VietNamNet Bridge – A fresh controversy has broken out as local authorities in the central province of Thua Thien-Hue plan to take almost 400 hectares from the core zone of local Bach Ma National Park to develop a tourism complex.

Visitors look out from Bach Ma Peak. The mountain is regarded as having one of the most beautiful peaks in the country. — VNS Photo Nguyen Van Sum

The park is a protected area under Vietnamese environmental laws and is a typical biosphere centre of the country.

At a seminar on Saturday, the provincial People’s Committee introduced to environmental, construction and cultural experts a proposal to build a 387.8ha ecotourism complex on the top of Bach Ma Mountain, which is part of the rich biodiversity park.

The complex will also include two cable lines. According to Wimberly Allison Tong & Goo, an architectural firm headquartered in the US, the complex would have two sections. The first serves as a transit area connecting the park with the National Highway’s section in the province’s Phu Loc District. It would accommodate the reception hall as well as the departure station of a cable car system.

The US firm works as the project advisor and its representatives said at the seminar that the second section would include a mountain-view village, a waterfall and valley-view village, a heritage-tourism village, a central village, a spiritual-tourism centre, a logistics centre, and a zone of nature conservation.

Two visitors enjoy the cool lake at Bach Ma Peak. Most of foreign visitors choose the site for trekking in nature. — VNS Photo Dang Dinh Sy

However, experts have expressed concern over the impacts to the nature in the park, demanding a reconsideration of how the proposal would affect the local economy.

Participants at the seminar demanded the advisor recalculate the expected number of total annual visitors to the complex, saying one million was too large for a site that does not allow tourism operations for the six months of the rainy season due to difficult weather.

The huge complex would mean large infrastructure would have to be built in the park, creating more pressure on its natural areas, experts said.

“It’s necessary to calculate the contribution of the complex to local economy,” said Tran Ngoc Chinh, chairman of the Viet Nam Urban Development Planning Association, adding that the province had learnt lessons from the construction of villas scattered in different places on Bach Ma Mountain over a hundred years ago by the French.

La Thi Kim Ngan from the Viet Nam Architecture Association said the complex planners must consider lowering the percentage of land they’re seeking to use in the national park.

Nguyen Vu Linh, the park’s deputy director, said the mountain has very high annual rainfall and humidity, recommending downsizing the project. Linh added that there is a great deal of thunder and lightning on the mountain peak during the rainy season, so the planners need to reconsider the complex location.

“Construction of the complex at vulnerable places, like in Do Quyen waterfall [in the park], will affect the biodiversity heavily,” he said.

A villa built by the French over a hundred years ago. Locals insisted that improving services at these villas is enough for tourism development in Bach Ma. — VNS Photo Nguyen Van Sum

“Ecotourism is part of the adaptation of conservation into the development context. It’s also meaningful to educate people about the biodiversity values,” said Professor Nguyen Ngoc Lung, deputy head of the Research Institute for Sustainable Forest Management and Forest Certification.

“With the complex, will the park authorities be able to fulfill the responsibility of forest protection as defined by the Government?” Lung questioned, saying he did not see any proof that the proposed complex would meet ecotourism criteria.

Lung and other conservationists also demanded a detailed environmental impact assessment (EIA) report on the project.

Researcher Nguyen Xuan Hoa, former director of the local Department of Culture and Information, said building the complex at the core of the national park would damage nature.

Hoa added that the focus in exploiting the existing French villas is enough for the development of tourism in Bach Ma.

Dang Dinh Sy, who has run a wild trekking tour in Bach Ma for years, told Việt Nam News that the park as well as the nature there is not suitable for mass tourism.

“Visitors choose to come there to trek, to enjoy the nature in a typical biosphere as well as to soak in the magic light of sunrise and sunset at the height of 1,400m above the sea level. But definitely not to stay in modern hotel facilities,” he said.

Sy also showed consensus with researcher Hoa, saying the key to tourism development in Bach Ma is to make full use of 139 French villas at the site.

The Bach Ma National Park was formed in 1991 with expanded area of nearly 37,500ha. It is home to more than 4,500 flora and sauna species, including endemic and endangered species listed by International Union for Conservation of Nature. 

Source: VNS