Decree to prevent transfer pricing could inadvertently harm Vietnamese companies

Setting a cap on loan interest deductability is a tool to prevent foreign invested enterprises (FIEs) from conducting transfer pricing. However, the application of the regulation on Vietnamese enterprises as well has stirred controvesy.

On November 5, 2020, the government issued Decree 132 on guiding tax administration for enterprises engaging in related party transactions.

Decree to prevent transfer pricing could inadvertently harm Vietnamese companies

Replacing Decree 20 dated February 24, 2017, the decree 132 includes new changes: the maximum loan interest deductibility has been raised from 20 percent in the old decree to 30 percent of EBITDA (earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization), while subjects of the exemption from the cap have been expanded.

An accounting expert said the new decree has set clear regulations to fill in the legal loopholes which had been a topic of debate for a long time.

In particular, a very ‘big hole’ in the legal framework that multinationals have exploited to avoid tax has been ‘filled’ with the phrase ‘sharing costs between related parties’.

For example, company ‘A’ in Vietnam, which paid a common corporate income tax rate of 20 percent, had taxable income of VND10 billion. Its parent company ‘B’ in a foreign country would apportion a management cost worth VND10 billion to ‘A’.

As such, ‘A’’s taxable income would be zero and the tax would be zero instead of VND2 billion (VND10 billion x 20%)

With the trick, the tax payment duty would be transferred from A to B. Meanwhile, B would have to pay Foreign Contractor Tax (FCT) of 10 percent at maximum, and the tax amount for B would be VND1 billion only (VND10 billion x 10%).

However, while prasing the General Department of Taxation (GDT) for its measure to prevent transfer pricing committed by multinationals, the expert said it is unreasonable to apply the regulation to both FIEs and Vietnamese enterprises.

He said after the Decree 20 was promulgated, FIEs, which bear the biggest impact from the decree, did not make complaints.

A representative of GDT explained that during the compilation of Decree 20, FIEs, through their legal consultants, made suggestions about the decree through different channels.

The expert said FIEs did not complain about Decree 20 because they knew the taxation was right. The application of a cap on loan interest deductions when calculating corporate income tax is recommended by OECD and there was nothing to worry about.

Meanwhile, Vietnamese enterprises have complained about the taxation because they find the taxation unreasonable.

What about Vietnamese enterprises?

“Is thin capitalization bad?” was the question. raised to a finance expert after GDT held a press conference on the promulation of Decree 132 and explained that one of the purposes of the decree is restricting the thin capitalization.

 
Setting a cap on loan interest deductability is a tool to prevent foreign invested enterprises (FIEs) from conducting transfer pricing. However, the application of the regulation on Vietnamese enterprises as well has stirred controvesy.

The expert said he cannot say exactly ‘yes’ or ‘no’, because this will depend on specific cases and the strength of every economy.

“I wonder how Vietnamese enterprises can live if GDT wants to restrict thin capitalization? 98 percent of Vietnamese enterprises have small capital and very few ones have big capital,” he said.

“Applying 100 percent of the OECD regulations designed for developed countries in Vietnam proves to be…” he said, not finishing the sentence, but showing disappointment.

The expert went on to say that OECD itself does not recommend applying this anti-transfer pricing measure to domestic companies.

The representative of GDT also admitted at the press conference that the regulation on setting a cap on loan interest deductions is being applied for the first time in Vietnam, so the problems in implementation are unavoidable.

The major reason behind this is that Vietnamese enterprises have small stockholder equity and operate mostly with borrowed money.

In reply to the suggestion that the regulation on the cap on loan interest deductions should not be applied to Vietnamese enterprises, GDT said under the law, there must be discriminatory treatment to different economic sectors, so the decree must cover both FIEs and Vietnamese enterprises.

Nguyen Van Phuc, former deputy chair of the National Assembly’s Economics Committee, said that Vietnam should continue to study international regulations and practices, and provide more detailed guidance to specific business models and business fields.

The application of the regulations in accordance with international practice should be implemented under the roadmaps and with reference to BEPS (base erosion and profit shifting) to ensure that the regulations are feasible and reasonable. 

Hai Dang

New regulations on cap on loan interest deductions released

New regulations on cap on loan interest deductions released

The regulations on the cap on loan interest deductions will cause enterprises to face difficulty as they have small capital and operate mostly with borrowed money.  

Amended regulations on cap on loan interest deductions cause concern

Amended regulations on cap on loan interest deductions cause concern

The new decree, according to experts, has yet to fully solve the inadequacies of the old regulation on the loan interest deductibility cap.

 
 

Other News

.
Stock market 2021: records broken
Stock market 2021: records broken
FEATUREicon  30/12/2021 

Covid-19 posed difficulties to many people in 2021, but not to securities investors. They earned big money as the VN Index climbed to new highs.

Hanoi warned of more serious traffic jams if it bans motorbikes too soon
Hanoi warned of more serious traffic jams if it bans motorbikes too soon
FEATUREicon  30/12/2021 

If Hanoi authorities prohibit motorbikes by 2025 in the center, when the public transport network is still not capable of satisfying people’s demand, many would have to use private cars. If so, the traffic would be even worse.

Tourism 2021: opens today, closes tomorrow
Tourism 2021: opens today, closes tomorrow
FEATUREicon  29/12/2021 

The tourism industry experienced another tough year in 2021 as policies applied by local authorities changed often.

Farm export deadlock at border gates: long-term solution needed
Farm export deadlock at border gates: long-term solution needed
FEATUREicon  29/12/2021 

Preliminary treatment centers and cold storage warehouses along the border and systematic logistics chains are both needed, experts said.

Finance ministry proposes tax policy to prevent land speculation
Finance ministry proposes tax policy to prevent land speculation
FEATUREicon  29/12/2021 

Prime Minister Pham Minh Chinh has assigned the Ministry of Finance (MOF) to study and design some kinds of tax related to the real estate market, including property tax, in order to stabilize the market and reduce speculation.

ESports could be lucrative for 4G, 5G service providers
ESports could be lucrative for 4G, 5G service providers
FEATUREicon  28/12/2021 

As the telecommunication market is getting saturated, new content services such as livestream and e-sports are expected to help telecom carriers maintain growth.

5,000 container trucks stuck at border gates amid 50 talks with China
5,000 container trucks stuck at border gates amid 50 talks with China
FEATUREicon  27/12/2021 

The Ministry of Industry and Trade (MOIT) reported that 1,555 trucks carrying exports to China are stuck in Quang Ninh as of December 25, and 4,204 in Lang Son as of December 25. Some of them have been deadlocked for a month.

Thu Thiem land auction puts an end to sale of public land at low prices
Thu Thiem land auction puts an end to sale of public land at low prices
FEATUREicon  28/12/2021 

Four land plots in advantageous positions in the new urban area of Thu Thiem in HCM City were sold for VND37.346 trillion through an auction recently.

Hanoi needs to change its way of managing Covid patient treatment
Hanoi needs to change its way of managing Covid patient treatment
FEATUREicon  28/12/2021 

As the number of Covid-19 cases is increasing day by day in Hanoi, the municipal authorities need to create another scenario.

Casinos suffer heavy losses, wait for brighter days
Casinos suffer heavy losses, wait for brighter days
FEATUREicon  25/12/2021 

As many as 56 businesses in Vietnam are licensed to provide prize-winning games at 63 hotels and nine casino businesses.

Metaverse: the race to enter the virtual universe
Metaverse: the race to enter the virtual universe
FEATUREicon  27/12/2021 

Metaverse is very close to human life. Right now, government agencies, businesses and citizens need a way to be ready to adapt to a future world.

Congestion at border gates, seaports stalls transport of farm exports
Congestion at border gates, seaports stalls transport of farm exports
FEATUREicon  25/12/2021 

Farm exports experienced a tough year in 2021 due to continued congestion at border gates. Despite this, agricultural produce still reached export turnover of $47 billion for the year.

Pandemic offers lessons and once-in-a-century opportunity: MIC Minister
Pandemic offers lessons and once-in-a-century opportunity: MIC Minister
FEATUREicon  25/12/2021 

Vietnam expects to jump into the second position in the region in terms of digital economy, just following Indonesia, officials have said.

When will congestion at Vietnam-China border gates end?
When will congestion at Vietnam-China border gates end?
FEATUREicon  24/12/2021 

Vietnamese exports stuck at Vietnam-China border gates has been a common sight for years.

Parents debate about need for handwriting practice
Parents debate about need for handwriting practice
FEATUREicon  24/12/2021 

Vietnamese parents agree that their children need to be good at math, but disagree on whether they need to have good handwriting.

Vietnamese fruits sell for sky-high prices in world market
Vietnamese fruits sell for sky-high prices in world market
FEATUREicon  24/12/2021 

2021 has been a fruitful year for Vietnam’s agriculture as many farm specialties have entered choosy markets.

Hanoi has ‘more than enough’ money to develop modern transport under new investment model
Hanoi has ‘more than enough’ money to develop modern transport under new investment model
FEATUREicon  27/12/2021 

The Cat Linh – Ha Dong elevated railway project provides a lesson on public asset valuation. Selling and buying back infrastructure projects at their real value will allow the effective usage of resources.

Lockdown is unnecessary amid rising Covid cases in Hanoi: official
Lockdown is unnecessary amid rising Covid cases in Hanoi: official
FEATUREicon  23/12/2021 

The number of Covid cases in Hanoi is increasing rapidly, but experts believe that re-imposing a lockdown would be ‘unnecessary’ and ‘ineffective’.

No guidance yet for international flight reopening slated for January
No guidance yet for international flight reopening slated for January
FEATUREicon  22/12/2021 

Airlines are ready to resume routine international flights from January 1, 2022 after two years of interruption. However, they are concerned as regulations have not been released. Meanwhile, some problems still exist.

Welcome int’l guests: overcoming fear to safely adapt to pandemic
Welcome int’l guests: overcoming fear to safely adapt to pandemic
FEATUREicon  24/12/2021 

For the January-November period of 2021, the number of domestic tourists was 34.75 million, and total revenue was 167 trillion VND, 40% down year on year.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN