Canada court rules US 'not safe' for asylum seekers

The US violates the human rights of asylum seekers by imprisoning them, a Canadian judge rules.

Canada's federal court has ruled that an asylum agreement the country has with the US is invalid because America violates the human rights of refugees.

The Safe Third Country Agreement (STCA), in place since 2004, requires refugee claimants to request protection in the first safe country they reach.

But on Wednesday, a judge declared the deal unconstitutional due to the chance that the US will imprison the migrants.

The ruling marks a major victory for Canadian immigration activists.

Lawyers for refugees who had been turned away at the Canadian border had challenged the agreement, arguing that the US did not qualify as "safe" for asylum seekers.

Nedira Jemal Mustefa, one of the refugees forced to remain in the US, told the court her time in US solitary confinement was "a terrifying, isolating and psychologically traumatic experience," according to the court ruling.

"We're all too familiar with the treatment that the US metes out to asylum seekers," Maureen Silcoff, president of the Canadian Association of Refugee Lawyers, told Reuters news agency.

The 5,525 mile (8,891 km) US-Canada border is the longest border between two countries in the world.

What is the Safe Third Country Agreement?

 

The Safe Third Country Agreement is a policy implemented to better manage refugee claims and to avoid so-called "asylum shopping" between countries.

But it is also driving asylum seekers to make what the Canadian government calls "irregular" crossings to avoid being turned back at official border points.Since 2017, when President Donald Trump took office promising a crackdown on immigration, some 58,000 people have crossed into Canada from the US in that manner to make subsequent refugee claims.

Canada had been processing their claims until the coronavirus pandemic, when the Canadian government said they would be turned back.

There have been calls in Canada to suspend or renegotiate the agreement with the US.

What did the judge say?

Federal court judge Ann Marie McDonald ruled that the deal was in violation of a section of Canada's Charter of Rights that bans the government from interfering in the right to life, liberty and security.

"It is my conclusion, based upon the evidence, that ineligible STCA claimants are returned to the US by Canadian officials where they are immediately and automatically imprisoned by US authorities," Judge McDonald said in her ruling.

"I have concluded that imprisonment and the attendant consequences are inconsistent with the spirit and objective of the STCA and are a violation of the rights guaranteed by section 7 of the [Charter of Rights and Freedoms]," she continued.

But the judge delayed the ruling for six months to allow Canada's parliament and the US Congress to respond. The ruling can also be appealed.

US immigration authorities not have yet to comment on the ruling. BBC

 
 

Other News

.
People aged 18 and older must receive two full jabs of COVID vaccines by late Dec: PM
People aged 18 and older must receive two full jabs of COVID vaccines by late Dec: PM
POLITICSicon  11/12/2021 

PM Pham Minh Chinh has underlined the necessity of providing two injections for people over 18 years old, as well as a third jab for those who need to be vaccinated against COVID-19 no later than December 31.

Vaccine passport to be issued soon: spokeswoman
Vaccine passport to be issued soon: spokeswoman
FEATUREicon  10/12/2021 

Authorities are urgently completing software to be used to issue vaccine passports forms that meet international standards, according to Ministry of Foreign Affairs spokeswoman Le Thi Thu Hang.

Vietnam responds to US-ASEAN summit rumours, not being invited to the US-led Summit for Democracy
Vietnam responds to US-ASEAN summit rumours, not being invited to the US-led Summit for Democracy
POLITICSicon  10/12/2021 

Vietnam’s policy is to build “a Socialist democracy in tandem with upholding people’s rights to democracy in all aspects of their social life.”

Nearly 200,000 Vietnamese citizens flown home from abroad: spokeswoman
Nearly 200,000 Vietnamese citizens flown home from abroad: spokeswoman
POLITICSicon  10/12/2021 

Vietnamese authorities and representative agencies abroad have worked closely with domestic and foreign airlines to conduct over 800 flights carrying home nearly 200,000 Vietnamese citizens from over 60 countries and territories.

Lawmakers agree to issue Resolution on policies, mechanisms for COVID-19 fight
Lawmakers agree to issue Resolution on policies, mechanisms for COVID-19 fight
POLITICSicon  09/12/2021 

The National Assembly Standing Committee offered opinions on the adoption of health care policies and mechanisms in the fight against COVID-19 pandemic during a meeting in Hanoi on December 8.

Automatic stay extension for foreigners stranded due to COVID-19
Automatic stay extension for foreigners stranded due to COVID-19
POLITICSicon  09/12/2021 

The Department of Immigration has issued a notice on automatic extension of stay for foreigners stranded due to COVID-19.

