return icon

Japan enters war of notes on the East Sea

Japan issued a diplomatic note at the time the US began a new government and Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi had just completed a visit to nine ASEAN countries.


Nhật Bản bước vào cuộc chiến công hàm về Biển Đông

Ships of the Japan Maritime Self-Defense Force, and US and Indian naval ships. Photo: Reuters



As a member of the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), Japan spoke out against China's Note CML/63/2020 dated September 18, 2020 in response to notes from three European countries – the UK, France and Germany - sent to the Secretary-General of the United Nations on the dispute in the East Sea on September 16, 2020.

Different from the notes of three European countries that fully list the notes of China (No. CML/14/2019 dated 12/12/2019, No. CML/11/2020 on 23/3/2020, No. CML/42/2020 dated 17/4/2020, No. CML/46/2020 dated 2/6/2020, No. CML/48/2020 dated 18/6/2020, No. CML/54/2020 dated 29/7/2020, and No. CML/56/2020 dated 7/8/2020, as well as the Appendix to the Official Letter of 9/6/2020), the note of Japan only named the note CML/63/2020.

Does not accept China's argument

The note of Japan shows the disapproval of the Chinese arguments shown in the previous notes and is generally repeated in the note CML/63/2020. The note also affirmed Japan’s support for the point of view of European countries above. That is:

Considering UNCLOS to be universal and unified, establishing the legal framework for all activities carried out on sea and ocean.

The Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA)'s ruling in 2016 is final and compulsory for the parties, the Philippines and China.

Freedom of the high seas must be respected.

The archipelagic baseline cannot be illegally applied to the offshore islands of the coastal state.

The note said: does not accept extensive activities to change the legal status of island features; and does not recognize historic rights in the East Sea that are inconsistent with the UNCLOS provisions.

In Note SC/21/002 dated January 19, 2021, Japan emphasized three issues: the use of archipelagic baselines, legal regulations of semi-submerged shoals and the maritime, and aviation freedom rights.

In its Note CML/63/2020, China argued that there is a long-established practice in international law regarding the offshore islands of mainland states and that such practice should be respected.

This is the reason to justify China's application of the archipelagic baseline that is only applied to the archipelagic states for Vietnam's Hoang Sa Archipelago (Paracel Islands) on June 15, 1996 and the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands which is in dispute with Japan on September 10, 2012.

The Japanese note stated: "There is no room for a member state to justify the application of baselines that do not satisfy the provisions of UNCLOS."

The objections of the US, three European countries, Australia and Japan show that there is no national practice that allows the application of archipelagic baselines to the offshore island groups of mainland countries like China argued. The semi-submersible shoals in Truong Sa have no island status, or rocks, no territorial sea and national airspace.

Therefore, it is unacceptable for China to object to the passage of Japanese aircraft over the airspace over the Vanh Khan (Mischief Reef) and the attempt to limit the freedom of overflight in the East Sea.

This is the first time Japan has introduced concrete practice on restricting its freedom of overflight in the East Sea and this action can be construed as a response to any intention to establish an Air Defense Identification Area (ADIZ) in this waters.

The first Asian country outside of Southeast Asia raises its voice

Japan, the first Asian country outside of Southeast Asia, has spoken out for its own interests and coordinated with other countries to prevent excessive activities that threaten peace, stability and development in the region as well as the freedoms of high sea in the East Sea. Japan's Note contributes to accelerating the internationalization of the East Sea, which China does not want.

Japan issued the note at the time the US had a new government and Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi had just completed a visit to nine ASEAN countries. This partly shows the fierce competition of major countries for influence in this area.

It also represents Japan's efforts to strengthen relations with countries in the region in order to response to Chinese aggression in both the East Sea and East China Sea. It represents the policy pursued by Prime Minister Suga's administration against any action that escalates tensions in the East Sea.

Settlement of disputes in the East Sea or East China Sea cannot be based solely on the threat of using force, but on international law and peaceful measures.

Nguyen Hong Thao

Germany sends warships to East Sea - a strategic turning point

Germany sends warships to East Sea - a strategic turning point

The German government has announced plans to send its warships to ports of Japan, South Korea and Australia, passing through the East Sea this summer.

Japan, UK voice concern over East Sea, East China Sea situation

Japan, UK voice concern over East Sea, East China Sea situation

Four ministers from Japan and the UK on February 3 voiced serious concern about the situation in the East Sea (South China Sea) and East China Sea and opposed any unilateral attempts to change the status quo, according to Reuters.



Vietnam enjoys trade surplus of US$710 million in H1/2022

Vietnam enjoyed a trade surplus of 710 million USD in the first six months of 2022, the General Statistics Office (GSO) reported on June 29.

GPS collars to be used on wild elephants in Dak Lak

GPS collars will be fitted to 28 wild elephants in the Yok Don National Park in the Central Highlands province of Dak Lak, a workshop heard on June 29.

VN asks for Jordan’s cooperation in helping Vietnamese survivors of Aqaba gas explosion

A poisonous gas explosion at Jordan’s southern port of Aqaba on June 27 killed 13 people, including 5 Vietnamese citizens.

Foreign artists make music with inspiration from Vietnamese epic

The classic Vietnamese epic Lục Vân Tiên, which may be read in a variety of languages and dialects throughout the world, has been given new life by international artists.

More than 800 medical workers in Hanoi resign

As many as 532 medical workers in Hanoi resigned in 2021, while 82 workers transferred to other jobs.

Vietnam to produce dengue medicine Dextran

Dextran, a high molecular solution, is only used for severe dengue cases, but only one company in Thailand is making the product. Vietnam has lacked this fluid over the last two years.

Ministry listens to firms' difficulties, pledges to raise support

The Ministry of Planning and Investment will propose policies to remove obstacles for enterprises and enable them to seize opportunities to accelerate production and business, Minister Nguyen Chi Dung said.

Vietnam's e-government procurement system set to launch in August

The e-GP would allow effective and transparent management of the public procurement process.


Newly-established businesses in H1 exceed 70,000

Australian Foreign Minister enjoys Pho ga in Hanoi

Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong enjoys Hanoi's specialty of Pho ga or chicken noodles as she arrived in the city on her first visit to Vietnam.

Vietnamese ceramic artist sets two Guinness World Records

Two Vietnamese ceramic works will be recognised as having set Guinness World Records at a ceremony in Hanoi today (June 30).


USAID assists Vietnamese businesses to reduce greenhouse gas emission

Vietnam Airlines plans to restore its entire flight network by the end of 2023

The restoration of international flight routes is an important condition for Vietnam Airlines to reduce losses and become profitable in the near future.

Saigon Zoo elephant dung used to make paper

A Saigon Zoo member of staff and a group of students are transforming elephant dung into paper.

Future of Hanoi’s 120-year-old Long Bien Bridge unclear

Long Bien Bridge, the iconic bridge across Hanoi’s Red River, has degraded, but no major repair plan has been finalized and its future is unclear.