Vietnam's proposed overhaul of specialized high schools has sparked debate among teachers and education experts, who argue that changes to entrance examinations must be accompanied by a carefully planned transition and broader reforms to how talented students are identified and nurtured.
The Ministry of Education and Training (MoET) recently released a draft circular proposing that specialized high schools replace subject-specific admission streams with three broader categories: Natural Sciences, Social Sciences and Foreign Languages.
Under the proposal, students would initially study within these streams before choosing subjects for advanced specialization.
The ministry has suggested implementation from the 2027-2028 academic year for schools meeting the necessary requirements, while other institutions could begin in 2028-2029.
Thai Van Tai, Director General of MoET's General Education Department, has emphasized that the draft remains open for consultation and no final decision has been made.
While acknowledging the need to modernize specialized education, teachers and experts have questioned whether the proposed approach would accurately identify students' abilities, reduce examination pressure or fulfill the broader mission of developing national talent.
Teachers warn of heavier academic workloads

A teacher at a specialized high school managed by the Hanoi Department of Education and Training expressed concern that the proposed admission structure could significantly increase students' preparation requirements.
Under the current system, candidates generally concentrate on their chosen specialized subject. The proposed model would instead require them to prepare for examinations covering broader academic fields.
The teacher said the Natural Sciences stream appeared particularly demanding.
"For example, a student intending to specialize in Chemistry would also have to study Physics, Biology and Informatics, alongside compulsory Mathematics. This could substantially increase their academic workload," he explained.
Although broader assessments might provide a more comprehensive picture of students' knowledge, he questioned their practical feasibility.
"Students preparing for specialized school entrance examinations already face considerable pressure. If we cannot reduce that burden, we should at least avoid adding to it," he said. "Not every change necessarily represents an improvement."
Nguyen Thanh Cong, a teacher at a university-affiliated specialized high school in Hanoi, raised concerns about the proposed examination weightings.
Under the draft, Natural Sciences candidates would take advanced Mathematics, Literature and a Natural Sciences reading comprehension and competency assessment.
Advanced Mathematics would carry a weighting of at least two, while the other examinations would have a weighting of one.
For Social Sciences candidates, advanced Literature would receive a weighting of at least two, alongside Mathematics and a History-Geography competency assessment, each weighted at one.
Cong questioned the educational basis for using advanced Mathematics as the principal measure of aptitude in Physics, Chemistry, Biology and Informatics.
"Strong mathematical thinking does not necessarily mean strong ability in natural science subjects. Physics, Chemistry, Biology and Informatics each require their own distinct competencies," he said.
He argued that the proposal appeared inconsistent with its stated objective of selecting students whose abilities matched their specialized fields.
Experts question the three-stream structure
Vu Khac Ngoc, an examination preparation teacher in Hanoi, also questioned whether the division into three streams was academically sound.
He suggested that the proposed structure appeared to use Mathematics, Literature and Foreign Languages as the foundations for three streams, with other subjects grouped around them.
According to Ngoc, Mathematics and Informatics share important foundations in mathematical reasoning, algorithms and computation, but are not identical to experimental sciences such as Physics, Chemistry and Biology.
Combining all five subjects into one Natural Sciences stream could make the assessment structure unnecessarily complex and less effective at identifying individual strengths, he argued.
Ngoc also called for a reassessment of the role of specialized foreign language education.
As Vietnam promotes English as a second language in schools and artificial intelligence increasingly reduces translation barriers, he believes specialized language programs should offer more than communication skills or preparation for international certificates.
Such programs, he suggested, should develop deeper expertise in linguistic reasoning, cultural studies and comparative linguistics rather than focusing primarily on IELTS or SAT results.
Despite these concerns, Ngoc supported the broader objective of restructuring specialized education, provided the changes were supported by sound academic reasoning and a clear implementation plan.
Calls for a longer transition period
Beyond the examination structure, educators have expressed concern about the timing of the proposed changes.
Pham Thai Son, an education expert in HCMC, said policymakers should conduct thorough research and consult parents, students, former students and teachers before finalizing the regulations.
He emphasized that specialized schools differ in size, staffing and operating conditions, making a uniform approach potentially unsuitable.
Rather than relying exclusively on written questionnaires, Son recommended direct surveys and interviews to capture concerns that stakeholders might hesitate to express formally.
He also stressed that specialized schools serve a distinctive role in identifying and developing talented students.
They should not be viewed simply as institutions with high entrance examination scores, but as learning environments with specific curricula, teaching methods and educational objectives.
Accordingly, any change to admissions should be assessed for its potential effects on students, teachers and individual schools.
Vo Kim Bao, a teacher at Nguyen Du Secondary School in HCMC, recommended postponing implementation by approximately two years.
"Students have spent years studying and preparing for these examinations. If the regulations change suddenly, their previous preparation may no longer be appropriate, causing considerable psychological pressure," he said.
Another HCMC teacher argued that major changes to examinations and admissions should be announced at least three years in advance, equivalent to a full high school cycle.
This would allow students and families to make informed academic plans while giving education authorities time to test new approaches and gather feedback.
"A three-year transition does not mean freezing policy. Problems must still be addressed, but appropriate transitional arrangements are needed so that students do not bear the risks," the teacher said.
