return icon Vietnamnet.vn

Why foreign retailers withdraw from Vietnam?

Capital withdrawals of foreign retailers in Vietnam have fielded a number of queries on whether the firms had sustained losses or if the local business climate lacked enough incentives.

question marks remain as foreign retailers withdraw from vietnam hinh 0
French retailer Auchan makes headlines in mid-May when confirming its withdrawal from the Vietnamese market. (Photo: Auchan)

 

 

 

Former chairman of the Hanoi Supermarket Association Vu Vinh Phu claimed there are many factors causing the withdrawal of foreign retailers from the Vietnamese market. Many failed to seek a proper consumer segment and suffered losses due to high costs and poor administration.

Phu said that Auchan is a multinational corporation with a business network of 4,000 locations across 17 countries and territories worldwide.

Since its inception in 2015, the French retailer has spread its arms to 18 locations, primarily in Hanoi, Ho Chi Minh city, and the southern province of Tay Ninh.

Local media reported that Edgar Bonte, CEO of the supermarket group Auchan Retail has decided to sell 18 loss-making stores in Vietnam. These outlets reaped some EUR45 million (US$50.4 million) in revenue in 2018 and are still suffering losses.

It comes as no surprise that retailers suffer losses during their operations and eventually choose to close down. Phu, however, urged the publication of relevant information on the retailers from state management agencies such as the State Audit Office, and tax and customs authorities.

In fact, the country has been offering a string of incentives to foreign direct investment retail firms, he said.

They are entitled to pay 50 percent of the current corporate income tax rate within their first two years of operation while they are leveraged to select good locations for business.

Additionally, foreign retailers operating in the country have decisive advantages in terms of brand and scale when it comes to negotiations with local suppliers.

He exemplified his stance by the fact that many local suppliers and producers reportedly have to provide foreign retailers with a 30 - 40 percent discount per product which they want to put on shelves at foreign-invested distribution chains. This puts domestic firms at a considerable disadvantage, he claimed.

Despite this, several foreign retailers such as METRO Cash & Carry, BigC, and others have still reported losses and even METRO Cash & Carry and BigC have been acquired by Thailand’s retail giants.

This is an unusual development as foreign retailers have been provided with such incentives and discounts, Phu stressed, noting that Germany’s METRO Cash & Carry had been asked by local competent agencies to pay VND500 billion (US$21.5 billion) in tax arrears.

This case serves as a good lesson for state agencies that are in charge of managing the retail and financial sectors, the expert said. State agencies must work on developing a more favorable business climate for retailers towards fairer treatment and transparency.

METRO Cash & Carry was acquired by Thailand’s TCC Group in 2014, after the former suffered consecutive years of losses.

Local media reported that during 12 years of operation in Vietnam, METRO Cash & Carry only enjoyed profits of VND116 billion (US$4.98 million) in 2010 while reporting losses in the remaining years, ranging from VND89 billion (US$3.82 million) to VND160 billion (US$6.88 million).

Moreover, amid thriving development of the Vietnamese retail market, Parkson retail chain in Vietnam, a subsidiary of the Parkson Holdings Berhad, has reportedly made poor performance in the country in comparison with regional peers.

In early 2018, Parkson shut down its final shopping mall in the country, thus putting an end to its business in the Vietnamese market after 13 years of operation. The retail chain had previously planned to open additional shopping centers in major cities nationwide, but it halted the scheme in 2014.

France retailer Auchan’s exit from Vietnam draws interest from potential buyers

France retailer Auchan’s exit from Vietnam draws interest from potential buyers

French supermarket group Auchan Retail’s plans to sell its loss-making business in Vietnam are already drawing interest from potential buyers, Reuters reported.  

Convenience stores help domestic retailers compete with foreign rivals

Convenience stores help domestic retailers compete with foreign rivals

With certain advantages, convenience stores have been an increasingly popular shopping destination for customers, and they have also become a choice for domestic retailers to compete with foreign rivals.  

Retailers seek workers for expansion plans

Retailers seek workers for expansion plans

Some retail chains are seeking hundreds of workers as they plan to open more shops to scale up their business.

MORE NEWS

PM to attend ASEAN-EU commemorative summit, visit three European countries

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh will attend a summit commemorating the 45th anniversary of the ASEAN-EU relations in Brussels on December 14 and pay official visits to Luxembourg, the Netherlands, and Belgium from December 9 to 15.

HCM City Party Secretary: robbery must not exist on streets

HCM City Party Secretary Nguyen Van Nen said the city has a bad reputation for robbery and he has asked relevant bodies to deal with this.

Positive prospects for Vietnam’s stock market in 2023

The stock market saw a trading session with the strongest growth rate in Asia on December 2 as the Vietnam-Index surged by 4.22 percent.

A look at VN fashion through “Taste of Heritage”

After three years of suspension due to the Covid-19 pandemic, the Vietnam International Fashion Week Fall/Winter 2022 returned to Hanoi in late November with eye-catching collections in the spirit of 'Taste of heritage'.

Vietnamese interested in metaverse and fintech

According to a recent report by Meta and Bain & Company, Vietnam is among the top 3 countries besides Indonesia and the Philippines to adopt new technologies such as fintech and metaverse.

The opportunity for a chip-making industry in Vietnam

Chip production will fuel Vietnam's aspiration to become a prominent manufacturing hub in the region.

R&B legend Babyface, 2022 Masked Singer Vietnam’s winner to be on stage together

The much-awaited item of the 2022 “Ho Do" International Music Festival in HCMC will be a duet performance of R&B superstar Babyface and singer Ngoc Mai who won the Masked Singer Vietnam 2022, said Director of the festival, musician Huy Tuan.

HCM City to launch overnight cruises along Saigon River

Ho Chi Minh City’s tourism authority plans to launch overnight cruises with ships accommodating hundreds of people along the Saigon River starting next year.

Value of Vietnamese national football team hits record high

The total market value of the Vietnamese national football team has skyrocketed to EUR7.6 million, equal to US$8.01 million, marking a record high, according to the renowned German football site Transfermarkt.

Ministry announces 218 firms as prestigious exporters of Vietnam

As many as 218 companies have won the “Prestigious Export Business” title for 2021, according to the list unveiled by the Ministry of Industry and Trade (MoIT) on December 5.

Vietnam, RoK agree to upgrade ties to comprehensive strategic partnership

Vietnam and the Republic of Korea (RoK) have agreed to upgrade their ties to a comprehensive strategic partnership, President Nguyen Xuan Phuc told the press following his talks with RoK President Yoon Suk-yeol in Seoul on December 5.

Tourists flock to Sa Pa to see clouds

The number of tourists to Sapa (Lao Cai Province) has rocketed in recent days to admire the amazing clouds.

Fried squid paste in Halong Bay

As one of the largest seafood regions in Vietnam, Quang Ninh has the tastiest seafood dishes that one cannot forget. Among them, fried squid paste in Halong Bay will leave a lasting impression on diners thanks to its unforgettable taste.

Experience Hanoi in its autumn glory

Thanks to its geographical location, the Vietnamese capital city of Hanoi witnesses contrastingly different weather conditions during the four seasons of the year.

VIETNAM NEWS HEADLINES DECEMBER 5

HCYU’s 7th National Congress to be held next week
back_to_top