High speed railway requires careful thought

Cao Sy Kiem, former director general of the State Bank of Viet Nam, talks to the newspaper Kinh tế & Đô thị on the need to think twice before making an official decision on the construction of the high speed North-South railway line.

Controversial express railway project to go before NA next year
Three scenarios for high-speed railway development in Vietnam
Big challenges hinder Vietnam’s largest infrastructure project

High speed railway requires careful thought
Cao Sy Kiem. — Photo theleader

Why should Vietnam limit the proposed budget for the high-speed rail line to less than US$58 billion?

High speed rail is one of the best modes of transport in a country’s economic development. Rail transportation can carry the most cargo compared with other means. However, the cost of rail infrastructure is always very high, ranging from the funding investment to the management and operation.

The plan to construct a high speed trans-Viet Nam rail line is not a simple task, particularly in with the State coffers facing a shortage. This is one of the main reasons why many have come out against the proposal that the Government should spend up to US$58 billion on the project.

Do you think the budget proposal is too expensive?

It is too early to come to such a conclusion. As I have mentioned above, investment in railway infrastructure is very expensive. Right now we should look at the proposal developed by the Ministry of Transport to see if it really fits our country’s needs and circumstances, particularly in terms of financial capacity.

Why is the railway not suitable?

Firstly, the project is not an urgent requirement, as the nation needs a lot of money for other things. Many developed countries have attracted investment capital for their national economic development. Meanwhile, the World Bank and Asian Development Bank have tightened their lending policies. In other words, it is not easy for Vietnam to mobilise tens of billions of dollars to construct its high-speed railway.

Geographically speaking, Vietnam’s topography is complicated with many mountains and rivers, constituting a major challenge in the construction of high speed railway.

 

Additionally, the MOT suggested the speed of the trains should reach as high as 350 km/h. Even for Japan, such a high speed train represents a challenge for engineers. So the MOT’s proposal is quite a tall order.

More recently, the Ministry of Planning and Investment came up with a budget which was less than half of the MOT’s. What do you think of the MPI’s proposal?

The capital investment in the high speed railway was subject to many discussions among concerned authorities. Yet, no final conclusion was made. And now the issue has come up again.

The MOT has come up with a proposal which puts the project at US$58 billion, a quarter of the country's GDP, while the Ministry of Planning and Investment has proposed a much lower total budget, around US$26 billion.

This is food for thought for concerned authorities to make their final decision. However, with a constrained budget, the less money we have to spend on the line is better. But whatever decision is made, we have to uphold the principles of high quality, yet with low cost.

Some have argued that if the speed of the train is 200 km/h, can the service compete with airlines?

I don’t think the train speed is a core issue. The biggest advantage of the rail line is the volume of cargo it transports, not the passengers. Meanwhile, the strongest point of airlines is its passengers, not cargo.

In both proposals from the Ministry of Transport and the Ministry of Planning and Investment, each has strong points and weak points. The long-delayed Cat Linh-Ha Dong urban line in Hanoi is an expensive lesson for Vietnam. The line is just 10km in length, but the construction time took more than 10 years while the budget has jumped considerably compared to the initial estimate.

For the North-South railway line, we have to conduct a thorough study before making a final decision.

VNS

 
 

Other News

.
Upward trend persists for M&A in real estate
Upward trend persists for M&A in real estate
BUSINESSicon  16/11/2020 

The recent trend of transferring sub-projects to other developers in large-scale real estate complexes is considered one of the efficient ways to bring many benefits to developers, investors, and buyers.

Recovery continues
Recovery continues
BUSINESSicon  15/11/2020 

As opposed to that of supply, the recovery of demand remains weaker, which means that the recovery of growth in the coming time will depend largely upon whether consumers can bolster their purchasing power

Gov’t orders solutions to support rice exporters to EU
Gov’t orders solutions to support rice exporters to EU
BUSINESSicon  15/11/2020 

The Government has directed the Ministry of Industry and Trade to coordinate with other relevant agencies to support local enterprises exporting rice to the European Union (EU) to make the most of EVFTA,

Retail spaces left empty as shops go online
Retail spaces left empty as shops go online
BUSINESSicon  15/11/2020 

Although Vietnam has managed to effectively contain the Covid-19 outbreak, many unsuccessful shops have shut down, as retailers have opted to go online to reduce operation costs, with the trend expected to grow further in the coming time.

International consultant to be chosen for North-South express railway project
International consultant to be chosen for North-South express railway project
BUSINESSicon  16/11/2020 

The State Appraisal Council has approved a plan to choose a consulting firm for the North-South express railway project through an international tender.

Amid global uncertainty, even traditional markets may be vulnerable: experts
Amid global uncertainty, even traditional markets may be vulnerable: experts
BUSINESSicon  15/11/2020 

It has been nearly a year since the first coronavirus-infected case was reported in China. There are now nearly 52.5 million infection cases worldwide and more than 1.29 million people have died of the disease.

New decree to prevent transfer pricing, limit thin capitalisation
New decree to prevent transfer pricing, limit thin capitalisation
BUSINESSicon  14/11/2020 

The Government’s recently-issued Decree 132/2020/NĐ-CP would help prevent transfer pricing and limit thin capitalisation to develop a healthy investment market, Deputy Director of the General Department of Taxation Dang Ngoc Minh said.

Proper mechanism needed to attract investors to PPP projects
Proper mechanism needed to attract investors to PPP projects
BUSINESSicon  14/11/2020 

A proper mechanism is needed to attract investors to infrastructure projects implemented following the public-private partnership (PPP) model, experts have said.

Oil fields becoming depleted, difficulties lie ahead
Oil fields becoming depleted, difficulties lie ahead
FEATUREicon  14/11/2020 

Oil and gas companies are struggling to cope with falling prices, oil field depletion, and difficulties in seeking new fields.

Business support packages in the frame for maximum impact
Business support packages in the frame for maximum impact
BUSINESSicon  14/11/2020 

With many businesses becoming gradually exhausted and in critical need of state support, many National Assembly members have asked the government to apply feasible solutions to lift them out of woes.

Curbed inflation eases concerns
Curbed inflation eases concerns
BUSINESSicon  13/11/2020 

The big rise in public investment disbursement will not cause high inflation this year due to a decline in public and business demand and oil price, as well as government efforts to stabilise prices.

Focus on efficiency for new incentives
Focus on efficiency for new incentives
BUSINESSicon  13/11/2020 

A list of sectors that could benefit from special tax incentives in Vietnam would be utilised to grow enthusiasm for overseas investors and, as a result, help to contribute towards luring more high-quality foreign direct investment.

Pressure on the Finance Minister
Pressure on the Finance Minister
FEATUREicon  13/11/2020 

As the holder of the keys of the national treasury, Finance Minister Dinh Tien Dung is facing great pressure.

Demographics, rising income, geopolitical shifts to drive ASEAN’s growth
Demographics, rising income, geopolitical shifts to drive ASEAN’s growth
BUSINESSicon  13/11/2020 

10 ASEAN member states are on the cusp of a tremendous leap forward in socio-economic progress and their growth will be propelled by four mega-forces, including favourable demographics, rising income levels, geopolitical shifts and digital tailwinds.

Local firms told to prepare for RCEP export opportunities
Local firms told to prepare for RCEP export opportunities
BUSINESSicon  13/11/2020 

Vietnamese businesses should prepare to export their products to other ASEAN countries ahead of the possible signing of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) this week. 

Pork prices drop after country flooded with imports
Pork prices drop after country flooded with imports
BUSINESSicon  14/11/2020 

Vietnam spent VND5 trillion ($214.78 million) to import pork in the first nine months of the year, leading to a drop in prices.

Hanoi authorities to inspect farmstay projects, land violations
Hanoi authorities to inspect farmstay projects, land violations
BUSINESSicon  13/11/2020 

The Hanoi People’s Committee has assigned the Department of Natural Resources and the Environment to set up a taskforce to inspect farmstay projects and deal with land law violations.

Daily visits to local e-commerce sites top 3.5 million: VECOM
Daily visits to local e-commerce sites top 3.5 million: VECOM
BUSINESSicon  12/11/2020 

Online shopping traffic in Vietnam so far this year rocketed over 150 percent against a year earlier, with daily visits to e-commerce sites growing to 3.5 million, 

RCEP - A new boost for regional enterprises
RCEP - A new boost for regional enterprises
BUSINESSicon  12/11/2020 

The Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) agreement, expected to be signed on November 15 within the framework of the 37th ASEAN Summit in Hanoi, 

Enterprises need to be pro-active during the pandemic
Enterprises need to be pro-active during the pandemic
BUSINESSicon  13/11/2020 

Nguyen Bich Lam, former director general of the General Statistics of Vietnam, talks on what Vietnamese enterprises need to do to maintain their business production during the COVID-19 pandemic.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN