return icon Vietnamnet.vn

Equitisation doesn't necessarily mean a better future for SOEs

Equitisation should be a magic wand to improve the performance of a State-owned enterprise (SOE), but in some cases, it is not.

{keywords}
A storehouse of Vietnam Southern Food Corporation (Vinafood 2) in Tra On District, Vinh Long Province. VNA/VNS Photo Dinh Hue

Vietnam Southern Food Corporation (Vinafood 2) in mid-March 2018 launched its IPO and sold 115 million shares, accounting for nearly 23 per cent of its capital, to bidders for VND1.16 trillion (roughly US$50 million).

After the IPO, multisectoral firm T&T Group bought 25 per cent of the firm and became the strategic investor at Vinafood 2 for about VND1.2 trillion.

The total fundraising was worth nearly VND2.3 trillion and the State cut its ownership in Vinafood 2 to 51.43 per cent from 100 per cent.

Vinafood 2 expected the equitisation would help turn its losses into profits but to date, the opposite has happened.

The food trading company in the second quarter of 2020 recorded a loss of VND43 billion. After six months, Vinafood 2 made a total loss of VND160 billion.

The company has logged an accumulative loss of nearly VND2.2 trillion.

Changes in rice purchasing policies in foreign markets, stricter barriers to protect local producers, and the temporary halt of rice exports due to the COVID-19 pandemic have led the poor performance, according to Vinafood 2.

According to analysts and business insiders, the prolonged underperformance of the firm is caused by a lack of efficient corporate governance.

The State investor still has the controlling stake in the company while the strategic investor has little power, so the company has shown little change in its corporate governance and business policies.

If there is no change to the management structure at Vinafood 2, the company may risk losing both the State and shareholders’ assets, analysts warned.

In an extraordinary shareholders’ meeting in March 2020, T&T Group representative Do Ngoc Khanh suggested Vinafood 2 should make a specific business plan to stop making losses in 2020-21 and begin earning profits in 2021-22.

But as T&T Group has only a 25 per cent stake in Vinafood 2, its voice is not strong enough to change the company’s structure.

Another case is construction firm Song Hong Joint Stock Corporation, which is managed by the Ministry of Construction. The company was equitised in 2010 but its performance in recent years has worsened.

In 2019, Song Hong made a loss of nearly VND67 billion, raising cumulative losses to VND958 billion. The owner’s equity capital at the end of 2019 was negative VND651 billion.

If the State still controls a company, it becomes very hard for the strategic investor to make changes to the business operation, governance and performance, analysts said.

The issue would harm the business, its shareholders and even Vietnam’s economy as Vinafood 2, like other large-cap SOEs, is the leader in the rice business, so if the company fails to make a profit, the nation and people would suffer, they said.

“Companies must be taken care of before and after equitisation, because they are the ones that keep the country alive,” T&T Group chairman Do Quang Hien told Đầu tư Chứng khoán (Securities Investment) newspaper.

“I’m not talking about money, which is easily raised. What we need is regulatory support. The State should give up its control in sectors which are not concerns in terms of national security because it the State still holds more than 50 per cent of capital, we cannot change the mindset in corporate governance,” he said.

The Ministry of Planning and Investment said in its project on improving corporate governance for SOEs that State representatives are often unaware of the need to protect the rights and benefits of smaller shareholders.

The ministry said SOE equitisation plans often lag behind schedule because there are too many issues regarding the valuation of land properties, assets and debts.

Those issues put State representatives under pressure to both earn profits when selling State capital and follow the rules to avoid legal violations, the ministry said.

“Some business top managers worry they may lose power and benefits if the company is shared with investors, so they are unwilling to comply with the divestment plan,” the ministry said.

“However, the penalties on those individuals and their actions are not strong enough, leading to slow and inefficient equitisation of SOEs,” the ministry added.

The ministry recommended the State keep control of companies in the fields of cash printing, savings insurance, social development banking, securities depository and book publishing while giving up its power in other sectors.

Economist Ngo Tri Long, former director of the Market and Price Research Institute, said the prolonging issue will result in bigger losses for SOEs.

Slow equitisation will halt business operation and unsettle staff, thus, downsizing the production and productivity, Long said, adding the worst-hit are the State and thousands of workers in those companies.  VNS

Vietnam looks to attract foreign investment in equitisation of SOEs

Vietnam looks to attract foreign investment in equitisation of SOEs

As the Government is focusing on accelerating the privatisation and divestment of State-owned enterprises (SOEs), attracting foreign investment is important to the success of the progress,

Equitising State-owned enterprises to boost growth amid COVID-19

Equitising State-owned enterprises to boost growth amid COVID-19

Dr Burkhard Schrage, Senior Programme Manager of Management at RMIT’s School of Business & Management talked about the work of equitising State-owned enterprises during the COVID-19 pandemic.

MORE NEWS

VIETNAM BUSINESS NEWS JUNE 26

Agricultural sector ensures food security, exports

Vietnamese become famous for gold-wearing ‘hobby’

The hobby of wearing gold all over the body has attracted the attention of the public, even foreign news sites.

Hue Festival 2022 opens with glamor show

The week-long Hue Festival 2022 was kicked off on June 25 evening by a unique art programme and Ao Dai (Vietnamese traditional gown) show.

Bach Long Glass Bridge - A news tourist attraction in Moc Chau

A glass-bottomed bridge named Bach Long (White Dragon) was recently inaugurated in Moc Chau and it has immediately become a new tourist attraction.

Vietnam among few countries totally re-open int’l tourism market

Vietnam is the only only Southeast Asian country that has reopened international tourism without any COVID-19 restrictions, the World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) said.

Foreign Ministry spokeswoman’s story of being a writer

Assistant to Minister of Foreign Affairs, Spokesperson of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs Le Thi Thu Hang says journalism not only means reporting information, but it also has the function of leading public opinion.

Another S.Korean airline resumes direct service to Khanh Hoa

An Air Seoul flight carrying 187 passengers from the Incheon international airport arrived at the Cam Ranh International Airport in Khanh Hoa Province on June 24.

Interest subsidy vs monetary loosening

Some recent reports have indicated that the monetary policy of the State Bank of Vietnam (SBV) is not in sync with the global trend.

Developers expect smoother LNG policy planning

In Vietnam, about 20 LNG-fired power projects are in the pipeline. Some of these programmes, however, have yet to identify a fuel source.

National Assembly Chairman arrives in Budapest for Hungary visit

A high-ranking delegation of the National Assembly (NA) of Vietnam led by NA Chairman Vuong Dinh Hue arrived in Budapest on June 25 afternoon (local time), beginning an official visit to Hungary.

Next Top model crowned Miss Universe Vietnam 2022

Ngoc Chau, the winner of Vietnam’s Next Top Model 2016, was crowned Miss Universe Vietnam 2022 at a grand finale held in Ho Chi Minh City on June 25 evening.

WB, FTSE Russell pledge regular coordination in upgrading Vietnam's stock market

Representatives of the World Bank (WB) and FTSE Russell have committed to further supporting Vietnam to build a sustainable stock market, particularly via regularly exchange and coordination in the market upgrading matter.

Regions, sub-regions must be linked for development

In 2004, the Politburo released Resolution No 39-NQ/TW on socio-economic development and assurance of national defense and security in the northern part and southern coastal area of the central region by 2010.

Ensuring information security for digital platforms the top priority

Deputy Minister of Information and Communications Nguyen Huy Dung stressed that ensuring information security for digital platforms must be considered the key task, inseparable from the digital transformation process.
back_to_top