return icon

Int’l researchers reaffirm value of PCA ruling on East Sea

International researchers and experts while attending a recent teleconference reaffirmed the value of the 2016 ruling on the East Sea by the Permanent Court on Arbitration (PCA).

Prof. Dr. Thomas Engelbert, from University of Hamburg, chairs the teleconference.

Prof. Dr. Thomas Engelbert, from University of Hamburg, chairs the teleconference.

The July 9 teleconference, hosted by the Department of Southeast Asian Languages and Cultures, University of Hamburg, attracted speakers from University of Applied Sciences (Bremen), Charles University (Prague), Deutsche Welle (Bonn), and Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik (Berlin).

It was held to mark five years after the July 12, 2016 PCA ruling on the East Sea (internationally known as the South China Sea).

In his opening speech, Prof. Dr. Thomas Engelbert, University of Hamburg, noted that the situation in the East Sea has witnessed tense developments since the ruling was given.

Violations of international law have continued to occur, prompting many countries to voice their objections, he said.

The negotiation process on a Code of Conduct in the East Sea (COC) between the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) and China has been continuously delayed and has not been completed yet.

According to the researcher, the recent times has seen the United States shift its strategic focus to the Indo-Pacific region, while the European Union (EU) and many member states have also shown interest in the region by issuing their own strategies for the Indo-Pacific.

The professor said that amidst tensions in the South China Sea, Japan delivered a diplomatic note to the United Nations early this year, officially rejecting China’s sovereign claims in the East Sea. Similar statements were also made by the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Malaysia, Australia, New Zealand, Indonesia, Vietnam, the Philippines and the United States.

Such statements prove that the international community pays great attention to the East Sea, expressing their desire for a safe and stable sea that ensures and facilitate freedom of navigation, said Engelbert.

At the same time, he said the international community always upholds the compliance with international law, and strongly opposes actions that violate the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) as well as the PCA’s ruling.

International experts and researchers coming from Europe voice their support for the ruling, saying it has far-reaching legal results

International experts and researchers coming from Europe voice their support for the ruling, saying it has far-reaching legal results

Meanwhile, Professor Suzette Suarez from University of Applied Sciences (Bremen), affirmed that the PCA’s 2016 ruling especially plays a critical role in the delineation of the outer limits of the continental shelf in the East Sea.

The delineation of the limits of the continental shelf is a binding and mandatory procedure in UNCLOS, and therefore China’s ‘nine-dash line’ and its sovereign claims in the East Sea have absolutely no legal validity, he concluded.

Echoing Professor Suarez’s view, other experts and researchers also highly appreciated the PCA’s 2016 ruling, which they stated has constituted an important legal basis for resolving the East Sea issue. They also suggested that relevant parties should respect international law and not take actions to complicate the situation.

Sharing his view, Dr. Rodion Ebbighausen, managing editor of Deutsche Welle’ Asia Department, said that three EU countries, namely France, Germany and the Netherlands, have put forward a national Indo - Pacific strategy. In April 2021, the Council of the European Union published the “EU strategy for cooperation in the Indo - Pacific”, which will be further developed until the end of 2021.

According to the journalist, in all these documents, which are broad in content, freedom of navigation, the rules-based international order, and in almost all cases, the East Sea are mentioned. At the same time, the EU wants to pursue an inclusive and inclusive approach focusing on peaceful means on the basis of international law.

A panoramic view of the teleconference hosted by University of Hamburg (Germany)

A panoramic view of the teleconference hosted by University of Hamburg (Germany)

During the teleconference, researchers affirmed and clarified the position and role of UNCLOS in the peaceful settlement of disputes in the South China Sea, and at the same time, reaffirmed the value of the 2016 ruling by the PCA.

On July 12, 2016, the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague ruled the case Philippines versus China in the East Sea. The ruling, based on the provisions of the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea had far-reaching legal results.

It invalidated China’s claims to virtually the whole East Sea, where altogether six countries claim territories. China’s claims based on historic grounds, especially the self-proclaimed ‘nine-dash-line’ of maritime borders, is incompatible with international law.

The PCA ruled, that the waters of the South China Sea beyond the territorial sea were legally part of the high seas, in which vessels from any state could freely navigate and fish.

Source: VOV


Mortgaged assets of enterprise whose owners fled the country are up for sale

Agribank’s Bac Hai Phong Branch has announced the auction of assets used as collateral for a loan provided to Kai Yang Vietnam Co Ltd.

VN-China's Taiwan coordinate in verifying identity of victims drifting at sea

After receiving information from Taiwanese authorities on the case, the Foreign Ministry directed the Taipei office to urgently work with Taiwanese authorities on the matter.

Over 3,200 phishing pages detected in Q1

Phishing attacks have been on the rise in the first months of the year. Chong lua dao, a not-for-profit cybersecurity project, reported that it has discovered 3,271 websites scamming Vietnamese users over the last three months.


SBV's draft regulations encourage banks to support corporate bond market


First-ever baguette festival honours national delicacy

1.6 mobile subscribers in danger of service termination after March 31

The Authority of Telecommunications (under the Information & Communications Ministry) yesterday announced that 1.9 million mobile subscribers successfully certify personal information with their carriers.

Case of four flight attendants carrying drugs remains under investigation

Regarding the case of the four Vietnam Airlines flight attendants who transport drugs from France to Tan Son Nhat Airport, the police have initiated an investigation and will provide updates on the results.

Foreign ownership at some local banks may rise to 49%

The State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) has proposed increasing the foreign ownership cap at some commercial banks from 30% to 49%.

Chinese manager arrested for murdering staff member in Binh Duong

A Chinese director of a company in the southern province of Binh Duong was arrested on Thursday after allegedly murdering a female staff member.

Hundreds of flights added for surging national holiday demand

Vietnamese airlines have provided around hundreds of additional flights to serve travel demand for Reunification Day (30/4) and International Labour Day (May 1).

New 3D virtual space promotes Vietnamese betel nut culture

The practice of chewing betel has deep cultural roots in Vietnamese traditions and is a customary element in engagement and wedding ceremonies, as well as during conversations.

HCM City organises first-ever bánh mì festival

Visitors can browse and enjoy a wide variety of Vietnamese bánh mì with many types of fillings, including vegetarian, as well as other baked goods and sweets.

20 districts, thousands of communes to be eliminated as part of admin reform

Eight districts and 563 communes have been eliminated as part of administrative reform. The figures will double or triple in the time to come.

Vietnam a potential market for shoppertainment: report

Vietnam is one of the most potential markets in the Asia-Pacific region for shoppertainment - a trend that combines online shopping with entertainment.

Education Ministry urges schools to boost vigilance after spate of scams

In response to a spate of sophisticated scams targeting parents and students, the Vietnamese Ministry of Education and Training (MoET) has called on schools to increase their vigilance and strengthen their coordination with parents.