Improved business environment is the key to FDI not tax and land incentives

ASEAN countries need to choose between recovery based on wasteful competition for investment or coordination, cooperation, and joint hands to generate sustainable tax revenue to spend on health, education,

 and other public goods that are essential to fight poverty and inequality.

Improved business environment is the key to FDI not tax and land incentives
Maximum length of land lease (including extension) in ASEAN countries (years).

COVID-19 is posing enormous challenges to the ASEAN region. In addition to the health and economic crisis, foreign direct investment (FDI) inflows into developing Asian countries are predicted to decrease by 30-40 per cent and tax revenues are collapsing.

The workshop “Towards sustainable FDI attraction in ASEAN: Business environment is the key driver” in Hanoi on November 11 shared findings from a recent research by Oxfam and partners, emphasising the importance of coordinated efforts by ASEAN governments to stop redundant incentive packages and prioritise enhancing the business environment for investment promotion.

Before the pandemic, countries in the ASEAN region were competing with one another in a race to the bottom by offering excessive tax and non-tax incentives to attract FDI without real value generation. Instead of building a business environment that could be the key determinant in FDI location decisions, governments in the region have adopted wasteful and aggressive tax policies that have only benefited large foreign companies, according to recent research by Oxfam and partners. In response to the pandemic and to promote sustainable development, ASEAN needs to avoid falling into the trap of needless competition.

Over the last 10 years, countries in the ASEAN region have been competing in reducing their corporate income tax (CIT) rates and offering aggressive tax incentives to foreign multinational corporations. As a result, ASEAN’s average CIT rate has declined from 25.1 per cent in 2010 to 21.7 per cent in 2020. In addition to CIT cuts, the use of other enormous profit-based incentives to attract FDI, like tax holidays, are prevalent in ASEAN countries.

The costs of redundant fiscal incentives can exceed the benefits of additional FDI, undermining national tax revenues without evidence of return. Lost budget revenue due to CIT incentives was estimated to be 6 per cent of GDP in Cambodia and 1 per cent in Vietnam and the Philippines.

Besides tax incentives, the use of non-tax incentives has been widespread among ASEAN countries and exacerbated the race to the bottom in the region. The competition in providing non-tax incentives is centred on land incentives. Long-term land lease is available in all ASEAN countries and Thailand even allows foreign investors to own land in some special cases. Vietnam and Laos provide rent exemption or reduction to investment projects in hard-hit regions or in promoted business lines.

This competition in land incentives among ASEAN countries is subsequently enlarging socioeconomic inequality, and the obscure mechanisms of granting land incentives in Cambodia, Laos, and Myanmar are opening up opportunities for corruption and rent-seeking.

“While business should be a race to the top, competition in tax and land incentives is a race to the bottom. The granting of land incentives, particularly the extension of leasehold terms, lacks transparency which could increase the risks of corruption,” said Pham Van Long, a researcher at the Vietnam Institute for Economics and Policy Research (VEPR).

 

The ASEAN region is experiencing unprecedented economic inequality, as some countries still have the highest poverty levels in the world and most countries in the region are failing to invest sufficiently in essential public services. COVID-19 will only amplify poverty and inequality due to the differences in the ability to secure jobs and in the levels of access to healthcare. Myanmar, Indonesia, Vietnam, and the Philippines are among the top 20 countries seeing the largest increases in poverty headcount ratios over the world due to COVID-19.

Unnecessary tax and non-tax incentives affect countries’ capacity to mobilise domestic revenue and therefore spending levels on public essential services to face the pandemic by fighting poverty and reducing inequality. “The absurd situation is that they may not necessarily determine the level of FDI inflows as many policymakers often think,” said the representative of VEPR.

Improved business environment is the key to FDI not tax and land incentives

Many researches find that business environment indicators are key determinants of FDI location decisions, such as economic stability, political stability, local markets, transparency of legal framework, labour quality, the quality of infrastructure, particularly the density of high-quality roads, among others.

The report, building upon comparative experiences of other regions and exploring case studies from ASEAN, makes five recommendations for ASEAN countries to act cohesively: set up black and whitelists of tax incentives clarifying harmful taxation; stop the competition in providing site incentives; agree on a common minimum tax standard; establish rules for the good governance of investment incentives; and agree on a list of business environment factors that are key to attracting FDI.

“ASEAN countries should join hands in the fighting against poverty for millions of lives in the region. It’s high time to realise that tax incentives and non-tax incentives are deepening social and economic inequalities, and that is not the key to sustainable foreign investments. Every government needs sustainable revenue to spend on health and education services and other public goods which are essential to fight poverty and inequalities; so, all the member states need to unite to prioritise enhancing business environment instead of giving away ineffective incentives,” said Mustafa Talpur, Regional Inequality Campaign lead, Oxfam in Asia. 

In 1996, competing to lure investment from General Motors, the Philippines offered a CIT exemption for eight years and Thailand offered a similar exemption with an additional amount equivalent to $15 million. In addition, in 2001, to appeal for investment from Canon, Vietnam provided an exemption for 10 years, but the Philippines matched Vietnam by giving an exemption from 8-12 years. Finally, in 2014, in order to entice Samsung, Indonesia offered an exemption for 10 years while Vietnam offered one for 15 years.VIR

Nguyen Huong

Policy improvements to become rising star

Policy improvements to become rising star

As a promising land for foreign direct investment, Vietnam could grow into the most advanced country in the region – as long as more flexible mechanisms in granting special incentives to large-scale projects are realised.

How to attract high-quality foreign direct investment

How to attract high-quality foreign direct investment

Industrialization requires high-quality foreign direct investment (FDI). Many issues must be addressed, including how to developed a skilled workforce.

