Google ordered to reveal author of Australian dentist's bad review

The Australian court ruling forces the US firm to hand over details about the anonymous poster.

Google ordered to reveal author of Australian dentist's bad review
The ruling forces Google to reveal the reviewer's personal details

An Australian court has ordered Google to identify the person behind an anonymous bad review of a dentist.

Dr Matthew Kabbabe, a teeth-whitening specialist in Melbourne, sought the order so he could sue for defamation.

He claimed user CBsm 23 had damaged his business by telling others to "STAY AWAY" from a procedure criticised as "extremely awkward and uncomfortable".

The ruling forces the hand of the tech giant, which has previously defended allowing negative reviews on its site.

Under the order, Google will be required to pass to Dr Kabbabe any personal details such as any names, phone numbers, location metadata and IP addresses linked to the account. 

International law allows for people to seek documents from overseas parties that they need for their case.

 

'Groundbreaking' case

Google had previously rejected the dentist's requests for the review to be removed, or to share information about its author.

According to his affidavit, Google had told Dr Kabbabe: "[W]e do not have any means to investigate where and when the ID was created."

However, Justice Bernard Murphy ruled that Dr Kabbabe had grounds to pursue a defamation case and that Google was "likely to have or have had control of a document or thing that would help ascertain that description of the prospective respondent".

Mr Kabbabe's lawyer described the ruling as a "groundbreaking" win for small businesses, and argued Google had a duty of care in providing a platform for potentially defamatory postings.

"If you're out there trying to hide by anonymity, even via VPN, I think the court system's catching up now and there are ways and means of obtaining that information," Mark Stanarevic told the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.

Google is yet to reply to queries about the ruling. The firm has previously been reluctant to remove bad reviews, but has done so in several instances following court orders.

Last year, it told Australian law reform experts that defamation cases over online reviews could lead to the suppression of consumer rights and free speech. BBC

 
 

Other News

.
Quang Binh man hands over rare monkey to national park
Quang Binh man hands over rare monkey to national park
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  14/02/2020 

A stump-tailed macaque, a rare and precious animal, was handed over voluntarily by a local resident to the Phong Nha-Ke Bang National Park Management Board in central Quang Binh Province on Thursday.

MWC 2020: Smartphone showcase cancelled over coronavirus fears
MWC 2020: Smartphone showcase cancelled over coronavirus fears
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  14/02/2020 

The world's largest mobile industry showcase will not go ahead, organisers confirm.

Vietnamese scientists actively share information about nCoV
Vietnamese scientists actively share information about nCoV
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  14/02/2020 

The measures Vietnam is taking to cope with the nCoV epidemic are based on the experience and scientific research results that have been accumulated for many years, since the time it faced SARS epidemic in 2002-2003.

Thousands to attend ITU Digital World 2020 in Hanoi
Thousands to attend ITU Digital World 2020 in Hanoi
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  14/02/2020 

Thousands of delegates from telecoms and IT firms and State management agencies from more than 100 countries and territories worldwide will attend ITU Digital World 2020 (DW20), slated for September 6-9 in Hanoi.

WWF-Vietnam, GreenViet work to protect endangered primates
WWF-Vietnam, GreenViet work to protect endangered primates
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/02/2020 

The World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF)-Vietnam and the Centre of Biodiversity Conservation, GreenViet, will work together on a project to protect the gray-shanked douc langurs in the central province’s Nui Thanh District in 2020.

Car-sized turtle fossils unearthed
Car-sized turtle fossils unearthed
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/02/2020 

The turtle is believed to have lived in northern South America between 13 and seven million years ago.

First cloned cows in VN expected this year
First cloned cows in VN expected this year
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  14/02/2020 

The first cloned cows in Vietnam are expected this year under a project implemented by Prof Nguyen Van Thuan and his co-workers.

Survey finds public lacks knowledge about pollution levels
Survey finds public lacks knowledge about pollution levels
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/02/2020 

Contrary to the perception that the community ‘is shouting for help’, many people are not complaining much about pollution, while business households are indifferent to the problem.

Second round of Aus4Innovation Partnership Grants launched
Second round of Aus4Innovation Partnership Grants launched
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  12/02/2020 

The second and final round of the Aus4Innovation Partnership Grants kicked off on February 11, with total financial support of 2.32 million AUD available.

Australia fires: New South Wales blazes all 'contained'
Australia fires: New South Wales blazes all 'contained'
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  13/02/2020 

Australian fire officials call it "great news" after "a very traumatic, exhausting and anxious" time.

Australia fires: 113 animal species 'need emergency help'
Australia fires: 113 animal species 'need emergency help'
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  12/02/2020 

Koalas along with birds, fish and frogs need the most help after Australia's fires, says a report.

Professor takes new approach at Harvard's Vietnamese language program
Professor takes new approach at Harvard's Vietnamese language program
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  12/02/2020 

Prof Ngo Nhu Binh is the first person to teach Vietnamese language at Harvard University in a methodical way.

Viettel, Vingroup to pioneer manufacture of 5G devices
Viettel, Vingroup to pioneer manufacture of 5G devices
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  12/02/2020 

Vietnam is not only a pioneer in experimenting with 5G, but also aims to be a manufacturer of 5G telecom devices that could be launched on the market as early as this year.

HCM City to check motorcycle emissions
HCM City to check motorcycle emissions
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  12/02/2020 

HCM City authorities have approved a programme to check exhaust emissions from motorcycles that use public roads in the city.

Startup CricketOne pursues sustainable food concept
Startup CricketOne pursues sustainable food concept
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  11/02/2020 

CricketOne, a startup supplying food ingredients extracted from crickets, was recently named the winner of a competition for social startups called Blue Venture Awards.

China launches coronavirus 'close contact detector' app
China launches coronavirus 'close contact detector' app
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  11/02/2020 

The announcement highlights the high level of Chinese government surveillance of its citizens.

Vietnamese per capita plastic usage was 41 kilos in 2019
Vietnamese per capita plastic usage was 41 kilos in 2019
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  12/02/2020 

Vietnam discharges 0.28-0.73 million tons of plastic waste to the ocean each year, or 6 percent of the world’s total figure, ranking fourth among the countries polluting the ocean the most, a study shows.

Hue fisherman cleans up the ocean
Hue fisherman cleans up the ocean
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  11/02/2020 

The image of a young man with a boat full of garbage collected from the ocean has become familiar to people in Phu Vang District of central Thua Thien-Hue Province.

Vietnam works with developed countries to deploy 5G
Vietnam works with developed countries to deploy 5G
SCI-TECH & ENVIRONMENTicon  11/02/2020 

Both Viettel and Vingroup have stated they will commercialize 5G telecom devices by 2020.

Vietnam announces 70-min rapid test kit for new coronavirus
Vietnam announces 70-min rapid test kit for new coronavirus
FEATUREicon  10/02/2020 

Good news has come as Vietnamese scientists have successfully created a toolkit to quickly detect the 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) within just 70 minutes, instead of the three hours needed for other usual test methods.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN