return icon

Former director of Bach Mai admits violations in inflating price of medical equipment

Hanoi’s People's Court on Thursday opened the first instance trial on the inflation of prices of medical equipment in Bach Mai Hospital, one of the biggest hospitals in Vietnam under the management of the Ministry of Health.


Defendant Nguyen Quoc Anh, former director of Bach Mai Hospital (first row, left) at the trial on Thursday in Hanoi. 


Former director of Bach Mai Hospital Nguyen Quoc Anh admitted violations in price gouging of medical equipment and took responsibility for signing a joint venture contract between Bach Mai Hospital and BMS Company to appraise and raise the prices of equipment.

In April last year, Nguyen Quoc Anh and seven defendants were prosecuted by the Supreme People’s Procuracy for the crime of abusing power and position while performing their official duties according to Article 356, Clause 3 of the Penal Code.

Nguyen Quoc Anh was the director of Bach Mai Hospital when the alleged wrongdoings took place.

The other defendants are Nguyen Ngoc Hien, former vice director of Bach Mai Hospital, Trinh Thi Thuan and Ly Thi Ngoc Thuy, former chief accountant and deputy head of finance at the hospital, Pham Duc Tuan and Ngo Thi Thu Huyen, director and deputy director of BMS Medical Technology Joint Stock Company (BMS), Tran Le Hoang, an appraiser from the Hanoi Valuation and Financial Services JSC (VFS) and Pham Minh Dung, former director general of VFS.

During the investigation, Nguyen Quoc Anh and Nguyen Ngoc Hien were detained while the remaining defendants were released on bail.

At the trial, defendant Ly Thi Ngoc Thuy filed an application for trial in absentia due to illness and had a hospital certificate.

The trial panel approved Thuy's application for a trial in absentia.

To prepare for the trial, the panel summoned 37 victims but only three were present.

The trial also summoned a number of other people including representatives of Bach Mai Hospital, BMS Medical Technology Company (now Life Energy Company), VFS Valuation Joint Stock Company and a number of others.

According to the indictment announced at the trial, in the process of signing a joint venture contract at Bach Mai Hospital, defendant Nguyen Quoc Anh and others took advantage of their duties and powers to violate the provisions of the law.

Defendants Tran Le Hoang and Phan Minh Dung evaluated the price of robotic systems for cranial nerve surgery – the Rosa Robot – at VND39 billion (US$1.7 million) to allow BMS Medical Technology Joint Stock Company to join a joint venture with Bach Mai Hospital to install the robotic system.

Specifically, on February 20, 2017, VFS Company issued a valuation certificate showing that Rosa Robot costs VND39 billion, but three days later, this robot was imported from France for VND7.4 billion ($319,000), including taxes.

The increased purchase price of the robotic system brought profits to the collective and individual defendants with Nguyen Quoc Anh benefitting more than VND331 million.

Defendants Nguyen Ngoc Hien and Trinh Thi Thuan were determined to benefit by VND150 million and VND50 million, respectively.

The investigation showed that from February 2017 to May 2020, Bach Mai Hospital used Rosa Robot to perform cranial surgery for 639 cases, collecting more than VND22.9 billion (US$1 million) and the hospital paid the costs related to 551 cases to BMS Company.

According to the assessment, the cost of surgery with Robot Rosa was more than VND6.6 million per case but the hospital and BMS Company charged patients more than VND23 million.

The difference was more than VND16.5 million per case, causing more than VND10 billion in damage to the patients.

During questioning, Nguyen Quoc Anh admitted the violations and responsibility for signing a joint venture contract between the hospital and BMS Company which led to errors in the appraisal and increase of the medical equipment price.

Nguyen Quoc Anh admitted to receiving from defendant Pham Duc Tuan a total of VND100 million and US$10,000.

However, defendant Nguyen Quoc Anh said that the money was just a gift for holidays and Tet. 

At the trial, defendants Nguyen Ngoc Hien and Trinh Thi Thuan also admitted their violations.

The trial will continue on Friday.

Source: Vietnam News

Doctors found guilty of criminal activity, shocking society

Doctors found guilty of criminal activity, shocking society

A number of violations by medical staff have been found recently, and many medical doctors, who have the respect of society because they save peoples’ lives, have been handcuffed.

Procurement of medical equipment during Covid-19 is a sensitive issue: MOH

Procurement of medical equipment during Covid-19 is a sensitive issue: MOH

Mistakes in purchasing medical equipment and materials to serve the fight against Covid-19 can easily be perceived as examples of wrongdoings and embezzlement.


Downpours cause human, property losses in northern Vietnam

Hanoi and other northern provinces were inundated following heavy rains on May 23 and 24 that have caused human and property losses.

Vietnam puts forward numerous important proposals at WEF Davos 2022

Deputy Prime Minister Le Minh Khai has shared the nation’s plans to build a low-carbon, green-ecological-sustainable agriculture system with three pillars; ecological agriculture, modern countryside, and smart farmers.

Various Party members in HCM City disciplined

The Ho Chi Minh City Party Committee’s Inspection Board has disciplined seven Party members for their involvement in four cases monitored by the Central Steering Committee for Corruption and Negative Phenomena Prevention and Control.

Government proposes delay to submission of draft amended Land Law to NA

The Government has proposed a delay to a submission of the draft Law on Land (amended) to the National Assembly (NA) until the Party Central Committee issues directions on reforms of land-related policies and laws.

New records, outstanding athletes of SEA Games 31

A total of 22 new records were set at the 31st Southeast Asian Games (SEA Games 31) which concluded with a colourful ceremony in Hanoi on May 23 night.


Traffic accidents claim over 2,760 lives in five months

Obstacles yet to clear to pave way for robust industrial property development

Vietnam has not yet reached its full potential in industrial property development, due to inadequate regulations and a lack of social infrastructure.

Teen suicide: 'red warnings' ignored

According to statistics, about 2% of children suffer from depression. The rate is from 5% to 8% for adolescents. The rate is higher among children after puberty.

Prime Minister to host dialogue with farmers on May 29

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh will host a dialogue in Son La on May 29 with a participation of 500 delegates, including 300 typical farmers, cooperatives and enterprises in the agricultural field along with experts and scientists across the country.

Will housing prices cool down in late 2022?

The boost in sales and the slowdown of the land bank expansion are expected to help  land and house prices decrease in the remaining quarters of 2022, according to VNDirect Research.

Just 15 percent of urban wastewater treated

According to the Government's report, the total amount of wastewater collected and treated in urban areas is very low, only about 15 percent whereas wastewater in most rural residential areas is not treated.


Tight material supply impedes textile exports

Stock, real estate markets too hot, need close supervision

The Government has submitted to the National Assembly a report about the implementation of the 2021 socio-economic development plan and the deployment of the 2022 plan.

Hoi An sampan riders: the hardships and the smiles

Entering a new normal phase after more than two years of being hit hard by the COVID-19 pandemic, sampan riders in Hoi An City are eager to get back to work, expecting prosperous, stable tourism development for the town.

HCM City to host Smart City Asia 2022

A Smart City Expo & Forum in Asia (Smart City Asia 2022) will be held at the Saigon Exhibition and Convention Centre in Ho Chi Minh City from May 26 to May 28.