 
 

Other News

.
4% inflation target set for 2021 within reach: experts
4% inflation target set for 2021 within reach: experts
BUSINESSicon  07/01/2021 

Vietnam is likely to meet its target of reining in inflation at a rate of below 4% in 2021, although experts warn that unfavourable factors could impact market fluctuations.

Vietnamese billionaires’ net worth increases after battling headwinds of 2020
Vietnamese billionaires’ net worth increases after battling headwinds of 2020
BUSINESSicon  07/01/2021 

2020 was a difficult year for the global economy including Viet Nam, but some Vietnamese billionaires still saw their net asset value increase.

Disbursement of public investment at record since 2016, still misses Gov’t target
Disbursement of public investment at record since 2016, still misses Gov’t target
BUSINESSicon  07/01/2021 

The disbursement of public investment was estimated at VND398 trillion as of the end of December, meeting 82.8 per cent of the Government’s plan – the highest rate in the 2016-20 period, according to the Ministry of Planning and Investment.

Vietnamese dragonfruit needs to find new export markets: Experts
Vietnamese dragonfruit needs to find new export markets: Experts
BUSINESSicon  07/01/2021 

In the first 11 months of this year dragonfruit exports fell by 10 per cent because of the COVID-19 pandemic but still dominated Vietnamese fruit exports with shipments of more than US$1 billion.

Fintech forecast to be robust this year, driven by the creation of regulatory sandbox
Fintech forecast to be robust this year, driven by the creation of regulatory sandbox
BUSINESSicon  07/01/2021 

The regulatory sandbox for financial technology (fintech) which is expected to be created this year, coupled with efforts to promote the use of digital financial services, are expected to accelerate the development of fintech in Vietnam.

Brexit deal met with relief across Europe
Brexit deal met with relief across Europe
BUSINESSicon  07/01/2021 

After four long years of debate, negotiation, elections, and more debate, the United Kingdom has finally and officially left the European Union. 

Party congress to highlight critical role of private sector
Party congress to highlight critical role of private sector
FEATUREicon  07/01/2021 

Vietnam’s development outlook is set to be formulated over the next few weeks when the 13th National Party Congress takes place in Hanoi, 

Country’s IT groups pioneering in digital transformation efforts
Country’s IT groups pioneering in digital transformation efforts
BUSINESSicon  06/01/2021 

The Vietnamese IT market has seen a strong increase in digital products, platforms, and services in 2020, with many gaining bolder steps in domestic and international markets.

Building a modern Vietnam for all
Building a modern Vietnam for all
FEATUREicon  06/01/2021 

The Vietnamese economy has been witnessing tremendous achievements over the past few decades under the sound policies and strategies by the government and the great contributions of the planning and investment sector. 

Cash flows to Vietnam, more young people start up businesses
Cash flows to Vietnam, more young people start up businesses
FEATUREicon  07/01/2021 

The Covid-19 pandemic has disrupted investment flow into Vietnam’s startups, but for venture funds, Vietnam is still considered a priority market in Southeast Asia in 2021.

Investment funds beat the market in 2020
Investment funds beat the market in 2020
BUSINESSicon  06/01/2021 

2020 marked an unexpectedly successful year for big investment funds in Vietnam, with Pyn Elite Fund having the best performance.

Over 14 billion USD mobilised through G-bond auctions at HNX in 2020
Over 14 billion USD mobilised through G-bond auctions at HNX in 2020
BUSINESSicon  06/01/2021 

Nearly VND324 trillion (over $14 billion) was mobilised through G-bond auctions at the Hanoi Stock Exchange (HNX) in 2020, accounting for 108 percent of the set plan.

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS JANUARY 7
VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS JANUARY 7
BUSINESSicon  07/01/2021 

Handicrafts target $5 billion in export value by 2025

Vietnam heads towards modern, integrated agriculture
Vietnam heads towards modern, integrated agriculture
BUSINESSicon  06/01/2021 

Minister of Agriculture and Rural Development Nguyen Xuan Cuong talks about measures to promote modern agricultural development.

After fast growth, domestically assembled cars face downtrend
After fast growth, domestically assembled cars face downtrend
BUSINESSicon  06/01/2021 

The year 2020 witnessed many ups and downs of the car market. In H1, demand dropped dramatically because of Covid-19, but in H2, cars sold well thanks to the preferential vehicle registration tax.

Digitizing traditional markets – $10 billion potential
Digitizing traditional markets – $10 billion potential
FEATUREicon  06/01/2021 

Traditional markets and groceries still hold the largest share of the consumer retail market, but new business models are scrambling for a piece of the pie.

Inflation control cannot be taken lightly
Inflation control cannot be taken lightly
BUSINESSicon  06/01/2021 

Although many forecasts said that inflation would be controlled at less than four per cent this year, economists recommended it was still important to pay attention to inflationary pressures.

Concerns for reform
Concerns for reform
FEATUREicon  06/01/2021 

A strategic advisory body on reform and development is essential in the transitional economy in Vietnam.

Cross-border taxation to bolster national budget
Cross-border taxation to bolster national budget
BUSINESSicon  06/01/2021 

Collecting tax from cross-border platforms as well as people profiting from them is the government’s leading mission in 2021.

Fitch Solutions revises up Vietnam GDP growth forecast to 8.6% in 2021
Fitch Solutions revises up Vietnam GDP growth forecast to 8.6% in 2021
BUSINESSicon  05/01/2021 

Vietnam’s strong growth momentum in manufacturing is expected to continue in 2021, supported by growing external demand from trade deals such as the EVFTA, UKVFTA, and RCEP.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN