return icon

Vinalines case shows that arbitration law is being ignored in Vietnam

 VietNamNet Bridge – Vinalines and its partners agreed in the past that company disputes could be brought to the Vietnam International Arbitration Center (VIAC), but the shipping firm has not obeyed VIAC’s judgment.

VietNamNet Bridge – Vinalines and its partners agreed in the past that company disputes could be brought to the Vietnam International Arbitration Center (VIAC), but the shipping firm has not obeyed VIAC’s judgment.

relate news



Equipment left under the sun and rain at Van Phong port.


Vinalines, the country’s largest shipping corporation, lost a case brought to VIAC earlier this year, and it was forced to pay VND62.5 billion to the South Korean SK E&C as compensation for breaking a contract for the construction of a harbor at Van Phong transit port in Khanh Hoa province.

Vinalines, which did accept the verdict, petitioned the Hanoi People’s Court, asking the court to annul the verdict. It also asked for the relevant ministries’ intervention to help speed up the trial of the case.

The Ministry of Transport has sent a dispatch to the Hanoi Court, asking them to try the case soon in order to help ease Vinalines’ difficulties.

While the Ministry of Transport backs Vinalines, lawyers have criticized the shipping corporation’s behavior.

They cited the Commercial Arbitration Law as saying that Vinalines must respect the judgment of the arbitrators, because it agreed before to have disputes to be arbitrated at VIAC.

“They (Vinalines) chose VIAC and therefore, it must obey VIAC verdict,” a lawyer said, emphasizing that the agreement on dispute settlement was a provision of the contract signed between Vinalines and the South Korean partner.

The lawyer went on to say that as Vietnam has become more involved in global trade, its enterprises must respect international laws and practices.

According to Lawyer Nguyen Manh Dung from the London-based Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (CIArb), under the Commercial Arbitration Law, the disputing parties themselves have the right to choose three arbitrators for an arbitration council. One of the arbitrators will be chosen by the plaintiff, the other by the defendant, and the chair of the arbitration council will be chosen by the two arbitrators.

The chosen arbitrators cannot be VIAC’s arbitrators. In principle, arbitrators must be independent and objective when considering cases, while no one can intervene in the arbitration council’s work.

The disputing parties do not have the right to appeal against arbitrators’ decisions, and therefore, the decisions take effect immediately, not only in Vietnam, but in all the 149 countries which are the members of the 1958 New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, unless one of the parties’ petitions the court to annul the arbitrators’ decisions.

However, Dung said, the court will only annul arbitrators’ judgments if it finds serious violations of the arbitration proceedings.

The lawyer warned that if the Vietnamese court annuls arbitrators’ judgments, Vietnamese and foreign businesses will lose confidence in Vietnamese arbitrators and Vietnamese laws.

In fact, Vinalines is not the only Vietnamese enterprise asking the court to abrogate arbitrators’ decisions. Many similar cases reportedly occurred in the past. As arbitrators’ decisions are not respected, businesses are hesitating to bring cases to Vietnamese arbitration councils.



Aviation industry forecast to fully recover in 2025

It is not until 2025 that the local aviation sector can fully recover due to rising fuel prices and the slower-than-expected reopening of international markets, according to domestic airlines.


Hanoi airport faces serious congestion during summer peak

Hanoi and Hoi An among Top 25 Overall Experiences in Asia

Motorbike tours around Hanoi and cooking classes in Hoi An have made it into the Top 25 Overall Experiences in Asia, as voted on by readers of TripAdvisor.

Vietnam, Hungary seal judicial cooperation deal for 2022-2023

Vietnamese Minister of Justice Le Thanh Long and his Hungarian counterpart Judit Varga on June 27 signed a cooperation programme between the two ministries for the 2022-2023 period.

India conglomerate pledges to invest 10 billion USD in Vietnam

A joint venture between India’s Adani Group and Vietnam’s Anh Phat Investment Construction & Trading JSC has been approved by authorities of Da Nang to start studying the development of a major seaport in the central city.


Govt approves appointment of contractors for North-South expy project

HCM City hi-tech park to speed up investment procedures

HCM City will focus on helping businesses invest in the Saigon Hi-tech Park in Thu Duc City by addressing slow administrative procedures, a conference on facilitating investment heard on June 27.

Korea, Vietnam to mark 30th anniversary of relations with cultural events

The Korea Content Creation Agency in Vietnam will organise a series of cultural-entertainment events this year to commemorate the 30th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between the two countries.

HCM City to promote AI in education sector

HCM City will need to promote the application of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the education sector as part of its effort to become a smart city by 2030, experts said.

Additionally-registered and share-purchased FDI soars sharply in first half of 2022

Despite newly-registered FDI dropping in the first half of the year, additionally-registered and share-purchased investments increased significantly on-year.

Vietnam joins hands with France to renovate Hanoi’s Long Bien bridge

Vietnamese and French experts will join hands to renovate Hanoi City’s deteriorating Long Bien Bridge in the coming months.

Lessons learned from urban railway projects

The urban railway projects that have been and are under construction are all behind schedule, so the total investment must be adjusted.

Prices hit record high, Vietnam earns big money from catfish

Export prices have been escalating in all markets and hitting new records in the US. Vietnam’s catfish export turnover is expected to reach $2.6 billion this year, the highest in history.

Phu Dien Cham Tower in Vietnam sets world record

The central province of Thua Thien – Hue on June 27 held a ceremony to mark WorldKings’ recognition of Phu Dien Tower built by the Cham people as a world record.

Explosive e-commerce growth drives demand for logistics

The rapid growth in e-commerce is driving an unprecedented increase in demand for logistics services, including express delivery services, according to industry insiders.