A school principal in HCMC similarly argued that policymakers must take responsibility for the feasibility and consequences of their decisions.
He called for thorough impact assessments, meaningful consultation and sufficient preparation time before introducing major changes.
"Education needs administrators who are willing to innovate, but it also needs people who listen, exercise caution and take responsibility for their decisions," he said.
Gifted schools must focus on developing talent, not just exam results
Hoang Ngoc Vinh, former Director General of MoET's Professional Education Department, argued that the debate should extend beyond examination formats to the fundamental purpose of specialized high schools.
In his assessment, reform must begin with a clear understanding of how these institutions can identify, nurture and develop exceptional abilities.
Resolution 71-NQ/TW calls for renewing specialized and gifted school models to cultivate national talent, including expanding STEM and STEAM programs.
Vinh said this mission requires a shift in educational objectives rather than simply changing admission procedures.
Public resources, family investment and social contributions should create meaningful opportunities for students to develop distinctive abilities, rather than focusing primarily on academic awards and university admission rates.
Statistics on university major selections in 2023 raise questions about the outcomes of specialized education.
Among 25,111 students from specialized high schools, 7,510, or 29.91%, selected one of eight STEM fields, compared with 31.04% in the general student comparison group.
Only 818 specialized school students, equivalent to 3.26%, chose natural sciences, life sciences, mathematics or statistics.
Within narrower subject categories, 96 selected Mathematics or Applied Mathematics, 33 chose Physics and 98 selected Chemistry.
When related disciplines were included, the figures rose to 354 for Mathematics, Mathematical Informatics and Mathematics Education; 66 for Physics-related fields; and 345 for Chemistry and Chemical Engineering.
Meanwhile, 48 students chose Literature or Creative Writing, rising to 213 when Literature Education was included.
Vinh acknowledged that students specializing in Mathematics could successfully pursue careers in engineering, finance or economics, while specialized schools also serve students interested in languages and social sciences.
Nevertheless, he argued that the diversity of university choices should prompt closer examination of the outcomes that specialized education is intended to achieve.
Many families invest substantial time and money in preparing their children for specialized school admissions because they expect access to excellent teachers, motivated classmates and high-quality learning environments.
Academic awards may also provide advantages in university admissions, scholarships and overseas study.
However, these individual aspirations do not necessarily align with the broader national objective of cultivating talent in particular fields.
Vinh argued that entrance examination scores and academic awards alone cannot demonstrate how much students have developed during three years of specialized education.
Admission reform alone cannot identify exceptional potential
According to Vinh, the proposed broader academic streams and opportunities for exploration before specialization are consistent with the need for a strong educational foundation.
However, stream-based examinations are not necessarily better at identifying talent than subject-specific assessments.
Combined scores may conceal exceptional strengths in individual disciplines, while highly specialized examinations can encourage excessive test preparation.
He also highlighted equity concerns.
Students from families able to afford extensive tutoring and access experienced teachers may enjoy significant advantages, while those with strong potential but fewer resources could be excluded after a single examination.
"Examination scores reflect only part of the abilities students have demonstrated. They cannot fully capture curiosity, the capacity to learn new things or sustained creativity," he argued.
Vinh suggested that examinations remain necessary but should be designed to assess aptitude rather than test-taking techniques.
Portfolios, practical assessments, interviews and student projects could provide additional evidence of potential, provided they were evaluated against transparent criteria and did not create further advantages for wealthier families.
More importantly, he said, talent identification should continue throughout students' education rather than ending at admission.
Reform must extend to teaching and school governance
Citing Identifying Gifted Students: A Practical Guide, edited by Susan K. Johnsen and Joyce VanTassel-Baska and published by Routledge in 2022, Vinh distinguished three essential tasks: identifying gifted students, assessing their progress and evaluating program effectiveness.
Entrance examinations address only the first.
The remaining tasks depend on the quality of teaching, learning opportunities and school management.
Specialized education, he argued, should not simply mean additional lessons and more difficult exercises.
Chemistry students should have opportunities to conduct experiments, develop hypotheses and test their findings. Mathematics students should explore open-ended problems, while Literature and History students should engage in research, debate and creative work.
"If we want students to develop a passion for science, we must give them opportunities to practice science," he argued.
Vinh recommended stronger partnerships between specialized high schools, universities, research institutes and businesses.
Such cooperation could provide students with access to research projects, scientific mentors and better practical facilities, while allowing teachers to update their professional knowledge.
He also called for continuous assessment of students' progress and interests throughout their studies, helping them choose suitable specializations and develop their abilities.
Schools should monitor educational outcomes from admission through graduation and beyond, using the findings to improve teaching and demonstrate the effectiveness of public investment.
Academic prizes, he argued, should not remain the principal measure of success.
Ultimately, Vinh maintained that meaningful reform requires coordinated changes in admission, talent identification, curricula, teaching methods and school governance.
Changing the entrance examination is only one part of that process.
The decisive question is whether specialized schools can create environments in which exceptional abilities are continually discovered, nurtured and developed into genuine talent.
Le Huyen - Thanh Hung - Hoang Ngoc Vinh