Struggle for AO/dioxin victims in Vietnam endures

Significant attention has been paid to a hearing on January 25 for a trial brought by Vietnamese-French woman Tran To Nga against the US companies that provided the chemical toxins used by the US Army in the war in Vietnam.

Struggle for AO/dioxin victims in Vietnam endures hinh anh 1

The trial held in the Crown Court of Evry city (Photo: VNA)

At the trial, held in the Crown Court of Evry city in the suburbs of Paris, lawyers for the defendants spent more than four hours arguing for their clients, which are 17 chemical producers from the US, including Monsanto (acquired by the German group Bayer in 2018) and Dow Chemical, while Nga’s three lawyers had only one and a half hours.

Lawyers William Bourdon, Amelie Lefebvre, and Bertrand Repolt have stood side-by-side with Nga for more than 10 years.

In 2009, she testified for Agent Orange (AO)/dioxin victims in Vietnam at the International People’s Tribunal of Conscience, in Paris. In 2013, the Crown Court of Evry accepted her lawsuit and one year later she received notice of the first procedural hearing, with 19 US chemical companies to stand trial.

The public in France has described the trial as “historic”, through which Nga and the organisations supporting the lawsuit hope to promote international recognition of the “crime of environmental destruction”.

Lawyer Bourdon said the US chemical companies have used every possible means not to prevent this trial - since they can’t - but to argue that Nga’s activities are unacceptable and groundless.

The defendants’ representatives claimed that the Crown Court of Evry doesn’t have sufficient capacity to deal with the case.

Lawyer Jean-Daniel Bretzner of Monsanto said the companies “acted in line with State orders and in the name of that State” and are entitled to judicial immunity.

Bourdon stressed that these arguments are outdated, and that Nga’s lawyers are relatively confident, as the law has developed towards enhancing the responsibility of private entities, even when they declare they acted under pressure from an administration.

Struggle for AO/dioxin victims in Vietnam endures hinh anh 2

Tran To Nga (R) answers press agencies' questions on the sidelines of the trial (Photo: VNA)

Secretary-General of the France - Vietnam Friendship Association Jean-Pierre Archambault considers the January 25 hearing an important stride forward in the lawsuit Nga has pursued for more than six years to seek justice for Vietnamese AO/dioxin victims.

He categorised the arguments presented by the lawyers defending the US multinational companies as disgusting, noting they believe their actions followed US Government orders and, hence, they do not bear any responsibility for producing the dangerous herbicides that are still tormenting millions of victims in Vietnam even though the war ended decades ago. He also pledged support to the struggle by Nga.

Marie Toussaint, a Greens member of the European Parliament, expressed her discontent over the defendants’ lawyers providing incorrect arguments that Nga no longer has AO/dioxin in her blood.

 

The US companies tried everything possible to cast off their responsibility in AO production, Toussaint said, adding it is a historical fact that in war, atomic weapons destroyed not only land and people at the time but also severely impacted the following generations, and the same thing has happened with chemical toxins like AO/dioxin.

She affirmed that justice is needed to make peace, and no one has the right to produce hazardous chemicals that affect many generations, regardless of wartime or peacetime.

Voicing his support for Nga’s lawsuit, Mayor Jean-Marc Defremont of Savigny-sur-Orge city said the US chemical companies produced herbicides that seriously destroyed the environment in Vietnam but have yet to be subject to any punishment.

For her part, Nga said that although the court is scheduled to issue a verdict in May, for her, the struggle will continue.

“We will remain patient and persistent, as we have been for the last six years or more,” she affirmed.

Nga, born in 1942, filed the lawsuit in May 2014. With the support of several non-governmental organisations, she accused the companies of causing lasting harm to the health of herself, her children, and countless others, and of destroying the environment.

She graduated from a Hanoi university in 1966 and became a war correspondent of the former Liberation News Agency, part of the Vietnam News Agency. She worked in some of the most heavily AO/dioxin affected areas in southern Vietnam, such as Cu Chi, Ben Cat, and along the Ho Chi Minh Trail, ultimately experiencing contamination herself.

Of her three children, the first died of heart defects and the second suffers from a blood disease. She has also contracted a number of acute diseases

On April 16, 2015, the Crown Court of Evry city held the first hearing on the case, but since then, lawyers for the chemical companies have tried every way to draw out procedures.

The trial was scheduled to open in October 2020 but was postponed due to COVID-19./.VNA

French court to hold hearing on AO lawsuit

French court to hold hearing on AO lawsuit

A French court will open a hearing on a lawsuit filed by Vietnamese-French Tran Thi To Nga against 14 multinational companies for producing and selling chemical toxins that was sprayed by the US army in the war in Vietnam, 

Vietnamese AO lawsuit makes French headlines

Vietnamese AO lawsuit makes French headlines

French newspapers have been reporting on a lawsuit filed by Vietnamese-French national Tran Thi To Nga against 14 multinational companies for their role in producing and selling chemical toxins that were sprayed by the US army during the Vietnam War.

 
 

Other News

.
Up to 118 new COVID-19 cases recorded on June 15 morning
Up to 118 new COVID-19 cases recorded on June 15 morning
SOCIETYicon  15/06/2021 

The national tally of COVID-19 infections rose to 10,999 after 118 more locally-transmitted cases were confirmed in the past six hours to 12pm on June 15, according to the Ministry of Health (MoH).

Hanoi's relocation of universities, hospitals, industrial establishment still slow
Hanoi's relocation of universities, hospitals, industrial establishment still slow
SOCIETYicon  15/06/2021 

Relocating universities, hospitals, and polluted production facilities to reduce population pressure on the central areas of Hanoi is an important goal of the six residential planning projects in four core inner-city districts.

