return icon

Origin fraud threatens local exporters

After a local silk importer was recently found to be disguising Chinese products as Vietnamese to sell them in India, experts have warned of the risks of losing out on exports and preferential tariffs due to intellectual property (IP) violations.



The Department of Post-Customs Clearance Inspection from the General Department of Customs revealed that it had recently discovered a company in HCM City using its certificate of origin (C/O) to pass off Chinese silk products as Vietnamese and export them to India.

Customs officials said the firm imported finished silk from China to Cat Lai Port in HCM City, then labelled them as 'Made in Vietnam' in a local warehouse.

Customs officials deemed the move tax evasion as silk exported from Vietnam to India are only taxed at 5 per cent, while products shipped from China have a tax rate five times higher.

Each year India imports from 2,200 to 2,500 tonnes of silk from China with a value of US$750 million to $800 million. According to an India market insider, the Indian Khadi and Village Industries Commission (KVIC), the Karnataka State government and the Silk Association of India (SAI) recommended banning silk imports from China to support domestic producers, which should help Vietnamese silk enterprises gain a stronger foothold in the Indian market.

However, the insider told a Vietnamese newspaper: “Such a case has swept the hope further away.”

“It is also a sign that some Chinese silk exporters have taken advantage of the lower tax position of Vietnam to export their products,” he added.

Deputy director of the Trade Remedies Authority of Vietnam under the Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) said: “If Vietnam does not take active measures to deal with the problem of evading trade remedies, especially through origin fraud, those activities will affect businesses and industries first. In the long run, it will have a negative impact on the competitiveness of the whole economy, especially in the context of joining a series of high-demand free trade agreements (FTAs)."

The problem doesn't lie with silk products alone and from the beginning of the year, customs officials have uncovered at least 77 cases where they discovered 24 violations of origin in exporting. Customs said bicycles, solar batteries and wooden items accounted for the majority of cases.

The trade remedies authority said origin frauds have a great impact on trade defence lawsuits. In the first eight months of 2020, Vietnamese exporters faced 27 investigations for fraud of origin, greater than the figure for the entire of 2019.

Nguyen Thuy Duong, a lawyer from the Hanoi Law University said: “The risk of evading trade remedies and origin fraud has been increasing, especially in the context of the escalating US-China trade conflict and Viet Nam participates in many new FTAs such as the comprehensive and progressive Trans-Pacific Partnership Trade Agreement (CPTPP) or the Europe-Vietnam Free Trade Agreement (EVFTA).”

To make matters worse, regulations for dealing with origin fraud and illegal transhipment are not very strong. For example, the firm that evaded tax when exporting the Chinese silk only faced an administrative sanction of VND60 million ($2,588) and another VND550 million of illegal profit (it is the profit they gained from the Chinese exporter) for the trading.

Lawyer Duong said when origin fraud helps violators enjoy tax incentives, countries suffer losses in tax revenues, affecting domestic industries and reducing the benefits of joining FTAs.

“If there is a suspicion of fraud or inaccuracy of the C / O issuance, in the CPTPP for example, if the importing country discovers a series of similar acts by the exporter or the manufacturer regarding fraud or counterfeiting of goods to enjoy preferential tax, they may decide to stop granting tax incentives for similar goods until it is proven those goods meet preferential conditions," he added

To deal with the problem, Nguyen Cam Trang, deputy head of the Import-Export Department, MoIT said: “Together with more investigations and checking products and export activities, we are educating and providing information to local enterprises, warning them not to join hand with foreign exporters (to commit fraud).”

Recently, the Trade Remedies Authority built an early warning system for many industries and products at risk of being sued for trade remedies.

The customs officials considered it necessary to add regulations on calculating illegal profits for local firms which outsource some of the work to help foreign exporters take advantage of tax incentives.

Customs also said the MoIT needed to have specific guidance documents on all relating C/O activities for products with labels 'Made in Vietnam' so that they could investigate fraud more easily.  VNS

Vietnam Customs Agency vows to combat origin fraud

Vietnam Customs Agency vows to combat origin fraud

The Prime Minister has given instructions to fight against origin fraud and illegal transshipment to protect brands and the prestige of Vietnamese goods.

Vietnam takes serious measures to block exports with origin fraud

Vietnam takes serious measures to block exports with origin fraud

Amid the US-China trade war, the US is paying higher notice to Vietnamese products. As a result, enterprises have had to change business practices to adapt to new circumstances.


Vietnam to attend ASEAN Tourism Forum 2023 in Indonesia

Vietnam will participate in ASEAN Tourism Forum (ATF) 2023 themed “ASEAN: A Journey to Wonderful Destinations”, and the Travel Exchange (TRAVEX) trade fair in Yogyakarta, Indonesia from February 2 – 5.

Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City among safest cities in Southeast Asia

Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City have both been included in a list of the safest cities in Southeast Asia, as compiled by statistics site Numbeo.

Action plan issued to accelerate national anti-corruption strategy building

Deputy Prime Minister Le Minh Khai, head of the steering committee on building the national anti-corruption strategy by 2030, has signed a decision on the issuance of the committee’s action plan.


Latest guidance on one-way money transfers from Viet Nam

HCM City proposes removing hindrances to develop real estate market

Ho Chi Minh City authorities made a proposal to clear bottlenecks for healthy and sustainable development of the real estate market.

More high-value foreign investment projects needed as tax policies change

Vietnam needs to improve FDI quality, attracting high-tech projects that promise to bring higher added value.

Khmer's ginger cake of love and faithfulness

The ginger cake of the Khmer ethnic group in Soc Trang Province is a beloved traditional treat that is often offered to ancestors on important anniversaries such as the Tet (Lunar New Year) festival.

HCM City promotes digital transformation in education

Digital transformation is considered key to improving education and training quality, as proven by the effect of HCM City actively applying digital transformation over the past five years.

Hanoi to close fruit shops lacking proper food safety preparations

The capital city of Hanoi encourages the expansion of safe fruit businesses while clamping down on fruit shops that do not comply with food safety protocols, specifically street vendors.

Dutch diplomat donates Vietnamese paintings to national museum

Vietnam National Fine Arts Museum has received two paintings from former deputy ambassador Ellen Berends of the Netherlands to Vietnam.

Hanoi's unique rice cooking contest in photos

On the 8th day of the first lunar month each year (January 29, 2023), Thi Cam village in Hanoi’s Nam Tu Liem district holds a rice cooking contest.

Hanoi proceeds with park revitalization program

The implementation of Hanoi leaders’ promise to revive parks has begun: admission to Thong Nhat Park is now free after the removal of the fence, and Con Coc Flower Garden has a new look. However, there are still many things that need to be done.

Vietnamese farmers on board the ‘digital agriculture train’

In the digital era, next-generation farmers can fertilize and water their fields in Binh Phuoc from afar, even in a different country.

Vietnam forecast to become second-largest economy in Southeast Asia by 2036

2023 is predicted to be the year of many challenges for the Vietnamese economy due to the gloomy outlook of the global economy and multiple crises.

Prenn Pass leading to Dalat to be closed for expansion

Vehicles will be banned from using the seven-kilometer-long Prenn Pass to travel to Dalat City as work on the pass upgrade and widening project begins on February 6.