During earlier discussions of the draft Penal Code, several lawmakers expressed concerns about proposals to abolish capital punishment for illegal drug trafficking and the rape of children under 16.
In its report explaining the proposed revisions, the government outlined the reasons for removing the death penalty for drug trafficking.
According to the government, there is currently no convincing evidence that capital punishment is more effective than life imprisonment in deterring drug-related crime.
The report noted that offenders involved in highly profitable criminal activities conducted in secrecy generally believe they will escape detection, rather than weighing the difference between a death sentence and life imprisonment before committing a crime.
The government therefore argued that stronger deterrence would come from improving investigative capabilities, detecting and prosecuting offenses promptly, dismantling criminal networks at their roots, identifying and arresting their organizers and ringleaders, and confiscating all financial gains obtained through criminal activity.
It also maintained that abolishing the death penalty for illegal drug trafficking while retaining it for illegal drug production would better reflect law enforcement realities and distinguish between the nature, severity and criminal intent associated with the two offenses.
Experience in combating drug crime has shown that many offenders lack a full understanding of the law. Some are recruited or enticed into criminal activities, while others are deceived or coerced into participating.
The government argued that such offenders may still be capable of rehabilitation, education and making amends for their crimes. Applying the death penalty to these individuals would therefore not be entirely appropriate.
The Ministry of Public Security, which led the drafting process, reported that between 2020 and 2024, law enforcement agencies detected and investigated more than 20,000 drug-related cases annually on average, arresting over 31,000 suspects each year.
In 2025, authorities investigated and solved 21,998 drug-related cases, arresting 44,354 suspects.
From the beginning of 2026 through September, drug crime investigation police nationwide successfully handled another 17,633 cases, arresting 35,380 suspects and seizing substantial quantities of illegal drugs.
People from ethnic minority communities and particularly disadvantaged areas account for approximately 30% of those involved in illegal drug trafficking.
Meanwhile, suspects used weapons to violently resist arrest in nearly 30% of cases.
The ministry also reported that, in recent years, drug quantities involved in most cases have exceeded the highest thresholds specified under the sentencing framework that previously allowed the death penalty for illegal drug trafficking.
Why capital punishment is being abolished for child rape
Regarding the proposal to remove the death penalty for the rape of children under 16, the government emphasized that this remains an exceptionally serious crime requiring severe punishment.
However, when comparing the offense with crimes that will continue to carry the death penalty, particularly murder, the drafting agency concluded that the severity of the consequences and the corresponding punishments were different.
It therefore considered retaining capital punishment for the rape of a person under 16 disproportionate in relation to the penalties imposed for other offenses.
The government's report explained that if the rape of a child under 16 directly causes the victim's death, the offender could still face the death penalty for murder, provided the legal elements constituting that offense are established.
Existing death sentences to be commuted to life imprisonment
The National Assembly also approved a resolution governing the implementation of the revised Penal Code.
Under the resolution, from the date the 2026 Penal Code is officially promulgated, courts will no longer impose the death penalty on individuals convicted of offenses for which capital punishment has been abolished.
Death sentences handed down before the law's promulgation for offenses that no longer carry capital punishment will not be carried out if the executions have not yet taken place.
Instead, the Chief Justice of the Supreme People's Court will issue decisions commuting those death sentences to life imprisonment.
Tran Thuong