Health Ministry sets up standing COVID-19-prevention unit in HCM City
Health Ministry sets up standing COVID-19-prevention unit in HCM City
SOCIETYicon  15/06/2021 

The Ministry of Health has decided to establish a standing division for COVID-19 prevention and control in Ho Chi Minh City, which is headed by its Deputy Minister Nguyen Truong Son.

Vietnam confirms 71 new COVID-19 infections
Vietnam confirms 71 new COVID-19 infections
SOCIETYicon  15/06/2021 

Vietnam reported 71 more COVID-19 infections, including one imported case, in the last 12 hours to 6am on June 15, according to the Ministry of Health.

HCM City extends social distancing order for two more weeks as COVID-19 outbreaks grow
HCM City extends social distancing order for two more weeks as COVID-19 outbreaks grow
SOCIETYicon  14/06/2021 

Chairman of HCM City People's Committee Nguyen Thanh Long on Monday agreed to prolong city-wide social distancing in line with the Government's Directive No 15 until the end of June, amid developments of coronavirus outbreaks in the city.

HCM City universities adjust enrollment plans for academic year
HCM City universities adjust enrollment plans for academic year
SOCIETYicon  14/06/2021 

Many universities in HCM City have changed enrollment plans for the upcoming academic year because of the ongoing COVID-19 outbreak.

The bumpy road of a 25-year-old female teacher elected to the National Assembly
The bumpy road of a 25-year-old female teacher elected to the National Assembly
FEATUREicon  15/06/2021 

Nang Xo Vi, the first Brau ethnic minority female teacher elected to the NA, said she is grateful to the people of Dak Me hamlet, who contributed packages of seasoning powder and shampoo as well as emotional support so that Vi could go to school.

Vietnamese in Southeast Asia’s COVID epicentres stay calm and optimistic
Vietnamese in Southeast Asia’s COVID epicentres stay calm and optimistic
SOCIETYicon  14/06/2021 

Nguyen Trung Dong, a Vietnamese engineer working in Vientiane, Laos, received the first shot of Sinopharm’s COVID-19 vaccine two weeks ago.

COVID-19 vaccine fund receives over 211.3 million USD in cash donations so far
COVID-19 vaccine fund receives over 211.3 million USD in cash donations so far
SOCIETYicon  14/06/2021 

The national COVID-19 vaccine fund has received more than 4.85 trillion VND (211.35 million USD) worth of donations from 291,818 organisations and individuals as of 5pm on June 13, according to the fund's management board.

COVID-19: 92 new cases reported on June 14 morning
COVID-19: 92 new cases reported on June 14 morning
SOCIETYicon  14/06/2021 

The Ministry of Health confirmed 91 new locally-transmitted and one imported COVID-19 cases in the past 12 hours to 6am on June 14, including 73 detected in quarantined or locked down areas.

Bac Ninh eases social distancing, Quang Ninh reboots tourism
Bac Ninh eases social distancing, Quang Ninh reboots tourism
SOCIETYicon  13/06/2021 

The northern province of Bac Ninh eased social distancing measures in several areas, starting from 0am on June 13.

103 more COVID-19 cases recorded in Vietnam, daily caseload at 297
103 more COVID-19 cases recorded in Vietnam, daily caseload at 297
SOCIETYicon  13/06/2021 

Vietnam has confirmed an additional 103 locally transmitted coronavirus cases in five localities during the past six hours, raising its daily count to 297, according to the Ministry of Health (MoH).

Over 93,000 students enter 10th grade entrance exam in Hanoi
Over 93,000 students enter 10th grade entrance exam in Hanoi
SOCIETYicon  13/06/2021 

More than 93,000 students throughout Hanoi took part in the 10th grade entrance exam for the upcoming school year on June 12.

Temporary blockade imposed on HCMC Hospital for Tropical Diseases
Temporary blockade imposed on HCMC Hospital for Tropical Diseases
SOCIETYicon  13/06/2021 

The municipal Department of Health decided to impose a temporary blockade on the HCMC Hospital for Tropical Diseases in the evening of June 12 after some healthcare workers in the hospital tested positive for Covid-19.

Vietnam’s top leaders consider vaccine passport
Vietnam’s top leaders consider vaccine passport
SOCIETYicon  13/06/2021 

Vietnam vows to pursue the twin goal of containing Covid-19 and developing the economy to serve the recovery plans.

Businesses face difficulties in vaccine imports
Businesses face difficulties in vaccine imports
SOCIETYicon  13/06/2021 

The Government has created conditions for localities and businesses to stimulate the import of Covid-19 vaccines, however, no proposals have been sent to the relevant agencies.

Tropical low depression develops into storm
Tropical low depression develops into storm
SOCIETYicon  13/06/2021 

A tropical low-pressure system has developed into a storm, internationally named Koguma, becoming the second hitting the East Sea since the beginning of this year.

Most of fresh Covid-19 cases linked to industrial parks
Most of fresh Covid-19 cases linked to industrial parks
SOCIETYicon  13/06/2021 

The Ministry of Health this morning, June 13, confirmed 96 Covid-19 cases in seven localities, with 67 cases linked to previous patients in industrial parks.

VIETNAM NEWS HEADLINES JUNE 12
VIETNAM NEWS HEADLINES JUNE 12
SOCIETYicon  12/06/2021 

UNICEF welcomes Vietnam's approval of programme on child protection online

Methamphetamine use on the rise in Vietnam: UNODC
Methamphetamine use on the rise in Vietnam: UNODC
SOCIETYicon  12/06/2021 

The number of methamphetamine users in Vietnam increased by nine times from 2016 to 2020, a new report has found.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN