Government social protection policy falls short: survey

The Government's social protection support policy has struggled to prevent vulnerable people from falling into poverty and to protect those already poor from descending deeper into poverty due to COVID-19 pandemic, a survey has found.

Government social protection policy falls short: survey
A fruit vendor in Hanoi. COVID-19 pandemic and its negative impacts make informal workers like her face more difficulties to make a living. — VNA/VNS Photo Thanh Tung

The survey was run by the United Nations Development Programme, UN Women and the Centre for Analysis and Forecast under the Vietnam Academy of Social Sciences (CAF/VASS) to assess the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic on vulnerable households, especially those of ethnic minorities and internal migrant and informal workers. 

The telephone survey conducted in April and May this year got responses from 930 vulnerable households and 935 household businesses, micro small and medium-sized enterprises in 58 out of 63 provinces across Vietnam.

The survey's findings were included in the report 'COVID-19 Socio-economic Impact on Vulnerable households and Enterprises: a gender-sensitive assessment' that was released last week.

Under Vietnam’s social protection support packages targeting vulnerable groups, financial support was given to people for three months from April to June.

Regular social assistance beneficiaries and people who contributed to the nation including veterans were eligible for VND500,000/person per month; poor and near-poor people VND250,000/person per month, workers with temporarily suspended labour contracts without salaries VND1.8 million/person per month; informal workers who lost their jobs without labour contracts and who lacked social insurance VND1 million/person per month; and affected household businesses with annual revenue less than VND100 million VND1 million/month.  

According to the Ministry of Labour, Invalid and Social Affairs, by June 18, the cash transfers have been made to 98.7 per cent of regular social assistance beneficiaries, 109.8 per cent of those who contributed to the nation (more were found eligible than the initial estimate) and 72.1 per cent of poor and near-poor households.

In sharp contrast, only 1.14 per cent of eligible workers with temporarily suspended labour contracts received support. Just 0.24 per cent of workers who had their contracts terminated and were not eligible for unemployment insurance benefits were aided, with the figure being 0.6 per cent among workers without labour contracts and social insurance that lost their jobs.

As for household businesses with annual revenues of less than VND100 million that suspended operations due to the pandemic, just 1.28 per cent got the cash.

“If the Government’s social protection package was delivered on time, for example, if monthly cash transfers were made in April and May and reached all the originally intended groups, the national income poverty rate could have been as little as 17.2 per cent and 9.9 per cent instead of 26.7 per cent and 15.8 per cent if no cash transfers were made in the two months,” said Director of CAF/VASS Nguyen Thang.

The report shows COVID-19 has caused income to decline substantially across vulnerable households and workers, resulting in a surge in transient income poverty and pushing chronically poor households further into income poverty.

The highest decline in household income due to COVID-19 was recorded in April, with the average income of surveyed households in the month only 29.7 per cent of the December 2019 level. The figure increased to 51.1 per cent in May.

The average income of surveyed households declined by more than 70 per cent in April and 49 per cent in May, compared to December 2019.

“Transient poverty was a challenge for poverty-targeting of social protection support to lessen the negative impacts of the pandemic,” Thang said.

“The rapid change in the poverty situation resulted in the social protection support package missing many households and people that became poor and near-poor since the pandemic's outbreak, notably the vulnerable (lower middle income) households in rural areas,” he added.

The report also identified several groups left out of or under-served by the Government social protection support package, both by policy design and implementation. 

For examples, families of young workers, especially those with small children, single mothers and/or single bread-winners, those without savings and with house rent burdens, families with members suffering from serious illnesses and under treatment in specialised hospitals, with people with disabilities and the elderly.

These families by design were not eligible for the social protection package even though many of them lost jobs and income and became poor/near-poor. 

 

Complex rules and procedures in identifying and verifying eligibility prevented several groups from accessing the package. 

These groups include formal workers that lost jobs or had their hours or wages cut but were not eligible for unemployment insurance benefits, informal workers that lost their job or experienced income reductions and affected enterprises that had insufficient resources to pay their workers. 

People also found barriers to accessing Government support, such as the requirements for applications for support for laid-off workers to be submitted by their employer, or applications for support for internal migrant workers to be certified at both the original and destination places of migrant workers.

Caitlin Wiesen, Resident Representative of UNDP in Vietnam, said the actions of the Government of Vietnam and the innovation of the Vietnamese people had been key to Vietnam’s initial success in containing the COVID-19 pandemic and in limiting its negative socio-economic impacts. 

“I believe that similar anticipatory approaches and innovations will play a critical role in helping Vietnamese enterprises and people achieve a bold, sustainable, resilient and gender-sensitive recovery”, she said.

