Private enterprises lack internal strength and driving force to develop

How will Vietnam overcome challenges to realize its development plans? Nguyen Dinh Cung, former head of Central Institute for Economic Management (CIEM), shares his perspective with VietNamNet.

Private enterprises lack internal strength and driving force to develop

One of the great successes of economic reform in Vietnam since doi moi (renovation) is the establishment of a community of businesses from different economic sectors with many ownership modes. Vietnamese enterprises are operating under similar legal forms as in other market economies.

High in quantity, small in scale

In terms of quantity, enterprises in the private sector account for the overwhelming proportion, 97 percent, while SOEs (state owned enterprises) account for 0.38 percent and FIEs the remaining.

The enterprises employ 16 million workers. The workers in SOEs account for 7 percent, private enterprises nearly 60 percent and 33 percent in FIEs (foreign invested enterprises).

In terms of total assets, SOEs account for 28 percent, private enterprises 53 percent and FIEs 29 percent.

In terms of stockholder equity, SOEs account for 20 percent, non-state owned enterprises 56 percent and FIEs 24 percent.

In terms of net revenue, SOEs account for 14.5 percent, non-state owned 57 percent and FIEs 28.5 percent.

In terms of pre-tax profit, SOEs account for 21 percent. The figures are 36 percent for non-state owned enterprises and 43 percent for FIEs.

If considering financial efficiency, the ROE (return on equity) is 9 percent for SOEs, 4.5 percent for non-state owned enterprises and 15 percent for FIEs. Meanwhile, the profit to sale ratio is 5.6 percent for SOEs and FIEs, while it is just 2.4 percent for non-state enterprises.

The figures show that while private enterprises account for the overwhelming proportion, they mostly have small and micro scale, with very few enterprises having medium scale. They have low technology and low competitiveness.

Lacking inner strength and driving force to develop

This is attributed to several reasons:

First, the ratio of profit to revenue and to assets is too low. Stockholder equity is not high enough for re-investment and development. Therefore, most private enterprises have to rely on working capital from relatives and friends. Only a small part of the enterprises can access bank loans.

Most private enterprises lack capability to innovate and receive technology transfer, and lack the driving force to research, develop and renovate technology. In other words, private enterprises lack inner strength and motivation for development.

Second, one part of private enterprises doesn't want to expand investment to become large enterprises.

This is attributed to unclear and overlapping laws which can be understood and implemented in different ways by different state management agencies. The bigger that enterprises become and the more business fields they cover, the higher legal risks they face, which may cause big losses or loss of all of their assets that had been created over decades.

 
While private enterprises account for the overwhelming proportion, they mostly have small and micro scale, with very few enterprises having medium scale. They have low technology and low competitiveness.

In this situation, there is no reliable and effective tool and institution, especially independent courts, capable of protecting their rights and benefits.

Third, another part of private enterprises wants to grow but cannot, because they cannot access resources for investment and development. Surveys have found that capital costs are too high. The inability to get enough capital and access land are the big barriers for private enterprises in this group.

Fourth, some of the hundreds of thousands of private enterprises are crony enterprises. The number of these enterprises is not high if compared with the total number of operating enterprises, but they appropriate significant resources and deprive business opportunities from authentic investors and businesses.

The enterprises of this kind contribute to creating an unfair business environment which lacks transparency; distort the allocation of national resources; and distort the value and constrict the business motivation of genuine businesses.

It is the enterprises of this kind that make it difficult for other enterprises to access resources and business opportunities. This is a major obstacle for the development of private enterprises.

Large private groups vulnerable

Vietnam now has some large-scale private enterprises, called economic groups. There are some similarities and differences between the economic groups and groups in some Asian economies prior to 1979 as follows:

The similarities include investment in multi business fields; reliance on bank loans; lack of transparency in administration and business; and relatively friendly relations with the government. They are big if compared with the size of the economies, and so they are not allowed to collapse.

Regarding differences, some foreign economic groups specialized in manufacturing, developed strong R&D (research and development), and expanded their business across the region and the world. They have had specific products and strong brands. Meanwhile, Vietnamese private economic groups mostly target the domestic market, focusing on real estate and consumer services. They still cannot develop and master technologies in their fields and don’t have global competitiveness.

It is obvious that Vietnam’s private economic groups are not as powerful as Asian private economic groups before 1979, and they are vulnerable. If the businesses collapse, it will take a longer time to recover them and the collapse may cause bigger losses to the national economy.

Therefore, developing the private sector, including economic groups, in a balanced, effective and sustainable manner must be a top priority task in the coming time.

It is necessary to amend unreasonable policies to help private enterprises increase their strength and overcome obstacles so they can feel secure to expand investment for development.

The 13th Party Congress Resolution has set specific goals for Vietnam’s socio-economic development.

By 2025, Vietnam would become a developing country with industry going towards modernization and income surpassing the lower average level.

By 2030, Vietnam would become a developing country with a modern industry and higher than average income.

By 2045, it would become a developed country with high income.

Nguyen Dinh Cung

Will 24 years be enough for Vietnam to become a developed country with high income?

Will 24 years be enough for Vietnam to become a developed country with high income?

The 13th Party Congress Resolution says Vietnam aims to become a developed country with high income by 2045, when it will celebrate the 100th anniversary of the country's establishment.

Vietnam's private enterprises grow slowly

Vietnam's private enterprises grow slowly

Many Vietnamese tycoons regret that the largest beer company in Vietnam, the Saigon Alcohol Beer and Beverage Joint Stock Corporation (Sabeco), has fallen into the hands of Thai investors.

 
 

Other News

.
Domestic violence during the pandemic
Domestic violence during the pandemic
FEATUREicon  01/11/2021 

According to the Center for Research and Scientific Application on Gender-Family-Women- Adolescents, during social distancing, violence against women and girls not only increased in the number of cases but also changed in some aspects.

High taxes and fees cause jump in petrol prices
High taxes and fees cause jump in petrol prices
FEATUREicon  02/11/2021 

Taxes and fees make up nearly 40 percent of the petrol price. The environmental protection tax is now at the ceiling level.

Car importers’ request for lower registration tax worries domestic manufacturers
Car importers’ request for lower registration tax worries domestic manufacturers
FEATUREicon  02/11/2021 

The request for a registration tax cut, if approved, will mostly benefit luxury car buyers.

Hanoi’s proposal to collect fees from cars entering inner city raises concerns
Hanoi’s proposal to collect fees from cars entering inner city raises concerns
FEATUREicon  02/11/2021 

Hanoi is considering setting up 87 toll collection stations in an effort to restrict the number of cars entering the inner city.

PM Pham Minh Chinh's trip to Europe and Vietnam’s responsibility for global issues
PM Pham Minh Chinh's trip to Europe and Vietnam’s responsibility for global issues
FEATUREicon  01/11/2021 

Attendance at COP26 has been a good opportunity for Vietnam to express its views on climate change, and to affirm its determination to contribute responsibly to global efforts.

Vietnamese paintings at international auctions reach milestones
Vietnamese paintings at international auctions reach milestones
FEATUREicon  31/10/2021 

Vietnamese paintings, especially the artworks created by those who studied from the Indochina Fine Arts College, have attracted the attention of the world’s art collectors.

Will students return to school in November?
Will students return to school in November?
FEATUREicon  30/10/2021 

A vaccination campaign for children will be launched in November throughout the country.

Foreign travelers in doubt, though 7-day quarantine requirement has been removed
Foreign travelers in doubt, though 7-day quarantine requirement has been removed
FEATUREicon  30/10/2021 

From November 2021, foreign travelers to Phu Quoc, Khanh Hoa, Quang Nam, Da Nang and Quang Ninh, if testing negative for the coronavirus, will be able to take package tours and not be required to have a 7-day quarantine.

Drinking rainwater, sleeping in buses: the lives of bus drivers, attendants
Drinking rainwater, sleeping in buses: the lives of bus drivers, attendants
FEATUREicon  30/10/2021 

Becoming unemployed and running out of money, bus drivers and bus attendants have had to drink rainwater, and eat and sleep on buses, waiting for the day the bus station resumes operation.

Vietnam needs to consider giving booster shots, though many people are still waiting for second shot
Vietnam needs to consider giving booster shots, though many people are still waiting for second shot
FEATUREicon  01/11/2021 

It’s necessary to think about who should get a booster shot first.

Safe cocoons protect children orphaned by Covid-19
Safe cocoons protect children orphaned by Covid-19
FEATUREicon  29/10/2021 

Most of the 1,500 orphaned COVID-19 youngsters are living in families of freelance workers in HCM City. Without financial or spiritual assistance, the previously limited path to these children's future has become even more bleak. 

Opportunity to build a brand for Vietnam education
Opportunity to build a brand for Vietnam education
FEATUREicon  30/10/2021 

In 2016, Vietnam was the 8th destination but in 2019 the country ranked 4th out of 40 destinations for short-term courses and internships for Australian students in the Indo-Pacific, including regions in Asia, following China, India and Indonesia.

Vietnam auto industry: turning risk into opportunity
Vietnam auto industry: turning risk into opportunity
FEATUREicon  29/10/2021 

The Vietnam Automobile Manufacturers’ Association (VAMA) said the fourth outbreak of the Covid-19 epidemic that began in late April 2021 has forced many automobile manufacturers to reduce capacity or even suspend production.

Hundreds of millions of US dollars invested in Vietnam startups
Hundreds of millions of US dollars invested in Vietnam startups
FEATUREicon  29/10/2021 

Amid the Covid-19 pandemic, many startups in online education, health care and goods delivery have received huge capital from foreign funds.

Clean or cheap: seeking safe energy options for Vietnam
Clean or cheap: seeking safe energy options for Vietnam
FEATUREicon  28/10/2021 

“The international pressure to reduce coal-fired thermal power is huge,” said an expert involved in the compilation of the draft of national power development plan 8.

Parents, experts have different views about reopening schools
Parents, experts have different views about reopening schools
FEATUREicon  29/10/2021 

Students in Hanoi may be able to return to school as the city has been listed as a green zone. However, no final decision has been released.

Petrol price hike puts pressure on consumers, threatens inflation
Petrol price hike puts pressure on consumers, threatens inflation
FEATUREicon  28/10/2021 

The prices of goods and services have begun escalating following a shocking hike in petrol price, reaching a 7-year high, announced by petroleum distributors on October 25.

Vietnamese need to be of the same mindset to overcome current challenges
Vietnamese need to be of the same mindset to overcome current challenges
FEATUREicon  29/10/2021 

The current challenges are unprecedented and Vietnamese people need to share the same mindset to overcome them, according to Nguyen Dinh Cung, an economist.

Should films be sanctioned for employing artists involved in scandals?
Should films be sanctioned for employing artists involved in scandals?
FEATUREicon  28/10/2021 

Filmmakers have reacted to a recent proposal by a NA Deputy to stop screening films or revoke licenses if artists in films commit ethical violations.

Petrol price at historic peak, Government urged to cut environmental protection tax
Petrol price at historic peak, Government urged to cut environmental protection tax
FEATUREicon  27/10/2021 

To force petrol prices down, the Government needs to cut the environmental protection tax rate, which is at the ceiling level.

 
 
 
Leave your comment on an article

OR QUICK LOGIN