/04/2021 

Many sugar mills have had to shut down because they cannot compete with imports.

Wind, solar power projects complain about VAT refunds
Wind, solar power projects complain about VAT refunds
FEATUREicon  31/03/2021 

Wind power developers, who are running against time to put their projects into operation prior to November 2021, now face another problem: they may not get a VAT (value added tax) refund because of certain regulations.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN