The Hanoi People's Court opened the first-instance trial of Le Thanh Than, chairman of Muong Thanh Group and chairman and general director of Bemes Company, on charges of deceiving customers in connection with serious construction violations at the CT6 Kien Hung residential project.

att.d0OckLlslBZRBhoN y_3hR759CtIZFuIOTgSfDlg6eE.jpeg
Le Thanh Than appears at the Hanoi People's Court on November 18. Photo: Thach Thao.

Five former officials from Kien Hung Ward and the former Ha Dong District are standing trial alongside him on charges of negligence causing serious consequences.

They are Do Van Hung, former chairman of the Kien Hung Ward People's Committee; Nguyen Duy Uyen and Bui Van Bang, both former vice chairmen of the ward; Nguyen Van Nam, former chief construction inspector of Ha Dong District; and Vuong Dang Quan, former deputy chief construction inspector.

Than is being prosecuted under Article 198, Clause 2, Point d of the Penal Code, while the five former officials face charges under Article 285, Clause 2.

The trial is presided over by Judge Luu Ngoc Canh, deputy head of the Criminal Court at the Hanoi People's Court, and is scheduled to continue until November 30.

Than, widely known in Vietnam as the "bamboo-pipe-smoking tycoon" for his habit of smoking a traditional bamboo water pipe, remains subject to a travel restriction prohibiting him from leaving his place of residence.

The case was previously brought to trial in August 2023, but the court returned the case file for further investigation after identifying several unresolved issues.

How 519 apartment buyers became victims

According to prosecutors, the CT6 Kien Hung project had received official approval for its detailed construction plan at a scale of 1:500. However, Than subsequently directed construction activities that seriously deviated from the approved plan.

Beginning in March 2011, he allegedly provided misleading information about the project's legal status, assuring prospective buyers that it had been approved, that its apartment and building designs complied with construction regulations, and that apartment prices included land-use rights.

Prosecutors said these representations encouraged customers to purchase apartments without knowing the extent of the project's planning violations.

Construction was completed in November 2012, and residents began moving into their apartments in January 2013.

Investigators found that Than had unilaterally changed land-use purposes and substantially altered the approved construction plans.

In the high-rise section, the developer increased the building footprint and height, changed designated functions, added apartments and constructed an additional tower, CT6C, which was not included in the approved plan.

In the low-rise section, the developer expanded the construction area, increased the number of houses and violated designated road boundaries.

According to the indictment, Than sold 519 apartments to 519 customers who were subsequently unable to obtain legally recognized land-use rights and property ownership certificates, commonly known in Vietnam as red books or pink books.

Prosecutors determined that the transactions generated more than VND531 billion (approximately $20.4 million) in illicit gains, an amount they also identified as the financial damage suffered by the 519 buyers.

The indictment further alleges that local officials failed to inspect, detect, prevent or address the violations despite their continuation over an extended period.

During the investigation, Than acknowledged the conduct described in the charges, explaining that he had been too eager to seize business opportunities and had not completed the administrative procedures needed to seek approval for adjustments to the project's detailed construction plan.

Compensation remains unresolved

To address the consequences, Than proposed negotiating directly with apartment buyers to repurchase their properties or refund their payments.

Under his proposed arrangement, the CT6C tower would subsequently be demolished at his expense.

However, Bemes Company has so far been unable to reach agreements with the affected customers.

Than therefore requested that the Bank for Investment and Development of Vietnam (BIDV), through its South Hanoi branch, provide a guarantee covering the amount he would be required to repay under the law.

The proceedings also originally involved Mai Quang Bai, a former construction inspector in Ha Dong District. Following his death on November 23, 2024, investigators discontinued proceedings against him.

Hanoi proposes solutions for violations at 12 projects

The criminal case comes as Hanoi authorities consider a broader plan to address longstanding construction and land-use violations at 12 residential developments associated with Than and his businesses.

The municipal government began seeking public feedback on a draft resolution on October 10, proposing special mechanisms to deal with projects developed, managed, owned or financed by businesses linked to the property tycoon.

The developments include CT6 Kien Hung, Dai Thanh, CT5 Tan Trieu, Xa La, CT11 and CT12 in Kim Van - Kim Lu, VP3, VP5 and VP6 in Linh Dam, and the HH1, HH2, HH3 and HH4 residential complexes.

Authorities have acknowledged the difficulty of enforcing demolition orders at buildings where large numbers of residents have already established their homes.

According to the municipal government, removing illegally constructed sections and relocating thousands of residents could have significant consequences for social welfare and public order.

The draft resolution therefore proposes dividing the violating structures into three categories.

The first category covers completed buildings or building sections that may remain in their current condition if they satisfy requirements concerning structural safety, fire prevention, infrastructure capacity, urban planning and other legal conditions.

The second category covers structures that may remain conditionally, provided that deficiencies can be addressed through technical improvements, additional infrastructure, changes in building functions or the relocation of affected residents.

The third category comprises structures that must be demolished because they fail to meet essential safety or planning requirements and cannot be brought into compliance.

The municipal People's Committee would determine which buildings fall into each category following technical assessments.

Under the proposal, developers would bear the full cost of corrective measures, relocation, compensation, temporary accommodation, demolition and infrastructure improvements.

Public funds would not be used to cover expenses arising from developers' violations.

For buildings allowed to remain, developers would also be required to surrender unlawful gains associated with the violations and fulfill outstanding land-related financial obligations.

Once those obligations were completed, developers would have to prepare the necessary documentation for authorities to issue property ownership certificates to eligible buyers.

If a developer failed to submit the documents despite fulfilling its financial obligations, buyers would be allowed to apply directly for the certificates.

The draft emphasizes that allowing certain structures to remain would constitute a special remedial measure, not the legalization of unlawful construction.

Years of violations across Hanoi housing developments

Than built his reputation through affordable housing projects that attracted strong demand from middle- and lower-income buyers, particularly during periods of weakness in Vietnam's property market.

In 2012, when the real estate market was struggling, developments associated with Muong Thanh offered apartments at approximately VND13-15 million per square meter, drawing substantial buyer interest.

However, inspections later uncovered widespread violations involving excessive building heights, unauthorized apartments, changes in designated building functions, incomplete land procedures and fire safety shortcomings.

A Hanoi inspection announced in 2016 found serious violations at nine residential projects associated with Muong Thanh, while three other developments had been examined by the Government Inspectorate.

All nine projects investigated by the city were found to have seriously breached their approved detailed construction plans.

At VP3 Linh Dam, the number of floors increased from 29 to 32, while apartment numbers rose from 192 to 451.

At VP5 Linh Dam, the developer increased the building height from 29 to 33 floors and the number of apartments from 216 to 805.

The violations were even more extensive at VP6 Linh Dam, where the building rose from an approved 25 floors to 37, while apartment numbers increased from 138 to 840.

At the HH1 and HH3 complexes, buildings originally approved for 816 apartments each were developed with approximately 2,000 apartments each.

Across 12 buildings in the complexes, inspectors recorded more than 8,896 apartments accommodating an estimated 26,688 residents, more than four times the approved population of 6,300.

At CT6 Kien Hung, the number of high-rise apartments increased from an approved 231 to 1,602, an additional 1,371 units.

The low-rise section, originally approved for 15 three-storey townhouses, was instead developed into 38 four-storey properties. An area of 718.8 square meters designated for a kindergarten was also converted into low-rise housing.

Inspectors found that the violations placed additional pressure on transport networks, schools, childcare facilities and other public infrastructure.

They also identified failures to complete land allocation and conversion procedures, outstanding land-use financial obligations, construction undertaken without the necessary permits and apartments handed over before fire safety requirements had been satisfied.

These longstanding violations have complicated the issuance of ownership certificates and raised concerns about the legal rights of thousands of homebuyers.

Hanoi's proposed special mechanism seeks to resolve those problems while maintaining accountability for developers and protecting residents who purchased homes in the affected projects.

The proposal remains a draft, and the outcome of Than's criminal trial has yet to be determined.

T.Nhung - Thanh Hue - Hanh Nguyen