Elisa Fernandez, UN Women Vietnam Head of Office, said the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic were not equal among different groups of people, nor between women and men. 

“COVID-19 may be more lethal for men, but the socio-economic impacts of the pandemic are hitting women the hardest and exacerbating existing social and economic inequalities.

"A recent study by McKinsey shows that at the global level, women’s jobs are 1.8 times more vulnerable to this crisis than men’s jobs.

"Women make up 39 per cent of global employment but account for 54 per cent of overall job losses”, Fernandez said.

“If gender differences in the economic impacts COVID-19, including the burden of care and risk of gender-based violence, are not addressed adequately, it could have a serious impact on women's ability to fully participate in the economy in the longer term. 

“Gender-responsive recovery measures should include strengthening childcare support and respond services, enable women’s access to new sources of employment, reskilling opportunities, and access to credit for women-lead business”, Fernandez said.

Thang from CAF said a top priority was to assist people and communities vulnerable to extreme poverty because of the pandemic.

“The impact of lost employment and earnings is felt most deeply by the poor. Government action should help those people who have the smallest margin of safety, for whom the loss of income for a few months is catastrophic,” he said.

He emphasised the need to speed up public work programmes that would help generate jobs and incomes as well as cash transfers to protect the livelihood of vulnerable people and boost domestic demand.

He also suggested expanding regular social assistance - cash transfer - targeting categories such as people with disabilities and their carer, children under 6 and elderly aged from 60 to 79, pregnant women or considering the expansion to single-parents working in informal sectors.

A residence-based system of social protection, which excludes internal migrant workers, should be changed to the one based on national citizenship, for example through the digitalisation of registration and verification of eligibility to the application of digital payment tools.  VNS

Covid-19 plunges Vietnam’s ethnic minority households into poverty: UNDP

Covid-19 plunges Vietnam’s ethnic minority households into poverty: UNDP

The coronavirus pandemic has had a disproportionate impact on vulnerable households in Vietnam, especially those belonging to ethnic minority people, migrant and informal workers, 

Many households see income fall of 70% due to Covid-19

Many households see income fall of 70% due to Covid-19

Many households in Vietnam have experienced an income drop of up to 70% due to the Covid-19 pandemic, according to a survey carried out in 53 cities and provinces nationwide.  

  • Tags :
 
 

Other News

.
The Coast Guard provides medical examination to Catholics in Loc Ha District
The Coast Guard provides medical examination to Catholics in Loc Ha District
SOCIETYicon  28/06/2020 

In the Cua Sot area, the Coast Guard collaborated with the Northern Association of Young Physicians, Hapro Hanoi and other units to organize medical examination, consultation, provide free medicine, and donate 500 kg of rice to local residents.

The High Command of Coast Guard Region 3 provides information on the country’s sea and island situation
The High Command of Coast Guard Region 3 provides information on the country’s sea and island situation
SOCIETYicon  28/06/2020 

Information on Vietnam’s sea and island situation in 2020 has been provided to 340 officials and members of the Party Committees of Phuoc Buu town and Xuyen Moc commune by officials of the High Command of Coast Guard Region 3.

High Command of Coast Guard Region 3 promotes dissemination of law to local people
High Command of Coast Guard Region 3 promotes dissemination of law to local people
SOCIETYicon  30/06/2020 

The High Command of Coast Guard Region 3 cooperated with the Propaganda Department of Xuyen Moc District Party Committee to organize a meeting 

The High Command of Coast Guard Region 3 hands over antiquities to local museum
The High Command of Coast Guard Region 3 hands over antiquities to local museum
SOCIETYicon  15/05/2020 

The High Command of Coast Guard Region 3 has just handed over the antiques illegally salvaged by fishing vessels to the Museum of Ba Ria - Vung Tau Province.

Coast Guard vessels perform the task of inspecting Vietnam - China fishing activities
Coast Guard vessels perform the task of inspecting Vietnam - China fishing activities
SOCIETYicon  23/04/2020 

During this joint inspection, the Coast Guard forces of the two countries will conduct the inspection and supervision of the implementation of the Fisheries Cooperation Agreement at 9 points in the Gulf of Tonkin’s common fishing area.

50 students from Nhat Quang Secondary School participate in “I love my country’s sea, island” contest
50 students from Nhat Quang Secondary School participate in “I love my country’s sea, island” contest
SOCIETYicon  31/05/2020 

The High Command of the Coast Guard held the contest “I love my country’s sea, island” in Nhat Quang commune, Phu Cu district, Hung Yen province on May 30.

Regulations on equipment, funding and facilities for the Vietnam Coast Guard
Regulations on equipment, funding and facilities for the Vietnam Coast Guard
SOCIETYicon  20/03/2020 

The Law on Vietnam Coast Guard, took effect on July 1, 2019, is a law of special importance, specifying the activities of the Vietnam Coast Guard.

The Coast Guard organizes "I love my country’s sea and islands" contest in Gia Vien
The Coast Guard organizes "I love my country’s sea and islands" contest in Gia Vien
SOCIETYicon  27/06/2020 

This morning, June 27, the High Command of the Coast Guard coordinated with the People's Committee of Gia Vien district, Ninh Binh province to hold the contest "I love my country’s sea and islands".

Seriously implement the Law on Vietnam Coast Guard
Seriously implement the Law on Vietnam Coast Guard
SOCIETYicon  02/03/2020 

The High Command of the Coast Guard has deployed the development of a project to propagate and disseminate the Vietnam Coast Guard Law in the period of 2019 - 2022.

Coordination to ensure technical conditions for the Coast Guard
Coordination to ensure technical conditions for the Coast Guard
SOCIETYicon  01/03/2020 

The coordination regulation to ensure technology for the Coast Guard will help the Coast Guard fulfill the task of protecting sovereignty over the sea and islands in all situations.

Ensuring implementation progress of the Coast Guard construction scheme to 2020 and the following years
Ensuring implementation progress of the Coast Guard construction scheme to 2020 and the following years
SOCIETYicon  01/03/2020 

Projects under the scheme to build the Vietnam Coast Guard until 2020 and the following years are being implemented at the right pace to ensure proper progress and quality.

Checking combat readiness work at the High Command of Coast Guard Region 1
Checking combat readiness work at the High Command of Coast Guard Region 1
SOCIETYicon  07/05/2020 

The mission of the General Staff led by Lieutenant General Nguyen Van Nghia - Deputy Chief of the General Staff of the Vietnam People's Army - has inspected the combat readiness work in 2020 at the High Command of Coast Guard Region 1.

The Coast Guard Region 2 completes 100% of the phase-I combat training plan in H1
The Coast Guard Region 2 completes 100% of the phase-I combat training plan in H1
SOCIETYicon  16/06/2020 

In the first 6 months of 2020, the High Command of the Coast Guard Region 2 completed 100 percent of the phase I combat training plan with high quality and efficiency.

The Coast Guard Region 3 performs well the tasks of protecting sovereignty, maintaining security and order in H1
The Coast Guard Region 3 performs well the tasks of protecting sovereignty, maintaining security and order in H1
SOCIETYicon  17/06/2020 

In the first 6 months of the year, the Coast Guard Region 3 deployed synchronous solutions, well performed the task of protecting sovereignty, maintaining security and safety at sea; 

Collecting comments on codification of the "Vietnam Coast Guard" subject
Collecting comments on codification of the "Vietnam Coast Guard" subject
SOCIETYicon  22/05/2020 

The web portal of the Ministry of Defense has just published the codification for the "Vietnam Coast Guard" subject for collecting comments.

The Coast Guard builds "Great unity" houses for fishermen
The Coast Guard builds "Great unity" houses for fishermen
SOCIETYicon  23/06/2020 

The High Command of Coast Guard Region 1 cooperated with the Quang Ninh Provincial Party Committee’s Public Affairs Department to start the construction of houses under the "Great unity" program for local fishermen in difficult circumstances.

The Coast Guard actively spreads love for the country’s sea and islands
The Coast Guard actively spreads love for the country’s sea and islands
SOCIETYicon  09/06/2020 

The contest "I love my country’s sea and islands" took place at Nhat Quang Secondary School (Phu Cu district, Hung Yen province) on May 30 attracted 50 students.

Drafting joint circular on coordination in arrest and custody of Coast Guard and Border Guards
Drafting joint circular on coordination in arrest and custody of Coast Guard and Border Guards
SOCIETYicon  12/06/2020 

A conference to discuss the development of a joint circular regulating the coordination in arrest and detention of the Coast Guard and Border Guards took place on June 12.

Two death sentences handed down in Dong Tam case
Two death sentences handed down in Dong Tam case
SOCIETYicon  15/09/2020 

Two death sentences and one life imprisonment have been handed down to those involved in the murder of three policemen in Dong Tam commune of Hanoi’s My Duc district earlier this year.

Vietnamese students are to enjoy full health insurance
Vietnamese students are to enjoy full health insurance
SOCIETYicon  15/09/2020 

Tran Dinh Lieu, Deputy General Director of Vietnam Social Security talks to the media revealing that almost 100 per cent of pupils and students have coverage under the National Health Insurance Fund.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN