return icon

Leaders eye bond market revamp

The recent cancellation of new corporate bonds has sparked a public discussion about the dissemination of misleading information and the multiple hazards lurking in the debt market.
Leaders eye bond market revamp

State bodies may compel Tan Hoang Minh to repurchase some bonds, Le Toan

Investors, on the other hand, are concerned about an appropriate solution to this conundrum.

Deputy Prime Minister Le Minh Khai last week signed and promulgated Public Notice No.304 on the rectification of corporate bond market activities and land auctions, after acknowledgement that numerous hazards and illegal manipulations have been impeding investors’ faith.

The decision came hot on the heels of the State Securities Commission’s (SSC) decision to cancel nine bond issuances by real estate developer Tan Hoang Minh Group between July 2021 and last month, totalling $436.1 million, owing to concealment and dissemination of misleading information.

The DPM also cautioned that lingering risks from the private placement of bonds by real estate companies with huge issue volumes and high-interest rates should be taken into account.

The Ministry of Finance (MoF) and the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) thoroughly monitor the financial and monetary market developments, including the issuance, investment, distribution, transaction, and use of corporate bond capital to guarantee compliance with current legal restrictions.

The Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment is also required to study and enhance the inspection of conducting auctions of land use rights.

A total of eight lots with a total value of $353.5 million released in 2021 have been declared by the Hanoi Stock Exchange, out of nine cancelled bond issuances by Tan Hoang Minh. Information on one issuance has not yet been released.

The unprecedented cancellation of the Tan Hoang Minh private bond issuance has caused an uproar in the market. The cancellation occurred after the bidding process to buy a land lot in Ho Chi Minh City’s Thu Thiem Peninsula for a record $106,521 per square metre late last year. The company soon thereafter decided to pull out of the transaction in January, forfeiting millions of dollars in deposit money.

SSI analyst Trinh Thai stated, “Some are concerned that Tan Hoang Minh might face default risk from the scandal, which could trigger a domino effect in the property sector as seen with Evergrande in China. We might need to wait for the response by Tan Hoang Minh to see how it could resolve its obligation balance to pay off debt holders in the event claims from investors come due.”

In terms of systemic impact, she added, Tan Hoang Minh has a smaller foothold in the property sector overall, which means if a domino effect were to ripple into the market, it would likely be limited in scale.

“However, we might expect the corporate bond market to be muted given the regulatory crackdown on market misconduct which has ramped up since last year, as well as the government’s tightening of legal requirements and loopholes,” Thai said.

On the flip side, bondholders are concerned about whether their investment money will be lost and, if so, how they will recover their funds from the cancellation.

The relevant state bodies would compel Tan Hoang Minh to repurchase bonds. But Tan Hoang Minh may not be able to purchase all nine cancelled bond lots immediately.

Tran Minh Hai, director of law firm BASICO, referenced Decree No.128/2021/ND-CP dated December 30 on sanctioning administrative violations in the securities market, stating that individual investors have the right to obtain money back to acquire bonds and claim reimbursement from the issuer.

“The demand for compensation for damage must be made to the issuing firm within 60 days from the date of the SSC’s handling decision on the cancellation of issued bond lots,” Hai said.

In this specific instance, he argued that bondholders have not comprehended well enough the financial capability, business strategy, and collateral of the issuers. Therefore, when firms fail to fulfil their obligations, bondholders encounter various challenges.

“In the meantime, investors need to promptly disclose information to the business side and urge them to refund the money. Depending on the progress of the case, there will be further measures to collect the money back,” he said.

Truong Thanh Duc, general director of ANVI law consultancy, further remarked that if Tan Hoang Minh cannot buy back all nine bonds cancelled because money has been poured into other projects, it would be extremely difficult to handle. “Relevant parties have to go to court to continue to complete the cases,” he said.

Outstanding corporate bonds as of 2021 are estimated to be around $60.8 billion, implying a compound annual growth rate of 46 per cent between 2017 and 2021. The figure made up around 11.4 per cent of the total credit outstanding of the whole economy and 14.5 per cent of GDP last year.

“The market size of corporate bonds in Vietnam has increased by leaps and bounds in just a few short years,” Thai of SSI highlighted. “Clearly, Hanoi is not bluffing when it comes to establishing efficiency in both regulations and enforcement in the market. We see this bellwether change as a welcome pivot towards a more fair-play environment for raising capital, and to ultimately build more financially sustainable giants that can go toe to toe with its regional and international peers.”

Source: VIR


Fashion shows to spread quintessence of Vietnamese culture and heritage

The series is the brainchild of former supermodel Ha Vy and director Hoang Cong Cuong, who is the mastermind of several big events in Vietnam including the opening ceremony of the Southeast Asian Games (SEA Games) 31 in Hanoi in May.

Low-carbon rice production helps Vietnam meet emission target

Rice, which is Vietnam’s most important crop and grown on more than half of its agricultural land area, accounts for 48 per cent of the agriculture sector’s GHG emissions and over 75 per cent of methane emissions.


Number of air passengers down 14% in September

Vietnam needs highly skilled labour force to compete

The vocational training system of Vietnam needs reforming to create highly-skilled human resources that meet the requirements of the labour market in increasingly integrated international market, experts said.

Lengthy visa process a setback for FDI firms

The visa process does not always go smoothly. Sometimes, it moves so slowly that some specialists cannot enter Vietnam on schedule, leading to production disruptions.

Petrol and oil price stabilisation fund requires thorough appraisal

The Government needs to carefully evaluate the effectiveness of the petrol and oil price stabilisation fund in keeping the commodity’s retail prices stable before deciding to maintain or eliminate the tool, experts said.

Embedded finance the next big thing: summit

Embedded finance is the next big thing in the financial services industry as it has integrated seamlessly into the local fintech landscape in recent years, experts said at a meeting last Friday in HCM City.

Entertainment and cultural events of the week (September 26-October 2)

Upcoming entertainment and cultural events in Vietnam's major cities on September 26-October 2.


PM orders urgent measures against Storm Noru

Beauties wow in traditional costume contest at Miss Grand Vietnam

Vietnamese beauties boasted of their charm in a traditional costume segment of the ongoing Miss Grand Vietnam 2022 taking place on September 23.

State Bank’ rate hike necessary to defend VND, control inflation: ADB Country Director

ADB Country Director Andrew Jeffries has talked on the recent interest rate hike by the State Bank of Vietnam in the context of the Fed, ECB and a number of countries raising their rates to curb inflation.

Prop-tech has potential but faces challenges

Many prop-tech startups are facing challenges, though it is a new market with potential in Vietnam.

Prime Minister asked to stabilise rice price

India's restriction on rice exports is said to have an impact on the volume and price of Vietnamese rice exports.

Vietnamese artworks to go under the hammer in France

The auction’s highlight is Les Rapides de Cho Bo, a six-panel lacquer screen with gold highlights, painted in 1942 by Le Quoc Loc. The artwork is estimated to fetch €400,000 ($396,000), the highest price of the lot.

A pearl in mountainous province

Referred to as the “Halong Bay of the northwest region”, Nong Dung Lake has recently been attracting tourists as an ecotourism destination due to its emerald water and poetic scenery.