Sovereignty over cyberspace an important part of national sovereignty: official
Sovereignty over cyberspace an important part of national sovereignty: official
POLITICSicon  09/12/2021 

Ensuring sovereignty in cyberspace helps to protect national sovereignty, said head of the Party Central Committee's Commission for Information and Education Nguyen Trong Nghia.

Vietnam urges enhanced awareness, enforcement of UNCLOS
Vietnam urges enhanced awareness, enforcement of UNCLOS
POLITICSicon  09/12/2021 

Vietnam called for promoting the awareness and enforcement of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) while attending a plenary meeting at the UN General Assembly’s 76th session on December 7.

Vietnam, New Zealand sign action programme to promote strategic partnership
Vietnam, New Zealand sign action programme to promote strategic partnership
POLITICSicon  09/12/2021 

Vietnam and New Zealand on December 8 signed the Vietnam - New Zealand Action Program for the 2021-2024 period through an online platform, with a view to carrying out the strategic partnership between the two nations.

Urgent issues expected to be submitted to NA’s extraordinary session
Urgent issues expected to be submitted to NA’s extraordinary session
POLITICSicon  08/12/2021 

The 15th National Assembly (NA) will consider a range of important issues that will be submitted to the legislature by the Government for consideration and decision at the next extraordinary meeting scheduled to take place in the coming time.

Party Chief highlights traditional friendship with Laos
Party Chief highlights traditional friendship with Laos
POLITICSicon  08/12/2021 

General Secretary of the Communist Party of Vietnam Nguyen Phu Trong met Chairman of the Lao National Assembly Xaysomphone Phomvihane in Hanoi on Tuesday.

WHO hails Vietnam’s willingness to share technologies in COVID-19 fight
WHO hails Vietnam’s willingness to share technologies in COVID-19 fight
POLITICSicon  08/12/2021 

The World Health Organisation (WHO) has highly valued Vietnam’s innovation spirit and willingness to share COVID-19 prevention and control technologies.

Vietnam's top leaders welcome Lao National Assembly President
Vietnam's top leaders welcome Lao National Assembly President
POLITICSicon  07/12/2021 

President Nguyen Xuan Phuc affirmed Vietnam’s consistent policy of prioritising and developing special solidarity with Laos while receiving President of the Lao National Assembly Saysomphone Phomvihane in Hanoi on Monday.

NA Chairman: fiscal policy plays leading role in harmonization with monetary policy
NA Chairman: fiscal policy plays leading role in harmonization with monetary policy
FEATUREicon  07/12/2021 

National Assembly Chair Vuong Dinh Hue has asked commercial banks to share difficulties with businesses, stressing that such support will also help themselves and that banks cannot have profits without businesses.

Government urged to launch economic stimulus package
Government urged to launch economic stimulus package
FEATUREicon  06/12/2021 

National Assembly deputies have recommended that the Government design an economic stimulus package, but both the Government and the National Assembly have yet to discuss the topic.

Why has Da Nang taken the lead in digital transformation?
Why has Da Nang taken the lead in digital transformation?
FEATUREicon  06/12/2021 

Since 2010, Da Nang has identified information and communication technology as one of the three strategic breakthroughs in socio-economic development.

No one must be left without food or clothes after floods: PM
No one must be left without food or clothes after floods: PM
POLITICSicon  05/12/2021 

Efforts must be exerted so nobody is left without food, clothes or shelter after the recent floods, Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh ordered on December 5.

Vietnamese President's Russia visit impressive: Russian legislator
Vietnamese President's Russia visit impressive: Russian legislator
POLITICSicon  05/12/2021 

Andrey Vladimirovich Yatskin, First Deputy Chairman of the Council of Federation (upper house) of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation. said that the Vietnam-Russia relationship is experiencing a period of strong growth.

President's visits to Switzerland, Russia produce fruitful outcomes: Deputy FM
President's visits to Switzerland, Russia produce fruitful outcomes: Deputy FM
POLITICSicon  04/12/2021 

President Nguyen Xuan Phuc's visits to Switzerland and Russia were a success with specific outcomes, Deputy Foreign Minister To Anh Dung said in an interview granted to the press following the visits.

NA Chairman chairs meeting on special policies in COVID-19 fight
NA Chairman chairs meeting on special policies in COVID-19 fight
POLITICSicon  04/12/2021 

National Assembly Chairman Vuong Dinh Hue chaired a meeting on December 3 to discuss the Government’s proposal on several special mechanisms and policies in the fight against COVID-19.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN