VietNamNet Bridge – A newly effective bill, government Decree No.59/2017 on the management of access to genetic resources and the sharing of their benefits (issued on May 12, 2017), was expected to protect the country’s rich genetic resources.

A rare primate being cared for at the Endangered Primate Rescue Centre of the Cuc Phuong National Park in northern province of Ninh Binh. — Photo: VNA/VNS

In 1992, the World Conservation Monitoring Centre ranked Viet Nam the 16th most biologically diverse country in the world, while the World Bank said “the entire country is included within Conservation International’s Indo-Burma hotspot, one of the earth’s richest and most threatened biological regions.”

Nguyen Dang Thu Cuc, head of the Division of Genetic Resources and Biosafety Management, under the Viet Nam Environment Bureau, said machinery and human capacity in the country remain limited, therefore genetic samples are usually sent abroad for analysis, and “this is a notable source of loss of genetic resources.”

She cited the recent case of an American university’s 2016 finding what they claimed to be an “anti-cancer” agent in Cuc Phuong National Park during various trips held with Viet Nam’s institutions in the 1990s.

“This is a lucky case, as they credited the source of the agent, whereas there are several other cases, where previously lax legal provisions allowed unscrupulous foreign parties to ‘steal’ genetic resources discovered in Viet Nam to claim as their own, and make profit from it, is that fair?,” Cuc said, during a workshop on Decree 59 yesterday in Ha Noi.

The decree, years in the making, aims to remedy this situation by providing a “tighter protocol in granting access to national genetic resources to a foreign entity.”

The creators of the decree admitted that this is Viet Nam’s first legal document that addresses in detail the country’s compliance to the 2010 Nagoya Protocol on the use of genetic resources, so there might be issues translating the document to reality.

These issues can be addressed in later revisions “as soon as every two years, instead of the usual five-year-window” from experience gained in the implementation period, said Nguyen Van Tai, head of the Viet Nam Environment Administration.

Ass Prof Dr Le Van Hung, from the Environment Department of the Ha Noi-based University of Natural Resources and Environment, said that the current term requiring that 30 per cent of monetary benefits gained from using genetic resources from a provider shall be paid back to the provider is too high.

Hung said the international standard of 0.5 – 3 per cent is appropriate, as long as a solid valuation mechanism is in place, since “in many cases, only much later after the genetic sample was collected, could it be utilised in a commercial product.”

Other participants also voiced concerns over administrative paperwork, however, lawmakers responded that follow-up guiding documents would “iron out the wrinkles”, including an expedited mechanism for academic institutions working with international parties.

A civil society representative said attention should also be focused on the community aspect, namely “folk wisdom.”

The representative cited the example of traditional medicine made from local herbs by ethnic groups in the northern mountainous province of Ha Giang, saying if a pharmaceutical firm wants to commercialise such products, measures should be in place to help the community "strike a fair deal with those companies."

Decree 59 defines the Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment as the “national focal point” for the implementation of the Nagoya Protocol. Together with the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development, the two have the power to “grant, extend, or revoke access licences to genetic resources.”

VNS